High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7165/2016dismissed

Icici Lombard General Insurance Co Ltd v. Ashok Kumar & ORS

2019-08-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"#$% %%%""!&&$ '!

$(!

%%%+!

!"#$% %%%""!&&$ '!

$(!

%%%+!

%%%""!&&$ '!

-.!!/* $(!

%%%+!

$(!

%%%""!&&$

-.!!/* $(!

%%%+!

0$!10! 2 23 %%

!$3

%' &($ 5/ $!

1 $(!""!&&$62

! "#2 1

"!$7%2 %

%-2&*%85/ $!

1 "!$7%2 5 1 "!$7%2 5 1 "!$7%,2

%9 !!"-2:(0(2&&5/ $!

1 "!$7%2 5 1 "!$7% 2 5 1 "!$7%2

%%-%-2:(&5/ $!

1 $(!""!&&$ 2

1 7%$2 1 "!$7%2 % ;;;;

<#$(2 !

5 (&&2 " !11 2%!%

12&! !(&112

"#5 12&! !(&1 1 &2$ 5=(2 ((/! !$1$(! ! 2!$% < 2!1&# $$!5$(!1 $ 1$(! ! !$($% % $ $3, %%5-(% 5:! $, #!

1-(%0!

( +.5 2!$ 1 /2&&:! (:5 4&2 ! -$$2 7::&5 8!( 2& 2 $5 &&:=2$((2 =21!-$%<!!

0!/2$(!2 :($!

< #-2 =!

!:2:$(!2 $ # &!(/2: !:2 $27%9+

)!00!&>!=(!$(!#( ! (!! :9$!& $8(& * ) (!$ 58

42 )"/!(2 &!(/2: !:2 $27%9+ , (!

!21$!

!1!

!$ $(!11!2:/!(2 &! !2: 2/!

# "!$7%6-.!!/* 2 (!:&2:!$!

5$ /!

#(2:( "!!5 !1 !(21$!

2:$(!

$ # &!

! 2: !:2 $27%9+9,50

5=(2 (= !2: 2/! # ! 2)-2:(5

$(!

1"!$2$2!

5 ):2 $$(!

$ # &!1 5 &$$&#&&$(!$( !! 2!

1!&&$(!

11!

!&$2"&!2.

! !2/!2.

2:($)!!5 2:($!#!$(5< #-2 (!

2:($(5=(!

-$%<!!

0!/2(!

(! 2:($ 2!

$(!

" 1$(! # -(% 2)-2:(5

$(!

1 !/!&&$(!$( !!2.

!$ 2/2&9 "2$&5 &2$#2"

2/$!/!(2 &!5=(!

!-$%<!!

0!/2 = ! &

:($! < #-2 !2! 2$$!2$(!( "2$&1 $ !$!$1 $=# 1$!

2 ("5-.!!/ * 6 "!$7%(1&!1 $(! "$&!/2:$(!11!2:

/!(2 &! !(2$$(! "$1 &+7%$!% % 1 $(!

11! !

-! $2 5,,, 4= !:2 $!

!:2

"!$7%-.!!/* =2$(4&2 !-$$2 2& % 4!$2$2!

? &2$6 (12&! &2"!$2$2

! 2: 47% 1 !

-! $21 $ '!(2 &!

$ :2 $ 2%!% -.!!/ * 6 2/!

5 '2.# * 4 .2$-2:(6=!

!"#$% 2

111!2:/!(2 &!5 &22: "! $2$$(!$!1+ %

&)( $12.

11!

#(22$(!$ /!(2 &

2!$% @2$( !: $!$(1-$%<!!

0!/25 !" $! &2 "!$2$2 ! 2: 47% 1 = 12&! #"!$2$2!

? &2$

2%!% (

5+/2* 62 5< #-2$0!/25 < #7!(0!/2< #-2 0!/22 :($!

5:2 $$( /!

# 5 &22: "! $2$$(!$!1+ &)( <$( $(! &2 "!$2$2 =!

! $ 2! $:!$(!

# $

2!$ &2 8 &5 & (!

!21$!

!1!

! $ $(!

& 2 !$( !=!

! !&$!$$(! ! 2!$% !2:"$$$2 !5&&$(! (""! ! 11!

! $!

2$ =!

!1 !% 8(!" $2!

!11 ! !A$!"" $2$2!

$&!!/2! !% 1$!

(! 2: :!$ 5$(! &2"!$2$2 =!

!" $&# &&=!=2$( #8 &/2!= $!%% %4!$2$2!

() * 5 =( ( 12&! 4 7% 1 = = ! "! $21+ %,5

?"!$2$2!

$(!

=((12&! 47% 1 =!

!= ! "! $21 + % 55

?&:=2$(2$!

$$$(! $!1%B"!

1 $(!

$!112&2:1$(!"!$2$2 $2&&12& !&2C$2"# &! #

7%$,.2$&# !/!

&&#% 8(!2

! "#1!&$::

2!/! #$(!= "

#$(!8 &12&!$= !" $!""!& !1 !$(2 $%

8(! &2$ 2$(!$="!$2$2 =!

