High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3251/2021dismissed

Rishi Kumar Sharma v. Lata @ Hem Lata

2025-05-16Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri30 pages

! *"

"#"& (!

#& "#"&

""#

( (

!"#"$ %

$ 1 ( % 2 "#"$3 $"&"#"3 '

() *( +

&"#"3 ,

- .

(

) * ' % ) *( '

) *(

+ /

*( )

!"#"$3 00000

% 7 ( 67 7 ) . +

! 4 ""#

4 $" (

( 7 +

( 5 . 5 .+ . ( +

57 7 7 (5 5= (6 67

%+ ( 5 +)+ (* () *5 +

( 5 (( 57 (* =

! $ % 5 +

9+ = 8

)92 +

+9 92 ;35= 5 ) 77 * 5=

< #9 "#" 5= ( B7) = 8

. 5= ( + 5= 5 ?

?7 . .

++ 5+ / ?

# "#") 5

) ( ( = )

7 +

. > #2 "

"## ( 5 5 + .(?

% 5 +

$ + '

7 7 ?7 +

7 5= ( +* ()"$

"# @ ) (

+* (. 5= ,

( B 7)

) * $ 67 ( #2 "#$ C 3 % %

.+ * (

9 $ 88 +

7 (7 "

"#" + 6 7 ( #2

"#$

, 7 (= + (7) ( . ++( 5 . ).(. ?

( DC 8 .7 ( ) *

( ?7 . . +

7 ( 7167 ( ( =+ ( DC 8 5 ( ( 5+ 8

5= +

@ *. +

++ 5= ( .+ ( DC 8

* 5 .

) + (

#2 "# $ . 5 . . *

"# 2 C 3

" ) .+ + (

"+ +E+ + , (( )"# ##& +

) :

+"##&;39 #9 "# $) 7. (

"$ $+ )+ + % ( +

+ .

. * # "#< 5= B( '

' 7

8 )A ) 5 3 . = "#)###1 .++ ( + + ( @ . +

+ (5 5=&

"#<)

C + 7 7

+ (

$ % .+ + ( "& + 8 +8 ( )9<$ +

83# "# #!) .

8+ B( ' 7

) A ) *

#9 #9 "# !) .

(

+ "#)###1 + ++7+ ( *5= 5 +

*5+ 8

+ ) 5 7 / "2 + "

#& "# <) .( 57 7 .

. 7 8/ / 8$21"#< +

( 5= .+) ( *. * "

#& "# #< 5= = B7)A

% + ) < "#2) .+ * ( +

+ ( +

9 $88+

7 "

"#"). 5= . ( 7

67 ( #2 "#$ 5=

( B7) @ @ *

( 5 ) + 7 7+

# "#2) + ? .+ ( + *7 = + + (( )

( . . % %

( . .

. *

#$ #!

"#9 C &3 5= ( B7)

= 8

)

. ? + 7 ) ( 5 ?) = % . ( 7 5+

)5= = 5 )5=. = =+8 !9&"#9

) * !

#2 "# #9

!3) (+ . . 7

6 ( 5= +C * % %

) ?7 + 5 3) .

5 . . * "$ #"

"# #"$) 8 !9& "#9. . .

& % 5 +

2"8

+ F 7 ( "+ +"# ##& . # "#< < 5= B( ( ' 7

8 ) A ) 5F (7 ) . 5=

= ( + "#)### #1 .+ * +

"$ + + "##&) .( ( ( 5 7 8' ' #<#2"#

"$ #"

"#"$) . . . % ( "&8

+ ( )

(+ .+)( .+57 .

+ "#)###1 * #< #9 "#2) . .

( . 5=

* ( = ( .

+ #< #9 "# 2) ( ) . + + . )5= = 8

(( + ( 7 "&

"$+ +"##&) *75 +

.+) 5

+ (

% ! .+ 7 ++ * * 5

# "#"5+ +

= 8

+ #) 9)! "1 7 .

( .

. () 5 2)"$)###1 (( +

2 @ .

= (

+ (

#2 "#$ ?7

67 (

) 2# 7 ? ( # "#"

% .

7 C(

+ 5 + 7 C (

5= + * ) ) ( + ( ++ +(

@ ? (

. +

5 +

( 7 *

= * (

+ 5 )

) 5= ( 7 =

. . $+ '

9 % ( +5= 5 + . .

