← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2954/2011disposed of

Gadhori Devi And ORS v. Naraini Devi And ORS

2022-04-20Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal12 pages

 





!

" #$ %

&

% 





      

   '" ((  

 

 

      

 

  ! 

)

*$+

, # 

+ -

"+   " #$  %      " &%     

'()!' 

   *+',(,'  " - . %%   + -

"+.

#

 $   %/  '()!' *+'

,(,'      +  .   

 . 

 0  0 /% 



 . 

  1 

0 

 .  

  



%  

       -  

    2   /  

 

0  0 -3

3 -%  $./4 

+   !((  %0

 - 5      0 /

 

% / 0     

0  /0 

%/

 6   '

Devitya | Shish Ram (now deceased) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Smt. Piari (now 2. Ram Rati

3. Shanti 4. Gadhori

5. Naraini Devi 789-*

: 9 

 9 

9

:

9

:

9/

:

:

;:

7 7 7 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

 ''''''''''''''''''''''''

20$ -;$/% -



% !$2 )/8$ 0 -< 9

,:

9

= :

; 1

   

0    ! - %-2$%-$ -- 

./     -* - 

 %  

 /

   0

    0

   -   2

 /  

 .

1 

 -

+     !((/

0

  -   -  



= ) 1 

 - 

0

 

 0 

+ / .  -/- =    .

%0 0

.

- -  1 /

0 . 

   -   

 

    -

 1  /  0

 . -



/ 

   /

 %/-

  

   5/  

./       - .

$.4  

0      %   

 .

$.4   -

     

 -  > -  ./   



 .  ) 1   % 

 .

%   / .  '

? +    

        

    @A 2.

Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to injunction as alleged? OPP 3.

Whether the suit of the plaintiffs is not maintainable in the present form? OPD 4.

Whether the plaintiffs have no cause of action and locus standi to file the present suit? OPD 5.

Whether no proper court fees have been affixed by the plaintiffs? OPD 6.

Whether civil court has no jurisdiction? OPD , 

B 8 5        

 

  + %  

  

+$./ %

 +- %-0  %  1 + C6

  5  0/ - %-0    .

$.4 -3*

 $.4

 -/   .

$.  4    1    + %        0  

 %    0

-   

/

.

 -  -0 - ./ -4 %-0  A 

.

% -/ -



-0 -    % -

-0 - /

0 



-0

-  

 ,

      .  

/

0  

  0D/ 

 

 0 /%/

/   &     .

 





/   ./ .



 .-  $  %     .  

     + 

   

  

 



8;9*: 5 

  %()9



E () F:+ 0  .%  0- 

0

8=   

   -  0

 



0

+  -

8;9*: () % ./



   

% 

 

 /

    2.-      0      *    "/ 010 21 3, "/ 214 21  

5  6(.

#/7 10 $271 3, 10 4 -4  8



+97: #0799 "; 3, "1<: #4

-17 21  5

 86   %

    .  ' 

  -4 % %/   .    





8;9*: ()  

0- 

/ 0 /



     .

 

0- 

% 





/0 D  =  .

% 0

- - 

  G   -4 %-0    .

$.

4 

  /

0$./ 5/

     -1 

% 

.

 

 -

    -  .   0

% -  -0 -  $ 



-0 - 

  -  

-0 -  



   

   1    

 -0 - D

   

.  







   - 



   0

   

     -0- D /

%- 





0

   %       %$ % 

 %-0- D   - 

(  .

% /0     6  

8;

() '

?8;C6



+ HC

  %0

.

-  6

..

 / %I  - - 

..

%J      -     %   

    + 

  . / .  H 9:1   . 

6 - D %   0  . 0-    

0 

 90:1  .  - D  %   .

 . .   -%0 

     / 

0.



/ .+  :1 0 0/ - %

 /-

  . 

6 - D  

-   . %

0 

 % 

-             D/ .

     .  - D%   .   K

  .

 %0 0 

 - 

/ 0  - % 

   - 0 

    5



8;9 : ()

 

0 0/ - % 

/-

 

6  . - D  

-    D/ .

   . 

- DC   . -0- D

 0 0 

 - 

/ 0  - 5    



 - 0 

   F0  * /

.  

  8;9 :   "/

=;1        

 -   // 

   .    

6     - D      -      

D/ .



 

 1 

      .  -   

   

   5 #/7 10

=;1%  

 *  .

8;9 : ()    '

?

8= C

  D    /   -  

 0 /  0

 0  



  .  

%  - 

0/0 0

 

      0

                .  

%

0  

% 02

  

 *  0

.

/ - 



0  

0 .

.

02

  

 * %   0  

     0

    -

0/0 0  

A -0  . 

8;



 / 

8= C

 %

     . .  

 /  



1    0    0   -    .   

.  /  0-  

 /

-     

  0    9 :    

  8;    



 5   

8= C

            0         .

/   -  0   $       

 0     .

 .



8; .

8; 



    +       0          0  / / %

8= C

    - % /



0 / 0

 %      0      

    

  0

 

    . 



 /



 0 .

.

02

  

 * 5/%

8=.





 // 

 0  / *  /0 . 

 

./ 0  0// - 

 8;  

 $/  .

 0    0   

 / 1  / %



 

 -  9 :

 

  8;%  G%     0  /   .

/ -  -

%

        .  /     0

  / 1   %



  /  0 -     

 

/

5

 .  /     0         % 

% 



 0      0//

   - 

  -

-   . . 0  0 -  

 .    -

    

  8;     

   +

   

/ 

8= C

   



 

0   .  /       0      

-D - 



+

    

0

 

0 

 -

.

-  

    

  8=    

 B    % +79: #07 +9 ";>

=;1%  * % . / 

/ D #/7 10>   1 2.-  0  *  0  . *   

! *  5  /

% 

/ * %

+

0

       -   -    1

   -     

-

5 -

  . % -.

   

%

  %./    %/ /

 -1 /



  !((  - - 

 

-    

0

 

 

 0

-0- D 0  -1



 

 /   

    5 

-

% * 



+ 5  %0%  %- -4 %-0  0

   A      .          -  4 % -0  %     *                  

   

 

8;9*: () 0  



 



8= 5 C

 %=,

8= =,  6   '

"8= "1?

?

@=7 ?

=4 1A=71 :0 9B  : H5  - 

0/0 % 0  

   0

       . 

%

0  

%02



 

 *  0 .

.

I   0 

      

  - %    0

.    + %  /

    0



 

   

5     %( =98 ( =:%  

0 0/-   





J ; 5

 -

  .

8=

=,  

 

 - 0  1  

8;          +       0

    0         

   - 5    

%   - 0/ -  



  . -0- D  

   D/ .-    -  . -0- D %

 

8;9 : ()

. 0 .

/  

0  - 5

%  



  / 0  .

/ /



0 

0 /

      - 4 %  -0  %  /   .  +   

  -%  % -0 - 





1

% 



-0 - 5   % 



   %

%- 

0 ./  

%/

   A0 % 

-0- D

 5 

-

% * 

0 6

0 0

 





   -0- D

 %  -%

 -0 - D 5   %..

/ -4 %-0  % /

     A

/

   -0- D

+

 % 0 0  

% 

 %/  

   -

 

 ! 1   *   -  

  

     

  

0  



0      .



 

 L  .-

%  . 

  -  )  

/  0

  /    -     

0

- 

0  M     5    

     /        

./ %()850

  -   0

 0  

    . 

     . 

  0



%  /      0

     /  .

- 

  8   .-

 

 %

%       ! 

+ -

"+

D

# %

+  D .3   N 3 +  0 N 3