High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7212/2016allowed

Murari And ANR v. Deepak Tayal And ANR

2019-05-01Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!!"" # !$%&" '! (

) &* +,-. !!""

% /-. !0

*1-. !0 (. 3 4 &- 5%5- 6 . " - + $ !" 74 6 68*.""3*"64 "& 3"3.3 )+9: 4330;';< 3. " 4&!$%&"8!0- ! - 6"&- )

3 4 < & 8

)6= 34 &86 - 4 3 "6!

) # " - >> 3 !!$%&"8.+5?5?5@64 /"5 ? 3 /" 38 3. "-"636!+ ! "6 74 >7

6 (."3+ $+ 336 .""3 ="3 5%5- 6 6&" .3 3 0;'@7 A 6&"+43.4&(.+ $43!""A 4 6-+ 6&" B .""3*"64 6*- !08!$%&"+ "63 3. " .3 3"366= 3 6&"43.4&(.- "4 6"& (. $""+ , A (. 6 "!" , $ " , A!4& 6?.";!"- 6-+ 3"(.

44 3 A $ "35'0 7 ) - <<-<75(?+ (") 6 33-4 !!!" +63 "6!5 +6 464 "!0- .".6 .4& 6 - !5'- $!"+ $+.

< " &! $ . " 3 +3 !-+ % +3! + + !0' 3 63""3- +3!!&6" "6! 5 +6 464 "! 08 6!&-!! "6!63 !+ !" !0+ "3."..3 " 6 6 !"&+.") !"!&6"

"6! !"3 !- ""+3 + 6 C B 3 (.$ !" 3"3.3 3. " 43 3 ;';< 4& ! - ""3D(( 5 !.-+ !"& 6!+ 6 6+ 6D(( < C "6!"4"46 3 - $4& !<+6D(' 7 '" * !". !! !. "6 5!. - !E"603

7 6(C4F63) $(C -!0. .3"GF'-!&3GF' !& !"&GF'< 3 " " !- "6 !+64& %4 ".+< - + " "633. & ."!!"4 ? -+ + !-+ !

!! 3 " 5 . " " !433 3 56&46 %4 "+ ""3 + 0 4.!07

!"#$% & '

( ( !$)%* +

& '

(

, -

++ ( . (

, -

/0 + (

++ (. (

' +

++'-

- 1& &

' +

++'-

& - -

, -

- ' ' 2++ +

- ' ' 2++

- +

++'-

'++'-

&- -

++'-

' (

+ 4

56, $, -

- +

++'

3& +

' -'+-

31 77176(

( +

;+.-5 + "!! %4 " 4+3% 3 %4 " 04. "& 4 !+3!"+6!!" .@%4 "! + "3+ 6"!6! ) # " % ! 6".&""4&!.".- ! B !. 33

4& +4" 4!!!"6"

, !

!." &- 3 "&!6&3 4 . "4!

C ""3 + ." - &$4 !! !44" 6-) # " ! +" "3" 5 + !. !6! 6!!-+ , &+ !!& 63"3"!.!-+ 3$"" ;&! " !! 4 ! + " , 3 &! ! % %4 " 4. "&-+ "63, % "6 ""&!. !0+ 4& 3"3.3 3. "- "+ (.

" "-+ $ , % "6 "6 .4" !08!$%&"+ 4& 3"3.3 3. "% "6 "" +"" 6& . % " . 6! 6 $-&+(C-+ 6&. 436!&5'GF(-!&! ) <?(?GF(-!& 3 GF(<-!&! 66!GF(754 "!0 !" !&"GF'-!&'?GF'!& !"& GF'<% !0!!

+ 4& 3"3.3 3. "% -. 4& "6 3 4 5 " .4" !4& %4 "4 ++3"&4&5 ""&4" 3 (.+ 3"3.3 3. "4&!08!$%&"% - 3 %4 " 0. . "63 ! ?63 0- %4 " & 6!!&4"5 6 -6 +34 & 6 ; 4 5%5 5 !66!

- 3 64>&54&4 ".

!"!# $4&.* ;3 ? + + " "3 + 3 3 6!-+4. G "43. ! '-E!6 +$6 @ " 6!& & % & % '

( !&) $ 4&?* ? + + ""3+ !!&66! "3"!.

> .6-+ + H"-+ 4. 6+43$ 6! 4- + !!"&!!"6 6 !!"6 +$ 4'7-E!6 ;+.- , 36 "! 6!& 5 - +>&3 5%5-+ "4F! +$36!"3 3 66 - + ! & + H " + $ 7 & 63 ! 3 3 6- 33 " +F!

+ 6 "&6% -6 + !!.46 5 ! - 5 3"" 6-+ "4!!!!!$6 "&6 4' -E 5 .+ & * + , - )' & ' .

/(!

0 . "&7I 6 4 + !!3 6 "&6 $' -H-7J'>-7E 56 & '

1 2 - - ' 3

0$!

"!// I46+!"F! 3 !&"66 '7-E!

6 - "!&6 '7-FJ' -7E 56 & '

12 - - '3 ! 6 "!"> + "4!!!3 6!!&4"6 ' -7F>J --E 5 .+ & * + , - )' & '.

! - "6 "36! ." ' -E "' -E "F!-"

'<-E% "6!6 ' --H<-J

-<-E % "6+ "4"3K I! 66 "3 "6!"" "": 6!+- "4"& ""4, ."4 ! % ". "6 % 3 %4 " 0<4. "& +3% 3 0<. 3 ! % !!""4 " !!""E"6 ""+

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#