High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2658/2011dismissed

Devi Dayal And ANR v. Randhir Singh And ORS

2016-05-02Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages

"#$$%&'&() "*

$+&"*","(#-$.

//$,,"(#'

0$.'1'

"(2-&.&(3-#-$.'

$'/(2$(#'

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

4-$#-$. $/.#$.',%",/"/$.'5"*6$",,7$2#'$$#-$81235$(#9 6$.$$..$2##-$ $/.#$.'.(#9 : 4-$#-$.#-$81235$(#'-1,26$.$/.#$2&(#-$&3$'#9

.$'$(#) .(&,;'-$#"./",$(&.2+%"#$7&#- . -&#"3/",2+%"#$ ."//$,,"(# .;1,+&.".7",2+%"#$ ."//$,,"(# ..1("&($(&.2+%"#$7&#- .;1'-"3." "-"8"(2+%"#$ .#-$.$'/(2$(#' <<<<< *)+%,'

//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'".$&( $31,".$%(2//$","3"&('##-$ %(%1..$(#&(2&(3'"%#7-$.$6*#-$'1&#'$$>&(3'/$%&&%/$..5"(%$ #-$"3.$$5$(##'$,,2"#$2

&(.$'/$%#,"(25$"'1.&(3

>"(", 5".,"' $(#$.$2 &(# 6$#7$$( #-$ /".#&$' . " ##", '",$ %('&2$."#&(?

,"%'"3"&('##-$/"*5$(#

,"%'"'$".($'# 5($*-"'6$$(2$%.$$2 .(&, ;'-$#"./", ,$".($2 $(&. 1('$, "''&'#$2 6* . -&#"3/",2+%"#$"//$".&(3(6$-","//$,,"(# -"'

."&'$25"(&,2'165&''&('7-&%-".$'155".&'$2-$.$&(6$,7)=

-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"2(#6$$(.$"2*"(27&,,&(3 #/$..5#-$&./".##-$"3.$$5$(#&($''$(%$#-$'1&#7"' &,$2(?

7-$.$"'#-$#".3$#2"#$.$@$%1#&("(2 .$3&'#."#&( #-$ '",$ 2$$2 7"'

.&. # #-$ ".$5$(#&($2 2"#$ " (#&%$ 2"#$2

! 7"'

'$.+$2 1/( #-$ .$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&' 7-$.$6* #-$* 7$.$ %",,$21/(#/"*#-$6","(%$"51(#:?

,"%'"&,&(3 7-&%-#-$$".($'#5($*

,"%''-",,6$2$$5$2#-"+$ 6$$(.$&#$2"(2#-$"3.$$5$(##'$,,%"(%$,,$2A 6!

-$ ".$" '13-# # 6$ /1.%-"'$2 7"' 2$%,".$2 "' %(#.,,$2($+&2$(#&&%"#&(2"#$2

-13-#-$ '"&2(#&&%"#&(7"'.$'%&(2$2(B

:($@/,"("#&( -"'%5$.#-."/$.&2#7*$".'&(&,&(3#-$'1&# #-$.$"#$.A %!

#$. #-$ $@/&.* #".3$# 2"#$ (

#-$ .$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&' '$(# " .$/,* # #-$ ,$3", (#&%$ 2"#$2

!+&2$@ 2"#$2

"(2-"2."&'$2 #-$68$%#&(#-"##-$'",$2$$2%1,2(#6$$@$%1#$21(,$'' "(2 1(#&, #-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#' 6#"&($2 C 68$%#&( $.#&&%"#$D .'-.#E F!.5#-$2$/".#5$(#7( "(21(#.* ,"((&(3A 2!

