Sikander And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others




    
 

  

  !"#   $
 "

"!%# &  !"#    '(  

   

 !
!"
#

 
!    

 !
 
#

  $ $)*+$, (-$+'$ .$/$0+.+/, 1,#$2 .$+/0+31/', (-$$'(  4444  


#

   "+ '$ ' + 0 5( /($ $5 6  +
/ (,7+$+'$++558(+-$+ 3((#$2 8$/5/$.$)89$(,$- /5,:,  ( -(   

   

 ((  6  ;

</$ :=,+<+> ''(<9?+0/0/($5  6,  55 @ '  + $ .$)8 $3 !$ ;.!=+$/8+($$$/3,(520272'$3, (A/+8+3'/8(,/+</8+ "+ $ 5 '$2 $ 8 ( (-$3  B(( ;

</$  =(55/0A/'$(8 $8+$$3,7+$02/$'.!+-0(-$(0 55( /' 02 ($ $$/3, 0( )8 /  ($  $'( 55+(',$52+0'$3

$3+'</-!$ /3 $$2,.$)8
33, 0($5-$2  +$  /$2 (5, + 0$  -5-(  + '$'$+'$7$)8 $$2( +$38'$$7$)8</-!$ /3 $$  ($ .$)
33  #$2  8$/5/$ .$)8 9$(;+$$$$$(>+# .9?=,7++($' .!"+$-+3'52+# .97$$5$8-$( /($+>#$2 8$/5/$9$($- /5,

,7++7$ $'5(+2$:(+1-$3#$2,<$ '7$$$(02/0 ;=,$(7+
5/;<<-=,;<<<=( ;<<<=/0 ;=

+/*0 8$/5/$$(/ .$) ,  6 ; ''505  #$2=, ( + #$2 

8$/5/$.$)89$($- /5,:-(((  : '$ /56+( /5,+''3+' '(5/3+058-+$,7$03(02+ /+$3(8+/+'$/5$5( +05,7/5(+7++''3+'>$1$5 .8$;$3=?(></-!$ /3 $$2?70 3(02+ (3$-
33 '$ ''(<>9?+( /5,+'+$1$5.8$;$3=7055( 0272'$3$338+</-!$ /3 $$2

 "+1-$3#$2-(

   

(( 6 ;

</$ :=3((+: /5,7+$

, /5 6 7 /0/(, ( + '  + >$ 1$5 .8$;$3=?7$3(>$.$)8$3

!$? ''(<9,7/0/($5+<+$5 6,+3(558/'+'.!7+8(/($ 

 
 
     
   
 
  
       


 

 


  

 

 
     !"
 #
 
$%

 "+'$558++2''$+(+$'(( '$($8$(8+$(3(3(+'3,7 /$(02+$'(++3(3755-$03('$- %/$+$(7)02+9$($$# .9+ 38+5(6 $$3$'(++' $A/$-<'$,+3+/5(055(/'0272'$3 52"+9$((((++$:3$'.!0 +1-$3B9/$/$''$-5"+$$ -505'.! 7$ ( +-0 55(/' 02 72'$3-( $($((  : ;

</$ = /$+$558(++'.! 7$55(/'//520272'$3$3+'</- !$ /3 $$2+.$)
33,(+3(( /5  7$-$3('$- ++$+7, (-$3

((  ;

</$  =+0/( 02$'(

#$2/05$-
33,7+$02 ' +-0(-$(055(+$/8+($$$/3,02$528/' +3(($-$/5  

88$-($3++$'(,+'$ +-''$+(+
/$,)8+$5,3(+$0-

6 "+5$(/5''$8$+'$+$8/(+ +3'/8( /5A/,7(7+/'$'$/5( 7+/)80*$3+'$,7+7$7$)8($ ', ( 7  - 3'53( 02 + $'( +35- "+$$ + 3'53 +$, $ /+ 58 8'  3   -5'$-'$'5/$5*/ $8/(++ ((/+$'(5578+3(( /5(558 /' + '  .! 02 72  '$3, $( + 583 <'+'$++ /5+-0$($($(/( (+$'$37550('$+/3(( /5 /$+$ $8/(++$'(55(/'+'.!

$+'6 2$$5202'$3,(+$7558('$3/7+ +('$,+($'$3$2''57/5((-)(  /$+$/$8(+558/'+'.!+$/8+($$$/3 //5(-5- $5 +
/ (, +$$50B55805($$)8((($52 +'.!


 



 ! "##
$%%

 $& "'( !(

!'

)*#


+#

, #

 !(

!'

-.   /"01 22"'# #


 $  #


34(534 34 '  # $ 

-

 21#

 ##

# ( 6

#!

