High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-CARB/37/2023dismissed

Punjab, Small Industries And Exports Corp. Ltd. v. M/S Bhullar Const. Co. And Another

2025-08-11Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri16 pages

! "#$%&'(()# * +,-**-*. --(( /* # 0#((* *# '-10* -

"* * 23(&4(56 *0--(( -("#*56 *0* - 77777

"*1*0 --( #*& !0.' 5 89 5 * : 0 (1

1 (: 0

'-1:* --(*'** ;- 0--( 50* - 06-# --* 0*#:0 # (-- 0 ' .* # (*0--( --(( #%' 00 --( --(( *-*0-***%$ #*& < 0*%* ( 5889* 0*5=*%* > : 0 3*

%1 0 (* *%**5 30*%10--((3 **-1 #' 5<5 !0

('* - 30 0* '0 5 (: 30 0 0 3*

'# 3 **1 * ? @ -* #' *' 0 0 3* A0 --( %$ ( #* & < 0 *%* 53* '

%10(*( * B#:

#'"* : *5 ''* ( #*5 0:*05 6 $#:'

::*6 %1 0 $#:'5 0 --( --((

*-* 0 '6 0 -* --( (: 30 0 --( C: (1

(:0--( ) -(0#-* -'%10--(( --( *' # (%*0(*''* (#*5%#0 -

:0'-#:$#:'

5*D# *--(1: * * -10*53 'A0--( *%:0

* -1 3 '6

5 30 0 3 (6* !

A0**5**6:0** **'0 # ( 30 0 # 0 '* %* 0 (* ''* ( #*5 0:*05 - 0 % #:0 *' 0 * ( *:*: #%(1*-***:--(%*0E:0#*) #*0* -( 0 0 --( *-* F6*' *:G530- '06:'1*'( 06(6 0** 0 ( *# #*530 0* #(C: ''*--' # ( -** 0 --( ) #*0* -( 0 0* ((10-*0--( (:0--(5%#* 0 * #'

%1 *( .* # (*0--( 0 #%'0((1 0--(3 (#*& 0*%* *30 00

-* (' 8 1 5 -*6 #* * ( 9 0 .' 58 A0# 50(15 5 (1

) #*0* #%' 0 * %$ 06: % * %1 0 : *10 #*530**50'*3 *(**'6: 0 %$ #-*(:50 : *10 *0-* --( * --( *' ** ''* ( *%* #* 0 -*6 & 0 ''* 5

! A0 -*('*-***:--(#*0 -*6 0 % * C % 9 1 0# 5 (1

1 (: 0 --(0 % ( #( "* *5(* # (*0* - 0 -- 0-* --( 0'-#:**-

%10 (*''* (#*50:*0) %0(0 * - 0630-*6 & 0*%* 5 (1 %1 -*

1 (: 0 --( %

) #*0* #%' 0 0 -*6 & ! 0 .' 3#(--(1--(-***#*& 0 ''* 5

! ( 0 % -(

' ( )530 0 ((3 --( 0 *

' (

E* (* # ( * 0 -* 30 0* %(

-*# 0* * .* # ( * 0 --( --(( *#: 0

(* # ( * 0 * - 0 *:# 0 0

$#:' **

#-* 0 % 6**#(%10*$#: 0 0'*

! "# $!# %&'( ') * * ') + 5' (+*+ ) #*0* #%'00$#:'

#-* 0 ( % '-((1 6**#( %1 * * #-*) 50# 5 00--( --(( %:F6*' *-*0 - C:(:01-* #* * C:0 -**--(0--( 3 #( E 50(1(:0--(% A0*

#* :* * 5303#(%0 -*('*-***:--(0 #*: ** -

%1 0 ( * B#: #'"* : *5 ''* (#*50:*0 A0 (* # (*0--( --(( 00--(3 (#*& 0*%*

# 050-*('*-***:0 ' 8 *'0 0'-#:**5*'

* (90.' 5

- '(150'-#:**

0 % -

%1 0 (* ( * B#: #'"* : *5 ''* ( #*5 0:*0 ;* 0 ''* 5 --( *' *''* ''* (6 * -*6 #* 0-* )/ & -*6 0 1 -* ::*6%10$#:'***-

%1''* (#*50

(6( * B#:5'1--(0''* (--((6 0E:0#*30-*9 *'0$#:' ***A0-*6 0*5 -#( 0--( 0(((*' # 0 ** -

%1''* (6 *''* (#*0*

- ((1#'*#***< 06("* #*5 8 * 0*5="> '%10''* & 0*%* & %: 30 % (# 0 --( 0(( ( *' 1 ** * * ''* (6 *''* (#*0*3 0

