High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5957/2019dismissed

Executive Engineer, Public Works Department B And R Div No 1, Mini Sectt Bathinda v. Niranjan Singh And Others

2020-02-18Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina7 pages

!"#$ $%& '% ! ( % )% *

&% '& + '

% %,-& &.%/0&/1 '% ! ( -%) '*

'& + ' #%# 23 ! 2 $)&.%*

&4% .% 0'

5&'.,,'+ %

%66 7 ,%.% '%%

, ' 8&& + -. &%9

&%%8

5&.+ '0,

&% 8 ,' 8/ &

%, !8, "9 #+%6 $ $%& '%% '% %,- &.%/0&/1 '% & &&

&%,,

&''%'3: +%'8/&66%,%$%& '% 08% %

.&8/&+ ;%++,% ''

, &!%++ <%,66 6%6

%, &% '86+ & %,% '&%8

'6'$&&+ &% 8 ,' &6 &*+68

.&&%%8 6 &&+ 6 & 6+

'' = 5%.& &,% '+.%% ,%, %% &6%7 '* =>$&% %,- &.%/ 0 &?&0 @5&<% '07 ,, $%& '% ''&%.%' :5&+ ' .& % ' 8

& ,%6% . %' .& & 6+ % %' &%.%'5&/&%,,

'&%68 & 08%>6>66 A%'9 # A%'9 '6%

&% 6 6+ % : 5&'+%6 &%%'&08%&%

%,% '6% ,%,B%69 '&8/%.%'

& %6 6+ % .&% /8% %,'% 1 & 8) ,' '* =:&08% ' ,% 0 &?&0 @ &'+%6 +,%''&%&

%&,% '%

8&%

'%+8,% %

'&01 '

& &08%66' 6 ' 8/&%

&&%%,% '% % &,%.% '% 5&,% '.% ', % .&%

.&%+% &6.& &%++,% %++ <%,66 .% 6%'&66%,* & %6 6 /

, '

&% %7.%6%'&%6 8 %++ '%<%,66 & %9+& %+&%

= ++% ''

&,% 7 '86+ &8) .%%'.&+%++ <%, 66 8/&,% >+++%/

5&%7',% '%,, &% %,- &.%/ *%,'6+%#++%'8/&+ %%&'.& %0

!>:5&%.%'&,,%%&' %0

!> 5&,% '7'.'

',%

& - &.%/%,,

'&% %,- &.%/ && '646

46 $%& '%* $%& '% # &*%! )%85&%7 '3 ,,% %,

8&'&.'

5&%.%'&08%%%&'%0

!>=

08% % = C% )% *

&% '& D

1 '%% '&C5&,% '' &66%, &%+%&,% ' '%7 % ,%,,% '% 8

' 66%, ++ +%9

& %')

%% .&,6+%&,% '&%'.%/' &+% ',66%,- &6+ % %6 .,'8,%8,8'6 ' %'% .&A*&', & A% 6+ % 5% +% / <% ' 07

&%8,% ',6 0 =&?0 =@5& 08%&,'&%&,% ' 66%, %%,,

,,% B % %4&'66%,%.,'%% ,% .,,%++,/%+& '0+.% &6&*8 # %,>6>6+ % 0&/<% '07 $%& '%8/ &08% %'

6%9 %,%''B%69 ,% ' 5&08%%++,'&8%8% %' %,>6>B%

69 ,% 'B % %4&'8/%

8 E>+ *7%F%'&66 6%' % /+ +'

6 &+'

'* =:&0 '&.,,8''' %'% .&,%. , '8/ /&

%' &' &7 &,6'& %++,% %++ <%,66 3 5

&6+

'' ,% '66%, .&&%', '&%++,% %++ &% &,/,6'& %6 % &&+& ,8'

'&+ &0 5&,% 'G'

&%&,'&% &%++,% '& &%++,% ',,% ' ' ' .&&&&%8 ' %, '%

&'+%,&%++,% %+,%. ' %/ ,% % <%,66 %

8%++ ',, ' & %9

5&,% '.%%7' =% '%/% &+ + &,% '%')

&%7',% '%,, 8% & % ,%, ++ &% 8 + 8/ & > .&,%

& %,B 6 & %, &+% &66%, &% '&%&+

%++,% '* =:&0 &.&%&08%&% & && ' % ''' & 6% .&& ' &%,,

8 & 5& %++ <%,66 &+% '%% &

%&,% ' % '&%%')

&%7',% '%,,

%8/ , %')'% & + %++,% & %&,% %

8 ''%&

%&,% &/% =.& & %8/,% '.%%7'

&%'& ,18, & & 9

&%&%&,% '%, %8,/% '+% &/+ .

,/8/%,,6% % '&'+ &,% & +%+%&6%7 %, %6 )% '% %8,6+ % 5& 66%%, '6

6+ % &,% '%7'+%/%8, &+ +, &0 =.&&%6 : 5& <%, 66 %++ ' .,' 8 ,9

% & %')

,% '.&&&% 8 %7'6%&.&&%7'

'1 &6% 6 .&%+&% 8 .

& .& +,% &%,,%+&&% % '&+ % %8 & 6 +%&+.

.&&+ *%

+ >%7',% ' &8 &0&/ ,

% '8%%8, .&& % 6% % %8,% % % '',

%++ % <%, 66 1 6% % %8, 1 -% ' 4% B'&%%6 1< ! )%8 -%/% %:

201 ! )%8

-%/% %

&&,'&% .,',% % % ' +%' ''

, &'!>%6 '6 *

!&+ +,&%8 ' ,+' '0,

& %6

&+' *6&% 'G% (& $&% .% %

,% ,::.&,,/

'!%6*

& * '<%, #$2 !< .& &&,'%,,.2> H1 . # $ & ' &

*6-% ' 4% % ' % & B'&% %6 % &01 ! )%8% '-%/% %

' !%6 *

& * '<%, = &%8 &,'

&% & '

%++ & <%, 66 ' '

, ! %8, '* ! & &%

'&,' 8 ' . '0,

& 1 '%1 & %' -%6 &46% > !< .%8 '8/ &&%% + '* !% % &6+

'' 6% % %8, & 8/6&%

&&%' &+ & 8% %

8+,%'.

,6& ,%. .&& .,, ,' &%

+ '* !6% % %8,H 5&,.% %++,' % % ' % % 8/ &

6)'

6 % $% *

&I$%,.% *

&% & % &8*

&% '& 3: ,

2 3

'%) 46%$%% 4%&6<%,*99% ,= %6

&% + & '0,

& 1 '% '* &' , !' 6% % %8,% % % ''6

%++,% %++ <%,66 5& 6&%&%& .% + 8,, % .&&8& ,% %% ' 8'6'.&6+,%/ = .&%8 8&&+ %'6'

,6 .& E>%&5&&%,,8'+' & !!% ",%A ' !B%'%1 '%,* '%& &% %&&6 / %'%,++1 .,' & ,% & + &% 8

'6' ,6 5&+ .,,'+&6 /%''

'+'+ , +%/6 &,8&&% .& &6 &

: %&%6 +%' &%8,' &%

8&%+++%$ &&' % / &% 6%/87'1+ &+

-01 & 6&.&%'

&+% ,/ ,+ .&&% 6% % %8,1&%%9 %,%8,6& %8,&6 & +

&%&%

' %,+% '&'6%,&+ %+%6& 6&66%,%$%& '%

!"##$#$