← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2923/2011dismissed

Nirmal Singh Etc. v. Sarup Singh Etc.

2015-09-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages





     



 !""#$%$&'"(!")*"+  !,-.

  $+) /$&0,  &!,"+ (("// &!% 1"+%2%  +2($&0, !,"+%  "%(&3"&!%  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$+&',-%  4,"!,"+ "(+!"+%/# /( ("+%) 5*" //6"3!%""!,"7230)"&!8  *"+""++"3!!," "(+!"+%+&!8  4,"!,"+!,"7230)"&!%,2/3*"+"(+!"3$&!,"$0"%!8

+"%"&!'

+ 9 +$&-"&$+3:# !"6$!,

%/;  +$&-3:# !"- +!," (("// &!%

++2& $&-"&$+3:# !"6$!,

++72&1""+, +) -3:# !"- +!,"+"%(&3"&!% <<<<< )(*$+& ," (("// &!=3""&3 &!% +"$& "02/ +"#&3((" / 0 $&%!

!,"7230)"&! &33"#+""3 !"3>-6,"+"*5!,"96"+(("// !" 2+!%"!= %$3"!,"7230)"&! &33"#+""3 !"3?.?( %%"3*5!,"$:$/ 230"  "&$+  $:$%$&-  !$ / -  6,"+"$&  !,"  +"/$"  :$%=@=:$%  %("#$$# ("++) &#"!," 0+"")"&!!%"//3 !"3 6 %+"7"#!"3 &3 +"2&3" +&"%!)&"56 %+3"+"3&"%%"&#"-!,"96"+(("// !" 2+!"A"+#$%"3!,"3$%#+"!$&2&3"+"#!$&!,"("#$$# "/$"#!- ? &30+ &!"3!,"3"#+""+%("#$$#("++) &#" 0+"")"&!!%"// *5# //$&02(&!," (("// &!=3""&3 &!%!"A"#2!" &3+"0$%!"+!,"% /"



3""3&+"#"$(!!,"* / &#"% /"#&%$3"+ !$&  + 9 +$&-  /" +&"3  "&$+  3:# !"  %%$%!"3  *5  %/;

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

+%("#$$#("++) &#"&"%%"&#"-!,"96"+(("// !"2+!, %&! ;"&$&!#&%$3"+ !$&!,"#)(/"!"+"(+!0$:"&*5"6 &D 2+$ "2+!,"+%2*)$!!"3!, !!," 0+"")"&!!%"//- +")"&!$&"36 %&!!5("3*5!,"+"0$%!"+"3""34+$!"+,"$&;, 3*/!!"3$&# %" %$0& !2+"%*!,!,"6$!&"%%"%-$"- ,$&3"+$&0, &32;,3":$&0, ,"%( #$&0*"!6""&!,"/$&"%!,") $&*35A 4BC6 %&!"E2 / ," +" )"&!$&"3$&!," 0+"")"&!!%"//$%, /%, +".$0, % $%6 %-6,"+" %!,"%2$!$%+, /%, +"B$0, %$%6 %," +")"&!$&"33$%#+"( &#$"%," :$/56"$0,"3$&!,")$&3!,"96"+ 2+! &3!,"96"+2+!2&3!, !!," 0+"")"&!!%"//6 %%2++2&3"3 *5%2%($#$2%#$+#2)%! &#"%-*2!+3"+"3++"2&3!,"" +&"%!)&"5 $&%!" 30+ &!

$&03"#+""+%("#$$#("++) &#""2+!,"+%2*)$!!"



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

.

