High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/100/2014dismissed

Pooja Sharma v. Vikrant Sharma

2015-01-27Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta17 pages

!"#!$% &'

(

)* +* )* ,,,, $-.-"/ .#.012"3-$+!#$'345!/-!"3 .+!""'345!/-

$/0-!11-66!"/ $ !63--1 2"70'345!/-

$/0-$-.1"3-"/ ,,,, '

! "

"# $%&& '(! )! %&&*+,"( - ./0 "!"

1" 2 ((- !(1"

"#,!3"!"

1"$"--"2

./,"/"

!,"("--,

"(("-#!3 #1"

5 6 65"(( ./-"

"-( #$1 $3"!"

1" - !("""-

! "

(7 "

"( 82 ! 1"

"# ., ! "

( ,"( (-19 5% 655"1 $"

# (" 1(

"#$!/ !". "(!(." , "1 """

! , - 0$" "#! "1-/$ (","(. 5 5 655:$ ,!( (-/ ( / ! "!

! "#! ,"(. 5;

655;$,!(-#1"

/,"( (

0 "!"

1""4

!"( !1"

"#$ !" 3"!"

1","

(!1" !( "1-/11. (,"(

-$(-#$ #" /" - ".- "! $ "

(!1"

!"1$"- "$!"

"4-/!(!("(,"((" "

(!- "-/< 4$1

(#" !( "#! .

" !"

(!,"

(! 2-",( "1-/ = (11$3"!"

#!(,(!($." !. ! "#! ("$ ! ,"( 1- !"#! .!"4

!("

"# (!4 /! "1-/ !/ "---,!!

!"-( "--# !" "(!/," # ! $!/!"4"/"-"( &5$55$555>2 ! ( 1!!(!- (" 0

-( /1" ( # "

!1 " !( "

( ! 4 !

" .

"0!!" (" -#( ! "#! ("

("4!- !( "#! $!0- "#!!"

(!.!"4 ! "--"

5% 655:$ ! "! ! "--" !

#! !( "(( "!"#! - " "-( 1-"!@ "-

8 "#( "(@-"(($1 "-(# #( "= ( 1" 6 655A (6A$6$6:$B%" : ! ""-@ ' (! ) @ *+"#"(!1"- "CDC 4($ 1

! "! ! "--"

" ( ! " "1(! " !"

"(( !1(1 !!"!,"(- ,!"- "4 !"(--!( ( "-!(!

,","/ ! " $! "-#,!!"--"("

-4#("

" 1!( "1-/" (-

"""$.! -"(. "141 , (. "(!( ".( " ,!!( 1((!"--",- -"4!!( ! ( "-/ !,- 4-"4! "#! "-!!(

! ! "--# !". "( ! .!"4 (!,./!"--"! "1."

01 !1!

$655A" 0" "

11 "("

" 1!( "1-/ <"- $<"- "#"

!"--"

" ( ! " "1(! !"!!"

((! 1"

"- -"( (---4

,!! ("4!( "" !,- "

!(1 "#!

5% 5% 655B$,!!("

( "1 1!1$3"!"

"#!1" ! "

" 4 (,"(4 2# "!

./!1!(1.-!'"@" / ( "(

,"( ""

! ,!!+ ""

/$655;$!"--" 1 !1 !"(!,"( #" . "1(( ("(!/, !"4# (7"-

(( -# 6 5;

655;$,!! "#! ,"( . $! #! ( !,-/. !-

! (,".("1-(, (" 4" 1"/ "(/ "( "

!" / ! !-

! ""-/((7 - !1 .# .-# "- "! ! !-

E! ! ( -( !( ! "--"$ ("

"-#9#$ (! "

1 !" (! ,"( !"4# 7 "1"

"- !/( "- -"( ,! ! (( " ! - ,!"4 !,"

!!. "1"--/ - 11($ (!,- -"4!!("B855 " 71 #"5855 11((!,- #!4#" 1."

0-"#! -"4#.! !-

,!!1 !.!"4 !"--"-

! !1-"4!1" 1"-!1"-#,!!( "#!

(" !($!,"(!

" ./!"--"" ! "!

(? (" 1- "#!1 "-(

1"- "(( 5;

655;$ ! #"4 " "- "

- $ 1 $ ,! ! ,"( # ? / ( .

! 22-", " (( 22-",40" "" ! ( -

1"- (

2:::6 655%'F +"#"(" 3"." ! ( . !3"." "

/""#!@ "@!" #"

!#!

""-/(("( " !'0 "!"

1"+,"( !.-# "- "! ".!"4 ! $,"( !- !"!,"(!.-# "- "! ! !- ,! "("--" 3"!"

1","(!.-# "-1!