-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&''-7$2#-$&.&(#$(#&("#$. B

:.#-$&.'##&5$(B

?+&2$@

%",,&(3 1/(#-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'#$@$%1#$"(2.$3&'#$.#-$'",$ 2$$26*"//$".&(36$.$#-$16 $3&'#.".(B

?-$ ".$5$(#&($2(#&%$7"'.$/,&$2+&2$.$/,*2"#$2

/ 7-$.$ &# 7"' 5$(#&($2 #-"# #-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#' -"2 ",.$"2*.$&#$2#-$$".($'#5($*"(2#-$"3.$$5$(##'$,, -"2",.$"2*6$$(%"(%$,,$2+&2$(#&%$2"#$2

"(2 #-$ '1&# -"' 6$$( &,$2 ($ *$". #-$.$"#$. &$ ( ?

?#-1'#-$.$"2&($''"(27&,,&(3($''&'%('/&%11',* "6'$(#A $!

,,#-$/,"&(#&'-"+$(#'#$//$2&(##-$7&#($''6@ $@%$/#.($/,"&(#&("5$,* "(2-&.&(3-7-&(%.''= $@"5&("#&('/&,,$2#-$6$"('"'-$7"'(,*$G1&//$27&#-

,"%'"(2(##-$$(#&.$6","(%$'",$%('&2$."#&( :?

,"%'7-$.$"'#-$#-$.#7/,"&(#&'("5$,* "(8$$# &(3-"(2 "5 ".#"/2&2(#'#$/&(##-$7&#($''6@+$( #-$.$"2&($''"(27&,,&(3($''-"'(#6$$(/.+$2"#",,A !

-$"3.$$5$(##'$,,2&2(#$(+&'"3$#-$%(2&#&( 6#"&(&(3 "##-$&('#"(%$#-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'-$ '1&# 7"' (# 5"&(#"&("6,$ "' +&2$ (#&%$ 2"#$2

#-$"3.$$5$(##'$,,7"'%"(%$,,$2"(2#-$.$&'( %-",,$(3$##-$'"5$ ('1//.#-&'".$5$(#&($2'165&''&('.$,&$21/(#-$ 81235$(#.$(2$.$26*(D6,$1/.$5$1.#&(* 01

- 23%4 5446 27 0 894,: 0;0 /(2#-1'1.3$'

#-&' 1.# # .51,"#$ #-$ ,,7&(3 '16'#"(#&", G1$'#&(' ,"7 . 2$#$.5&("#&(6*#-&'1.#)= &!

4-$#-$.#-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"26$$(.$"2*"(2 7&,,&(3&(/$..5&(3#-$&./".##-$"3.$$5$(##'$,,2"#$2

&&!

4-$#-$. #-$.$ 7"' " %(#&(11' .$"2&($'' "(2

: 7&,,&(3($''(#-$/".##-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'"'#-$'1&# 7"'&,$2(?

7-$.$"'#-$6"((#-$%(#.,,$2".$"

7"'.$'%&(2$2(B

: ..1("&(,$".($2$(&.1('$,"''&'#$26* .;1'-"3." "-"8"(2+%"#$"//$".&(3(6$-",#-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'&( '1//.#-&'".315$(#'-"'."&'$2#-$,,7&(3'165&''&(')= "!

-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'2&2(#'-7#-$&.&(#$(#&(# "//$".6$.$#-$16 $3&'#.".(B

?"'#-$*-"26$$( %",,$21/(+&2$(#&%$2"#$2B

!#-1'#-$"%# "(2%(21%##-$2$$(2"(#'&'",'#6$'$$(.#-$/1./'$ $@$.%&'&(3#-$2&'%.$#&(1(2$.$%#&( #-$/$%&&%

$,&$%# H: .'-.#E H:%#F!A 6!

#&'(,*#-$'$,,$.7--"'#6#"&(#-$ "(2(# #-$ +$(2$$ ( '1//.# -&' %(#$(#&( .$$..$2 # #-$ '#"#$5$(#4=7-'#"#$2#-"##-$ "##-$.$,$+"(# /&(##&5$7"'.$G1&.$2#6$6#"&($2.5#-$%(%$.($2 2$/".#5$(#.$@$%1#&("(2.$3&'#."#&(#-$'",$2$$2A %!

-$'1&#-"'6$$(&,$2(&($5(#-'#-$.$"#$.&$"#$. B

?#-$.$.$#-$'"5$%"((#6$'"&2#6$7"(#&(3 .$"2&($''"(27&,,&(3($''A 2!

