Deepinder Singh Dhillon v. Narinder Kumar Sharma And ORS.

































  
 

  !

 
 "  
 

 "#$ "$%&'($)#$*+$, -.

/   

 



















































  


 

 





































  
 ' 01  (
(" 12 1

,$&$#'


 

 
!"
# 



$


!
%

  &
$


&'


(   '
!"
#
")   (" 12 1 . * 


"
#
+'
 
")  
  

,

-

%

,,



"
. #
 
( 
#
(!
 "   / 0"1


#
 


 
"
#
 ")  



+
#
&+
2 ! +'
# 
/ 
0
+'
("'
% "

% " 

3/45
%
"

 
+'
 
 ) "

 

6"

  "
74

73
 % "
44

4
#
  
#
 

" 8.
9#
 
: 
"
#
8.:;
 %

!
+

!
3 * 

%
"

 
+'
 
")  
 % 
#

< 


 
+
#
% "


!
 % 
# 

//47

#
% "



=
% "




 "


6"


+
+


%   '

!
#
"
7
#
 
"
#
8.
+'

!

+
 '
 
+'
 
 ) "
%
1

































/ 

 
  '

* 


%
%! 
" 
+'
 ( 
0"

#
 
( 

#!
#
 

 57/47

 
 

#
! "

/=7/47

* ")  
 #
#

!%
"
   
"

 
  '

=
% "

%
 
 +'
 
( 
0"


=8/47
,
 

 
  "
%
#
+'
 
")  

/8/47 % "


"
"

#
"  
+# 
 
(  = * 


+"
#
 
 
"


  
 
 
#") 





 
5


#
 
  6"

 
+

+

+
 "1

 


,

-
#
 
((

"
 


 
6" 
#
%
 %

"
#
"
% !
#
1

"
#
 
"

+

  . * 
"

+


 


+ #
#  
% 
" 
 



!
!"

'
 
  
 
"
# 

!
  '
+
# 

!
  '
,
=

+
"  

0
 
"

 "!"
+"


+'
 
( 

0345& (677 #8$,0

-9 :;(

 <


 

    



    





 

    

   

      



   !

 "

#      





   

 #

 



































3





$   



#   





 





   % %  &   

  '

 %    (  )**+!%,,!

&  

 #

   



    

    

- -



0(*,(=85&3$,#8>&3(=8 #8$,&0 /9(7));(7),$*$
7,#
&$&--?
"#"'

 
#

6"


% "


%

+'
 
>
(   








.$$  '  



 



 

?
,
 
!%
#
 
 
 
"
"
+

&"




 
 


 # 

+
"  
   5 ,
 
+"1 
" '
 
! 
 

 
   
5


#
 
 
6"


"
#
"   
'



 
% 


 

 
+
 +
 "1

 

,

-
#
 
((

% 

"@'
 
6"

#

+

+
&"
 


,,


#
 
((

%
 !
 !
#  
"
#
8.
*
 

 # 
 
( 
%
 " 

 "  
"#"
! 
 

 
# 
 
  5


#
 
 
6"

% "

 


+%


  

    

 



+,)*/012

"3 '4

 " 

 5 %' "% 6  "!

  6

'

































=  #% 

  

4 %4! 8  9

9

%:%;(  !

    .;  %  &    '   4 

  #

 ' 4 ;:7 89

%:%; ( #    ;





' 

1

      ;

    '

     

  

  

  

)+  

  : <,



 

) 9

:

 "

"

= 

    

  6  

'

     %

*  

    :   <,      '          ' 

   "         ;

 

    = 

  "

5 >    

 '



 ' 

/







 

 #

%'

?.$ 7 8%'

?$$ ?@  7 8

"  "

.

;

%&  '

4   

;





'

19 

1 





  "



  

   

 "   ;

 %'

?.$  8



*,   3   3 ' 4    "! %'

?2$$?@   8

A /,   3     "

'4    "!   

 '  

 ;  7 8

%:%; (

 

  "  '    ;

    

  

   

       

    

   ?

'

 

   

  

            '

  

  )+     

  : <,   '  



 = 

  "

5 >       

<

  ;

  

  

 "

 '



 9%%

































.

9

% 5"!  



'

    %  :8 9

9%%  +,**    '    "!'



 )9

:

 "

"

"

   ;

 

 '





  9  %  %  %      

  



  

)+  

   : <,

 

)9

:

 "



" '

  

 

*

  

   ;

'   " "         "   )29

:

 "



"#



 

  ;





= 

 

  #.