!& 2

$2 12!=2$( $(!$1 "! $2= !$$(! #$(!8 &(/!

12&!$(! !" $!""!& 7$2 !

1 $(! ""!& =!

! 2

! $ $(! "! $2/!

5=("$2""! !$( :( !&% (/!(! &! ! !&1 $(!" $2!

:2:

$( :($(! ! % 1 "! $2= !$"!$2$2!

? &2$ () * 2 47% 1 $12.

11!

#(22 $(! 2! 2!$$$(!$!1+ %,5

?%8(! "&2$"1$($ $2 1&&=

!2 &!>"!

+ %5

? -"! 2& 2!$5 $ " $$2 $$!$ + %

1! 2:

+ %5

? 42 11!

+ %

? 4@ 2.

!? &2$(!" !$($(!=

1 $!

2: ! 2: + % 5

? "!

$( !.#2::(!&$(5(=!/!

$1 2!$&2.

5(!(

! !"!

!$2 &!$($1$!

$(! 2!$(!= $)!$ 2/2&9 "2$&5 &2$#5=(!

!(!= !2 &!:&&#!>2! "

/2!$ !$!$ 1+ %

?( !! "!$ #(2(2

!$!$5!2 2!

5 "! 2&2!$ /!# !!$ %4@0 2) 7) 5=((!2 &!:&&#!>2! &2$

% % (!" !$($ (!12!2.

(2 "!

!$2&!2!2 &!:& !" $D>%4@?<12/!1$(!2.

/2 ! $("225$(:( ("22 !: 2:!$! $21# $ != ! !2/!%4@,0 %+.2/* (2)1 * (2)9 "2$&5

$!( 2(!" !$($ (:$$ !$!$1 (21 , % % = 1 / 2 2.

(2 "!

! &2!

$$($ = $)2:$ !$!$1 2/2&9 "2$&%8(2 =2$!

( $!

$212!$($!>"! 1""

>2$!&#+ %5

?=!

#$(!

"!$2$2!

(2 $ !$!$"!$2$2!

= /2 !:& (2:("

$!2 2!$% 8(! 8 & ( :

$! 1 + %5

? &# 1

!2 &!>"! %9=!/!

5)!!"2:2/2!=$(!1 $$($$(!2.

11!

! # 2!2.

(2 "!

! !2/!$ !$!$ 2/2&9 "2$&5 &2$#$(!1 * (2)9 "2$&5 $!( $(!1 $$($#$2!

5$(! ! 1/ 2 $ "!$ "

( !1!2 2!

2$(!1 1 2&& 5 ! !2"$ 5 (! !$ %2 $ )!"$ $$2!

2$:!$ 2 "& ! & $$( !!= ! $= 1$ !!2 &!>"! %8( 5$(! "! $2!

$($(! !( !$

8(!8 &

!/ 2 (! &2)! "! 2&2!$5 " $$2 $$!$ ( :!

$! "! $2 1 + %

?2$($ !: %9=!/!

512$($$(! "! $2 (& (/! !!:

$!!

211!

!$(! !" $!&#$(!$ &&=! &&! $2/!&#2 $(!&=!

2!%

/2!= 1 $(! $$!!$ 1 4@, 0 %+.2/ *

(2) $($ "!$2$2!

? &2$= /2 !:& (2:("

$!22!$ 2!

$(!1 $$($ &&#"!

11!

2:2.

2 2! 2!$ !

!A2 ! "! 2&2!$1 2:12.

!:22: & (!&$(5 1

$ ! :

$! $ $(!

&2$?"!$2$2!

2$($ !: = $(! !% 1 $ " $$2 ( :!

! !

!5 1

2 &&=! )!!"2: 2 /2!= $(! 1 $ $($ $(! "!$2$2!

? &2$=&(/! !A2 !

$ !1$(!

# $$!$ 2:$(!"!

21(2 ( "2$&2C$2=(2&!:2:1

1&&="$ !$!$!/!$(!

=2 !$&)1$!

!(25 $(!

$ !:

$!$$(! &2$ () * 2$2 :

$!$(2% 8(!8 = ! 1+ %5

?1 &

1 ! 2:5=(2 (2#/2!=2 $(!&=!

2!%8(! 2$2

!( !$

( !!= !$$(! &2$1

"2 11!

#$(!8 &5=(2 (2 .

$ &&1 #2$!

! !% 8( $(!$$& "! $2 !

$$+ %

?% 8(!8 = ! $$& 1+ %,5

"! $2&:=2$(2$!

$E%B"!

1 $(!$!1 12&2:1$(! &2"!$2$2$2&& $& !&2C$2% $($ =#5 $(! !( ! $ ! $ + %5

%8(!""!&&$? &2$ (&& !!$2$&! $ ! /!

$(!!( !$=2$(2$!

$$$(! $!1%B"!

1 $(!$!112&2:""!&$2&& $&"#!$%8(!$(! $!

2$2 (&& !2$(! ! :2/!2$(! 2:2&= % @2$( ( 212 $25 $(! 12&! # ""!&&$ 2 &&=!" $&#% 2:$ "! $2= ! #$(!8 &$&!:&

!$$2/!

