High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2700/2011dismissed

Baljit Singh v. Nasib Kaur

2018-03-01Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

!!"#$#%& '"()* +,# #%-( ..!++% /!'$0$ $#120'

!"!$!3 ('0-(4 $

!$.%3!%

!"#$%& '( $(')#

'!$!% &

'5$(#%-+)36" !) ' (!..!++%

''$(--'7+)36" !) ''!$.%3!% 1 88888 (')#*% ..!++% 9.+#% ##$#% !-0+'!"%3..!+-#%$ (!

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

+5# 20'(! '-! 3 !% (!'!:!% #%!3-'!!:!% $!++7$ >;; (! -'!!:!% $!++ 7$ $"'#1!3 1< '!-0+' !!3 C'# !' 0+$(%20:' %"(%3 C9> %>;;) (!3 !'!D!"0 #% %3'!-#$ ' #% (!$+!3!!37$!D !%3!3 ;;)10 $0: ))@9$ !3 (6!1!!%.#3#% (!.'!$!%"!-#%3!'#%-(%3

%-+#%-(%3 (!$:!7$!%3'$!31< +5# 20'%30+120' ($1!!%0' (!'.+!3!3 ( (!$+!3!!37$% !D!"0 !3#%"! (! 6!%3'7$3!+<#%- (!!D!"0 #% (!$+!3!!3) (!'!'!)+!-+% #"! 3 !3;;D ?

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

! !

# $ %&

( &

) *

) + , ..!++% 9.+#% ##%$0..' (!'!:!% #%!3"$!) !D:#%!3 C9$$#%-( (!.+#% # ) C9 %-+#%-( 7# %!$$ !D !%$#% ) C9=#5':,!! #%-()36" !)7($!'6!3 (! +!-+% #"!) C9B0'3!6#%-(7# %!$$ (!-'!!:!% $!++ ) C9?

%#+ 20:' 0. #%-!'.'#% D.!'

%3 C9> 0+$(% 20:'

%"(%3 !-0+'!!3C'# !'

% (! (!'(%3)3!!%3% (!'$!+ ..!'!3$C9%3+$!D:#%!3C9-#%3!'#%-(7# %!$$ !D !%$#% (! '#+ 0' ) 6#3! ,03-:!% %3 3!"'!! 3 !3 ;? 3#$:#$$!3 (!$0# )10 )(7!6!') (!47!'..!++ !0' '!:%3!3 (! : !' (! '#+0' 6#3!'3!'3 !3?(!'!:!% #%!3 '3!''!:%37$"(++!%-!31< (!3!!%3% 1<#+#%- = ) 10 (! $:! 7$ 3#$:#$$!3 /#3! ,03-:!% %3 3!"'!! 3 !3 =*) (!$0# 7$ 3!"'!!37!6!') (!..!+.'!!''!31< (! 3!!%3% 7$++7!33#$:#$$#%- (!$0#

'5$(#%-+)+!'%!3"0%$!+'!.'!$!% #%- (!..!++% 9 .+#% #)#%$0..' (!:!:'%30:..!+)($'#$!3 (!++7#%- $01:#$$#%$&9

C9B0'3!6#%-((3% %+<.'6!3 (!!D!"0 #% (!-'!!:!% $!++10 +$ (!.<:!% =)?)@9$ !'%!$ :%!<F

#-% 0'!$ +5# 20'%3 (0:1#:.'!$$#% 0+120'(31!!%.'6!3 ('0-( (! !$ #:%< C9?

%#+20:'0. ) #%-!'.'#% D.!' F "

(!'! 7!'! 3:# !3 $#-% 0'!$ 1!'#%- (! $:! !%3'$!:!% #% (!-'!!:!% $!++!6!%3 !#%'!$.!" 3#!'!% +%3)#!)=5%+$:'+$D )7(#"(7$ -'!!3 1!$+3' +$+!"%$#3!' #%>)*)=?@9 -#%$ (!'!"!#. .<:!% ?))@9F

(!7# %!$$!$7!'! (!$:! C9>0+$(%20:'(3 +$ .'6!3 (! !D!"0 #% (! -'!!:!% ) :0"( +!$$ '!-#$ ' #%$#120'C9)7(7$7%!'% (!' .' #%+%3:!$0'#%-=5%+$:'+$1!'#%-2($' >@>9 );9B );9> );9 %39 ;

'7(#"( (!3!!%3% (3!D!"0 !3$+!3!!33 !3 ;;D B?