% )2 9

:

 "

"# - 7 
 


'
+

 
2 
(
# 
% # "

 
8
+!



# 
"" +# 
 
( 
 
 
"
+

 +
"
#
"

 ""
 
 
")  
'

""
#
 #"
 

""
 
!
#
 
#% 
#
 
"


  #
 "

9A ';
% 




#% 

! # 
"  
#


1


,
#"

 
 
  8
  "
+!
 


 "
% !
 


 ) "
!

'
""
% 
: 
"



 :
 
 
'
1
#
"


 ""
# 
 
#  '
+ 
!
#

#% 
< 

 
4 


2 
"
#
 ) "

  "" 


# 
 

 
"   
#
 
" "
+
 %

+
!

""
#
 
 



































- 

 
 " 
 
5

7
 
"
 
 
 
% 
%  '
""
+'
  
##"





@#

+
"




+
#
 
&+  
+ 
"

% 

"


2 
"
#
 ")
+
"  '
+# 
 
( 
 
 
+&"

)"  
#
 
"
#
 
8 #
 
 


"
'
!
# 

 
" 
 
"" 
 
4


+


!




  
 

 
 " 
 
5

7
"
 +

 


 
"   
#
 
 ) "
 !  8 * 
( 
 # 
 " 


"

B
%   

 
5

7
#
 
 
6"

% "



  "

 
 
=

1

'

 


 


 ) "

#

#
## !
+# 
  

##"
+'
%'
#
""
'
 
#"
    

% 
 )+"
 
% "

 

"


 ""
 
 
#"



 
+'
  ) "
 
  4 C 
 



+

# 
#

 
 
  #
 

% 
 
 
")  


"!  " )%
#
 
('
:

 
0  
 ! 2 :
% "




 

#
3./475-)
9* '
#! 2"
*%'
* 
6


A 
!'
>
';
'

% 
 
6>"!
6  
&+

%
(   2
9 (2;
D 1 

% "




"



































5 ## !

* 

 

 
 

%
 
 ":
('
:

 
0  
 !
2 :
# % "




"!
% ) " ) 
%
%
 &" '
:

! 


,
 
D 1 :

:

! 

,,

B  
D 1 
% "


 

#
#
#
  
+'
 
"
%
=4.
( 
9C
( 

C! 2"
';

=7.
( 
9C
( 

6

'
C!
2" ';
"!'

0 
"
C

! ( 


% 
 
 
("
D 1 
 "
  
 


% "

+

 
#

"


## ! +# 
  
##" 

""
#
% "


  
 "


 ""

 "
/3
#
 
"
#
8.  * 
"
#
 
")  

 
  
 
 
 



 
 

 
 
# !
2
(
'


#
 
   'E
 

 !
2
('


 
 
'

# 

 ! 

""
#
% "



#
'
#
"

('
 

@ 

+


 
## !
#
+'
 "  
% 


+
 %
"
% 
('



 "


'

""'

 
 @ 
# %



'
 
 
+
#
 
"  






 

,

+
# 




+ #
#  
"
 
!
 @
"
C /-

 "
'
"
 
"

+

'
#
 "

+
"

 
# 
#
## !
%
#
+1


"
+'
 
"
% "

"
!

 
##"
#

































7 ! 
"   
C 
 
 
#
 ) " 
"
#
 
## !
#  

'
+'
 


#
+
!
  ) "
% 
  

( 
 =/48
* 
( 


 !
(
7
#
 
% "


%
+') 
#
 
 "!
"   % 
+"
C"
,

! 



!
"
 


 
'

 
"  
#

)


 
 
,
#"
 
# 
#
 
  (
7
#
 @
## !




#%
   

           / %




#
" 
 
")  



## !



' 
+
 
+
#
 ('
:

 
0  
 !
2 :
% 
 (2


#
 
%
 &"
%
+'
 

('
% 
 
 

("
D 1 

 
"
#
 
"

 



 

%
!
 
'
+ 

#

"

+
#  
 !
2
(
% "

 
"

   

# 
 
"  
# 3 * # 
 



+
"  

 
&" +
%


@


% 

4 

1     "    9 

  

   



  

  



  

   '

3 ;

)0-

 
@
%


#



+'
 
( 


 "  

=/48
2  "
#
 ) "
%
%! 
+

"

































8 '
"
 "'

 

+

#



"  "
'

% "


%




+



 
 ")  

'
"
%
+ 

"
 +
#
 
(
#
% "


%

 " 

 ## !

  
##" 
* 
"
 
1

#

"  

 
"" 
 

  = * 
 "
"
#
 



 
"+  "

0      5&  &&%#  ,  "$*%,#% $ ,*&  ,0

;
9
@>;-:



% "

 ( 
% 
  
! 
!




