← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6837/2016dismissed

Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd v. M/S Bharat Electricals

2016-11-28Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages



   

  

!"##$%&%'()#*+#,-

""!,!,.!'!%/0%1%",!'%2!*3%*%"#4-5#$",- !'$6780!

 #"%"%'#, 1#,&8& 9&6!,!"0#$",%$!0&--'48&",%!0,#!- 6!&# - !'$6780! !'"6#,  #&:'4#'"&  

  !"

"!

# $

%&

,#&#'"( ,1%&6!0!,2-4)$!"#- ,"6#!::#00!'" ,5!'/!.&6%-4)$!"#- ,"6#$!)#!",;,#&:'4#'"& <<<<< "!

# $

 '() "%$#*"%' ,5!'/!.&6%-4)$!"#-=6%&'"6#$!)#!"-!$$#:"&'"%$# '+#6!0"6#,#&:'4#'"& > ,1%&6!0!,2-0#!,'#4$8'&#0,"6#!::#00!'"&8+*%"&"6!" "6#:,#&#'"!::#!0%&!,%&%'28""6#4%&*%&&!0"6#+/#$"%'&%0#4 8'4#,5#$"%'?"6#,+%",!"%'!'4'$%0%!"%'$"- @@ ,&6,"

@@$"B &##7%'2&#""%'2;!&%4#"6#!,+%",!"%'!=!,44!"#4? C 6# +/#$"%'28,"6!&4%&*%&&#4"6#+/#$"%'&'"6#:,#*%&#"6!"!&:#, "6#:,)%&%'&5#$"%' @"6#'#=$"-%#-%$,-5*!00!'4#4%8* '"#,:,%&#&#)#0:*#'"$"- ,&6,"A$"B -"6#!::0%$!"%'

,&#""%'2;!&%4#"6#!=!,46!&"+#!$$*:!'%#4+.CD"6#!*8'" !'4-"6#,#,#-#,,'#8&0.4%&*%&&#4"6#&!*#+#%'2+!,,#4+.0!=

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

#,  $'",!$"-  ,5!'/!.  &6%-  0#!,'#4  $8'&#0  ,  "6# ,#&:'4#'"&&8+*%"&"6!"!&:#,"6#,!"%4#$%4#'4%$800#48"+."6#'F+0# 58:,#*#  8,"  %'  &*+,('

"-*.(

./.0,* 1,'232 '0- "-0,45 366,'2 7

0* (-05,'-  

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

     

          

 

       

 

   

   

  

            

 

 

  

                     !

"      

     

        

 

      

 #      $ 6#,#  %&  '  4%&:8"#  "  "6#  ,!"%  4#$%4#'4%  $800#4  8"  %' &*+,('

"-*.(

./.0,*2 4(2, 23:'($=6#,#%'%"6!&+##'6#04"6!",

&##7%'2&#""%'2!&%4#"6#!=!,4-%"%&"6#,#E8%,#*#'"0!="4#:&%" CD    "6#  !*8'"-  "6#,#,#-  "6#  +/#$"%'2  8,"  4%4  '"  6!)#  !'. $$!&%'":'4#,8:'"6#$0!%*+#%'2+!,,#4+.0!=0%*%"!"%'-.#" =804'",#,!%'*.&#0%'4#0)%'28:'"6#!,#*#'"%'#4:,)%&%'&' "6#$0!%*+#%'2+!,,#4+.0!=0%*%"!"%'',4#,"!::,#$%!"#"6# !,#*#'"%'#4  $'"#'"%'-  "6#  ,#0#)!'"  :,)%&%'&    5#$"%'    !,# ,#:,48$#46#,#%'+#0=(;

%%&'

          () '

                      

      

          !(                

  *          +,       

  

   *           -    



    

 

     *     

 *

              

  

 



   

   %.$ ':#,8&!0"6#!,#*#'"%'#4:,)%&%'&-"6#+8.#,6!&" %'4%$!"#"6#:,%'$%:!0!*8'"!'4%'"#,#&""6#,#'%'"6#%,!''8!0&"!"#*#'"

!$$8'"&!'4!&:#,"6#:,)%&%'&"6#'$*#!G$"-"6#&!*#6!)# "+#*!%'"!%'#4,!:#,%4&%G.#!,&6#,+%",!",!":!2#?@6!4 %'4%$!"#4"6!"8,0#""#,&4!"#4 @@@-?

-   !'4  6!)#+##'!44,#&&#4+."6#,#&:'4#'";&8::0%#,,:!.*#'" %'"#,#&"'"6#!*8'":!%4 '$#"6#!::#00!'"4%4'"!46#,#""6# !,#*#'"%'#4,#E8#&"-"6#,#,#-"6#$0!%*%'$!''"+#&!%4"+# +!,,#4+.0!=0%*%"!"%'%')%#="6#:,)%&%'&5#$"%' $" 6#,+%",!",6!&!0&"!7#'%'"$'&%4#,!"%'"6#0#""#,4!"#4

''#G8,#;,#$#%)#4,*"6#)#,'*#'"'4%!-%'%&",. 55  - 4.26!=!'-#=#06%!44,#&&#4""6#5#$,#"!,."6# !,.!'!'48&",. !$%0%"!"%'8'$%06#&!*#,#!4&"68&(;

 A&       

     %%    +,/%00%  1

23 4425

&2678  4   92 :    '

 9:    

;4<2:

<" <%00+0%<,=>=/     ,=%00%   

         +=?%00%            !

      

          

  

                    -



 %. 4

+@@% 

     $ ' )%#=    =6!"  6!& +##' +&#,)#4  !+)#-  '  2,8'4  , %'"#,#,#'$#%&*!4#8" ::#!0&"!'4&4%&*%&&#4 ;,/6,'

$

"!

#

 '(/,25

%&

#5,05,'

2:,(<.-=>',(2-,* ?,2> #5,05,'

,:'0(6), ?,2>