High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/37105/2025allowed

Rachpal Singh Alias Sonu v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-05Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

+ + + +/+/6@ 6@ 6@ 6@/@7A+:

@7A+:

&'$(2' . $!, &'$(2' . $!, &'$(2' . $!, &'$(2' . $!,%"%.&@ %"%.&@ %"%.&@ %"%.&@4@ 4@ 4@ 4@ : @

#$!% B1'& & $!'- ='-.%. * &&'$(%!) B1'.

$!2'!& +, +, +, +, -'.'!&, -'.'!&, -'.'!&, -'.'!&,/

90 +1 +

90 +1 + +

0 +-1011'< $!42=$&'($-& '& & $!'-1 +-1 ) !2'- !"

-422 & $ $! %!)*1 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> 04170:

4170:

4170: +

1 -'.'!&.'$!2 '& & $! .*''!

!( '2%!2'-'& $!C5$(& $2'$(- 3 3 ! -$'2%-'4567($-.

$-& &8-1119:D'& $!C$(& -& ; "- <%-<.

&47 7($-.

$-&8 9:E($-"-!&$( -'"% &$& '& & $!'- !.'*'- !"

" $1@2&'21614 -'" .&'-'2($ -& '$(('!'. %! .

'%!2'- -'& $!.@7:4@A5$(&

-$& -% %". !2 .; $&-$ %*.&!'

'. &4 5@ 7($- .

$-& 8 &9:4&$

'&& $!-'&4 .&- &+!.

.1 1

'"-=3'!$(& ' !?%'

'.& $! .& && '& & $!'- .!

%.'2$(* ' !" !=$ ='2 !! '-& !

!"&$ & !=$ = !" <"$(

;/ / %.<

'"'2 ;($%!2 ! $..'..

$!$(& '& & $!'-1 1 0'-!'2$%!.'

($-& '& & $!

'- . &'-&'2& && '& & $!'- . !%.&$2; . !'16110'-!'2$%!

!.'

($-& '& & $!'- .(%-& '-

.%*3 &&'2 &

& & ' 3!2&$-; -$= . $!. $( ( & & =' !$& *''!

'2F & 4!2& %.4& -$.'%& $!.

.'.%(('-.(-$3 !

'-'!&2'('&.1 1 0'-!'2$%!

!.'

($-& '& & $!'- . &'-& &'2& && .2'

;'2!2 &;& '-'$(!!$&*'(.&'!'2% $!

!& '& & $!'-10'-!'2$%!.'

. (%-& '- &'-&'2 & & & '& & $!'- . .

.%(('-'2 !-'-& $! ($- 3$-'

!;'-.

%.4-'"% . -;'2($- -1 C1 0'-!'2 &&' $%!.'

. $

$.'2 & -'.'!& '& & $! *;

-"% !"& & '

'"& $!.- .'2" !.&& '& & $!'--'.'- $%. !!&%-'

!24& %.4 '2$'.!$&2'.'-='& '$!'..

$!$(& '-'"% 10'-!'2 &&'$%!.'

.(%-& '-.%*3 &&'2& && !.&!&*

' .*--'2*;& - "$-. $( '

'& $! 6 $( & &4 !

!2 & %.4 & ' .3' $%"

& &$ *'

2 .3 ..'210'

'-!'2&&'$%!.'

.''<.&$

'$!-'$-2%.&$2;'-& ( &'

2&'2C11 @ !& '$%-&&$2;4F .

.&<'!$!-'$-21 @1 =' '-2$%!.'

($-& '- = -& '.!2 ='"$!'& -$%"

'= -'$-2.$(& '.'1 1

'& & $!'- F. --'.&'2 $! 161 F '-' !(&'- !='.& "& $!

!F.-- '2$%&!2

!F.

-'.'!&'2$!11C1 $&

C -$.'%& $ $!F &!'..'. ='*''! &'24* *%&!$!' .*''!'G3 !'2&

2&'1

'- = $!&'!& $!.- .'2&-" ='

'- .'&$2'*&* ' ..%'..