1%
" 
!  " 
#
 
"  
+ !
 2 

   

 

     







  #

 

 

 

  

 

"



   

 

> 

>

  

 

  

 

   

    

  ' 

    "



)  

 "  



   % 4

    '      

 

     

 

 

     

 

 =  

   

"

   '

$ 

 :

 +)A

 '

 



































4    '



'

  

 

   8      '



     6

     "  

  "   

     

 

' "



" 



   "  '"  

"      

       

 "    

   

&"

 

" 

 

  

'



 

 #

$ C "4 >     

 6

 D     

   D :

 +)A!   

" 





   '



 "'





"            

   "  

      



  

+ 

D 

D   

 

 



' 

 

 "

 

 "'

           

  

     3  

   

"

  



   

 "





 ' 



    



8   

:



































       !  



 

 

  "

 

    "

 

   8

    

 

     " 

  

   8  " 

   

 2  

$  '

 

= 

    

    "       

   

'

    2   '     

 "

         "      

  ( :

C

 

"



' 8 '

  

             "     "  

    ("

 

 '

  

2

2 '

 "

    28    8   

  

    "  "





      

"     

   

 

   "  

 

     

     8         6

    "    

 

  

 "       

 

     "  

































/

8  

2 

$ "

 

  

 

   



  "

 '   "



8

 

   

       

 

 "  "" 

,    

   

     " 

 

    

   

            "

 :



 

:

 <!)! $ 

  '  '



  



 B2 D! '"

  '  

 



)!  '"

    '     

   6

E

      

8  '      

            

  

   

   " 

          "

  



  

'     

   



          

    6

' 

 

     

  



 

 ' #

 :

  +)  

  :

   A    A)   

































3 

 

  

"   

6

'

 '  

 F 

:

 <!! '

            6

 .

 >

    6

          

 

 

 

 '



"'

 8

6

"

'

3 





 

  

   



.

>

2

@> ! 

8

 

     



 

 

 ( (4:

       '

'   "



" 8 ' 8 



  

  8    8

$

'







  

" 5   #



"



#

5

'  



"       

 

  



  

 



- . * # 
>
( 
 " 




 " 
6"
(
#
, 

"
#
# 
 ## !
# 
"

"  
1
"

 
 




2 

* !
 "
"

 
=7
#
 $ 
 


+%


































=


 

 

  

 

 

 '

"



"  6

   

 

   :

   +)A    

    $            8   

 

       %   4

     

"     

   

    



   



 

 



1  B !G   

 '

1=

1

 "     

2 " 





 

 H )!  

 

6     

      



  

  "    " 

 

 



 

 "            

   @

8"    

$

 



+! 

 '  ' 8  !    

1 



A! 4 

 "

  "   " ' "    

?

' 

,!    

  = 

    -

































. - * 
 
# 
 
 
#



 
=
, "! 

 
 "
#
 
( 

 
=7
#
 $ 
  "
+!

 @ 

"
+ #
"  
 " '
%  
 
'
!

#
'

+"
#"

 ! 

0

  '
  !
(
7
#
 
## !

C /-
'
+   
" 
#
 
"  :
%
9 ;


+ 
 
#

9;

%


 
% "

'



% 


#'
+ 
% 
 
 



* 


"#"
(
@ 
" 
#
+
#  
"  


""'

 "

'
('


(  
!  
 
+


+ #
# 

 

%
 
 
 
"

 
"'
#  
6"
 "
%
" '
!
+ 
   
"
 
+
#
 
('
#
% "




:"!:

 " 5 *
# 
 

"
2 
(
#



 # 

 
"
#
>
( 

03& (8A,3#8,$5& ,7"###,6(B##8$,&0

:

:;(

 -
% 
 
"
#
A

( 

 
 "
#

""#
"  

 
2 !
+'
#  .-
+ 
("'
* 
 "
    
%
  +'
 
( 
"

#

"
+
>" #
 
#%


+
#
#


#'

+ 

 
#%
##"

!  ;

2

    

 (   %

































- 

"&   

'

 

 "  





<)**12

00),*12

!    





  &

;

/00  6    





+AA,12

"



!    





  '  (52*,2:2,,

" 



!  



