Tanvi Bhatia v. Prtc & ORS
!" "#$%$&'(
&*$ + !$ ,,"-- &!
."/%0% &1!+"/% "%,&1"&!%
'2 34 4 /"%"&!' /%+5 &$// 61*# !"6 /!+" ,,"-- &! /%+7809 /4$&:- 64/ 60&; < 6 / -
/!+"/" %&%%! !"1$&!+" ,,-$# !$&61"- = >>1 =%$&
$-$&:!+" ,," -$%#&1&"1 ,,-$# !$&%! &1%1$%,%"1 /"%"&! ,," -+ %<""&,/"
"//"1<=!+"#- $9 &!%( ,,"-- &!% /%+/!2!+" ,,"-- &!%26 : $&%! 5 /11 !"1 ?
>6, %%"1<=!+"
-" /&"1 !/ ##$1"&! - $9% /$<0& -6 + &1$: /+ / %+/!6 2!+"
/$<0& -2*$1"5+$#+#9,"&% !$&!!+"!0&" % ) 5 % 5 /1"1 !!+"#- $9 &!& ##0&! $&;0/$"%%0
"/"1<=+"/ &)
6!+"#- $9 &!5 %:$&: /9+ &1$: /+! !$ - 5+$-"%$!!$&:$& <0%<" /$&:/":$%!/ !$&
((> <"$&:
1/$*"& ! %!%,""1 &1$& / %+ &1&":-$:"&!9 &&"/<= :$/4$&:+ /"%,&1"&!)@+"&!+"<0%5 %:$&:&/" 1-" 1$&: /9 ;,0/ ! !$ - &1/" #+"1&" /.$-- :"8 0-$ ! <0!)!5"&!0! #&!/- 10"!9/"%,""1 &1!0/&"1!0/!-" % /"%0-! !+$% ##$1"&!6!+"
#- $9 &! &1!+"/##0, &!%/"#"$*"1$&;0/$"% +"#- $9 &!% &1!+"/ ##0, &!% 5"/" ! 7"& ! ;"&1/ %,$! -6 !$ - 5+"/"6 !+"= 5"/" /"
"//"1!6+ &1$: /++"
)1 !"1)
+ 1<""&
/":$%!"/"1 /
"&#"%,0&$%+ <-"0&1"/4"#!$& 6))6))?6) >(
$&,-$#"%! !$&4 1 / !$ -
+" #!09 ##$1"&!+ 1<""&,/*"1 &1!+"
"&1$&:
*"+$#-"5 %$&%0/"15$!+/"%,&1"&!)(&%0/ &#"9, &=3" /&"1 /$<0& - !"/ :$&: !+/0:+ !+" "*$1"&#" &1 9"1$# - /"#/16 #9,"&% !$& %%"%%"1 %0&1"/'
4/ " 1% #9,"&% !$& 90&!
"1$# -<$--% %
) A( $& &1%0
"/$&:
% B6
A( 4,"#$ -1$"!
% B6
A( > !!"&1 &#"#+ /:"% %
A( B / &%,/! !$& % B6
A( //$ :",/%,"#!% % B6
A( %!% % 6
A( ! - % ) A( 3" /&"1#0&%"- /!+"#- $9 &!( ,,"-- &!#&!"&1%!+ !!+"
#9,"&% !$&C0 , $& &1%0
"/$&: &19 //$ :",/%,"#!%+ %&!<""& :/ &!"1%!+"#- $9 &!+ %%0
"/"1 D1$% <$-$!= -"
!0,,"/-$9<<0!!
5 %&! 0&#!$& -1$% <$-$!=!5 %,/*"1<=@( /401"%+"< 9 + 1,/*"11$% <$-$!= D -"
!0,,"/-$9<<0!$!5 %&! 0&#!$& - 1$% <$-$!=!5 %&!1$%,0!"1!+ !%+"5 % 19$!!"1$&9 /%,$! -&
?
&11$%#+ /:"1&
+ *"+" /1-" /&"1#0&%"- /!+", /!$"% &1,"/0%"1!+"
/"#/1 !$%&!$&1$%,0!"!+ !!+"
"&1$&:*"+$#-"5 % 0--=$&%0/"1 5$!+ !+" &%0/ &#" #9, &= !"/ :$&: !+/0:+ !+" "*$1"&#"6 #9,"&% !$&+ %!<"/"( %%"%%"1 % --5%'( 4/ " 1% #9,"&% !$& 90&!
"1$# -<$--% %
) A( $& &1%0
"/$&:
%B
A( 4,"#$ -1$"!
% B6
A( > !!"&1 &#"#+ /:"% %
A( B / &%,/! !$& % B6
A( //$ :",/%,"#!% %B
A(
) %!% % 6
A( ! - % 6)6 ) A( &+ &#"1 90&!
#9,"&% !$& % 6)6 ) A((((((% ) A( E%B
A( "%0-! &!-=6 !+" "&+ &#"1 90&! #9,"&% !$&
%B
A(%+ --<", = <-"5$!+$& ,"/$1 /!= $*"1 =% /9!+"1 !"
/"#"$,! #"/!$ $"1 #,= !+$% /1"/ +" "&+ &#"1 90&!
#9,"&% !$&%+ --# //=$&!"/"%!F D,"/ &&09 /9!+"1 !" $-$&:
!+"#- $9,"!$!$&6!$--$!%/" -$G !$&6$&*$"5 !+";01:9"&! &2<-"!+"
40,/"9" 0/! $& # %" ! ! "#! $# #! %"#!
&!!' (($#)"#! *+,*- "9 $&$&:
#&1$!$&% 1$%<0/% - 90&! %+ -- /"9 $& 0& -!"/"1 @$!+ !+"
/"% $191$ $# !$&$&!+"$9,0:&"1 5 /16!+" ,," -$% --5"1!!+" <*""H!"&!
&$-