High Court of Punjab and HaryanaESA/54/2017dismissed

Neelam v. Kamla Sharma And Others

2018-01-08Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

! "#!

!"#$%&'( %!()!

$ % & ! '(")#* +# ! % & ! (")#* +# ! #" ,,, -./ ! +

"!& 0& !# "" .12332.4

" 56 &)& "0 7 &# &)& &#8( !"&0 !"'

"0""..2932.1

"56""&&# & &* "0( !"&0 ! )&" :!&*! #5'*&# +&" 56 ! : "&

""+&"0& ! &"# : #"&

"56!;#: #

-3/ +&" #5'*&# *&&0 !

+ # 5:&+#+# &0&##+"& " 6! &0! ! +

! 0" ! "* !:& : #: #+# 6#+! !

5"#+! "&" # 322<322= " ! + ( ! &" # 6 : #&*6 &"(5 !"* >#

&0 ! '* &&#( " &# " ! + ( +&" ?* &##+!# #+)&*&#0& !:&!# 6

!# &6 #+ ! # &0& # * !" +&" )&*&#&&#0& &'6!&"! : #:"56 ! # )&" # "" 21..3224 # **# #+ #@6 #+ ! # #+ )&*&# : &&" & ( :!&*! : "&

" 56 ! !# &6 # 2A293221")56!&0!#

:!! &#&&# : "&

")&"# ""..2.32.2 -</ ! #5'*&# +&" 56 ! : *# " 56!"* ""* )"& "!+* #+ ! 5&0 :&+ #+ ! &0! ! "* !#" *&"!!+&"!)&*&#&&#&!& &"&)&"

**&6"! + (

""!&&0&#&!& &"&)&"

**&6 #!&0!#

&'6!&: # "# 5)&*"#21..3224!?* &#: +&"56!"* !#" &!& &"&)&"

**&6"# #: #+# 6#+ ! &0!!"* +

! *&"!!5&0 "# " #+ ! & # *

&6 # 5 #: #+ !

#+ ! "* "# " ! "6 5 **" # ! &0! #

( ! +# ( ! "&" !

&# " 56 ! #5'*# B ! * #+ ! #5'*# B & ! ! "* " !

5" : #: #+ !"& " 6"+ !& "!( !! &! &"!

&#'& &0!& &#

&##+! 6 " ! !# &6

-A/

#+! *# ":# " !#:! & &#'& &0! +&" !& " 6 #5'*&# ( :!&*! : "&

" 56 ! ?* &0 #

)&" # "" 24..32.3 ?* &0 #

! # *# "" +&"&0 ! ! '

"0 "5# !" *#&)":&! &#'& &0!&# # * ! #+ ! ?* &# "" 24..32.3 : &&" & " &#! + (!& " 6#5'*&# : +&" 56 ! # ! ?* &0 #

B&)& "0 7 &# &)& &#8( !"&0 ! "&

" ! #5'*&# )&" # "" .12332.4 56 !#"&0 ! ! +&"&0 #+ *#

&# !) # 5 &" 56 6 #+ ! *# !# &6&"!#+!#5'*# ! &#'& &0!& & #

&# #+ ! "& " " ! !# &6 ! "6 5 '*" ! #5'*&# +&" 56 ! !) 5 " " #+ ! # !?* &# !#

!)# 0&)6+&"&0& *#+

#+!)&C@@)&C! 6&D &##! !D &##+&*# 5"*&""&! &&# !"# "& #*

&6# 5 #: #+ ! 6 "" .12332.4 : &&" 56 ! ;#: #

)&" '

"0 "" ..2932.1 -=/ ; " *# +# !

5&" ! ! "* ! 0"6 +&" ! )&*&# &&# & !& &"&)&"

**&6:&!# "& *# &0!&

#:!! !

: #: # # 6#+!# &0&#: * ! #*&"!& +#5#: #+! (5 ! *&" #5"# "6* ("* & : 5#! # &0&#: +# :!&*!!& "&0 #6 &; " *# *" &* #

!! "#$ % "%&'&$ () " & *** !##"#)$ %%+(("

5&"!!& " 6#5'*&# " 3.

E1 !)#5"*&""56!?* &0#

+ +##:&0 #*"

&5&

!)5 & "56! &# !) # 5 "*&"" & ! :!&*! !) & 5:! -4/ ! #! !"( " *# +# !

#" *" &* # &,** -&

#./# 01.

*& 2* 34 * !!!" $%"$)!.

*5"-$4 -&6 "-$ 4 !!)" $ %"$ ).! " * 4* !#!" $ )+. "

5&" ! "*& &# " " 56 ! # # &# !& #+ "# " " :# " #

" :& 5 #" # *!0 & # & 5:! !D &##+& :# " 5 + # +# "*& &# 56 ! *# #

! 56 6"6&0! &# !&:&!!"# "*# )#&")&*&# " ! *!D &#:!! "# "

# ##!

#: #: #+! 6& # ) +*# &*# &" &0!D &#:!! ! ?& "!'

&# !&#+"# ""5:! ;"# " " # 5 ! #: #+ ! "& &6( "*& &# #+

# # D &# #+ & :& # #

(5 :! !D &##+&: "& *6"*&""&! 56! # (!!"*& &#:# "5

-1/ ! & * ( ! #

5#: !) # *#" #&#+! 6( ! "*&""!

#+ !"* 5&0"# " -9/

E1 #)&" "6 # ! !& " 6 :!# * & * & #5&&0 #

&# 56 ! "* ! &*&# * 5 +&" 56 !

# *#&&0 #+ "& #

&# + # ! &#)5 6

*!&*&#(!?* &0#

! #: # "'

"&* #D &# &0# &0! (&"& & ! 6 & &0 5: ! &* "&0 !# #+

0 3.

<= ( ! #)& &# !) 5 " ! 56 #: &0 ! ?* &0 #

# "&) #

&##+! 6#!"* &+*

6(56

#)&06

#5# "56!"* :!# +

#)* ! 6 ! & * ( !

+ ! #

*&" ! ! & & #

&#( ! *&" ! ! !"

"# ! 6# &#'& &0! -E/ )&"6( ! *# #+ ?* &# & &0 # #+ :# "#&)#)6

*!" &&#D &# ! 6 & )&: #+ &# &" "#: & &,* *7 8 "5 $ " *& 2*7 8 "5 $ !+&"&0 *# ""56! # :# "##

5:! &

&(&++&" +# " &&0&D ! 6 -.2/ )&:#++* "*& * * #+!* (

*! &

" #5 "*&""& ! ?* &# & &0 # #+ &&#:! ! *#& #6#*# &" !

#+ "# ""!D &##+#:

!&:# "5+ # # 5 " &" 56 ! *# #

& # & (&+&&&"566#+! -../ & " &*&#+:!#5'*&# # *

&6#5"*&""56:6#++ &0 &

!&)&:#+ &#&""#:& 5&5 '&8

&2* 5& * !##"#$ % "$ 1) ( ! ?* &0#

& ##5&0"#"*&"&

)#5'*&# 56:6#++##:&0 #*"

#++ &0&

"! #: ! # " )&"* *! #5'*&# * 5

'*"

-.3/ )&:#++# &"+* ""&0*& * * #+ ! * ( "&

!& &# &&# :&! &5 6 # ! # 0 ! & "*&"" D ! 6 & # # & #

&**# "*:&!: %!()! %&) 292.32.9

&* F!! #"B >&0 B# F!! # 5 B#