Devi Ram v. Haryana State Agricultural Market Board & ORS
!
" " #$ % & '" "() *" *+ ," )- ".
/ "
01! '
" " #$ % & '" "() *" *+ ," )- ".
/ "
"
+ /2& *3( "3
"./" " 4 + (! - . 3( "3 "./ " 55555
-&6 & ". " "0)! "36//" "."6 6 " /" " " "* ". * " * 7. "3 .63 8 )/ ! *& !99
3" "*
7. /" " **"" ./$ " ". 6 2 #)" 8* + ,"3 '"9 3 : 8 (" 6 "
3 6. . 6 //
; "*&3 *"" **"! " "
3 ". /" " 6 **"" ./$ " 7. "" * * " 6
3 3$9 < ". / ! " )"
33$96 / " 8 "
7.! )
99 < ". ! "3
3$96 "8/ ". *!/9! 6 "." "" 6 ". / & ! ". " ". **"! "*"" . * & *& " **! " * )6 ". ""= < / !
: *"/ "". ! "6* " */ * ""=< / ! " 8 !/ . * & *&3 6. . 6 " 8 . ) " " ! * ""
4 ( ) /" " 0 1! ' 4 9 9
3 ". " 6 " 3 6. . 6 //
; "*&3 './$' "
". 6 2 #)" 8*+ ,"3'"9 3: 8 6 **""". ! **"! " *"" "
7."" * * " 6
3 3$9 < ". **"! "/ ! " )" 33$96 / 8 " ".". " / &! " ".! )< ! "6". !
>" ! "" " ". " ". /" " 8". ". /" " " **&/ ". " * " * )6 ".!/ "" / * ""
4 7.* ! "./" " ". "".*/! "6, ". 6 2 #)" 8* + ,"3 '"9 3 : 8 6 " !/*" 6. ".
/ 6 ! ". " ".& 6 !/*"8; "*& ". !" 3 !/ "" / * ""*. 8 . ) >". 8 ". "/ " / " " "
4( ?9 93 /" *&. )8 8! "" !/*" */! "6,3 " 6 " ,
4 ".6 "/" " . 8 ! "* ". % & '" "() *" *+ ," )- 4' * >!! 8*/"&
9 *3 4 !
4. " " @". *A (/6. ."./ "../$ "*8
"". **""6 ". / & !". " **"! " *""3 ! !! 8 * " 3 6 " //*&3 *" " 6 ? " ) ". 8 * " 6 " ? " ) ". / 6*8/ "/ )". * "
4 * ". 6 " /" " . * 8 /* / 0)! " "- . ".
!
"# $%&'$%$ () ##" "#*+ 4( ? 9 0)! " "
/ 9 9 " "*
4 >". ".8 ".6 "/" " ". "".0)! " ". ,-%.')/0 1,2.3+6 !/* 6 ".8&"./ " "
4( ?9 7.6 "/" " . 8 //8&6 & /* * 8. * / "
" 3 8& ". '" &9!9B?" C
3 + ,"!! "": 8 " /* ! &80" 6 ".) " /" ;" 8 ) *D / " " . ) 8 / ". / "D ". /" " . // . ". " 6 ". * . " .) * & ". /" " . )
"! " "./" " " . 8 4 C ! "3". "! **"! " ./$ "" . 8 ! "" >". 3.638 ". " */! "6,. " , /* ".62 #)" 8*+ ,"3'"9 3: 8 >". 8 ". "". ""/ *".6 . 8 . ) /". "! ". **"! "*"" . 8 ! "*4
99 4 ". *3 6. ". / "" !/ / * "" . 8 ! >" . 8 ". " ". ". /" " 4 "8&". - 3.4310 1,2.3+ ,-%. ')/0 ,2.3+ ". 3".8 ! " 6 "/ " ** 36. **"! " ". 6! ".&
. . * * "./ " 4 E * "./" " 48! """. "". ". /" " 4 8& ". 0)! " ". " - . ,-%.')/0 1,2.3+ - 3.4310 1,2.3+ ". 8*"*& " " 8"6 ". ". /" " 4 ". >" 6 8! "" 8& * * ". /" " 4 ". " ". !" 3 ". /" " 4 * " 8 ) " ". !*
C ".".. 3* */ " )"./ " 8! """. "". "./" " 4 . "8&* & * . ". !6 * ".&
36. ". **"! "6! ".& $ 4 E *8! """. "". " / &! "6 ! 8& ". /" " 4 6 "." & /"" 3 ". 3 ".& " 8 6 /! """" """./ &! " ". ! "
4 E * ".8! """. " ***/! "6, . 8 " 6** " ! 3 ". 3 ". /" " 4 " " ". "".& 6 " * 8* "/ & ". "" !/ / * ""
. ".8! ! 8&* *
"./ " 4 7. **"! " ./$ """./" " 4 " /"
99 7. / &! " ". " * " * ! "" >" 6".6. *" " ". "". /"/" " **"! " ./$ " ".62 #)" 8*+ ,"3'"9 3: 8 >"6 ". &! ,"". ""../$ ". 8 **""""./" " 4 ". ,-%.')/0 1,2.3+ > ". " *3". " 6 .*
". **"! " *"" 6
7. " " ". / " ". " ". */! " 6, . " 8 " ". ,-%.')/0 1,2.3+38". 8 " ". / " 3 ". 3 ! " " )."*& 0" 7. ". ) ".6". "".*/! "6,6 " ". !&)" 8*! ,"
" "
"" ! 7.6* " ) ,-%.')/051&31% 1,2.3+6 ".) " ".*/! "6, "/" " *4 ". * 6 *! "* ".* ". "3 "6 ") **&.*". ""./" " 6 "* 8*"/ & &/ * !/ ""
7. "- . * 9 @F 7./ " * * ) ". ! 6. . ! " 6
".+ .3 3. 8 8&".% H8*'/!"