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

+"&3"+"3$&  /012 3   2411&5125607 6  6 2

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

8

% )"/$&"-#$!"3 &!,"+7230)"&!+"&3"+"3*5!,$%2+!$&0912,:6 41146 ; +<0$.1$%=@=:$%!,"0+ &!3$%#+"!$&*5 !,"96"+(("// !" 2+!- + +$&, %+""++"3!,"7230)"&!!,"

&H*/"2(+")"2+!+"&3"+"3$& 411 372; 69+ &(<  . ! %2*%! &!$ !"!, !!,"3$%#+"!$&, %!*" "A"+#$%"3$& + +"%!+ +"# %"-)2#,/"%%-6$!,#$+#2)%("#!$& ", %2+!,"+ +02"3!, !%$&#"!," 0+"")"&!!%"//6 % "A"#2!"3$& &3&6!,"% )", %*""&%20,!!*"("++)"3$& .-!,"+"+"-$&# %"3$%#+"!$&, %!*""A"+#$%"3-!,"& %("+!," 3$#!2)/ $336&*5!,"&H*/"2(+")"2+!$& 77 $16



 1

 72 2  261    1 776:1  411  #2  

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

<

3#2)"&!6 %!5("3$+%! &3!,"&%$0&"3 &3$&$!$ /"3"2+!,"+%2*)$!!"3 !, !!," +02)"&!!," (("// &!%!, !!,"*/ &;%! )(( ("+%, :"*""& #&:"+!"3$&! 0+"")"&!!%"//-!,2%- //%/ !&!,"$+ #"", %3+ 6& !," !!"&!$&!,$%2+!!!," 0+"")"&!!%"//!%2*)$!!, !, 3!," */ &;%$0&"3%! )(( ("+%*""&2%"3!#&:"+!!,"% )"$&! 0+"")"&!! %"//-!,"&!,"%$0& !2+"%62/3&!, :"*""&&!,""&3!,"%! )(( ("+- *2!62/3, :"*""&)2#, *:"!,""&3!,"( 0" &3!,"!5($&062/3 , :"*""&:"+!,"%$0& !2+"% "2+!,"+%2*)$!!"3!, !  %("+7 ) * &3$ A +!,"

5" +=-!,"!! / +" !,"/ &3, %*""&)"&!$&"3 %B$0, % $%6 %$&#/2)& &3&";$// , %*""&3"%#+$*"3 %?$0, %. $%6 %  &3 (+$+  ! $/$&0  !," %2$!-  /"0 /  &!$#" 3 !"3 ?

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

>

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

 *"  /;"3  $&!  +  !," 3723$# !$&!,"/$%*"!6""&!,"( +!$"% , :"," +3!,"/" +&"3#2&%"/+!,"( +!$"% &3 ((+ $%"3!," ( ("+*; ,"!+$ /2+!- !"+&!$#$&0!," 0+"")"&!!%"//-2&3!, !!," 0+"")"&!  !  %"//  6 %  %2"+$&0  +)  %)"  %2%($#$2%  #$+#2)%! &#"%- 0+ &!"3+"/$"" +&"%!)&"5-*2! /%+"&3"+"3 $&3$&0&$%%2" 6$!,+"0 +3!!,"+" 3$&"%% &36$//$&0&"%%$& :2+!,"+"%(&3"&!= (/ $&!$% &3!,"% $3$&3$&0%, :"&!*""& %% $/"3*5!," (("// &!= 3""&3 &!%"$!,"+*5$/$&0 ((" /+#+%%=*7"#!$&%$+) /$&0,$& "A )$& !$&=$&=#,$", 3 3)$!!"3!, !&";$// / &3$%#)(+$%"3B $0, %-*2!$&#+%%="A )$& !$&,"%! "3!, !&";$// $%"E2 /!?$0, % .$%6 % &3!,$% #!, % /%*""& 3)$!!"

3*57 $*$&0, &("+2% /!," 0+"")"&!!%"//-$!$%2&3!, !!

