← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/489/2021dismissed

Gunvi v. Sandeep Bhatia

2021-12-03Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl13 pages

   

  

 

  

   !  "!

#"# "

  $   !  % ( )  %*

*

      (  + %  ,- .

&  *  ////

   !##" *   #   * "   



 &# ( *# ".

#2 .

!  !  4! #2 5.

 *

 ( "  .

  

* ! & * # * "   !0   !  "!

 # "

  $   % '!.

0! 0 *%* '! * - 

9

9  " -0 %* '! * : *# 

;

*  !



    * !  .

#2 .



 (  :"

        (    

'

<

+ " &.

!    4! &

665 *   *   * "   * .



##2 # -0 *%*

* * '!.

02 *  #2.

 *.

*  .

0 2  #.

 !.

=0# 2  *##2 # # -0 *   

#  *.

*   !# 

 *  > -     0 

-"

  

'

&

# ! *##2 !  -     !     0  !

.

!  -  *#"  *#" *##2 * "

# -!# ! #  # -!#  "! 

 > # - !    

# # !

 :  -     ! 

#   *

 #2 #

*

  " ! "  -  ##0 2 *   - !

 :"

"  !# *  -  ! *#" > # -  !.

**#    # 2  ( "

? .

0! 

#   -0 *  *##2 - # #  !  >   

* .

*    .

# #2  *  

#   *.



 ## # # 0 -!# 0## -!#  !# #2

 ! .

  #  (!2 = @$  # # # #2  !   !#

  0!

"

*  # #2 '!.

0! *-#

*- "".

  "

 8 # .

  #   @$ .

! (!2 = @$ ! 

@$ @   (A

B2#.

0! - ! '!.

    !  $.

 " ##2  ! !   :"

.

6.

-!# 

 *.

*   # 2!"

  %* ! *   * 0!

* * 

 $* -  '!.

0!

*  .

# ! !  !   > - ! *  "   "  '! >    * *   #2 0 0  0 (A

   !#  $ .

'!.

0! :2 0.

! # **  0-$ !

.

      0 " !  ? ! !.

 A %* " ##2 * *



 #! "!.

  $  #"!

- !"

 **   **#

 ! .

 A

      *.

%*    !# ""

!#  # *-#2 ! # 00! .

0 !# 

* !# 0!

"   #2.

 "

7.

 ! "

: #   !   #  #2 "

*   =-  ! -   "

 6.

* !.

:    &  "

    .

#2 =  "

 #   # *  "   *

!    0!

* # *2

!# :  .

  *#"  # #2 !0

6   ## # # -!# ! #  !# & "#2.

 (  3   # * ! - #! "!.

"   

!   

- !    #  $*  0 

*- "".

   !# > #  "

 # "

!   !

.

 "!

 "

-!

 !# 8! ! !   "

 #   # * ! " !  "!

  > *   

'

&

%*  

# .

- 0!!.

"     

* #  *  *    

'

&

66.

# *   *   * "   .

*   ! -#0 4  





   

  



       !  

 "    # 

  $ 4   





      

!%    "  

   

       &'$$

; & * #   !0 *##2

-"

* %* ## # # # #  *.

*   !# 

    

'

&

66.

0 .

0##  -  -!

.

0##  .

*##2 !  -  *#".

! *  -  !  > ! # *  **#    #  ( "

? 

#   *.

 - "

#  * #   

  

'

&

66.

0  *##2  @ .

 .

 (!2 = @$ .

 @$ .

 (!2 = @$   @$.

! *  -  ! .

0  ##  '!.

0! ##2 *-#

*- ""

 !#

 ! .

 (A

 !  $ !   .

6.

-!#

 *.

*   ! # 2!"

  %* *   

*  0 .

 #2 .

! # *  # 

9  # * -  !  (A

  0   $.

!

.

 (A

  ! # **  0-$ !

.

-#0 ! "!#2  0      " '! ? ! !.

A %* ##2 **   * -

 -!.