-& $ !&'2 $! 2%- !" & ' $%-.' $( &-

. $%-& 2$'. !$& 2''3 &

-$ - &'& &$2'

='2''

!&$& '.'- = $!&'!& $!.4&& ..&"'4 '.& & 3; -')%2 ' & ' &- 1 $& !" &!" *

. *''! *-$%"

& ($-F-2 &$

!2 &' &

$$2 $( & '& & $!'- * *.$!2 !" (-$3 & -$'.. $( )%.& '$- !&'

'-('- !"F & -$.'%& $!'= 2'!'1 11 %-& '-4 '-%. $(& 'N 3! $ $-2'-. ..'2*;& $%-&4 *-$%"

& ($- -& *; & '& & $!'-4 !2 &'. & & & ' &- . !2''2

-$-.& !& !

!"!2($

;& '-'$(!!$&*' .22 '2% $!& '& & $!'-1.

'-%.&$2; '-& ( &'2&'2C11@( '2*;& '-!'2&&'$%!.'

'& & $!'- . -'2;.%(('-'2 !-'-& & $!($- '- $2$(;'-.!2 C2;.1 !&

.= 'F$(& '3&&'-4& '- "$- $.'2%!2'-'& $!6$(&

& .

.&!2. 2 %&'2 ! "

& $( & ' - -& ' $( & ' $!.& &%& $! $( !2 1 11

. $%-& ! )%2"3'!& & & '2 2 . H% F !2'- ='-.%. &&' $( H% F !2'- ='-.%. &&' $( H% F !2'- ='-.%. &&' $( H% F !2'- ='-.%. &&' $( (((( %!)* %!)* %!)* %!)* ..'

'2 !+ + + +/+/C6C C6C C6C C6C/ C C C C7 @,

,5@:I(&'--'

; !"

" $!& '-& $2' 2'!2 $(& ')%2"3'!&.$( (& $!9* '% -'3'$%-& !

%.. !-H &$$!=.1 $3'';14&&'$ ( -75:I*2%

3! !& &% ; =. 11 ;< 755: @I ='2 % 3

< =.1 &&'$(+ -.

&-!2!$& '- -4C7:7- 3 ! :C5CI I +$ 2+%.

3# %.. !=.1&&'7 $( ('

:-'

$-&'2. I - 3 !

' $1C@J 2&'2 2 611 & & '2 . K && .F. .

.%* .=.1

'&&'$(L'.& &'!" MIK & .

2 <-;# # ! =.1

' &&' $( L'.& '!" M4

' 0'=' &$

' 7- 1:

$1@@/ 2&'211& & '2.K+ +$ 332 3! ! ( <

=.1

' & &' $( %)-&MI - 3 !

' $15 $( 2&'2 @11& '2.$ H- .

!&-# $ -%.3=.1! $!$( !2 4

!2 !<%- %2 -; =.1 &&' $( + 2 ; -2'.

4 C7C: 7- 3 ! :6 6I . 24& %., K611

' - "

& &$ .

''2;

= & .('"%-2&$ -'='!&%!2%'!2 !G '&;!2$!'-!$3 !; !"&

-3'!& !& '* &;$(!%.

$='-- !".$ '& !&'-'.& = !"F *''!-'

'&'2 ;&%&'2 !& '-''!

*$='/-'('--'2&$% -'3'$%-&9.)% 2' . $!.$ '! !"% !'F= .&.$( ''2;&- .3 "3&'2 !&$& (%!23'!& - "

&&$ ('!2 *'-&;4 $!.& &%& $!1

' - "

& &$ .

''2; & $.'2 & & ' & 3' $( & ' --'.

!-'-& $! F $!& !%'. & !='.& "& $!4 !?% -;4 &- 4

-')%2 '& &3;-'.% &2%'&$ 3

' & 3' $( & ' $33 .. $! $( & ' $ $!.%33&' !&$ ( ! &;4 $% 2 *

'- !"!2?% <2 .

$. -'. !'?% $='--$F2'2$%-&/2$<'&.4& '=

-'..%-'$!& -$.'%& $!!2& - 3 ! )%- .

-%2'!& 3' ! .3% !!$&*'!'G%.'($-<''

!"& %.'2($-! !2'( ! &' '- $2$(& 3 - 3 ! )%.& ' .;.&'34 -& '- & 3 "%-!&'' $( .

''2; &- . !&'!2 2'

; *; 3 $. !" $! & ' $%-& !

-$''2F & F & -'.$!* -''($ %- $.'1 -.& ;4 & -$&'&.

&- 3 - .$!3'!&I .'$!2 ;4 & -'

%* .%.

