Vallu Singh v. Union Of India & ORS
! "!#$% &
%
% ''(
) *++,-'. //++ * !' ' / 0(
1$2 0#!- 0 - 3-
024
!
" !
# $ % !& ' ( ) * &+ ,
"&- %.!/01
3 - %.!/01
*
"&
"- %.!/01 55555 0 - 3-
0245# 3 ( 6) ( 7"
0 )9:
24;
< ):=4 2>)4 ,
&& &
?
, , , + & 78 0 )9:
2>)4
!
" # $
@ ! ( "
)=2 :
, " &+ *
* (
3 8B
, 8B 8B ( C "+ )> >: 2>>2 ,
! D ?
)9=A
E E , & , ): >= 2>>2
! ;
;> )) ,
&
" *
& )42 ) );
,
& " *
" , 2: >: 2>>A + , , D ?
ED
3
* 0 ;>4A 2>>: , ,
)> )2 2>>:
$ & D , 0 ) 2>>9
4) >) 2>>9 &
( ( , "
& 7 2:6>>>/F D (
! )9
?
+ &+ 6) , , , & &
&&
& " , 2> >= 2>)2
8 "" "
& " ,
,+
( &
&
3
, 6) " D F .C )6 ( " A;6 ,
ED 7E
, " + & (
, &&
.C A9 .C 6) .C 62
D F , .C ;2 " =;:
7 , , + , 26 >) )==2
"
,(+ " *
,
' 8B , C " , C
&+ 2A & & & 7 6>>>>>>/F ( D
" + 7 )=)>9A/F $ " &
.C 2 .C 4 .C );
.C A6 .C 64 .C 69 , , + *4 G" @ & 7*)
D " , "+ & & C
( + & (&
"+ & , " (& , ,
( " , , + &
&
( " "
"
, & ( + ,
(+ &
, , & ! , .C ;2 26 >) )==2
6
' 8B
& , ( &
$
( &
, .C ;2 , ( & &&
' 3 & , ,+ D F ( "
&
"
&
( , .C ;2 + , C&
& ( .C 62 , )9 )> )==6 ,(+ & , 7 A)6>>>/F 7 ;;A>>>/F $
( " ;;:
3 ,
& " * + ( .C 62 ! .C 6) >= )) )==2
, (
& &
, &
, "
&
!
& + .C A9 , + F?
)> >) 2>>4 (
, (
& &
8 ( , &
& + ,
! (
, & & ,
7
& .C 72/ .C 7=/ .C 7):
.C 7A:
$ ( + F ! & (,
&
"+
" + F! 3 "
"
( + (
, & ( & ( &
( + 1 ( ( + ( (
.C 62 )9 )> )==6 ( & , ,+ 7 ;;A>>>/F
&
3 , & " ( >:
+
& +
(, .C 62
(
! ,
)> >: 2>>2
! +
(
3 , & $ , & & " 3
, + &+ ( &
&& ( &
' $ " , ( + & , , & 7*)
D " , &
+
, "+
)
&
$
+
, & (
, )6I
& ( ( &
.C 62
7 ;;A>>>/F & " >:
+ 8, , , E( !
&
+ 0.5 '+ ,+ /' 2 * 8'#'98'"+5
:6;- 67 ,
<4,*- =5
7:;-+
" ( )6I
& ( ( & " & & 7 ):;;262 94 ,
7 ):;;264/F
?
+
& &
J , +
?
& + + " &
( 0
(
( + , "F & , & " & (
+ "
$
(
, & $ & , ,+ .C 62 , , & , & + (
,
&
3 , (
& @
"&
8-'.* - ",>8,.2?,''' ++5"'+5
):;
: '9'+;)65 , ,
( , ,
E( !
&
3 ( & @
)2 < )4
"&
8-'.E
, + +
! !
"
"
# ! $ !
" %"" &
'
! # %"" &
" ( '
" )
!
"##$ %"& '''
$()* "##$
+",
* !
!
(
") !
!
!
"+!
,
")
!
"+ !
!
!
(
&"-./' "
&"0"1. " " )
,
"2 !
#
) 4 5 6 !
% - . & / '
!
"##0
+#, * )
#
"
!
!
" )
@
!
" # $ ! ,
!7.8
( "+
# $ ! !
( &"-971/'7.8"
'
, # $ !
"2 7 + , , , E( !
&
, @
"+
+ ( &
.C 62 "+ ,
&
& 7 ):;;264/F &
!
& & "
"
(, ( + & ! ( + (
* , , & "
( 1
" & & C , *4 G" @ ( " C &
0 + (
" "+ (
(
$ , , ( (
,
,
C " & & & , , ( C , *4 G" @
"+ & & *4 G" @
,
, C
&
!
( (
, + "
" $ ( E( !
&
0A+ 4A>' , :.;5 '< * - ",>8 5
:7;- 6 (
E( !
&
!% *- =5
: ;- 75 " & " & " " + " &
, $ &
, 3 &
, , , + & & +
3 ( & E( !
&
):
< )9
"&
!%E
, " + ,
F
!
:
,
! ;
# -<& !
#
"+
!! ! # %
!
!
! "+ (
"
6 -==."
6 -==. !
&"7...../'
"
&
$
7..-
&"-71
>>
&"-1.
!
&"0.1.../' &"
?70.../' " ! '
' "!
3 , !
7@# 7..?
!
&" -91 -0.
( !&"019@../' &"??@@../'")
! -76 -==9"
, !
!
!
A -?
:
# @ -@
(
"
( ! (
)
:
)
"-78
,
,
(
-. -7 -18 -..8 ! ;
;
"5
!
!
"
")
!
7.
, !( ! 7.
"+
! ;!
&
" +
;
(
!
!
%
"
: "
!
" "
!
" + !
B2 D
+
,
+ "
& , (
6
& ( , &
, + & (+ , C
(
3 &
& 7 ):;;264/F &
! 3+ &
( & @ + ( ( &
7 + , ( & ( 6)
( & , , 0 - 3-
024C 24 >2 2>);
#!%