* 30 0 -*6 0 ''* 0-* )/ 0 ''* * 0#

!--.%/01234&.52..031344.25"%/36270 %#&344.25"%/"8"0"3#0H1-* ::*6 %10$#:'***''* (#*%(3 0 (6( * B#: '1 --( 0 ''* (--((#*30-* ,11 *'0$#:'*** 1 -* ::*6 %1 0 $#:' * **''* (#*0(6( * B#: ,* : *:( 6($#* *5 0 '1 %5''* (6 E:0#*'1--( 0 ''* ( --(( 6 0 E:0 #* 30 -* ,1 1 *' 0 0 $#:'*** "*60--( 0(((*' # 0** -

%1''* (6 *''* (#* 0* - ((1#'*#***I.)))0 6("* #*58 !8 '%1 0 0*%* ( 5889 9889

J30 : 10: 1 0*(3*0'%:* *.* " E:0#*5--( 0(((*'1*** * ''* ( 6 * ''* ( #* 0*3 0

* 300-*6 0

* 9-.&"7"360 &"0-30%/ 31 %--.%/0HA0 ''* ( --(( #* 0 ''* ( --((6 0((6#* - --( (%*30-* ,'0 *'0 (: # 0--( %**:0* -*6 3#( 030 ** -

%1 ''* ( #* (1 --(%( #* 0 -*6 ''* 5 30 0 %1 0 -*6 & -*6 *--(#'*#***< " 3(( & 0 *%* A0 -*6 ( -*

*% 0 -* (' 30 30 0 0 --( % -***A0# 5--(: 0'-#:**

#((1%(#*0''* 0-* ('*-***: # 0--( 9 *'00 '-#:$#:'***A0* - *'%1 0-,#** * #-*50*(6-* 0 5 ((3

K! A0# 5 *' 0

0' 0 *%* 3(( 0 * $#:' 5 (1#*& !0.' 0 % 0 , 0 %$ -1 * (# -#

!! A0 %#(C --( 5 036*5 0 --(( #*#* & 0*%* 5 * :6* %1 & 0 ''* &#% & 0''* ( #* -*6 0*#'*--( 3(( 0 (' -* % ((35 & 0 ''* %: - ((3 '-* 30 0 .' 30 0 :*( (35 30 0 ((3 *'*:& 8 0.' & 0''* (1 3-*('9 #*'(1*(( --( 0 * -*** #* & 0 *%* L "*# (0* *3#(#*0* 030#- # 0-* --(%*0 #*

5 *%$ 3* * %1 0 : *15 30 0 3*

*:(1 '-( 30%1 (* # (*0--((0'*3 *(

%1--:= (* '-( 2(1-##- >A0 -* (' ( #( %1 0 : *15 * # : 0 *D# 1 #'0-*-*0 * -15

1 50 ** (1 (#0

50-* --( 3 %**%1

' #(# -*# (0 --( 3#( ( 03 0 0 ' 3 --*(1 '5 30* 0 -*1* *

(:0--(5

1 5 *:#%1(* # (*0--( --(( A0 ,

# 30 0 * * * 300* & !0.' 3#(%--( %(--(-***

#* & 0 *%* * 30 & 0 ''* A0 D# '* 0*$#:% 00E>%(&#-*'#** * #-*0 (0*

#(300--( & !0.' , (#A0*(6-* 0$#:'5* 0#

;!* A0 6, D# 30 0 # 300*5* *' 50--( & ! 0 .' , (# %1 0

0' 0 ''* 5 0 % *:# %1 * F*:A0* '-*0: 0& 0''* 1 -*6 C & < 0 *%* & 0''* (1 -*6 *('-*9 *'0 0$#:'***--(: 530##*0* ::300*(1%10 -* * % !, ) '1 ( %-#00#:0 0 %$ ,-# - (--( (3 & <0''* 50(:#: & < 'C (* 0 0 -* , '0

-C * *1 '*1 1 31

* 5& 90''* * 30 0 & 0#( 0* 0 '' ' ** #( "5 3#( 'C (* 0 0 # :6

1 ( 3*

'530 0-* %,%1

1 *' 0 *6 0 #'' M ,-*10 -*50* 0*:0 ( 0 3* ' 0 #* ((3 0 3* ' % C * * A0 -*6 3 * #(0$#:'0

)

