← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/256/2011allowed

Beg Raj v. Rajender Singh And ORS.

2015-11-03Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages





     



 !""#$%$&'(")*"+,  +- .   "/ 0 !1"+% 22"33 &!% 4"+%5%

0$&-"+$&/1 !1"+%  "%2&-"&!%  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$+&',-%  61"!1"+ "2+!"+%3# 32 2"+%) 7*" 338"-!%""!1"05-/)"&!9  *"+""++"-!!1" "2+!"+%+&!9 , 61"!1"+!1"05-/)"&!%153-*"+"2+!"-$&!1"$/"%!9

+"%"&!'

+&5+ / $&.-(# !".

+!1" 22"33 &!

+4$(":// +8 3.-(# !".

++"%2&-"&!

+ &$ )4"+) .-(# !".

++"%2&-"&! ;;;;; )(*$+& 1"%1+!<5"%!$&$&(3("-$&!1"2+"%"&! "/53 +"#&- 22" 3$%!!1"$&!"+2+"! !$&2+($%$&%5&+"2" 3"-"#!$&!1"

5&0 * +"=")2!$&#!.>, +%1+!?!1"#!@.81$#12+($-"%!1 !!1" +$/1!2+"=")2!$&$&+"%2"#! /+$#53!5+ 33 &- &-($33 /"$))( *3" 2+2"+!7($%= =($%!"& &!$% ( $3 *3".81$#1-"$&"% %5&-"+'= ?   

       

   

   

   

         

 





        





 

  !

 "   

    

  ! 

"

 "

1" 22"33 &!=23 $&!$% +"$& "/53 +"#&-22" 3 / $&%!

!1"#&#5++"&!$&-$&/% #!.81"+"*7!1"%5$!+2+"=")2!$&($%= =($% 3 &-)" %5+$&/: & 3%A) +3 %5&-"+!1"$+!"& &#7.1 %*""&-$%)$%%"- &!1"/+5&-!1 !!1"% 3"-""-- !"-,BC."D"#5!"-*7!1"8&"+. 8 %$&+"%2"#!3 &-)" %5+$&/: & 3%) +3 %&"%%"&#".!1" 23 $&!$%8"+"+"<5$+"-!#3 $)!1"2+"=")2!$&<5 !1""&!$+"3 &-%3- &-&!2 +!!1"+"5&-"+!1"$+!"& &#7

+&5+ / $&.3" +&"-#5&%"3 22" +$&/&*"1 3!1" 22"33 &!=23 $&!$%%5*)$!%!1 !$&($"8%! !5!+72+($%$&%3 8.!1" !"& &!# &#3 $)2+"=")2!+7+$/1!&37$&!1+""%$!5 !$&% &-%$&#"!1" 23 $&!$%8"+"5&-"+!"& &#7$& & +" )" %5+$&/: & 3%A) +3 %.!1" 2+"=")2!$&+!1 !("+73 &-$&%!" -: & 3%) +3 %. 33"/"-37%3- ($-"% 3"-""-. +")"&!$&"-.8 %%5/1!.!15%.*!1!1"5+!%*"38 1 ("#))$!!"-$33"/ 3$!7 &-2"+("+%$!7$&-$%)$%%$&/!1"%5$!&%522+! 1$%#&!"&!$&.1"1 %+"3$"-52&!1"05-/)"&!+"&-"+"-*7!1$%5+!$& ./  / .011.2/ / .

3.1+4546$&7  &-!1"05-/)"&!!1"&E*3"52+")"5+!+"&-"+"-$&8.

011

./ / .

3.1+ 4476$&79  &-.!1"+"+".!1"

338$&/  %5*%! &!$ 3  <5"%!$&    3 8  +$%"%  +  -"!"+)$& !$&  *7  !1$% 5+!'= ?61"!1"+!1"!"& &!853-*""&!$!3"-!%"":2+"=")2!$& !1"2+2"+!75&-"+!1"!"& &#7!1"("&-++!1""&!$+"

9

3 &-9

+ &$ )4"+) .3" +&"-#5&%"3 22" +$&/&*"1 3 +"%2&-"&!%5*)$!%!1 ! %2"+!1"05-/)"&!+"&-"+"-*7!1"$($%$& "&#1!1$%5+!$&-  / .011/ :  / .+456$& 7; &- %8"33 %!1"&"+"3$"-52&*7!1" 22"33 &!=23 $&!$%.$".8 .

1 +!1"+$/1!2+"=")2!$&# &*"#3 $)"-<5 !1""&!$+"3 &- %3- &-&!8$!1+"/ +-!!1"2 +!!1"% )""1 % 3%#$!"-!1" 05-/)"&!+"&-"+"-$&68:/3 / .011&  / .+445 /</

31146!

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

1"+"<5$%$!" )5&!&A.$".!1"2+"=")2!$&)&"7& 2 + /+ 21!1"23 $&!.$!1 %*""&%2"#$$# 337)"&!$&"-!1 !$&# %" !1"+"$%%)""+++$&# 3#53 !$&!1" +" .!1"&!1"2+"=")2!$&*" /+ &!"-$&+"%2"#!!1"3 &-.81$#11 %&!*""&%2"#$$# 337%5/1!

7

&)7($"8.!1"$&-$&/%+"&-"+"-*7!1"&E*3"52+")" 5+!$&8.

"1 11 +853- 2237$&!1"2+"%"&!# %" + !1"% :"*+"($!7.<5"%!$& $$2%"- &-!1" &%8"+/$("&!1"+"!+" - !15%'= ?



   

     

 

   

     

   

 

 # $    ! %"

            

    &     



    

   

 ' 

  ! %"  

        

    (

        

    

     

     

     

   

 

"

1" +")"&!$&"-$&-$&/%!1"&E*3"52+")"5+! +" $&#&%& &#"8$!1!1"2+($%$&%!1"#!$)$3 +$%!1"($"8! :"&*7 !1"3" +&"-$&/3"5-/"!1$%5+!$& ./  / ."1 11 1"  $($%$&  "&#1. 81$3"  +"&-"+$&/  !1"  $&-$&/%.  1 %  &!  ! :"&  $&! #&%$-"+ !$&  !1"  -"$&$!$&    !1" 2+($%$&%    "#!$&     #3 5%"

5+!137!1"#!.81$#1$% 223$# *3"!!1"!"& &! &-.!1"+"+".$&)7 ($"8.!1"05-/)"&!$&8.

"1 11 $%05-/)"&!$&2"+%& ) &-&!$&+")1" 22"33 &!=23 $&!$%#53-&!#3 $)!1"2+"=")2!$& !1""&!$+"3 &- %!1"78"+" -)$!!"-37!"& &!%3 &-)" %5+$&/: & 3% A) +3 % &-&!: & 3%) +3 %("&!1$%5+!$& 68:/3 / ."1 11 +-$-&!1 (" &## %$&!+""+!!1"2+($%$&% "#!$& !1"#!



&($"881 !1 %*""&*%"+("- *(".!1"05-/)"&!% &- -"#+""%*!1!1"5+!%*"38 +"&!%5%! $& *3"$&!1""7"%3 8 &- +"1"+"*7%"!= %$-" &-!1"%5$!!1" 22"33 &!=23 $&!$$%1"+"*7-"#+""- "#+""=%1""!*"2+"2 +"- ##+-$&/37 1" 22" 3$% 338"-  <829 + )(*$

81.

&',-%