=

3$%#+"( &#5+"0 +3$&0!,";, %+ &2)*"+%)"&!$&"3$&!," 0+"")"&!! %"//-*2!$&)5:$"6-!,"+"$% #/"+$# /"++++"0 +3$&0!,"!! / +"  ;, %+ &2)*"+% &3 %%2#,$!# &&!*" %2*%! &!$ /0+2&3!3$%*"/$":" !," 2!,"&!$#$!5 &30"&2$&"&"%%!," 0+"")"&!!%"//:"&!,"+6$%"- %("+A !A -$!, %*""&(+:"3&+"#+3!, !!,"% /"3""3 "A"#2!"3$&!,"% )":$// 0" !!,"% )"+ !", %*""&)"&!$&"3$&!," 0+"")"&!!%"//,"%!+5/%$&0!,"%! )(( ("+%;"(!$& * 0*5 7 $*$&0,$%&!*"/$": */" &3$&)5:$"6-/ #;%*& $3"%+!,"+" %& !, !&6$!&"%%+)!,""/"#!+$#$!53"( +!)"&!, %*""&"A )$&"3!%,6 !, !  #!2 //5  !,"  3""&3 &!%  , 3  $&!"&3"3  !  ((/5  +  !,"  "/"#!+$#$!5 #&&"#!$&"$!,"+ &5 ((/$# !$&$&!,$%+"0 +3 //"0"3!, :"*""& %2*)$!!"

3+(+"( +"3, %%""&!,"/$0,!!,"3 5," 0+"")"&!!%"// , %*""&(+:"3!,+20,!,"!"%!$)&5 4=.2;,3":$&0,-) +0$& / 6$!&"%% &3":"&!,"! )(1"&3+ 4=7$!$&0,7$!$&0,, % /% *""&"A )$&"3!(+:"!,"+"0$%!"+A 4C1$%=@=:$%!," : $/ *$/$!5 !,"  * / &#"  % /"  #&%$3"+ !$&-  !,"  (/ $&!$%  , :"  "A )$&"3  4= D"/-+ &#, & 0"+- +$"&! / &; ))"+#"- !$ / - 4= %,;D2) +- & 0"+-! " &; !$ /  &3 4=> !

2&7 * !$& / &;," (("// &!=3""&3 &!%, :"&!*""& */"! # 2%" &53"&!$&!,"%! !")"&! +2($&0, &3 %6"// %! )( 1"&3+-6,, :"3"(%"3&!,"/$&"%!!,"&"%! !"3$&!,""A )$& !$&= $&=#,$"C $3 :$! ,"!+$ /2+!-6,$/" ++$:$&0 ! $&3$&0!, !!," 0+"")"&!! %"//6 %%2++2&3"3*5%2%($#$2%#$+#2)%! &#"%-6 %#)(/"!"/5*/$:$2% !,"+"(+!!,""A("+!-)2#,/"%%-":"&3$3&!(&3"+2(&!,"3""&#"



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

            

 

  

    



  !

          

     "   !

    #$%   &'

J  !        

 

   





 (  &!,"!5("3) !"+$ / !$&32!$!,"%!+;"%!,"%$0& !2+"%+$&$!$ / +" :"+!,"!5("3) !"+$ /+*"&" !, )   * *   !      

+ 

     

   



 

 



      





        

     

    

 

         !   

     ,  

   *   

 

  

        -

         ! 

  

     

  

 

   

   ,      ** 

  

   

   !       * *   !       



    

  



  %   

*              

     

                  ! " 

  

   .  /    .  / 

       0   

.  / %   +

  * 

.(  /  

  12$%!    

 

+   + 

   !    

 

 

  3   +   

  

   +      

   !  !  

 

  

4 5"   #$2#$



   

         

 



6"    

    !

 



        

 +    

             



     $  



  



*  %  +    

             

  4 D""($&0$&:$"6!," +")"&!$&"3*%"+: !$&%-3&!$&3 &5$//"0 /$!5 &3("+:"+%$!5$&!,"7230)"&! &33"#+""+"&3"+"3*5!," 96"+ (("// !"2+!,2%-!,"%2*%! &!$ /E2"%!$&%/ 6-&!$#"3 *:"- +" &%6"+"3 0 $&%!!," (("// &!=3""&3 &!% &3$& :2+!," +"%(&3"&!=(/ $&!$% ," ((" /$% ##+3$&0/53$%)$%%"3 73?72+8 )(*$

312 &',-%