$!2%'&$%!-'.$ ='2- " !.& & ' - .< & & '= 2'!' F

.."' $( & 3'4 & %.4 3 - !" &

3.'

(1 &"$'.F & $%&.; !"& &&

-' "-='1 %.'24 -'.%3'2 !

.%*)'&'2 &$ .; $" !2

%!2'-$!'-$%.$!2 & $!.1 ?%

; 3 .% !%.'2(-'?%'!& ;(

' (3 ;1

'-' . ;'& !$& '- $!. 2'-& $! & & . .&"'1

%.'2 *' !" !=$ ='2 ! ! $!&-*!2%!2'-& &45 !.' !=$ = !"$33'- ?%!& - "$%-.'!%3'-&'2%!2'-'& $!6 & $%-&. ! "-!& * &$ !

-$.'%&$- !2(&'- = !".& .( '2 -'.$!* ' "-$%!2. ($- *'

'= !" &

$(('!' -"'2J

'"'2!2& &4 ; !2 'G '2 & $%. &- . !$& $!

; 2 $

-'.. =' !-'-& $!I&$3 & "&'

'%.& $!.F'

.&$%-& !;

.'2&$2'('!2 3.'

(4*%&& '-' .!

F;($-.

''2;&- 1

.- "

!& .&!2& '-& $2' 2'!2 $(& )%2"3'!&. =' 22$F!.'- '.$( ( (%!23'!& - "

&.1

'$!'

&$( ' -& '.!'..'!& -&$(& 4"%-!&''2!2 -'.'-='2%!2'-$%- &- *'" !. F & & ' &% -'.&- !& .& $( & ' %.'2 !2 $!.'?%'!&

.&"'.4 !3'

;4 & ' .&"' $(

!2 -'= . $! .$ & & !; $.. *

'-3 .. * '!2=$ 2* '2'

;. !'

$(('!' &

& ' - 3 ! -$''2 !".

*' ='-&'21

' .

''2; &- 4 '- ;

?%!$!$(- 3 ! )%- .

-%2'!'1

=;=$ %3'$(F$-<!2& '-'.% &!& ' $ '4 !2%* &* ;<''

.& ''!& -'

%!2'-.&-'..!2.&- !1 $F'='-4& '.F$-2$(3$ '. !" !"$!& 3'1 &2$'.!$&.'-='!;-'2 &&$& 3<'. ($- .2 .&&' $( (( -.1

2'2 &$ =$ 2 $

-'.. $! !2 -'='!& !2 & -$.'%& $! ! $* "& $! &$ '2 .

& 1

'"%-!&''.'-='. .& '%.'2" !.&$

-'.. =' -'/ '='. & ' %.'2 $( & ' !G '&; !2 - 3 ! -"'.!2 .& ;4 & -$&'&.

/ *' $.& $- 3'3$- '. 2 33'2 *; &

' * &; $( & ' %.'2 &$ 2'('!2

'$!.'?%'!'.$( -'/&- 2'&'!& $!

!!$'!&4 &

-$='! $& '-F .'4 -'

. 2'

- =& $!. $( ) / ('4 %.%

;

$-&!&4& '*%-2'!$(2'&'!& $!$( = ;$!& ' !!$'!&3'3*'-.$( .

'& $( & ' 3&&'- F 2'.'-='.

'"& $!. ! & -'.'!& .' -'

&' &$ -'

& !" &$ $33'- ?%!& &; $( 5@1L

'$!. 2'- !"* '& & $!

& &;4& '$%-& .&$<''

!3 !2& 6$( &45@F 3!2&'.

%.'2 $!

; (&'- '- !" & %* 2 &.'

($(&F !$!2 & $!.F -'

& & ' %.'2 . !$& "% &; $( & ' .!$& <'

;&$$33 &!;$(('!'

'$!* 1

'.&- !"'!&- "$%-.$ 3%.& *' 3'& % $%.

; .-%& ! N'2 (%!23'!& - "

&&$.

''2;&- 1 !!$&*'-'!2'-'2!%"&$-;*;%!F

-& % - ;F '-'.% 2'

;7.: .!

)%.& ( '2&& ''!2$(& -$.'%& $ !!$& *' <'

& *'

!2 *-. ($- ! -'(%"' !- "$%-. 22$F! !'& $

'" .