&(%$#-$"3.$$5$(##'$,,-"'6$$("25&##$2#-$.$.$ #-$'"5$7"'(#.$G1&.$2#6$/.+$2#-.13-#-$#$'#&5(* #-$"##$'#&(37&#($''$'A $!

-$#&5$7"'(##-$$''$(%$#-$"3.$$5$(##'$,, 7&(3##-$&5/'&#&(6"(7&#-.$3".2##-$.$3&'#."#&( #-$'",$2$$2"'#-$".$"'13-##6$/1.%-"'$27"'2$%,".$2

"'%(#.,,$2($A !

-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"+$",7"*'6$$(.$"2*"(2 7&,,&(3#/$..5#-$&./".##-$"3.$$5$(#('1//.#-&' %(#$(#&(-$-"'2."7(#-$"##$(#&(#-&'1.###-$ %(#$(#',$3",(#&%$2"#$2

!#%(#$(2#-"# #-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#' -"2 #-$ >(7,$23$ #-$ /.51,3"#&(#-$(#&&%"#&(61#-"26$$(&('&'#&(3#-$ .$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&' . /"*5$(# #-$ 6","(%$ '",$ %('&2$."#&(&..$'/$%#&+$#-$"%##-"##-$'",$2$$2%1,2 (#6$.$3&'#$.$2A 3!

$-"'",'.$$..$2##-$%.''=$@"5&("#&(4=? $+&"*",I"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#7-$.$&(-$%"(2&2,*"25&##$2 #-"#-$2&2(#7"(##$@$%1#$#-$'",$2$$2&(.$'/$%##-$ /./$.#*"'#-$/.&%$'#-$/./$.#&$'I,"(2&(%.$"'$25"(&,2A -!

-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'%"#$3.&%",,*'#"#$2&(#-$.$/,* 2"#$2

!#-"##-$*-"26$$(.$"2*"(27&,,&(3# /$..5 #-$&. /".# #-$ "3.$$5$(# "(2 &# 7"' ."#-$. #-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'7--"2%55&##$2#-$6.$"%-#-$ "3.$$5$(#6$%"1'$"'/$.#-$&('#.1%#&('#-$(#&&%"#&( #-$+$.(5$(#&(%"'$"/".#*&(#$(2$2#'$,,#-$,"(21(2$. #-$ %+$."3$ %(#.,,$2 ".$" &# 7"' .$G1&.$2 # '$$> ($%$''".* .5#-$2$/".#5$(#7("(21(#.*

,"((&(3 ( '1//.# -&' %(#$(#&( .$,&$2 1/( #-$ 81235$(#.$(2$.$26*#-&'1.#&( 7-445447 %293, << 0;0 : # %(#$(2 #-"# #-$ $G1&#*-"'#6$6","(%$2"(22$$(2"(#'%"((#6$/,"%$2"#

"(*&($G1&#"6,$'&#1"#&(&'/$%&&%/$..5"(%$&'2$%.$$2 -$1.#&'.$G1&.$2#%('&2$.#-$%(21%##-$/".#&$' .&3-#.5#-$#&5$$@$%1#&("3.$$5$(##&,,/"''&(3#-$ 2$%.$$"(2&(%"'$&#&'1(2#-"##-$*7$.$31&,#*6.$"%- #-$"3.$$5$(##-$*%"((#6$3."(#$2"(*/.#$%#&($G1&#* "(2(#-$'&5&,".,&($'#-$81235$(##-$(D6,$1/.$5$ 1.#&(=149 9

544

894,* <>< : "(2#-1'1.3$'#-&'1.#."&.5&(3#-$ &(2&(3'.$(2$.$26*#-$1.#'6$,7"'%(%1..$(#&(2&(3' %"((#6$&(#$.$.$27&#-1(,$''"(21(#&,#-$.$&'"3.'' &,,$3",&#*"(2/$.+$.'&#* (.$61##", .;'-$#"./",-"'2."7(#-$"##$(#&(#-&'1.# # "."#-$(#&%$2"#$2B