'+%3:!$0'#%-5%+$:'+$$ (!'!7$3#$.0 !7# ('!-'3 (!1+%"!'!F !

D % (!'-'!!:!% $!++'7(#"($+!3!!3($ 1!!%!D!"0 !3#:#+'!D !%$#%$#% (!-'!!:!% $!++ D =#%3#$.0 !)7(!'!1<% (!':0% B)?@97$ .#3(!47!'..!++ !0' ($"::# !3#++!-+# <%3 13#" !3#%1$!'6#%- ( (!-'!!:!% $ $!++D %3 D '! (!$:!+%3)10 1'!3#!'!% 5($'%0:1!'$) :0"(+!$$'! %3!6!% (!.' #!$7!'!3#!'!% )')#% D '7(#"($+!3!!3($1!!%!D!"0 !3)$#120'($ @> ( $('!)7(!'!$0+120'%3 +5# 20'?@>$('!

%3$.!' (!-'!!:!% #%3#$.0 !)#!)D =)%+<$#1 20'7$7%!' (!+%3F !

!6#3!%"!($1!!%+!3 ( $#120'7$1+#%3

1!"0$!)30'#%- (!'"'$$9!D:#% #%)$(!'!:!:1!'!3 (! 7'3$ $ 7!'!$ !3 #% (!7'# !% $ !:!% )7(#"( 7!'! " 0++<.0 (!'F

%9..!'%"! (!..!++% 9.+#% #70+3% 1! + (!"$!)') (! '%!<)%:!+<)$$#%-((3++ (!5%7+!3-! (!.'#%"#.+7# ('!-'3 (!$0# .'.!' < %3 (!'" #6# #!$(!'!'!) (!3!!%3% "0+3% 1!$#3 (6!1!!%3!%#!3 (!'#-( "'$$9!D:#% #%$#120' 3#3% 3!%< (!'!"!#. ?))@96#3!D %3$7!++ $ B)?@9 (!'!#$ % $#%-+! 6!':!% '!6#3!%"! % '!"'3 7# ( '!-'3 '-!'< "::# !3 1< (! .+#% # '!-'3#%- (!'!"!#. ))@9 (!30-( !'$%3) (0$) 0'-!$ (#$0' '$! #%-9$#3! (!,03-:!% %33!"'!! (!47!'..!++ !0'

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

..!'15)'!"'3$ (!0' 1!+7%3 (!6#!7 ( (!'!#$%'"! %3:!'# #% (!$01:#$$#%$ '#%-+)') (!'!7!'! 73#!'!% -'!!:!% $ $!++)%!'5%+$%;;;>'$0:B)?)@9 -#%$ .<:!% =)?)@9$!'%!$ :%!<6#$996#$D '+%3 :!$0'#%-=5%+$:'+$)'7(#"( (!$+!3!!33 !3;; D B?

7$!D!"0 !3'$0:B)*?)@9 ($%7(!'!":!#% (! .+!3#%-$ ( (!:0% 70+31!3,0$ 1+!#% (! (!'-'!!:!% (!'! #$%'!!'!%"! (!-'!!:!% $!++#%!# (!' (!.+!3#%-$'6#"!9 6!'$ 0+$(%20:'7(!%..!'!3$ C9>) ('0-($.!"##"

G0!$ #%)3#3% $< ( =)?)@97$.#3#%(#$.'!$!%"!(!'!'!)#% :<6#!7) (!!% '<'!"'3!3#% (!'!-#$ !'.+!$#% #%$#-%##"%"!6!%

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

7$7%!' (!!D !% @>$('!)0+120'%3 +5# 20' (!

!D !% ?@>$('!)7(!'!$$.!' (!-'!!:!% $!++#%G0!$ #%)#!) D ) (!+%37$7%!31<$#120'(0$) (!#%3#%-)#%:<6#!7) "%% 1!'!3-#%$ (!..!++% 9.+#% #%370+31!%1# !' 3!$ % "$ %<"+03% (!$+!3!!33 !3;;)7(#"(($% 1!!% "(++!%-!3

' (!'!$%$$ !316!)3% #%3%<#++!-+# <' .!'6!'$# <#% (!#:.0-%!3,03-:!% %33!"'!! (!47!'..!++ ! 0' $01$ % #+G0!$ #%+7'#$!$'3! !':#% #% !$0+ % +<) (!..!+#$3#$:#$$!3 /*0 (')# 12/ %&34$ )/5/267 82

928

)/5/ 5: 928