&%-' ! &.F .2$34 !$-2'-&$ '.'.%!2'-& '&4 . -$= 2'2 %!2'-'& $!/$(& '&1 $F ';'&$& -$&-&'22'

;.!2.;.&

'" .

& =' %- $.'1$%-&$( F !$&*'$3'$3

& != $ & $!$ !$&F & .&!2 !"!;& !"$!& !'2

'& & $! !.'"$='-!'2*;& '- "

5@4 & ' $%-& 3%.& .&- <' )%2 !&'!&&$%-*& '3'!'$(2-%".!

&$( -!2'G '2 & $%.&- 1-$ $!

%.'4 - .<. &-!.($-3 !" -'/&- 2'

!$%&$3'!& & '& &$& - !

-"$4& '%!'?% =$

( '2 &$ $! %2' F & ! -'.$ !-'-& $!4 & 3 &&'. " !.& & !2 *'-&; "-!&'2 %!2'- & F $='-- 2 !"& '.&&%&$-;'3*-"$-'

&45@$%"

&&$*'$!. 2'-'2.

F$-2.4"-!&$(* !.' '-& "-$%!2$(%!2%'2'

; !&- 4!!$ $(& &45@1M $('& $!6$(& &45@ @ " !.& & ' *<2-$ $( %.'29.

'- "

&&$ ('!2 '-.$! *'-&;

--!&'22'

;. !& ')%2 -$'..4 !' & '-&&- *%&* '&$& '%.'2!$-

" ) $!*; $"'!&-'.$!.1! !2 = 2%

!$-2 !&' '- $2 $( & 3' *; &< !"

$!6$(& &45@1

'!.%-'.

''2;!2& 3'

;2 .

$. $( 2($-& '$!.& &%& $!$(.

' $%-&.

F'='-4& .$%-&!!$&&%-! .$!9.

&'3& !'(( '!;& &(-%.&-&'& F .2%&;/*$%!2&$'!.%-'& & &2$'.

$(! !2 = 2% 9.(%!23'!& - "

&.4

&4 !.&&%&'1L

'2' !"F & *

"$%-.$('& $!6$(& &4 $%. * !' *'&F''! & '" .

& ='

!2& '.-$.!&- "

&$(& '%.'2 !"'2 !-'-& $!4F & $%&)%.& ( * 2'&'!& $! !&$ %! & =' 3 - .$!3'!&4

'$()%.& '!2'?% &;1 &4

!('-'!' .& &F '-'& .

$!* ' & 3'4 -'.% & !" ! -$ $!"'2

-' $%. (%!23'!& - "

&. $( ('

F !24 . .% 4 $!2 & $! *'-&;

'&'2%!2'-'& $!6$(& '-(&.$(" ='!.'1 !$& '- ! !"&$$33'- ?%!& &;4$!& $&*'. 2&$*'('&&'-'2*;'& $!6 6 11 %-& '-4 . '- & ' . 2 %.&$ $2; '-& ( &' & '& & $!'- .

.&&'2 &$ *' !=$ ='2 ! 3$-' .' %!

!2'- &1 $F'='-4 & (&%3!!$ $&*'"-$%!2.%(( '!&*; &.'

(4&$2' !'& '$!'.. $!$( -'"% &$& '& & $!'- !& ' !?% %'.& $!F '!.' .32'$%& ($-"-!&$( -'"% ?%& ' !?%'

'.& $!*;-& $ !& !"% $!& (&.J -%3.

.&!'.$(& '. 2 1'

! ' !& .-'"-2!*'

'2 $!& ')%2 2"3'!&$(& $!9* '% -'3' $%-& !+% !+$ 213 - +% !+$ 213 - +% !+$ 213 - +% !+$ 213 - ---- .

2 =1 .

2 =1 &&' $( 11 !2 !$& '-4 &&' $( 11 !2 !$& '-4 &&' $( 11 !2 !$& '-4 &&' $( 11 !2 !$& '-4 7: 7- 3 ! : @ 7: 7- 3 ! : @ 7: 7- 3 ! : @ 7: 7- 3 ! : @I = . $! '!

