Subhash v. Sheela & ORS
!
" #$ % & &'
!
# ( )(* + ( %
&& ,- . .
(%
/&&
% 01 2& 2 2
2
!"
#$ %!"
& ''''
2
2
&
# (
)*+
,
, , -)./))#&001, + #..22.#&
#33
#5//
(
-* 6 ( ,
8
#$
+ ,
!
"# 2 23#22.#2
9 ,
+
# , , -)./)8#&00 *
,
1 $..
+
:++ ,
9 ,
+
9 , + ,
:
#
, ,
9
+ 9
" - +
9-- + +
(
+ +
;
! +
#
+
, $ <
+
,
8
= >
,
(
+ , )
!"
#$
/ ,
,
(
+
+ ,
8
#$
-
2 1 21
11
3 ?
@+
,
>:+ ,
+ ,
A
8
#$-
+ :
+ :
+ , +
0 >
+ ,
>:
+ , ,
,
-
+ ,
A
,
)+
,
/
:
8
&
,
A
8
#$-
5 :
+
+
#.
,
,
+ + )
!" $#
"
# "
% & ' & #
"
$ (&)*+,-- "
, !#
#
!
."
! # #
$
# . !
( $" #
% &
$ .'
! $#
(
!
% & '
' '
' '() *
( +'%
& ,-./ 0,1234 6
/! ) 0
"
"
"
$ )'
"
) ) ( " 2 % & "
)
"
"
# )'
"
3 " $ $#
# #
" "
$ "
"
45- 016 75* 4 18 8/ $#
"
# "
#
2 ! !
"
#
$ "
(
!
% & '
' '
' () *
( +' %
3 6
/2"9 1"
0
'
75 55 : ;
0 7** <- & & &
7*7
5*): )+ #)=
>
) ? $ #
"
#)1 "
. !
)
$ 2) 1""
$ # "
#) 0
5* & & &
! !
#
# $
) "
"
% &
"
"
) &2
! " #) $
1""
$ # "
#) ( 3#/ (
7
8 *
( +' '( & ) 9:) 9 1';'./ ',<;;,-.-3 =%6
# $ # "
#
$ ' $#
! # ( $" # ' &5 !# " ! !
$
""
0 "
$ 2 $#
$#
# # $ # 5 @
$" "
!
# !
A
#
$#
( $" % & $ ( $" " "
# !# "
" "
(
#
'('+' '
3,-./6 '
'>';?1 3 '6 '(' +' '
9 3,-./6 ' '>' @<, 34 '6 ( $" $ ! ! "
" # ""$ # !
!
A $# 1"
1 (
5
+'
A
& ,-.- 3,6 > >
6<1/3"=96 ( $"
! "
! $#
"
#
'('+'!
5* &3,-./6 ' '>'
@..3! 6 ( $"
# !# "
"
(
+'*'4 & ,-./3/6> >3
6,113
6 +'!
'3,-./6 & '>'.-/3"=96'
"
# % & $#
$
!
!
% &( '( ' '() *
( +' %
3 6 1
- 1 + 1
!
!
$
.
!
!
> "# +5 @" + 2 !
" % & '+
""
2
B %"
% & ' + !
"
#
# $ 2 "
2
!#
#
$#
! !
2
# # "
#
#
#
! .
" $
"$ . > #
!
$
$
#
$# " "
" $#
%" ' &5 ! !
$ ""
A ! $# " # $
"
$ 2 $
""
!
# $ 2
5 $"
A $
# "
( ! !
$
>
"
5 $ # ! 2 " % & '+ !
!
2
( 5
!#
#
" ! # B >
! !
(&)*+,--
$ #
#
# ! . !
"" # < A #
"
# "
$# "# ! $
" # !
# $ $# $# !
""
5 #
! # " ( "
#
"
$# B ?
!#
$# (9$ ( 1
7
8*
( +' '( 3
$# (9$ C ( 1
!