!."(( ! $! #!@ 4

66 5:

65?"(! ! #( = ( 1" B& 6B 5:

655% #( ( :65$&5%$%B$;6" 652D @ "- "C@C4($ 1

.1#!"! -"

!"!"--","(

( "

- /,!(1 ($.!( /,"(!(0,- #"

!"!"

" !"--"!"

"( 1"-"(,--"( !/( "-

-/!1$! "/ "

!(" # ( !"--" ( ! !, ("1 - ./ ! $ (! "( -1"

/ .3 ( ,! #"

1""".-/ !" ( (( " 1" "- "

( ./!

-/# 1 ($ ! "--" "

1 !" (! ,"( -#"--/,

, ! " -"

!", "#! ( , . ! , - 0 5 655:" 6 5;

655;

! "--# !" ! !"

. -4--# "-( " ."(-(( "--#"( "#"( ! ,! "1"-" - "#!

(","(--#"--/" -", --/ 14 1! ( / !"-( (" !" 1 !4 /.## 1"

"#$ ! !

" !( "1-/11. (,"

(! ,"(

-$(-#"

#" / ! ! -4-.(--,!!1"

"#,!! !!"(1 "/. ((,- 4"-!1 !"-( - !

-.!"4 !("0 ! 1 "#! ( !

!"! "! !"

"/--2,-- 4-/! 1" 1"- !1

4--# "--#"($!"--"-"

!"!

"#,"((-19 ,!# "1" (!," !# , / !(!" 3,-- /$# ($ "(!

,"(#4$.! "

9 !( "1-/11. (.## / ((, ("( !/ ("

"(# 1" ( 1 , / 1! 22-", "-- !

,!".((" .3 ".- 1(" (!,"(#41

-((."#( ./! " ! "1-/11. (" " !. ! (

"#! 6 5;

655;$! 1" 5-"

(!(!" =!"1 !1 "#!

!,"(1

-((-/.""( (!,"(".- - -! 1"

! !""/ $"( "

./! $!"

"0-"

5% 5% 655B !@,"( (" . # $ ".

#!"--"$! "

(" -"4( ! , #! "/ "/ 1" 1"-- " ,"(1"--/ ./! ! -4("

" 1! "1-/ ! - (".-(!!( .((("""$!/(! ."

!"--#"!"(!( -"4!1" 1"-!1 -#! (,"("--# ./!"--".."(-(("

,"((.1 !"! "! "-#,!! ( ".-(!"

! 2-",( "1-/,!" ?(!"!/(!- (("

-/!"

"(( ! !/( "--/"(("-!

"-( ?( "( 1"

1 , /"(!,"("(1! 1" (

,4 $! #"4! 1

-((."#(" ! !1" 1"-!1"-#,!! ,-/. "#! $,! !

= ( 1" 6 66 5 655%,"( #( "#"( !1" !( "1-/11. ("- "@4- ($1 $"

! #!4(#"./"

"4$$((("

& - $@/2$1

= ! $! - ./! ,"( "--# !"4. ./!1 ( "

/,!!( "1-/ 11. (,!"1"-" "#! 1 (/" -,

! "!(1"" /( !.- "-"

# ! 4"- /" "

1((.-/ ! ,"( ( "(,"((" . "-(" ( 1#!"! (!.-# "- "! "#! ".!"4" !""--! .-##( - # , / "

-(" 3,-- /

. " 1(" " ./!

" !( "1-/11. ($" "/ (1(("- ! ,"(1"

./!"--"

( - 3 4 # ! .3 (

"( ./!"--"" !-"

#( !"

($ --,# (((, "1 '+ E!! .!"4 ! ,"

( ! (4 /

-H '6+ (( ( 4 $,!! -" (-

1!(, 3"H

'+ E!! !(1""".-H

':+ E!! (( ./!(,"

1 -#! (H

':2+ E!! ! (- ((- !( 1"

"#,! ./,"/

!# "

- /H

: '&+ -

(.(""!("--#"($! ( !,((.7"(E:I! ! 7"1 E "

" "-$.

( $,! 4 1( BIE6"

3#!

"$ - $ ,! ? / !

1-" #4!3"."1"#!(@11((I E < #!$ ,! 4 / ,( 1 .-(! 1 ("

E>IE&!@!0"(!,"

< $ ! "- 2 ! @ =# # "

"#( ($/ "."

$,! "-- -4" 1(" 4

! E:>6

!! !" $"--"3"!"

1"""

"(E:

" 1"

"(- ( 4#("1 !7"1 "3" 1"E$

(!1"

E6$0"(D!"(0"

E$,!

. ! 4 ( " 4 /

5 655 " /

B 5% 655% !#!@ "

@( #!4 "

./!"

(" ! (.1((( 1"

! .!"- $ -"

"- @ "1 !