++ 5+ / ? # "#").

. ( = ( 5= .+ + ( 7

5 5=

7 ( ) ( . * < #9 "#" 5= ( B7) =8

(( 7=)

. +

/ ? # "#"

. .

+ 5 &

* 5= + < #9 "#")

5 7 !

(+ 5

5= / <

? . # "#") 5 7 *5

. .

++ 5= + 7 .

=+ ( 7

. 7 5 + / ?

@ @ +

7 ++ +

7 7 . . + * ( ) . + = 7 (F( 7

+ @ +

5 ( ( +=

+ ==

( + 5 .7 7 5 .

* (

< % .+ ( = +

7 5 5 ( 5

. +

)+ . * )5 5+ / ?

%7 7 = #9

#< "#" ( ?7 . . +

++ 5 5+ / ? ) *5

E * ( (+ .

.+ ( @

7 7+

. > #2 "

"# # ( 55 + + .(?

*5 7 (,(5 )"

"#) )6 = +

+ ( . . ( (

5 ++ +( 5 .

( + 5= .+

9 $ 88 +

7 2 67 ( #2 "#$ @

5( 7+ ( 5=

7 .* ) ) 75= .

.+) 5 + ( ()+ ( + 7 (

9$ 88 % )

= +*= ( * ( 57 5=

7 . 75 + ++ ) ++

7) 5 .

+ ( . .

5 ++ + C

5= %

A (+ 8

+ D735+

/ ? ) 57 * 5= ( B 7)

).(( 5 ( # "#"

% ( +

+ * 7 ) ((

5 (

) .( .

( +(). + 5 G

+ 1 H!" )- / #) 8 ) 7&<= ) 1 8=)

@ *

@. .= '

+ . . ) = I 8

1 @D73 ( 7 / ?

? $+ =5+ 1 B 5 73 ( B7) =8

@ +5=

1 D73 #1 1"J

9 % 2 #9 "#"#) .+* (*8

5 ) )+ (

2+ ' ( + (* =+ ( . ( 1 =

+ $#)###1 + +

= + ( 7 ( 7+ +

+ $!)##)###1 7. +

+ ( + 2)!9)& "1 *( 5+ +

5 . ?7 7 DC( % C ++( )

) ,

( A ) ( 8

+ *( . + +. % % ++ 6( . 7

++( ) =

+ 5 ) + 7 *(5 + 1 5+ + 5 5+ = = + + (

+ () .( . ( 5 + )!9)&"1 % 5 .

@ * + (

5 ++

5+ / ?

# "#") .

( ?7 . .+

. #< #!

"#"

@ 5 .) .+ "$ "#"

" + ( (

( 77

@ + () 2 #9 "# #"#) 6( +

7 *( 5+ .

. * #& #& "#" 5= ( B 7)

= 8 8

) A %) 5=

# 5 ?7 . .

++ + . * 5 5+ / ? # "#") +

7 7

% 5 ( 7 #& #& "#" 5+ +

5=. =+8 $$"#" (7)*

#< "#"") ++( . + 2)##)###1 + * + .+ 5=

5 ? ((

K *75

.+) * 8 $$"#"3 .

. . . 5= 5 #9 #9 "#""

%F + (

5+ 8

. .

*7 5 5=

/ ? + ( 7

6 ( + ? 5F = ( 1 .

=. .

3 5+ 7+( 1 .

$ E * +=( + )?7 7 ( + ( ( ( ( ( + ( A+ . * ( + () .5 +

= (+? ) * 8 @+ 7

)92<+

G +92<J3) * * * . + C

+ + = + ( 8 %D@ , , % ) *+,-./,0.1- 12 13 4,5,0/ 63 D* =

= ,

(

= 8

*( 8

* = = 7 8

7 *( 8

) ( = 5) % ? 7 *( 8

= 7 > ?

? ( * ( + C (7(6 6 ( + ( ?+

"3D* =?

7 + ( +(5 +L 3 *7 6 ( ++( 4 53 ) + =5(+ 5=

= ,

( = 8

7 *( 8

7 *(8

)

( = 5) % ? 7 *( 8

) 7 7(?