!!" K!) ;(C0

0'0*(+, *(#-# 50**0*-*6 0 ''* 30 0 -*6 * -* (' #-(30 (1-*6 30 0 0*-* --( 50-* -*63 30 0(0#* , (# 0 --( & ! 0 .' 5 3 #%(*-(0-*-*6* --( #* 0 0* -*6 0 ' & 0''* 5%131 * 5--( *'-*9 * (:--(50 5-*0 0(31%3

8 -*6%1* ( 9 0.' * A0 0* $#:' *( #- %1 * F*:*(( :# 0%(001*$#:' 30 0 ( 30 -*6 0 -*6 * -* (' -* (1 %1 30 0(1 % 5 # 0 & ! 0+( * 1 * & 0 ''* 3 ( -*

*6 :00%

(# 0 ''* 3#( 6** 0* 5 (#: 0 .' 5 * #( 30 05 0 --( %(1 & ! 0* 3#(%, (#A0 *:#'0 %*

0 ,0) $%&

' ( 6'

)&* + 5

8&9

5 ((3 &-99<5-*< K!, &0* 0(C *:# 0 0 %: '-( (5 *#* # 0 0

.' '# % 0##( %1--( &

0 30 0 -*6 05 =30 : 10: 0*30

1 0* (3 * 0 ' %: * >50-*6 03#(6**

# 0 (3 ) 5 & 9 9 0

- ((1 ((3

=+ , )

& #

# H! 9 J30 : 10: 0 .' 5 89 9 89 * 1 0*(3*0'%:* 5 '-#: 0 -* (' - * 1 # * --( %1 * : *-* %* * 30 0 ** '**#' 0 % ' #* 0 "*5 0 -* #*: 30 0 # 0 '**#' -( 0((%, (#> A0 -*6 3#( 06 % 30((1 #

*1 0 .' 3 0*3 , (# 0* %1 * 0%: '-( (*%16*# &

0 05 & <

0 '- 3(( &

0 5 --(10-*6 0.' K * '1 %L %6# (15 0**5 30* -* (' 06%(3050 -* 3((--(1 30 :10:0 **1 0 .' *'0 5 ((300%%1 '# % 0*3 # 30 0 %03* A0 *:#'5 0**5'# ( %*$ L * *((0 * 3*$ 0*:#' '%1&0*F*:00--( & ! 0 .' , (# :6 0

0' 0 ''* L

)630* 50 --( #*& !0.' *

(:0--(5 0# 5% *'* %10 #* *#( -*# ( 0 --( C:

(1 03 0 0 ' 6 '*( -* #(* A0(1:*#* 0* 00--( --((

*-*5%: *#'(10&50 (:01-* #* 0** 0 ( *# #**C: -**--( *::: # ( ) 3(( (0 - (*' %:6 (:0 (:0-- %0F6*'0(30 %#*'(1--()+

)

$ ' (!,+!53 0(0'*(1% # 0F6*' 6(65*1* C* (1 %( 3 A0 0 % ((3 '1 #% D# $#:' %1 0 -, #* A0 *(6 -* 0 $#:' ,* 0*#* K- ) -# 0 0 -*

*3*3((3** 6* 300

# 6(6 (#:0-*

*%-*('* C: #- 0 '* %1 31 (: - ( (6 -0 #*A01 ('00106

-* -* (' 30 0 -*' 3 -

30 '- -* '(* 30 #* -* :

) 0 % -(# %(

-%( ,-(53*- :D# 3010(1 %

' 0 ((1 '*(1 % # 0

F6*' * 3: 0 F6*' -*1 %*# . A0#:03*

# 0 0 '* (1300*3 :*

:(: *(%* *( C% 5 (%*(

0 % - 6

#% ($# 53*06300

* #'

50-*' C6: 6*# *(* A0 ('

# '-* ( ' 0*1 0* %#*# * '0(:1'C: 6*( %

- 63 0 '* 0(: %: # 6(%( A0 (3 (' ##%(1 % 6*1%15 (#:0F6*' / )#*635 0*:0'*'(( 0 :6*' % 5 0* : *#'( 0 #(

01 06 * %(

-%(,-(*0(10*3 % *5 0*

- 0 # #( ,-( 0 0 ( 3 C- -: * 6*( '0 1* # *%( :* -* #*( *-0-*

A0:6*'-*' * #* - ( %(: #* 0 01 -**' 0*# 30(: ''' (1 , - 0#( % # -%*0:6*'-*' A0 (3 0(* 6*1#*0 '(:0 0#( % 3*(*0%3L A0 --( --(( 3 (1 *D#* -( %# ( ' **'0* *0= # # >3 '#* -***:0--(300-*