! )%2"3'!& $( & $!9* ' %&& "

$%-& ! .' $(

- 2 - . - 2 - . - 2 - . - 2 - . =1 &&'4 55 7: 7- 3 =1 &&'4 55 7: 7- 3 =1 &&'4 55 7: 7- 3 =1 &&'4 55 7: 7- 3 3 ! : C66 3 ! : C66 3 ! : C66 3 ! : C66 A )%2"3'!&. $( & $%-& ! +/+ $1/ & & '2 . <

=1 &&' $( <

=1 &&' $( ((((

-;!

-;!42' 2'2$!5114!2 -) -) -) -) )=1&&'$( -;!4557:

)=1&&'$( -;!4557:

:::: 7- 3 !

7- 3 !

! :51 ! :51 ! :51 ! :51 %(( ' &$ .;4 (%-& '- 2'&'!

!& $! $( & '& & $!'- . !

%!2'-&- .!

!$&F--!&'2 !& '(&.!2 - -%3.&!'.$(& '.'1 1 != 'F$(*$='4& -'.'!&

'& & $! .

$F'21'& & $!'- .

$-2'-'2&$*'

'-'

'.'2$!-'"% $! .(%-! .

!"* J.%-'&;*$!2.&$ '.& .(& $!$(& '021$!'-!'2&- $ $%-&J%&;+" .&-&'1 $F'='-4 ! 22 & $! &$ $!2 & $!. & & 3; *' 3 $.'2 *; & ' $!'-!'2 &-

$%-&J%&;+ +" .&-&'4& '& & $!'-.

-'3 !*$%!2*;& '($

$F !"

" $!2 & $!., 7 :

'& & $!'-.

!$&3 7 :

'& & $!'-.

!$&& 2$%3'!&-;42%- !"& '& 7 :

'& & $!'-.

!$&* 3 ./%.'& *'-&;"-!&'21 3 '-F & !;'= 2'!'4$- $- &- 1 *.'!& 3.'

($!!;2&'*'($-'

1 7 =:

'& & $!'- .

!$& $33 & !; $(('!' F

' $!

* 1 7=:

'& & $!'-.

&- $%-&1 7= :

'& & $!'- .

" ='

!='.& "& !" (( '-J !2.

!$& !"' .

'-3 .. $!$(& $ 7= :

'& & $!'- .

!$& . & ..

$-&4 (!;4F & . '

$!' !%3*'- &$ & $( $!'-!'2 $ ' && $!

$!'!%3*'-F & $%& - $- %-&J

?+" .&-&'1 ! !; 3!!'- &-; &$ 2'

; & &- 1 7= :

'& & $!'-.

.%*3 3 &4$!& '( -.&F$-< !"2;$( '='-; 3$!& 4 ! (( 2= $%-&4 &$ & ' '(('& & & $33 .. $!$(!;$(('!

! .' & '& & $!'- .

$(('!' (&'- . *' !" '

4$!& '*. .$( .( = &4 *'($-' & ' $!'-!'2 &-

. !$& *''! !=$ ='2 !

!'(&'-*' !"-'

'.'2$!* 1 . ($%!2 &$ *' !=$ ='2 ! !;

-"'2 $! * ! & -'.'!& (( 2= &$-$& '-F .'4& '&&' .

3!2&'2&$3$='4($-&

'4 *%& $( $%- 3'- &.& '-'$(1 F & 4($-!'

& $!$( .*

-.'4 .

*' -& $ !&'2 % $!

51 !.'$(*-' $(!;$(& '($-'. 2$!2 & $!.!2& $.'

3;* *' 3 $.'2*;$!'-!'2&- $ $%-&J%&;+" .&-&'.2 -'&'2

'-' !*$=' $- $! $F !" !; $& '- .%(( '!& %.'4 &&'J$3

!!& .

*' & *'-&; &$ 3$ $=' !'

& $! $( * $( &

'& & $!'-1 1 -2'-'2$-2 !"

;1 1

$& !". 2 '-' !*$='.

* *'$!.&-%'2.!'G -'.. $!$( ! $!$!&

'3'- &.$(& '.'1 1 !'& '3 !.' .*''!2 2' 2'24 '!2 !"3 .'

!'$%.

& $!4 (!;4.

.$.&!2.2 .

$.'2 2$((1 %"%.&@ %"%.&@ %"%.&@ %"%.&@4 4 4 4 3 = - L '& '-.

'< L '& '--'

$-& @ @ @ @ 7+

0: !"J-'.$!'2, '.J &* ', '.J