Ashok Kumar & ORS v. Kulbhushan & ORS





    
     

   

 !

 "#$% " &&'' (% $%'

"%""  )&

  !

  "*+,&(  &&'' (% $%'

"%"" )&  "# $%

& &
%
&
%% -

. -"!/

"&&''




&01
 2 

 .$34'!/  .,"!/

"&&''
 2 

 ."%.%!/

& 


 .+.,"!/

&0


 %
&
%% ' 6"7%, "''& 


 2 

 3""&&'  ' &,%   /"'4""#&'2 1

06"' &"/

    8  "  '      9'   6 %'!  $'

"        :"  6 %':  /    

  4   2

 -  &&'  "/    '  8  "  '   " &4 %'%

" +//42

 3 8 7% ""4 &%. "("'4 ' &" +/$% 96

04 ' "& " "+/96

0 4 ' 8"44 +/#, &% "

+/%7%% 8"  /"'4""

#&'2 1

0!%%",',/, "

,  /"'!    9  ,  ,    ;<=

<=

!  &     6"    >  +/  $%     '        & , ,?,@"" 8' :+/+< !$': A6 %',"/!  % '%"+/$% "4""

#&'2 1

0%",',/, "

, 9 ,,;<=

<=

8&A 6 %'4"',"  "  
2!

B=&

"4% 
1!

B=%


1!

B=4"

"  C&% " ', "'

&'' %'' "4% B 4

%'&'  4&&'% 
!

B=%

' % 44' >4  "%


1

B=% ' '/

44" >& "%

B=44 % %'D&%

! B=44% 'D&%"

,,/ "E%% &!' "/

'"&&' A %'   " &&'' > '   ,% "

, &" 

6"%

/ &/""4&   %"",""  8" '6 %'F!"4/! '8"" &  %  "  /'  "    =4#       

7%,  9%()*+(,
+-./(+0123(+4 %*2*)1561/-.- /(+(4&1)7*(+5)71/-  8 *6*,

(92(1+1/(,
+-./(+0123(+4%*2*)1561/-.-(+. (2,*(- 7.7/. (2(+5)71/! 8 *6*, A  %'    "  &  4"'   %,  " ,%     8  '  %'    "  &&''!  %

  " E% &" 4 %'4""

''  %"" F%

"" &"

,"'8!"%! &%,42

 %&"' F"/"'%' " & "/, "%,""4"" ' 6"  &&''  >  '   "/  ,''8  &'  "  %,@",%&!" 8'

:+/+< !$':6"' "/D -G .%  .,"' " ,? :"''"!

$':  , ,%'%!,% 
1

B=&

"-G """

 &'8 +/"8

%

B=& " %+/" %7"  "  '       ,    8 ,?,  "  4  "  6"

 %"D -G0$ '!4"&""" ""%+/ "'8 
1!

B=& " 9% '%,99 <D- -2!  <D-2  "4,  &&    "      F&  8 '  9#-3!&",&"#-#-
4 &%&/"+/4& ,A6 %'" ,"'8," 8 -G0$ '"/ ""4"4B'' ""% E%F !<D- 1"'8 '' '"  & & 4""4 8F" .,"A%' " % '"48' 4F"

.,"$ ')A%' "&&''% ' 8""/"D ";4/!"  !"% ''8 &/ & ,F"/4 " !

" 4" " "'8  '84,&" 9%7% F" %' D "!7% D&  "


B=& "F /4 ",%' 9%" /(+(4 &1)7*%&! % %%&&" 0 
0

B=

!"4 8'" 

!4""#  " 
0!

B=& "F /4 ",%''4 8";:

9%






 

 
  
  



 

 )9)9/' !% B    &&'!

" 8  ,       "       

B=0

=0 

&&'8, %'&'  ! &8 "' 
 !

B=

D D 6"' '' 
1!

B= "  %'D&

B=' 6" 44' 
0

B=% ' %

 
!

B=F  "7%, 9%   (92(1+1/(,
+-./(+0123(+4%*2*)1561/-.-(+.

(2  ,*(-  7.7/.  (2 (+5  )71/  !  8  *6*,    0

  "9%    ' &7/* (21+1/(,
+-./(+0123(+4%*2*)1561/-.-1(+):(./(+5 )71/-' ' >& " ' 
0

B= % ' &'% 9' !"%!''

& 

!

B='
% = A &8

D D 
 !

B= A &%'%

0

B= A ''%

0

B= A 
1!

B=
%'D&
1!

B= )(,

!

B= 6" % &'84"&&''  ""&&'!'8!"''% " % '%' /&&'''"  1C &% "" % " ', "&''

'? &&  % & ,'  "'' "  D %' " 6 %'&   % & % "' "''%

G"  "   /       "   %  

&!


 2 

&  %*-(*,, 

 !



















.591   G""&#,B

HB G""& '

HB