 & *  *%* '!.

*     "  -"

"   .

! 0 !#  #:

 # ! # 00 ! :   # 

 - 0"

  !   #  #2 "

*   =-  "

 6.

7 ,   ! *  -  !  #! <"!

 #  

 

   .

*    ! !#

  4 (   

    

     

   )   

 *+ 

 ,*   + 

 ,*  

 

    -

           



   

  )./,

0  ,    





               

     

     -     

     

 #  

   

 1 )(  

  

    -   



 

  # 

 (    

2     

-) ) ,(  

   -           

     

    )        (  '

   

  



    

 ,

)3)  

     

        



-  2   2   



       



 *     !4 % 456-

70"          

    

   

 -       

     

 '     8-           -  

 ,  .   ,    )  

           '    

'  -'



2-        .  , (  

2-       

       

          '       

 -  

    9%%%%% *  (             '

   

  



  (  



 



 )  

  :  ; '

) '  



 #    

 

  .   ,)  

      ''

     #            

-           

  ) 

            



  .  , 

)   

             ).

/,   ,   (            ).

/,   ,   ''

(  

 

,7 4- ,   ''

)+/()4!)"<,  , 



            -       



-    $ & * # - " !0 .

0!       #2 " 

#   !  .

 (.

  0    2 =  .

-  ! : " *  0!  #  .

0    2 =  ! .

"   "

# #.

*  -  *  #0 %# #2.





 !

 

" #$

% & *  ' ( ( "

) *.

  '!

! -  

 :"

!

.

#"

.

* * " !  <C-# % *   +

 !

  ,-&$ , ! 

*  

(( *'

- *     -  ! *#" > *  .

 "

  .

    .

#    # -0 * .

! !  "!

0! *  ! *%* '!

 ( !"

- * *  # 2 #    *

*##2 0! ##  .

-"

*.

 *  !

*      .

-  0    **     = *.

   .

 #  : =   8!

.

"

"   0!#.

0!    !   0##    = *.

* #2 -#!

 ! *    #.

.

!0  "    **  *#  #   # *  # ( "     &  *   7 .

**  * .

  - -  .

# !

2 *  -: :

  .

 .

 ! "

: - *  <C-# % *  >  # &  #!!

  #" %&"

#!!

*  '

(( .

!# 0!  * .

0! * 2 * .

!  -

* .

 *  -:

 :

   *  * * "

#   *  !

.

.

 # * " 0  -"

* .

# * .

0     ! #  * 

" *   ! -#0  1  '



  

     



    1  )  

    

       

'

    

      

 

    2    

2      

-  '      

 



  -  

     

     

     

 *604<< 

3) 

  < *8 3 4              

   -

  



  6 ; .- 4  -

    > - )' 8'  -

-'

   ' -        

           

 ' 



  

 ,<!"  ; .- 4      

          





 ,  ) 3

 )

   

 2          (  

 ;-):-      -   #     

               2-       '

         7 ?



    -         '

 

-   -

   

  '



     

   

     

         

'

        

   %

    - 

 2-     

    

     -'

        

'   

  



-

   

@'

      

           - 

 -          

 

  ,    

  -  1 )  , )3)

-   -   





       -'

 

    -    

   

  1 ) 



-    

     '    

 (       '-

'

   

             

-   

                          

       

     

 0 '   '

   :  '

 

     

          

-      

  (       

    #  

  -   :

--  ) ) /)/* 

< -

 3        !8"  



 *604<< 

3) 

  < *    8  3   4   -  



 

  - (   



$



*  *.

#! "!

 .

- ! !  "!

'! > .

 .

! #   0!   # * "  #2.

 !

  ! "

##2 *   ! "

" - .

*  *  #  **# ! .

  $    2   ! * 2 &#! "!.

! !# #"

* 

 ( -# #2  .

- !  0!

* 2  *  "  !

! *-# :"

   !# "

   *   #  .



!"""

 3   #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0