!7-$.$&#-"'6$$('#"#$2#-"# #-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"26$$(&('&'#&(31/(#6#"&( "#$.#-$ .$'%&''&(#-$(#&&%"#&(#-1'#-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"2($+$.6$$( .$"2*"(27&,,&(3#/$..5#-$&./".##-$"3.$$5$(# .;1,+&. ".7", ,$".($2 %1('$, "//$".&(3 ( 6$-", "//$,,"(# -"' "2/#$2 #-$ ".315$(#' '165&##$2 ( 6$-", .;'-$#"./",61#'1//,$5$(#$2#-$'"5$6*.$$..&(3##-$2$%&'&( .$(2$.$26*#-&'1.#&(?6754467494,:

0;0 8 44/="

#%(#$(2#-"##-$%(2&#&(6#"&(&(3 ,&5&#"#&(#&,$'1&#%"((#6$$@#$(2$26*#-$'"&2%(2&#&(( #-$.7.2'-$'165&#'#-"#&(#-$"6'$(%$ .$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&' %1,2-"+$%5$.7".2.$@$%1#&("(2.$3&'#."#&(#-$'",$2$$2"(2 "%(2&#&(I.&2$.%1,2-"+$6$$(&5/'$2#-"##-$'",$2$$271,26$ '168$%##"(*#-$.#$.5"(2%(2&#&(7-&%-#-$/".#*5"*&(#$(2#

> "..&+$"#"(2#-1'1.3$'#-&'1.#.'$##&(3="'&2$#-$81235$(#'"(2 2$%.$$'6#-#-$1.#'6$,7 -"+$-$".2#-$,$".($2%1('$,.#-$/".#&$'"(2"//."&'$2 #-$/"/$.6>"(2#-$+&$7#-"##-$.$&'(5$.&#&(#-$"//$","(2.%$ &(#-$'165&''&('5"2$(6$-",#-$"//$,,"(#'.#-$.$"'('#-"##-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'6$.$#-$2"#$&@$2.$@$%1#&("(2.$3&'#."#&( #-$'",$2$$2(

+&2$@ &('&'#$2#-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'# /"*#-$$(#&.$6","(%$'",$%('&2$."#&(2$'/&#$#-$.$6$&(3"(#&&%"#&( 2$%,".&(3#-$".$""'%(#.,,$2($ .#-$'">$6.$+&#*,"1'$'B"(2 #-$(#&%$".$$@#."%#$2-$.$&(6$,7)= E

#-&.#*1.

,"%'(.1/#&,,

-"##-.13-#-&'(#&%$*1".$-$.$6*.$G1$'#$2# 5">$#-$/"*5$(##-$6","(%$"51(##-&.#*1.,"%'( .1/#&,,

"''#"#$2"6+$&(#-$(#&%$"&,&(37-&%-#-$ $".($'#5($*'&@,"%''-",,'#"(2'.$&#$2#5*%,&$(#' "(2#-$.$"#$.

5*%,&$(#''-",,6$"#,&6$.#*#2$",7&#- .",&$("#$#-$"6+$'"&2,"(2&("(*5"(($."(25*%,&$(# '-",, (# 6$ .$'/('&6,$ . "(* #-&(3 #7".2' *1 &( "(* 5"(($.F -$"''$.#&(&(#-$(#&%$.$+$",'#-"##-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#' 7$.$%(%$.($2(,*"61##-$6","(%$'",$%('&2$."#&(2$'/&#$#-$.$ 6$&(3 "( &5/$2&5$(# . .$3&'#."#&( #-$ '",$ 2$$2 -$.$ 7"' (

%%"'&(.#-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'#%5$.7".2.$@$%1#&("(2 .$3&'#."#&(51%-,$''/"*#-$6","(%$'",$%('&2$."#&("'&#7"'##",,* 1(%$.#"&(7-$#-$.#-$(#&&%"#&(&5/'&(3#-$6"(7"'.&(&(&#$#&5$. #-$.7&'$ -$ "//.$-$('&( $."'$2 (,* "#$. #-$ .$'%&''&( #-$ (#&&%"#&(&(#-$5(#- "*

