High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/9870/2014disposed of

Ram Bhateri And ORS v. Kapoor Singh And ANR

2018-10-10Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()) *+ ) +, !-%" ,!-& ..!//' & 0!-&1& 2.""-*%'3,'" ,!- !&."'4!' &

-!&!' (

-)21/4!!.2,'4!/5/647"$ !#"- ,!..!//' &)

-)0) +&5-"".647"$ !#"--!&."'4!' '")) /%+' &,7!#%/!4 ,!%'& ' ..!/&&%/%'3 ,!"-4!-4 !4 )).&&!49: ,! " "-$$%4!' /%+&-%91'/6%&- ,!-!%'

# !- "9!-!#!--!4 "& ,!-%91'/ '4%' !-+&"#5,%$,$/%+.! % %"'

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

>!&,21+-&"'"#3' ,) 1- ,!-& '4 <!'5& , ,!."/%$!

1 ,"-% %!&,49!!'41/:%'#"-+!4-!3-4%'3 ,!$$%4!' 91 '" ,4 9!!' /"43!4 #"- ,! -!&"' , ,! 4-%7!- "# ,! "##!'4%'3?%'&1-!4 +" "-$:$/!5&."/%$!.!-&"''!/,%+&!/#)

!-1&/"# ,!%+.13'!4"-4!-.&&!49: ,!-%91'/-!7!/& , -!&."'4!' '")?2.""-*%'3,"' ,!4 !"#$$%4!' %)!))=)= % &!/#,43" -!$"-4!4 @) $--:%'37!-&%"' , 9"1 )

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

+"' ,'44:&#-"+ ,!4 !"#$$%4!' " ,!*1.!-%' !'4!' "#

"/%$!6%&-$/%+%'3 , %./*%'3,,4-!$!%7!4%'>1-%!&"'$$"1' "# '$$%4!' 41! "-&,'4'!3/%3!' 4-%7%'3"#2.""-*%'3,)..-!' /:6 %''%'7!& %3 %"' , !'&1!46& !+!' &"#,-+9%-&"'"# +%5& '4 >!&,21+-&"'"#3' ,5!-!-!$"-4!4'4%'&1$,& !+!' 9" , ,!#"-!'" %$!44%4'" & ! , 2.""-*%'3,5&4-%7%'3 ,! "##!'4%'3+" "-$:$/!%'-&,"-'!3/%3!' +''!-) ' '1 &,!// ,! 7!-&%"' &! #"- , 9: ,! 5%4"5?$/%+' ?..!//' '")*+ ) +, !-%&-!3-4&-&,'4

= '!3/%3!' 4-%7%'3"' ,!.- "#2.""-*%'3,,&9!!'4%&$-4!4.-%+-%/: "' ,!%&&1!"#4!/: , ,4"$$1--!4%'#%/%'3 ,!../%$ %"' " ,! *1.!-%' !'4!' "# "/%$!6%&-)'" ,!-5"-4&6 ,!7!-&%"'&$"' %'!4%' ,! ,!%'& '$!"# ,!4-%7!-"# ,!+" "-$:$/!'+!/:2.""- *%'3,,&9!!'$$!. !4)

'4"19 !4/:6 #%'4%'3 5% , -!3-4 " -&, '4 '!3/%3!' 4-%7%'3 9: ,! 4-%7!- "# ,! "##!'4%'3?%'&1-!4 7!,%$/! 5"1/4 9! .-!-!A1%&% ! "!' !- %'$/%+.! % %"'1'4!-*!$ %"';;"# ,! " "- 0!,%$/!$ ) "1'&!/-!.-!&!' %'3 ,!$/%+' &,&./$!4-!/%'$!1."' >143!+!' -!'4!-!49:""-4%' !!'$,"# ,%&"1- %'

#65,!-!%'/&"'$$%4!' ,4.1-."- !4/: <!'./$!%'' !+. "7"%4,% %'3& -:$ /!'4 ,!#"//"5%'3"9&!-7 %"'&5!-! +4!(

2!!.%'3%'7%!5 ,!"9&!-7 %"'&-!.-"41$!4,!-!%'9"7!6 ,! #%'4%'35% ,-!3-4 "-&,'4'!3/%3!' 4-%7%'36%# //6 ,!,'4&"# -!&."'4!' '")2.""-*%'3,64-%7!-"# ,!"##!'4%'3?%'&1-!4+" "-$:$/! 5"1/4-!A1%-! "9!-!!@+%'!49: ,!-%91'/) %&$&!5,!-! ,! + !-5"1/4-!A1%-! "9!-!+'4!49$< " ,!-%91'/#"-!@+%' %"' #-!&,) 7!'/!-'!4$"1'&!/-!.-!&!' %'3 ,!$"' !& %'3-!&."'4!' '&1-'$!"+.':4"!&'" ".."&!&1$,$"1-&!"#$ %"' "9!#"//"5!4) '7%!5"# ,!4%&$1&&%"'9"7!6 ,!%+.13'!4"-4!-4 !4 ))6.&&!49: ,!-%91'/6%&&! &%4!)

!-%&-!+'4!49$< " ,!-%91'/#"-4!$%&%"'#-!&,)

- %!&-!4%-!$ !4 "..!-9!#"-! ,!-%91'/"'))) %&6,"5!7!-6$/-%#%!4 , ,%&"1- ,&'" !@+%'!4 ,! $/%+"# ,!..!//' &,!-!%'"'+!-% &) ..!/%&4%&."&!4"#)

/1$<:

B,! ,!-&.!<%'3?-!&"'!4( !&?"

B,! ,!- !."- 9/!( !&?"