$3 % C ( F +( +

( 53 + 5( "3 + ? 7 5= 8

7 *( 8

5( =5 (

55= 8

-* (

. 8+B B (+@ 3 % C ( F +( +

( 53 + 5( "3 + ? +

5( $3 5( =5 ( 5 5=

(

. 8+B (+ 78

&3 ? * 6 (

* (

5 .

( +L 3 =( 75+ 4 3 =

.( + 7 . 6 ( +) 5 7 5+ ) =8

+ .( ? 7 * ?

*6 ( ( + = (

7 ++( ( 5 = .

1+-.7,-89128,/9 9/:;134,5,0/ 63E

" =( +

( 3+5( &3+( 9)L 3 3

+ 7 4 53+

+ ? (

)+ + +

7 ( ?

+ ( (

+ (

+ ( (+ (

4 3 (

5 ?(7> (+5= ? )

+ ( ? * ( 5 +

? 5( 53+( 3 ( 35=((

C( + 7*7 5

=+57

"3 / . 7 = 7 ( = . + 57 + () = 8

7 7 ? 5( 3+( 9 =) ( + ( + =+

( 3+5( &3+( 9 (

5 5 5= ?

+ (

? )+ *

5 +

C( + 7*7

= + 57

= $3 E = (

? 5( 3 . + ( 5 5( "3) ?

( + (

(

5 .

3 D* = ?

) . 7 =

+ (5+

) ( . C

* (

5 .

575= ( +6 ()F =)+ =

$ 7 ( &3E .

5= ? (

* 5 .

) ( + ( 5 5= (

) + .( + ( 5 (* 5( 3+ (( (. .

!3E .

5= ? (

* 5 .

)

5( "3)

? *(

? = (

<3E ( + + ( + 5 ( &3 (

)(( (

( . ( ( + 7 . ( . ( 5+ (

+ ( 5( 3 J

% 7 +? * 9 (7 > ( + ( 5= ?

) 7* 5= * "# + + + * . * ( ?

? ?(7> (+ ( ) =. ? 8

.( + ( 5 (* 5( 3)+ (( ( (. .

@ ( ) / ? ?

? (7> ( (+ ( # "#").

+ 5 5 ( 5 + = C 7 ( + 7 7 ( + ( 5= .+)

. +

$# "#"

% 7++( 5 7 F ) *7 8 *)

. + #< #!

"#"

% ( 77

)

@ 5(+ ( 7 ( 5 *)

/ ? ) .( = 7

< #9 "#"

%) / ? *7 ?(7> (+

( *7 8

)

. ? 6 (

+ 7 .+

( (

( 7 ( ) . 7 ( = = + (7 C ( @

$+ '

7 + ( +* ( 5 +5= 5 (). .

7 * . . =) +

++ # "#") 5+ / ?

*7 * *

3) . 7 = = (( 7 7 7

7 (( ("$ "

"#. 577* * F .

5 556( * + + 92 2< % .+ ( *7

=56( ( ( . . ) 6( ?= 5 (

' * ) .

. . + + * (.

. * = * ++( ( + * "&8

"$+

+ "##&) ( *= @+ ( )( = ( 57 5= = 8

6 5= ?

% ) ( *.+

& / ? * .

# "# #" +) +

+ 5 ++ *

= * (

. . $ + '

=5*.+

+ = 7 @

5 + ? ( 5 = ( 7 ) C ( ( +

= = ( = =).( +

( DC(

. 5F

).(

+( +

. 5 * +

= * 6( 556( *+ +92< @+( *.

) 5= )

* )

? . + ( + ( (

= 7 *

. + 5 (* ( 7 + + (

5 . (( 5=(). + .* * ++

5 5+ / ?

"#"

/(7 5 ( (

5 . = ( . 7

( ).(. + =C(

. ( # "#". ( + . . 7 . +#< #!

"#") ) + 5 .

% = =( *7 (

+ ( 7+

C <

( + ) .

7 ( +

. .

! +

++ "#" +

7 ( ( * ' * ( . 5 5 + ++( 7 ( 5+ 8

+ ) 5 (?

(?7

+ % *

+ # "# #2 C

3). 5= 5 ++( ( DC 8.

. .+5 5 F = + ) 5= +

(

/ / 7 ( 5 .