:"(2#-$.$"#$.#-$.$'/(2$(#= /,"&(#&''$.+$2#-$(#&%$%",,&(31/(#-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'#"//$". 6$.$#-$&%$#-$16 $3&'#.".(B

?#&'%"#$3.&%"(2 /,$"2$2 %"'$ #-"# #-$ .$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&' -"2 6$$( "//."%-&(3 #-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'.$@$%1#&(#-$'",$2$$261#1,#&5"#$,*-"+&(3 "&,$2 # 2 ' %5/$,,$2 # '$(2 #-$ (#&%$ 2"#$2 B

? ".$5$(#&($2 71,26$"&,&(3&(5*21#*&((#.$$..&(3##-$.$/,*2"#$2

? @B!##-$(#&%$7-$.$&(#-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'.$&#$."#$2 #-$'#"(2#">$(&(#-$(#&%$2"#$2

#&'"5"##$..$%.2#-"#(

#-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"2"//$".$26$.$#-$16 $3&'#.".

"(25".>$2/.$'$(#61##-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'2&2(##1.(1/#-$.$.$ &#2$'(#,&$&(#-$51#-#-$"//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'#%(#$(2#-"##-$ .$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"2(#",7"*'6$$(.$"2*"(27&,,&(3#/$..5#-$&. /".##-$"3.$$5$(#(#-$&('#"(#%"'$&(5*+&$7#-$%(21%##-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#'-"26$$(##">$#-$$(#&.$6","(%$'",$%('&2$."#&( 6$.$$@$%1#&("(2.$3&'#."#&(#-$'",$2$$27-&%-&'$+&2$(#.5#-$ /$.1'",,"1'$'B"(2 '1/."!,,#-$'$"'/$%#'-"+$6$$((#&%$26* 6#-#-$1.#'6$,76*(#&%&(3#-"##-$.$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&'-"26$$( .$"2*"(27&,,&(3#/$..5#-$&./".##-$"3.$$5$(#"(2.&3-#,*' $@$.%&'$2#-$2&'%.$#&(1(2$.$%#&( #-$%# -$.$&'(.%$&(#-$%(#$(#&( .".7","'#-$'1&#7"'

< &,$281'#6$.$#-$$@/&.*#-$,&5&#"#&(/$.&26$%"1'$#-$.$-"26$$( $@%-"(3$%..$'/(2$(%$'.&3-#6$.$#-$2"#$&@$2.$@$%1#&("(2 .$3&'#."#&( #-$ '",$ 2$$2 "(2 '16'$G1$(# # #-$ .$'%&''&( #-$ (#&&%"#&(2$%,".&(3#-$".$""'%(#.,,$2($#-#-$1.#'6$,7 "#$. $@"5&(&(3 #-$ $+&2$(%$ #-.$"26".$ $@$.%&'$2 #-$ 2&'%.$#&( 6* 3."(#&(3.$,&$'/$%&&%/$..5"(%$("2$G1"%*&(#-$'",$%('&2$."#&( 71,2(#2&'$(#&#,$#-$1.##3."(#2&'%.$#&(".*.$,&$1(2$.$%#&(

#-$%# $$.$(%$&'&(+&#$2##-$81235$(#.$(2$.$2&(@9 8 544$?7 04,< 0;0 / 2(#&(#$(2#2&$.7&#-#-$&(2&(3'.$(2$.$26*6#-#-$ 1.#'6$,7-$G1$'#&(',"7(#&%$2"6+$".$"('7$.$2&("+1. #-$ .$'/(2$(#=/,"&(#&' "(2 "3"&('# #-$ "//$,,"(#=2$$(2"(#' -$ 81235$(#'"(22$%.$$'.$(2$.$26*#-$1.#'6$,7".$-$.$6*"&.5$2 -$"//$",'#"(2'2&'5&''$2

, *)+%

749 '(-.&