Sikha Batra And ORS. v. Shyam Beer And ORS





    
 



  !"" ##$$ %"&

' !"" (#      
 )"

"*+,'$-. "##$$

"(."""-. ""#/012&"3 #'  





 5##$"6+"&$ "+ 7#"-$ ##$8" '$  !!





 9" ##$$$:-#"'"6&"  ""-&8;$$;&6#

 "



 # $% )"1

  !"1:- "%8.

 &# 1 " ( < 1" %;"

!"-&"&. "-8"&+$

# &"  ==  "%$ -   + "# ' !"1"."-." +1:"-5/:

22&"3 #'>1&"""& 8"+"+" /(?,@A """""+"& $ +  #&(0$&%;" !" #.$.++"&  "+$ -0- %;"!"  ( ?:"".$$+"/9(0A ++"

,:$" #B":8+".8' ( ? "

$#&+#"#""&B:""" .$$+ $+"-)$ 3'-)$:$-
"8 : 8&=0 -+"& "C&-"&$$' ":#&:':"""& +"B 8&#"#"+ #"D$ -           #$  &    "   +$+".++"& 8'"#/1 '

!"5 ":"#"#$
2(/0A0 0  "      &"    @    0  2)3  : "+")$ 3'-)$:$"+#"-

%;"!"-:#":+8&'" :"+(A-D#" :$:" + "" #".$ $$"':" +EE$ ""        #"D$   :"  #  &#

0 "+ 2 '8 "$+$" ( ?- "$8"&+$ #$E

? "%"& ' !""E.+/=AA !#:""+".+"&   /      $  #  :  +.    "# (#/##"#".-&:" #"+6#"=== (#/0#&##""+  +&#$$+ #$.$.+ +"& "& :$$"#/.8 $$'.$." $.:$$#$ :"+$ #"+".8$B  #$&&$"".

"B": ":"'B'""8&"-"&$$'+ "B$ :"#&#"+ "+:"+"#-+"& :&": "#"" @A0=A8;:  "& ".":$+.$.".

 $$ #     #$+      #"-  $$:+  &  :" "   7"%;"!"( ? "

 .&$"-: #$&"+$+ ".+"& /(?,@A8'"#/-:8' "#/&":"#/0-$$+F ))  2&/#".-:"#""$  #--: &" : F)) 0 7""#/:$+.$. ".+$ --F)(0  ($ !#"$.&##"""#. $  ""+"+& -5"8&$&/     +    $ -  &  /0  +  "#  /0- "&$$' $ # 5:"$#"D$ 

  !" " %)/A++".'. #"""##$+:"-::+. "#$'"#/0##"" 2."$"&$"#"8++ "&+""2 #&+:"&8$ $8$8 5+5"8&$&/"8.&$' ""& 8&#:"+"#"$: ##"$ .>"5"8&$#"&: $+:" $#" #&"

A

== "%$ 5 "#" " $."'"$$8"'#".$.- &#"&"C&"#"."++& 8':"8$&8#"#"#$" $ ;&"#"&#".$&"&"'-&"+&$'#" '+ "8&.&$8#&7$$+ :.$&"-'" 8&#"#" #"88$
&""

"- == "%$ #    :$"  $+$  2  :      #".  #" #  ##"-:&;&"'":"#"#"'  +"$+$"#".#"-:+ $$"     9'#"  $  ##"        8  #  :$ ;&+  &  '#    #  5  5"8&$         8.&$'-:"&$ ""+;&5 $ &&$$'#"."#/:&" 8'"+$+".++"& - "&$:%;"!"( ?$"$.5 $ &"$:$$& "'. "+"5"$. #" )7 8"

+1 #$" $-)7A <& "-' :)705;#$ +-$ 3&" &8 .$ ?&$ +"- )$:$  
2( /0A0  0 "  &" @ 02)3:"+")$

3'-)$:$$""  ')705;#$

=

+-$ 3&"

?

-)$:$- ' !"1"# /8&#"$"&" @  02)35"+"
2(
 +:" +$+#""."+"& -&+ "+"
2(8'$8$"+$+ $&.$')7 8" +1 #$" $&+ .+"$++"#":#$ + 8""8'#$ #$8& ":#8$':.+8:."8' &1"& ".""".+ "$++"#":#$5"+"" $ :"$&$'&$  #$ "+":"+
2(+#"':-: " 5+&"D& 8 #" #"-  :      " $  "'      "+"+ 

+G8$"88'#$9: #"&$" 8" + 8 :#$":

+&"##"
2(86#$"$'8' )7 8" + >"&$"##$$D$ #$ $#'  8" +""8'5"8&$)72 6 -&"

       

     !"#$ %         &  '

        ()  !

@ #* + "  %   # 
" , " #      "  -

" $  
 #  "
        
  -         .#        )#
 #     #   /" # 0     ""   ) "       
 
   #- 

 
" 

  #

#  #  " -

      "  
# 
" *    " "   
"  
"  .  
& !12/3%#  #        #"&$ +:$ #$+&".+888'#$ 8$ ##"#"
"  -8

&":$'+": &#"&/:C& ':-:&"$$'  "

3&"D5"8&$-:"8+.5 3&"D5"8&$"&G &:$+ "& #""&"  $  5""-         :  &+      &$$' &##".$ 8&$&##"" ."$ "$#55"8&$:8.&$':"+8".+

 . 8" +$#$   #"/0:"5$ 6 ":  $')7A <& "-:&##""   "$  # 9   '  :  ";  8'  5"8&$  " &.+" "$'"" <& ": ':
2(:""# 5:$##"5"8&$+"8$. #'$8:"+&$$"5. &8'$ +&"8&5"#/1 "."+"& "#&##"8" 5"8&$':&$##+

 $"$'-"#/1:""&  ":" "& 8$++ &5"   "#/  "8&$'+" +& 8'"+$+".+ 5&&+.8.&"$  +  "#  8&  :  :"+$'    +    $ - &$ $'$+ $$ #
+& / 8$"."+.&" $ +"#55"8&$+.' #+&/ #$' ##+ &/#".-8"$'$$  "$ #5$+"+"&+ .8+.5:"#$+$$'&8$ 8&88':'###$

  "+$'-##$#5:"&"##$ " 5"8&$:" $ #"""+$"&$" #"5$ "#/0.$"'$. :"#/8+6#"55"8&$:&$6 """+& #":

" "##'""5#""&+ "&$""##"8"5"8&$A 

"""#".88&" "-5"8&$ '#"8 "".$8$8" 

#% !";

  &'()'(**(+,-.(/0,1(+23.4  (,0- &'()'(**(1-*)+56(  (,0-