!"#$%%&!%'()* & )6 **6 9
! "! #
$" " "$ "" $$ " " # $ % %$ " $ "
99
$" # &
""
' (""
$ "
#
# ! #' (""
% " $ " ) FG > * + , -!".*" / 8& "./ "9- ) " ) "*& ! * "" /" ". **"! " ! " ". ! * ! " 6
".+ .336 * " , " " !
". /" 6. . **6 9
* '"+ ' # " " " ,*-..- " " # /
% "
0 "
$
"
' (""
" #1
2
$ % %$ ' (""
" ) G E * "./" " 3 " 3. * " " ".+ .3 / 8& ". ". . (! " " ". / "9- 8 . // *6. .. " ". **"! "! 8& ". / " : 8 7. / " / " ". &". "
9
" " %# %$ 2
99 %$ 45/"/ $# ' (""
# 6
% "
(""
+ ,*-..-
$ 7 + 8%' #6
%
$# (""
"
" " " " 0 " $"
$ " "
" %
(""
% %$ $
" "
" 0
$)
> ". * )." ". 8 / *3 /*6 ".". " ".% H8*'/!" ". " FG ". //** "FG3 " " 8. * ". /" " )."*& ". " / * !/ ""*8* "./" " ". 6 * & / &! " " **! " ( ) " !/* ""3 " ) ". " 6 ". ) * *" / 8& ". - " 8& ". % H8* '/! " 0 *H F/ G3 /* 6 ". ". ) """. ! * *&/* **""8&". . (! " "3 ". /" " .* " "* " , / "& ; " * ".! "" ""
G 7 " ". ""./ ". !/6 ". / /* ". " ". ! !! * " 6 " **& / ""./" " ". **""" 8*".!" ".8 ".6#)" 8*+ ,"
7.
"
*8&".B" "C
".+ ,"!! "" *& , 6*)". "". "6 ) 6 "//*&6 / ". & *& > ". " 3 " //
*" " /" " )."*& ". " ** ". 8 ! " 3
9 " * " ". &9"9 & 8 " " 3 6 /* ". & 6. / 6
" ". /" " >" ; **&"". ""./" " * 8*"/ & !/* "" *& ". /"9/ / &! " ". **"" " %63. "8.** 8*"/ &/ * !/ ""
' ! * *&3 ". ) * *" / 8&".- ) " )! ". ""!/ "" ** " **"" "./" " * ".!3 3 . " " ) . 8* ! ".3.! & *8 " "*"".8 " ". *"
: ". ! " 3 6 **6 ". 6 "/" " / " .*". ""./" " 3 ".)
" !" ". 3 "* 8*"/ &/ * !/ ""
' ! * *&3 & ) * . 8 ?" 8& ". - " ". ! * *& " " **""3"./" " 6* *8 " "*",/ "& E" ". ! "" 8 )*& ". /" " H * 8 * "& " / & "" !/ " 8 9 "! )*&6 ". ".! ". *" & ". " " 3 ". /" " " "* " & 3 ". ! . ** 8 ! " . ! 6 ". ! ". ". " A 4 7. 0)! " 6 !/* 6 ".$ !/*! " 8& ". / " "
6 / 3 .* ) ". " *& !/* "" = < / ! 6* 8 . ) / ". 8 * " **! " ".". ""6 6
4 ( ". . **"" ,63.' %7' * , , ". ". "8&6 & 99 36. .6 8& " - . "! ".0)! " ". ,-%.')/0
1,2.3+ "6 ". "". 3 &3"6. ."./" " 6 " "*"6*8! 6 ". / ".! ".
99
> / 3 ". / " 6 " /" " ; *&8&".0)! " ,-%.')/051 ,63.'%7'51 4/ 8"3 ". /" " * " // . ) ". " %63". * "
") " 9 ""./" " 4 ". ") 8&". "- . ". " 6. . ". . 8 ""* B ".6 3 ,63.' %7'51 4/ 6 ". " "6 "/" " 6 * ".&
:". ! " 3".6 "/" " **6 >" .*". ""./" " 46* "8* 8*"/ &!/ "" / * ""
7.! ""8 )*& ". "" !/ " 8 9"! )*& 6 ". / ". ! ".
!" &
* " &3 " ". 3 ". /" " 4 " "*" & 3". !8! "".!6 ". / ! ".". "
+
+
) ) ."./ , )$ I$ ."./" 8* I$