1! ! !-$%<!!

0!/25$(!8

! /&!1(!

/2 !

$ !+ %5

?"!

$( !&#2:".:!$

!"% .:!!$ "

! # 2$! <! ( $2$&! #$ & %'(& $)& &*#+

,% # &

&+" - ! -5$(!$2&2 !1 ( !=21!=

$)!$ !+ %5

?2$2= !$= 1$ !"

"! $ $(!

1 (/2:$2$&!'

&.$/ & $ & ! 2!%,% # 2$!<! (1$(!

$5$(!$2&2 !1( !=21!=

!$ !+ %5

? "!

$(% 1 (/2:$2$&! % & & & !

01% & ! 2!% % # 2$!

<! (1$(! $5$(!$2&2 !1( !=21!=

!+ %5

?"!

$(% *!!"2:2/2!=$(!1 $ 2 $ !

1$(! !5$(!

:!1$(!! ! !5$(!! 2 ):

1$(!" $2!

512$($2$ =& !"

2$!21$(!$2&2 !1$(!! ! !

-$%<!!

0!/22 $)!$ !+ %5

?"!

$(% 9=!/!

5 $(! 8 & = .

$212! 2 !1 2: $ )!

! $21#$$= "!

&!>"! % $($=#5$(!& $ $2 !

$$+ % 5

> %*!!"2:2/2!=$(!:!1$(!! ! !5$(!&$2"&2!

1 = "

&# !%8(! "! $2 !

$$+ % 5

>% 8(! 8 & ( = ! 1 + %5

? $ "!$2$2!

7%6 $1&

1 $2 "2 (2"5+ %

?! ($"!$2$2!

7% $1 &

1&/!

11! $2+ % 5

? 1!

&!>"! %9=!/!

52/2!=1 $(! $2 1 $( 2$# 2

& $ )& &* #%.

& 3 & +

5 $(! &2$ ! !$2$&! $ :!$ "! $2!

/!$2&(! 2%!%+ %5

? $1 &

$$!5+ %

?$= &

1 $2+ %5

&!>"! 5$$&+ %

?% 8(!$$& "! $2 !

$$+ % 5

?% 8(!8 = ! "! $21+ % 55

?% $(2 =#5$(!!( !$ !

$$+ %5 5

%8(! &2$ =& !!$2$&!$:!$2$!

$E %B"!

1 $(!$!112&2:1$(!""!&$2&& $& !&2C$2 $(!!( !$1+ %5 5

?%8(!$(!

2$2

:2/!2$(!= (&&""&#$$(!!( !$ =!&&%

-2 !$(!$( !!!( !5$(!2 ! $2 =2$(

!: $ !&! !1 "! $2$$$(! &2$ 2 ( =2$( !: $!" 2$2$(!1 10+2 47%1 (&&

$212! 2:&#% @2$( ( 212 $25 $(! -- 12&! # ""!&&$ -(% $(!

2 &&=!" $&#% ! ! !&1 $(!""!&&$62

! "#(

$!!$($$(!2

! "#= = :&#!&2 &! 2 !

"!$7%= $"

/!$ !"

2:/&2!11! $2/!

2/2:&2 ! !5 (2$ (& !!2$(!

&/!1&2 2&2$#$"# "! $2 ! /!

# 2:($ !:

$!% @(!

! &! ! !&1 $(! ( /!(!!$&# $!!$($$(!2

! "#(12&!$2 ( :!$(! 1 "

/2:$($ "!$7% (/2&$!$(!$!

2$2 1$(!

!"&2 #5 (2$= $&2 &! $2!21# "!$ 2

!$(!8 !&$=2$( ( "! $2!$2&5$(!

!1 ! :

2 $(!

!$ !"$ ( $!$21&! ! !&1 $(!

! "#% 1$!

(! 2:$(! 2/& $!$2 :2:$( :($(!

! 512$($$(!8 !&$=2$($(2 "! $=(2&!! 22:

!7%, 2:($&# !$$(! & 2$($ 2 ! "!$7%, 62

! "#( $!>2!#112 2&1 $(!112 !1 2 $8 " $112 !

58! :57:&$"

/!$($$(! 2/2:

&2 ! !($ !!2

# ($( 2$# $(! 2/2:&2 ! !2

1/ 1 "!$7%= 1)! 2/&2 2"&# ! !1$(!

! $($ 2/2:&2 ! != !&&! !2:$ $ 1 $5 2$ $ !$)!$!$($2$= 2/&2 2!11! $2/!%$ !!

# ! $2 :

!!=2$($(!8 &$($"2$%8(!2

"#= 2:($&#(!&&2 &!$2!21#$(!2

!$2 ( :!$(!

&21 "! $2% 8( 5 45- 5 44 5 12&! # $(!

! "# $2 2

! $(! "! $2= ! #$(!

!!!( !$(!

!2 2$ ! ! !$ 2!

$(! !% %% !

< 2.

"#$%#$&&$'()$* +$',-). $ ( "#$%#$&&$+(&%'/0$ $ (