 78
 26(9

 3'#$%% 

 (7 322"4  #


*) *#

$%%&

 $&:,/''$+$8/3

 $ $, + 5$( /5 $ + $'(, +- $-$(+$8/3$(0+5+'$,02$8/8+ '$5-5(523(($/53$52+8$/(++ 373'53($33 ((++($ +3'52$528(7+3(''3'$/5$', 52$/3$0(02+'$-(+/5,$ (3$(++('$-(+8$/(2558( 35(,7+++'$+-5('/ 5$8/(+ +'$+-005+7++7+3(($/5 -5  $5   (   +
/  (,  7$852 558( 5/$8(++(-$3A/; </$  = 7 /(   , $52   7+ + /$2 /5, 7++$/$$52$,(+-07+($7$3(( : +-+$(+5$(/5$+'$(+-8 +$/8++(/3''((7++',7++$05 

$8$(++558+-$+3(( /5 $(,5(57+/++5580$(53( 8$/(,5)5)585-3',-5/(35$8+, +$/508/5$-$+$ $2
/5$-, $ /('52/$05,$0$$2$($3$2, $ 5/$05(35(<$'7$ 

 $($   + $8/3 $8$(8 + -5(2  + 3(( $/5  A/,   3'$-  + /,  <3 +

058'$-+$ 

+/*0 8$/5/$ $(/ .$) ,  6, ;$3(  #$2 8$/5/$ $(/ .$) , 6-(3(3(( =,$+'7$ /'+1-$33)$/5$$$28/+'/$'+

  D($ /0  ;=;<<-=, +  1-$3 

 3'7$($3$/5+320$A/$($8-$8+$-, $$/3   +   + 9$( (
33  "+ $5- '$-  

 /0  ;=E ;<<-= $ $ '$(/(  /($ F&'$ ()  * $ +

,,,

,,,

,,, - .

 
  )
 /
   
    
 )0    
  +

,,,

,,,

,,, -

.

 )   "
   
     

 


  
 
  1 ,,,

,,,

,,, -""


.


 0 
 0 
  0 
         2
        

 


G  $/5+$(/$2'$-7/5(+7++ 77557+'7$<+3($$/3,7++7 (02$$28/+3(3+''505$/5,-( (( 6 ;

</$ =D('/(52,+(3(($/5$ 55-8/(+-+$0/0/(B3((,$7+($7,$ 5578+(/'$57"+5$(/5$+$+

5(+7++3(($/5$A/$(0(5$(/5$-$, 2+8$/($8H(/($57"+52$8/3$(0$ /++$'(+35-((/'+3(($/5$ 58'$(3(,+$$,+2$7''($3558/' 2-2+0+(3(($/5 75'(/ ++9$($$38+5(6 +(((( 55/'+'.!

</$  := -5 $5   (   +
/ (

 

2,+$,7+$<83'52, 53'$3,-($8+ $57,+3'52+2 $8+/(+$/58-$8+$- 7/5(0$//5(-$ +0$-+#?05/'$3
/$+5(>##  2'

(/   #


0;"2 #

$%$--



- ('$8$'+ (,7++$<$(/($ 3$



 
 *       
 
   $ 4   

 )      


 0   
   

 
0  )
  

  "
  
  
0  
 
  
2 

$



   

  
  560   
  0 



 7 8 4 $ 9
 


 "
 )   56 
$ :  " 
)  "

     56  "
  





   $

 
 0  

 7 8 4 ) 
  4
!"
 +  5;6$ <  
 )  /
  
0  
   " 
  )   
  )
     $ =

  0       
      )  /
  
    
       )   2 $ 7/
 
  0 


 "
  

      56  > ?$ :    
  " 
   

   )   
     

  
 
   

   
    5;6   

  
      
 
  )   



   7
)

$

 ) 
      7
)

  @ A0 B3A0 <" 


)  
     5;6 )     




  
 

  
 )          /
   

$

  

0 
  )  
  $


    

   

 $ 4
    
  $

  
  
   
    2
    
 
  

     
     
0       )
      
   $

  )0    

    
       $ 4 *  
       

  
  

   
 )         
$ 4       
   
        )
   
     )
     $


   <
 'BB
 

 

   )      (
     <
 'B $



 
   

 )   
 
  
*  
   
 )    $ 4   


 
 
 
0 

    $


       

 
 
 )  
$ 4 
    
"   ) 
     
0 
  
C

D$ :     

   

     

       
 
  

   

     *  
 

  
    $% $ 4 

 
 )
 7 8 46 
 )
    

  


$

4 )
   

 
   

 
 )
  $ -
.

!"  " 

 



0   
  

 
   9
     
 
     (
    -<
 'B .$ 4  
  

 
  
 
     

    
 0  "

 4
 ( -.$ -

.

4 9
     )  * )    <
 '

'B

 'BB     
0 

  
0   

$ 4 
  

     
     
      

  
  

     $ 4 
0 0 
  $ -


.

4 *  

    
  


  )       
    )
     $ -
.

 
)   
      

 )   
 0   


0 

  


 

     $ 4   
 
  

   $ -.

  
  0 
  
   
    
   
 
$ 4   
 )
         
 $ -
.



  
   
 0

   
  

     " $ 4    

    
  
$ -

.

:
    ) 
   
  
0   2       $ 4
  )  

 
  

    
  
   
     /  /

 
) $G    5 ($  $2  $$ + 5( 585 ',+3$$58$(05',$3( $//$8B$$//$8  ($, '$$08 + /$B3(  $$/3 ( A/5, $$  5, -5/  $- $$(+3'52557++<5/-(3+3'52$ +'+/5(0)$3'$-82+(3$ 5 + '$$-  + 3'52$ "+ '7$  */(5 $-7  0 <$(/+3$52+7+++3'52$ $$22/5$/$2'$-$'52$0$$2$ -((/35("+
/$''5-$+*/(83 +3'52$($(+'$/5$'055(02($$$/3 $ '$3 $ 02 $$ "+
/$ +  $5  ($38 + 3+(582$$/3$528(7+$$5

6

-7+0-(/,7((23$+ '$'(+3(3($(852    $!"
#

 
! %  $ 
#

%              / ++$')8B$( & ++$ '$05 &