← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaESA/17/2017dismissed

Sheela Wanti Deceased Her Lrs. v. Krishan Lal Arneja & ORS.

2017-12-14Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal10 pages

      



 ! !"#$#%&'

(!!)*% #+!"!$!+ (,-.((!,/$00!))% $ 1$ 2,#$(%/),%!3%+ (!,$ !$0%+!% $ &

    

   

   

 



  

!"

#



$ % &    



 )* )+ ,)-   /

(

  0.  ,1 )1 ,)2   3

( %  /&

  



.





$ % & ( #4 0 5

!,"

6  (5   



 , ) 1*)

5  '( .0



$

 # 

 # 

7

(  5  0  

 )2 )* 1*8  /  

 .

   4 -)))79 )2 ), 1*-

 5 ( :.

# 3  



$ . #0  5 +) )+ 1*1



$ 5  ((( (  

 0 5   )1 )* 1*1

#%3&

 +8 1*1



$

;  <=. '



5( 4 -  0 ( 5 5 )2 )* 11>

  5  . 

 

5( 

 5  . 5 ?        )2 )* 11>  <=. '

 

(9

 

           

     

                             

 

   

 

                          ! "#

 $!%                

             

    

   

       

       &   

      '                     (  

     

 

  

    ) !+"

   (

 



$ 5 4 - 

  )* ) 11> )>  11>

), , 11>



$  ,) )* 111   .   5  /  %(.

&   5    5   5

(5 

 ( @

(5 

 ( 5 

  

  ,1  ,))-

 



$    ( 

 ,   + 5

,>  5

 

5

,>  5  <=.

(5   )2 )* 1*8



$ 0

  ;

 5

 <=.

(5

!2"

#  ( (.5

 ,   ) 5

,  5  )2 , 11>

5   

8 ) ,))*

.   7  

 /  %(.

&

 

 +) )2 ,))* @



 (.

   



$ 0 ( 5 

7

5   



$

0 -  ,))*

  (.

 



$ % & 0 .(

 5  5  ,),   '( ( 

.

 

.



  0

 A'(   ,1 )1 ,)2

 .  <0    )* )+ ,)-  A'( #  ( 

 A

 0 .(

 .  !>"

#  (  (     !"

#"

 #$ "   % %  &'()*&+   ,     ""  &('  *-.+ -" /0   "  ,   $  

 #"

  "

   !  " "

  !"(121 *34 0+56- 7 83   0    !  #"

 9"  

      ,

37 0*+&'':*(+  )1;<"!=  /  " #"

3 % 8    !"&''6*(+  * ,+6'5 , 4"!   !#"

 !   ! *;(+ (166   7  (6)      !     !"  #"

8"!

 ,   !" (1::-% 4   0  (5'

 (.( 

(



(

 (.( 0

B ,, 4( 33 #  ( ( (.5

  +8 #5 

 ,   .

 5 0 .5  . 

  5 .

 







(.(   

. ,   (

  

(.( .  ,   5   

!8"

#  ( (  ( B ,, 4( +

33



. 

 ( B ,, 4( , 33 .( (.( 0

  0 0  99 C     ( (5 

!-"

B     (  (.5

. 4( +

* B ,, 33 . '( 5    ( 5 0 . 5  . . 5  .  0  5  <=. '

)2 )* 11> #  (  

(   .

.



 

 5   A'( ( 

  

(

 D (

#  ( ( (.5 ( B ,, 4(

33     .



!*"

;

  (.5   ( 

!1"

# ! !#"

"! 4,(115*(+  *  + ;6' <=. '



. 4( +

* B ,, 33 . '( 5

 5 



( .  '

.

5 (

.  



. .   5  ( 

. '  0

0 5 .    !

, 3  !4#"

 

!

"3 , !4   !"(122 *+:1&  ( B ,, 4( +

33 

 5 

 .  (     0 .( B    

. (

 0 5   .( 

'  ( 0

 '

E '  

 2



 

(9

*+ ,    

      

             

 

 -     

  

 

(



 .      

     

  

          



  

  

   (







        

 /

 '     /     /

      

  

  

  

         

0

     

 !                        

       

  

     

   





       

        

0        

            

       

  



      

     

       . 

 

      

      

!

 

             

       



  

              

   

    

 



   

    

  

            

   



  

         

     

   

 

   

 

 

 

  

)

!)"

 0 . 0 

"3 !8,    !"#"

% ! 

 !"&'(6*&6+  * ,+;6

       (  '( 5

.





 5   B ,, 4( +

*



. 

 D

.   A 

 

 .(

 5

 F(

 F(5      4 

      #"

!3,     (11;*;+  -  2)5



 !  

 !#"

 4!

% !   !"(1:6- ;6(*+ !"

0

  ;

 

 7

0 .(  5 (

 55    0   )2 , 11> 0 <=. '

  .    ( 5 D 5   5 5   (   '  (

( (.  0    0   )* ) 11> )>  11>

), , 11> ( ' 

  )2 )* 11> 0. 5   0  ( (

(  

5( 

  5   5



   0  '( 



 0 5  (( 5 B ,1  ,))-     .



  .

 0   #

   



$ % &

5 0 5 3

( %  /&

  1  ,)    .

  

 (

 0

 5



 5

0 0    .

 0 (



$ % & 5



  

 

 5 

 .    0 0 ,  

( (



 <=.

(5

!,"

0

   ' ( (

  

 (    5

5

 5

2 , ,)-

 

  $  D7  G7 $  . G7