*%-*(') ( 3(( (00,-*

= # # > &

! 0 .' ( #:0 1( * * #( -:#-0%$ 0 , #E36*506: *:*0%$ #:0% 06#*%00*%* 0 ''* 5 -1 * (# -# 5 0 ,-*

= # # > % * 0 6* (: (1 %1 0 -* -*

*% * (: --( A0 (1 %

%131, -%131*#(A0 - 0 %

( %1 0 -, #* * * #-*A0*(6:

0*:** #* ;+ ( 5 '# % *''%* 0 '*(1 % # # # 0 %'#0 :6 5 0* *:0 0 --(( 06 (1 A0 3 ( # (1 -# 0

6 01

( ,/ 0- ((3 & - ) - 9!5-* K,) 5036*5

*1'-0 06* # # 0 % 03 -*1 (0 (1 D# '* *:0 A0 -*

# # -* * 0 ,* 0

**1$#* 6 0 #* %1 & ! ) # # -*6 0: #*0* 0 % M 0 --( * : (1 0 % '

0:*#() # # 0300#*0 D#*300*

* 0#( 0 (1 A0 - 0 '* #*((1 *# 0

*((*(6 0

:0(: 0-*1 * % '1 (( * *M %# 0

- 0

D#*1 30( ,* : 0

**1 -3* * # # 033#(#*((1% ('(1 # 0 0#*'1*:* *(6) $# 1D#*1 301 0 -*1 3 : ( #*: (( 0 ' 6(%()0 3'1-# 0 * % *#(: *(31 '*(*(6300#* (:30--( '#*& < 0 .' ) (: 30 # 0 --( 0 #* (( #- * 0 0 '%-*6 & ! < A0**5 #* -5 * 30 0 06 % ,-*

(1 ' '*( *(6%10-*6 & < 0 ' , 0 ' '* % 6C(:30--( 30 0(( % (1#*& !30#** & <L +! F60* 0%$ -1 - ( #:0% 06%0#*0*%* 0 ''* 5 * --( ( #*& 0*%* 0*:6* %1* ( 90.' *& 0''* 5 (1 %1 1 5

1 * 9 1 5 * - 6(15 %

%131, -%131*#() 30 0-*10 0*3 % :(:'*5 0*(1%1 # 0 -* 5 0

* 0 #*5 % 5 (31 %*:'000* 0- #* 00-- -*1'106 D#*%0D#1 $# 5 30 '1 3 % ( %1 0 * -*1N 5:(: *( 0 L

) %( 0 0 * * #-*5 0 --( 5 * : *' &." J99!

5 '-#::0$#:'0E>%(E:0#* '%150*3 (1 1 (:0--()0 5(C0-*

5 0* 3 ,-( 3*0 0 ' 0

(1 --( 5 %1 ' *6 ,: 1 A0 E>%(-,#* *:0*(:(1 1 5 '

0 --()0-* 50 # *5 0*%:(:(1

%109 -*-*6 *(:--(#*& 0''* ) ( %(00 0--(( *-*

# 0:*0 0 '* 0 % %1 0 ''* ( #*5 0 * B#: (6(5 0:*0 --*(15 0 # ( *-* : 0 *-* %* 0 ''* ( #* * 3 ( ( # ( A0# 5 0 --( --((0 %:*

(1:(:-#* #:0'*)#:0 06 #*'(1(:0--(300-*

*%-* (') ( 3(( (00' #'*-*-* * -1 (1#-0-*-*0 * -1 %10 -1:: 1 *#-0 (6*1) 0 -* 5 0 * -1 0 '-#: $#:'

3 -*-*

%#0 '3 (( (1 !

J ,-( *0 ': * 0 * (1*(1O'0 -*-*0 * -1 %: (( *'0 -1:: 1 *

- # 0* 50--( --((0 ' *%(1( 03 # # 5'# 0(

1 ::*#* '*( %( 0 0 , 1 , -( * #'

3**: (1

(:0--(%1 0-*('-*

*%%1(3

*:(150-* --( '

A0'--(5%:'%**5 '

' ( '

(

& 2 400* -C:* P J 400* -*%( P J