% & ('
'( ' ' () *
( +'%
3 6 "
#
" "
A
B ( 5 "
2
#" "
A "
"
> !
" " $ & ,) " ! .$ " ! '
" + "
! '+,0 ; = 0
: B >
$ 5 2 " 2 " "
( ! $
" #
" "
$
# ! >$
'
" B $
D # 1"" +.
$ B! %D -<))<,E- 4% B8 5 !"$ 7< # 55)
$ " &EE,)
" >
" $ & -5 ,) EE'5)-5,)
$ ,
" $
"
" " <*,)
E 0 # !
"
# $ ' +5 ! #
+ = '+'! = ',--? 0.,?23
"
E
=#
# "
"
# ! &<*'E)-E*,) !
+ 4 A '4 !
,-.<3,6> >3
6?/; "
&
!
>
& ,)
'
> A
#
"
"
& -7 ,) -
! "#
$! 5
$ "
2
#"
"
.
!
# ( 5
!
5 F (
9$>$ >!
##
,
++
+ ,
=)
,
, ,
+
" ( +
9
-
- + +
#2
+
=
, + ,
B28
;*
+
1 + >: CA$ :
)
= +
D
E(
23#22.#2 2/.32.#2
3. #$ CA2
+
2/.32.#2
+
D , ( E #= (
(
,
B$);
>:+ +
,
)! ! +
+
+ B2); +
+
(
(
,
+
>:+
A ,
(
( +
+ #& : +
(
>:
+
( ,
+ ,,
>:
, ",
- 7
:
' ( '
A &,-,.
;?,'
#3
, +
4
) ./;'! 'B
&B 8 '''
'''
'''
4$8
F "
$#
$) 48 <-
! "
# A" "
# $
$ "
$
#
#
$
"
# $3 ./@'>C
)
'B 48 "
# A" 1
#
" $
# G 8 $#
3 4$8
# ' $) 458G 48 # $ # "
# $ $# " $ # H.# #
I !
!
J "
# #
#
$# !
$
3 48 $ # .# #
$
! !
$# !
$
+!
#
$ AG 48 ! $ #
"
#" "
#
$# # $ .# $# "
#
"
#"
$ # 2"K 1"
0 75 4* 758 $ # .# # "
#G 8 ! !
4$8
$ ! !
!
'
" 2 !
8
$
!
48 !
#
$ # '
G% "!
$ $#
$ # .# # "
# #
#
$ " ! $
$# !
!
$
. # "
$
"
"
$
$. ! $) 48
# $) 48
! # $ #
#
" " #G 8 ! !
4$8 "
$ # 3 4$8 "
# #
#
"
' +! # # # " $ #
"" # $ "" " 0
$
!
"
"" "
'
# # ! 48 0 #
$
1
$#
! $# "
#
$ "
/
$
# $. #
# $ "
3
"
"
"
# $ $
4<8
! $# !
1
"
$#
#
$ "
! # '
# !
# !
# !
!
$
# B!" "
$ 48 # #
" $
#
$ " #
#
# $ #
!
F #0 ,
(
A
#/
CA$* 1
2/.32.#2-+ CA2*:
1 F
, (
+
" ,
+
, ,
#5 <
#=0 4
#=&*1
+ D
E F
, +
+ +(
+ +
"
2. :+
,
F
:
,
, ,
,
2# :
:
+ +
+
:
22 :
+
*1 )
*#1
#=&
+
+
+ , (
,
F
'
, +
(
,,
2$
, ",
- 7
:
'(')
"
&,--23?6
.<<' (
) E #
#
$ $# $
!
A ! $
" $ >$
!
: 0!
" & 1! 5-7E !
1!
$
1! $ "
4$8 $)
< 0
" !
3
" !
# &
' ) &
A 5
' && ) ) A &A 'F 2= ?
(
,
,
+
,
( ,
)
+ 2& :
+ , ,
+
,
+ #..22.#& A
:
+
8
#$ 23
,
*1
2
2
&& 9 B
,8 )
, 8 B