"  2

   "

  "     '

 9'       

  



    ++ = 

)<) = 

%'";

A/5

;

< ( @C "  8: 

( 
 * !
+ !
#
 
>
( 

 
  


+%
  '

      



 2

     



G    2

 

;

/00    >

 







    %

         2

 '      >



8

   2

        >



    

'" 

#      

   16 



"    

  "      $

 "      

































5



       

        

 

    = 

 

  



G  

'

 '

 '"  



   

      

 





  



 

   

 

   '

  

  



   

G ' "    '   '

#

 :

 9 

         >  F

      '



       

  "    

 

  

: #

        "



 



 

"

     "

 

 

  

@ '    :

 <!!



$ 

8

  

  



 "





  

 



  

      

 

  = 

   

    "    

   $





 " 

 



        

    

   

































7  '



  :



 



  =    

                 

      

    



 '

  



1 2

 - 7 ,
 

#
 
( 
 
"

03&(8A, 3#8,$09&7),;

  +
# 
 
#"
#
 
 
" #
 


 
 " 
#
 

% 

    

6" "'
0

"
#
%
 !" ""
 

 
"  
 '
"
 ""



%

* 
# 

"
+ %  
#
0 %
7--

 
>

 #

  "
 A4. (..
% 


"
"
#
 
#  !
 " 
+"
 + '
%#
#
 

 "#"'
"! 

 
(
#
:9;:

 
""   
7
#
C 
/-
2'
 

%
#

 

 C 
 !
! 
% 

% 

" 
,
 % 
' 

 
:  :
" '
"

 "
  
 
#
 
 
"" 
% 


 

    
C 
"


'



     
#
 
 #


#
 
C 

% 


  


""
#

"


1'



 


 
 


 
1
% !
  


 #
#
 
C 


#
+

  
0
  "
#

('
"
+
 

+
@!
#
    
C 
+"



"



"'

































8

  
+

+
 
(':
+
 '


"'
"!
'
! 
# 

 #
+'
! 
#
+

"

 "


 
""'



#
    
#
 
('

* 
: :
# "
#
 



 



+ #
#
 
+

 " 

%
+  '


 
 
#
  

"
+
#
 
( % 
 ! 

+"
,


"!"
 ( 
 

""
#
" 
+@
!

 
#



#
 
 " 
@ 

 
## !
#
 "  

C /-
% "


1

#
"  

 #%
 

 8 2 
(
#  

%

#
 
( 
  
+@
#"
A48)4=)/472 ,,
 44/47

+'
 ! 
#
, 
 '
#
2%
 $"
 
"
" 
 

 
C /-
+'
%'
#  
,
98 ;

980;
#
 

C 
% "

 

 
+%
   9

  B !% 

!%

!%    " 

! 

  ?

' "

  "   !

 

 "  

!

 

 

"

!

 

 

"

































/4  !  

   

   

 "  5  F '

3 "  

  



' 

!  

   

   

 "        

  

!   9

   

   

 "   '     

' 

- /4 C 
# 
 #
C /-


 

 
"   
 " 
 
 "
#
"
#

"  
%


)  



 


" "
%  
!

'
+"
('

(
 
%

@ 

+
#   
 

!
 
 " 

 "'
"#'
" 
#
'
 
+
#
 ('
%
% "


"  
 )
)   '
+
" 
F

'
+



 
 
 
:
# ( ":
%
+






"! 

0
!

"

!'



+

 
%
@ 
#
" 
# " "
% ! 

+"
('

(
 +
  "
'
#
44/47

%
  '

 >"

 

  
%
"


 "


/45 0'
'
 "

#
 
 # 

 
 

"
+ B
#

!
"
'
"

 " 
% "

% ! @ 
#


 
"#"
C 
% "


%
+  


## !

 !


/45
"


 

































/ +

 
 "
#
: ':

 "'
 

+ # #


 

#
 
( 


"
# 

 
 %

'
!
 
##"
#
! 
+"
"
# &   "
 

 
"
+
B
 "!'
#


" 
#
'
 " 
% "

% 
! @ 

+ "

 !

"


" 
%

!
 ##"
#
!

"


 
"
 

6" (

 
( 
! 
% 
% 
 %  B

"  

 #'
C /-
% 
!
#  / C 
# 

 
( 
# 

 +
"
# "
# 


"

 
  :
"
# /45

 
 


#
 " 
#

+ % 
 ! 

+"
,
% "

% 
"'

+
#
 
(')(
%
% "


%
" '


""'

 "

% "


%

+ 
 "

"" "
%
"#"
C 

# "

 ! 
(@'
  :
"
 

,


-

%

,,



"
.
((

% 
 
6"

 
 

















9(" 12 1 ;

 "

+
/-
/48 
< 
1 ) 
G


F) /
<   +
G













F)