? 6(

(7 ( 55= 5

= *7 ?7 (( 5+ 8

5 5= = ( ( + (+( =

= * ( =+ 5* ( 7

< #9 "#" ++ + = =7 = * =.

7 + ( =) 575 + +

"# % 5 +

5= .+ 9 9+

+ 92 ) 77 * 5= $ #$ "#"$ 5=

( B7) = 8

) A A ) . 5= (

$9 "88) 5 . ) = "# % ++

+ 7 5 =

) "$

#9 "#"#) ?7 + C

< (

$$ . ( &+ 88+ 7 7 + ( 2 + I ' ( +

(* = + ( . (1 = $#)###1 ++ + + = .(( $!)##)###1 + ( 7 ( 7 + 7. +

+ ( . ( + 2)!9)&"1 *( 5+ + + . . ?7 DC(I% C

++( ) ) ,

A . 5 8 77 + *(. +.

/ /,

+ @6( +

7 + "

&+ 7 * *(5+ 1 5+ + + 5+ = + + + = + $!

!)##)###1 7 1

+ () . ( + 2)!9)&"1 C 7 )!9) &"1 7 =) 5

+ ++ J "

@ ++ + (

"88)"$ #9 "#"#)? 7 + C

+ ( $9 I" . ( & + 88 + 7 + 6( +

/ " & +

7 *( 5+ 1

5+ + 5+ = + + + =+ $! ( 7 1

+ ( . ( + 2)!9)&"1 C =)

7 )!9)&"17 =)

7 +

2 ( + +

J % * #& #& ""

"#") 6(

. 5= =8

).( ( 575+

+ 5 5= .

= + 8 $$"#"

* ) 8

"9 #< "#"" ++( (

+ 2)##)###1+ * +

++ .+ K *75

.+ 5 ? (( )8 8 $$"#". . .5 5= 5 #9 #9 "#""

"$ % ( + 6( . ( 5=

5 5 5= +7 = (

+ * 5)

= .*7 $ #$ "#"$)

+ C

% = 8

+ (7

( .

++.+

+ "#)### #1 )* "#< +"# ##&

#< #9 "#2 "& 8

) =7 5 ; .7 = ( ) +

+ .+ %

+ 7 7

7 (

)( % % 5 77 * 5= +

= 5 + 8

7 + +( 56( 5= = .+ G, 7 ( + 7 ) ( + ( . 7 + (

"#)###1 .

( "& 8

8 * #< #9 "#2 ,

* # "#<) = = (

(( 7= () 7 = 5 "#)###1 5 + * + ( + *(1 5+ +

/ + ( 7

/ " &

7 + *(1 5+ + / + *

( ) ) + (( 7= J "

% ( )* > ++3) 7

+ ( *75 + *

( (

) 5 * = + =

? ( ( 7+ (* 7

+ ( @ ( 5

? *

= = 5+ +

= =7

+ + 6 ( + = 8

(( + . . 7 +

5+ ?7

( ) =+ ( 7 ( ( 7 *(5+ +

5 "& ( + 5 + 7 5 5 C =

( .+).( (5 5

7 * 5 ( + *(1

5+ '

' * (

' "# ( = 5 6( @ +

+ (

7( 7

=+ 5 + ( .

+"##& . 8

)((* 5 .

% ++.+ = *? (

6 ( )?7 (* =+

+ ( * .

. ( =? . @ +

5 ( $ "#"

*(5+ * 5 7

*75 =5= 8

"< #$ "#"$ "!

*7 5 7* C (

( *5 * ().+ 5 ( 5 + 5 + + ( .. = = .

=) ( + ++.+ + ( 2 +

' ( 4 (=) + 6(

+ 7 *(5+ 1 5+ + 5 5+ + = + =

+ ( % + 7 6( = 7 (

+ +

. + 5 + + 7 7 ( .* ( 5C

%( 7 5 (

3 = 5 3 .(. .

+"## #& 8

( *= "< @ + (

"#)### " #1 5 .

.+ +5 "&8

+"##& %5 ( + 57 7 = +

C C =

++ * + # "

"#"") 5+ (

5.)

