High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/9906/2014dismissed

Ashok Kumar v. Amarjit Etc

2015-05-18Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!"#"$%&%'()** &+,-./ 0 11"22 '! 3"0&.& / 04%! '#!+"0& "&1'#"'!&

( 56

7 - 67 0"&"'!(8

0 7+ 0/ 9#:$ !"9 0!+" 112%$ '!8 11"22 '! ;+"!+"0!+" "10!"0&2$ 2'"<&1 1"0/ =>" 22<"#!&"" !+"4.#?/"'!@ >"0""00"#!!+" "10!"00'! A ;+"!+"0!+"4.#?/"'!&+.2#>"0"10!"#%'!+"#%?"&!@ 88 88 - 67 9

6 &+,-./ 0 <'"0!+""'#%'?:"+%$2">" 0%'?

0"?%&!0 !%' 888BB + & %2"# !+%& 11" 2 ? %'&! !+" < 0# # !"# A9 1 &&"# >= !+" !0 $$%#"'! 2 %/& 0%>.' 29 !+ ',!9 %'&+0!5!+"0%>.' 259:%#"<+%$+ ' < 0#! !+"!.'" &9)9* 8 2'?<%!+%'!"0"&!CD1"0 ''./0/ !+" # !" %2%'? !+" $2 %/ 1"!%!%' !%22 $!. 2 0" 2%E !%' < & 1 &&"#%' :.0!+"$2 %/ '!&7%'$"!+""'#%'?:"+%$2"< & '! %'&.0"#9 !+"0"0"9 !+" 10"&"'! 11"22 '! 2'?<%!+ 0:"&+ -./ 0 #0%:"0<"0"/ #"4%'!2= '#&":"0 22=2% >2"!1 =!+" $/1"'& !%' +"'2=$'!"'!%'!+"2" 0'"#$.'&"20!+"

88 11"22 '!%&!+ !!+" 11"22 '!+ # 20" #=&2#!+"& %#:"+%$2"! 0"&1'#"'! 0"&1'#"'!8>"0"!+"0%>.' 29' /"2=9

,"&+-./ 0>"0"!+" $$%#"'! !%&&! !"#!+ !%'!+"<0%!!"' &! !"/"'!9 0"&1'#"'! 0"&1'#"'! 8 >"0" !+"

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

+" $ &"< &%G"#00"&1'#"'!":%#"'$"9!+"0"&1'#"'! $ /"<%!+ '"<12" 910> >2=! :%#2% >%2%!= >"$ .&"''%'&.0 '$"!+":"+%$2"%'H."&!%'9>= #":%&%'? ':"2/"!+#%/12" #%'?0"&1'#"'! & 1 0!=%'!+%&1"!%!%''!+"?0.'#!+ !&.$+:"+%$2" < & 20" #=&2#>=+%/!0"&1'#"'!>"0"!+" $$%#"'! 2!+.?+ 0"&1'#"'! 89 !"0 11" 0 '$"9 #/%!!"#1.0$+ &"&.$+:"+%$2">.!&.$+ #/%&&%'%&<%!+.! '=#$./"'!

8A8

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

+"%'%!% 2<0%!!"'

88 &! !"/"'!"%!+"0!+"10"&"'! 11"22 '!'0!+"&.>&"H."'!:"'#"" 11" 0"#%'!+"<%!'"&&>G!&! !" >.!!+"& %#& 2":"+%$2"

'2=1+!$1= ' %# :%!& 2":"+%$2"< &12 $"#'%2" '#& /"< &'!10:"#>= '=>#=!%&'!10:"#!+ ! !!+" !%/" $$%#"'!9 ,"&+ -./ 0 0"&1'#"'! < & %' ""$!%:"

1&&"&&%' !+" :"+%$2" !+ !+" 10"&"'! 11"22 '! '# !+" 22"?"#&.>&"H."'!:"'#""&! ="# < =0/1.!!%'?%' 11" 0 '$" '# "0%'? !+"/ 0 $0&& "G /%' !%' +"0"0"9 #:"0&" %'"0"'$"+ &!>"#0 <' ? %'&!!+"/!+ !!+"=+ #!0%"#.1! #"" !!+"$2 %/!+"$2 %/ '!& +" .!+0%!=!+"'5>2"7.10"/" .0!%'$ &"

%:%2*90"2%"#.1'>=!+"2" 0'"#$.'&"20!+" 11"22 '!%& '+"21 &%'!+ !$ &"9!+":"+%$2"%'H."&!%'< &0"H.%&%!%'"#>= !+"7! !" :"0'/"'! '#%!< &%'!+%&$'!"G!!+ !%!< &+"2#!+ ! 1"0&' %' $'!02 '# 1&&"&&%' !+" :"+%$2" &+.2# >" $'&!0."# &!+"5<'"05+" $!&!+"10"&"'!$ &" 0""'!%0"2= #%"0"'!&&.$+9#'!%'# '=/"0%!%'!+"10"&"'! 11" 2 '# !+"& /"%&#%&/%&&"#

&*9 8#"1&%!"#>=!+"10"&"'! 11"22 '!>"0"

!+%& .0! !!+"!%/"%2%'?!+"10"&"'! 11" 2>"0"/%!!"#!!+" 0%>.' 20#%&>.0&"/"'!!!+"$2 %/ '!&

- 67 )** &4,&