= (

+ + (5 5 ) *(5+ * 5. ?7+ + + )

++ .+ 3 = (7 + + (7 + (* =+

+ ( % * * * + )5 +"##& 8

)

+ + + ( +E+ , (( )"##& 1-90,*; *95.92/ ( 5( = C(

= ( + 77 * (*( (

)L 63 E 7 + 3+( ") ' 7

= + ++ 5= 77 * * + + =()5 3 + 74 53 ( C 4 (3 ( * + = * 4

( ) 7

= + (

+ 3 . ( )+ + 8+8 = .+ ( + 77 * =)(7 + ( ( "& ( )9<$"+9< 3 57+ ( "3%

= +7

F )+ 5 +*7 .( 77 *

( 5 ( . ((

"" $3 % ' 7

= ()

F * . = = + ( ( (+ ( = 3 % ' 7

= + 5 ( ( 7 ( +.6 ( (= + + 5( 3

+ (

. &3%

77 * . 5( 3 =

= +7

(+ !3K + = + ' 7

= =

. (

(( ( = 5 6 .

+ ? 5( 3) = 5 +

77 * + . 7 5 + ).(

= + = 5 5= 8+8 ( )9<$ !

*49* 21* <,.-09- @,*9-0/ 63CCCCCCCCC -,-89 12 =.>9/% 8?.54*9- ,-4 "3CCCCCCCCC $3@+ =

(=. ) = (+ ) .

* + ( ) + . . (+ ( C+ (7) + C( + .

.( = C

+ . ++( ( (' 7

=)+ * =

+ *=7 *=7 +) = ( =

+ ( ; ( ( =5) 7

+ = + * .

+ = 8

*=( 5+ (* = ( ( 5 . +

"$ = + .( 5 5( *+

+ .+( + *7 . )(' 7

5= ) = ?

. 7(++ )+ + 7 ( ++ . ) + * =( =7 + + ? ( + 6

L@+ 5 . ?

6 7 + .+; + (

) 5( 5 *. CCCC CCCC " ,**,-021*59>;1 5 ( = ( = ? ( + 5 + +.7. =)

122.-9 63E ++ +) 8

7 (* =+ +

=) =L 3 .

( +

++ 4 + *=+ 5= =* 5

=577 53 .

* + * 5 )+ +

8( +

(

+ 5 * 5

=) * ) + = + +) ++ (++ 7

+ )8

5 ( .

)

( + + ( + + 5 ) +

.+( (.

)+ ( 7) ( ( =

+ = +C ( $&< "3%

-* .(.

5C( ) + ( 5= = =

(C(

= ? 7 7 ( 3+5( 3 = + = ++ ( +

+(.

$3 E 8

( 53+5(

(( (.

+ *) + ( . .

8( 3) 8( . 7 (* =+ ( .

. (

+( * ( .

5 C( 5=

" 22980 12 /A8? =,* ( 3+5( 3+ **,-0 .

+( "5= =8

" 5C( . ( 6

(

( 6 ( ) . ' 7

. . ( + ( +(8

)

+ = (

= 5= ,

( 6 ( (

= " ,**,-021*59>;12 09**.01*; 01 =?.8? 0?./ / . 7 = 7 ( . + 57 5 ( = +

= .( 8 7 (

(

7 *) ( .

( 53+5 8

. * + 5( $3 C( +(.

22.-9.//A94:;,1A*0.-,-; 149 419/ -10 9B09-4 6 8 = + () . ++ 5= 8 8

= C 8

8( + .( 8 C ) + .

+ 5 5 .

( 3+( "5= ( 8 C ) + ( = (( 7= "2 +

= *..

7 ( + "##& 8

(= =5+ ( ( 5 5* )

+ ++.+ ?7 = ( ( 7 * *(1

5+ + 5 5 ) ((* .* * ?7 *. ( 7 ( ? 5= 5 =

6( ( *7C =

+ ( + +.* )5+ (

5.).

+ ( + 7 ) C (+ 6 ( ' * ?7 (

* +

$9 "8 8) ( ( 5=

++.+ =1 1 () .( = 5 ) ((* * % *+ 7 + + 6( ( 5F .

8* ( "& ( 8)

( 5+ 67

"9 @ 7 + 5* () )

+ =) $# / ( $ @ ).* )( +

+ .

6( 7 + .+ ? = =)+ * )5 + + ( + 7 7 ( +

( 5+ 67 7 7 7 ( = 5 6( ) (( (. .

$" $"

+ ( 5 +

+ +(* :

; +

+ 7) 8* B 7 , ,*3) ) 8

+ ( 6 ( $$ % ( + 5*( (* "#")?

?7 + C

+ + (

++( 7 "2 "&

"#!C( 5 .

+ + "I$ 7 7 7

+ + 5= + + + $I = .

7) 7 *) . = ( () . 7 7 (

.) ++ (

5= =

+ . ++ 5 7 C (5 5= + ( (* (. ( ( .

"! ++ *

+++

+ . *( 5+ + + . . ?7 DC( % C

++( ( 7 ++( *

* 7 7 + ++ 5 5 +

(

++( + ). 57( +

+ "I $) 5 =(( .

* 51* 5

+ + 5 + 7 "2 "&

"#!

+ 6( +

7 + +

7* 5 * 5

) 7 + + ) *(5+ + + + )+ * +

+ 7 7 =) 5

7 + ++ . 7 = = ..++ + J $ @

( (

7 A + 5 # =

. 5 / 3 @ +

7 = 75 . ( 5

A / + 7+ *(

).( . % ( 7

+ + / + =5 * *7 5 = . (F () ) 5

5* (

% ( 7

* * =(* +

* *+ A

) = ( 5 .

5*( 5

+( 6 ( $& + ( .

( 5 7 7 .5+ 8

.+.( 57 + 5= ( 67

@ +

5= ( 5 7 /

!"#"$) ( 5( * "

#< "#"$

=+ 8

(

+ (

. ( + / ) .

7 7 (( ) * 5

( ( (

5 .

@ 5

5* ( . "$ "#" . + * #& #9 "#""

% +

7 + ++; *( @ +

( +

= " 7 ? ( $# "#"$). +

( 7 . 6 + ( ( "

"# #"$) 5= = 7 B7

+ ( ' *

) . 7 +

( ( + (( (

% ( = (

= * (

* $!

E * ( (+ 5

/ ). *

( (( (

$< "2 /5 ) +6 7 ) 5

+ + 7 ) (*(+ . ) 7

5( @

D#E) )C)

5 * 5 5 +

+ + 5= .

?7 * 7 + ( (= . 5= 8

5 5 * . (

(=+ 8

. 57 75=. ) 8

. F ( (

% *. (5+. 5 +( *. 5 ?5= 7A(+

% % #"$"#"$

) ( #< #2 "#" ) (

"#" /88 #< <!& %)

(*(+ . ) 7 5 5( )5 5 (( 5( )?7*. + (

C $2 @ ( ) . 5 .

= ( ( 5 7 7 5+

7 = ( 7+ A 8 7 ( ( ) *

= 7 (

% ( + 8

5 .

A 92?).

. (+ A

8 7 "$# ? %) ( + 8

( + ( . 5 * (

( ). (7

+ ( $9 ' * ( ( ( =

+( * * ( +

"9 / )C( + 5

+ ( % (

5 + % ( +

= = (+ *

(( 5 5= 5 / 3) *

= 5

+ 7 .(

+ 57

@ = 5 (

8 @,9 ()

.( 7 57( ( 7 ( 7

(( ++

5 5= (( .

+ 6 ( (( 8

* 5 * =( > )

7*(+ ( 7 % C8

)

D$E % 7* ++( 7 ( + (+

7*(+ (7 7 (( D* 8

C (+ + .

(""& "

""< + 8 + @ + : + 8+ ( (7 + 8

;) .( * * 5 + # "

"# #"

(( 7 7=) *5(

+8 +

+ 6 5 = 7 8

) (

/ 2") 1@@ , # "

"#") * 5 (

+ 5 8

+ 6 6 5) = K % 8 7 %) *.+ ) ( F

=( =5 5+ 8

( * = ( (

( (* = (.

( 7*(+ (7

E *7* 7 +(

* 6( (

( $# 7 7

+ + 7 + (

C+

( ( ((

+ (

@ 7 + + 5 * )( +

+ + (* 5= ( (( 7=)

+ ( 575 + + 5= $ %( * + + 5

+ (

7 ( )+ =) + D

E ' =!)

)"#"& E ?71 E

5 M1/ M1/