-(!"!"--" 4" ,!! "! !"

(.3

! " !( "1-/11. (

-/./ -#

1"- "(( "#"(!1" !! ./(.3 #!1" !(.

<" "4!"

1"!/( "- " ! !"!1"

"#., !"

(,"(1"--/" "

"--/ "

,"("-(!- !""

- /!"

!"--","("-(" "( , (0

;

-/!

4, ! #(!((($!,"("--,

,! ((" "

((-4#!1"

"#.,! "

(,"("((

=-# "## 4 ./ ! 3 #1 "

6 65"(( ./-"

"-( #$1 $3"

!("""- ;

E!"4!"

!(.1(((1"

./ ( (!

" ( < "$-"

(- (#!"--""

"- #!$-"

(- (#!

(""

1! 4"- ( !"

(!"!

-4-- "--#"("#"(!"--" -"#-/ 1 "1"- (

",-- -"

(! "

,! ! "(

!1!/( "-" 1"-

-/$."-(" -"

( ("--#"

- #! !"(/ ! "

1 !"!- "#!

(","(. 5 5 655: !(, - 0,!!"--"$.

( !-#1"

/ !( 1"- !- ".!"4. 5;

655;

(" 4 !"" !( "#! ,"(. $ ! #!( ( ,!! ! !-

!((!(,".("1-(" 4" 1"/"1-/$ "(/ "( "!" / ! !-

! ""-/((7 -

!1"(!.-# "- "! ! !-

! / ! #4./

"(/ 4 ./! ( E:>

!".4$ 7"1 E&!@!

0"(!,"

< ( "( ! "- 2"(,--"( ! "-

7"1 ! @ =# #" "#( ($ '@=+$/ "."

$,!( !" 1-"

! @ "4 1"

" 3"/ < "

$ ! "- (((" !"

4 !.- ("1- 3"!"

1"$."./".!"4!"

1""

0 " !"

4 ! ,"

# ,! ! "

!# "!( ! ("1 ./!1"( E&>6 E&>:

! ! 1( 4 ./!1, "- ;

5% 656(! = ( ". " / ./ ! #( "

< "-$ 3". "

/""#!@ E&>&I "( 4# !"

4 ./3"/ < "

"4 1"

E&>AI"

0,- #1 !.-

("1- E&>B(# ./!".4"1 ((I!(, /

E&>;

"# !" 1- (

/ ( 1""

#! (" ! ( "-$! !/ / 6B 65$,! !,"( ,"

!#( "

< "-$#!@ 3"." "

/""" @!" #"

"-( 4 ! / ! /#!( ,(#" (" !(#" (

< !"0"

$ ! #"- ! ( E:>6'

((# ,"#( " -( (+ ! -(

",! ( 1

!7!.( 4 ("( )@ @ ! ( 1 ! 7!.( 4 ( ( - !"8 !(

7!.@'

0 "!"

1"+(!

.-# "- "! !(

7!.D'."./".!"4 !"

1"+

7!.' ( 3"!"

1"+(.-# "- 1! !(

7!.D'."./".!"4!"

1"+ * !".4 ( 1 !"--#" !

!"!( 1"- !- . !"--","(

1!(-( ! ,

($!,"(!.-# "- "! !."./ ".!"4!"

1",! "("--"3"!"

1","(! .-# "- 1!

(- !"--"

6 ! 4 ' (! )! *+,! !(-"(!""/ ( . #! " "4"- 1"

"#.,!(1!

"/1" ,!6;5 "/(" ( ((-$!1! 1"# 1"

$(!"--. -(4 ! "

!"!(!-#1" ( !"1"$-(( ".(!,!"!"

(!1"

"#!"

(("

!! ""/1,!! - !"4. 4

(-"(( !"!- 4 ./ 6 ! ". (1 "4 "((-/ ".(!, ./!"((!""!1,!! !- - !"4. 4 $ !"

(!"

(("

(!(($,! ,"( (- # ! -(4(( (!, !" ! ,"( / ! !(((!"4"

(("

( !( "

#1($ -"

(- - +!"/2 -42 !"3 !"/0-$4..02!<'

8-5-"/2426-1$/.(:&

((#! "

(!" $-"

(- # ,!

4!1 !""

1 -/!"

(, ( ##! "1

$655A--! "! !- ,"(. 6 5;

655;

! (,"(!"4/! 4!"!!"

((! "--" ! .#4 ! !"1" $!(

1"--##!"! !- ,"(. !, - ! E:>6 !"

. ./ !

4" ,! "-( !@ (#"/ "."

! "--#" ! "--" !" (

E:>6!"

. ./! ( 4(. 3

2 #!-/"(4 , !("1 - . ./! 1"

! ( 4"- / "! / ( -/$ ! "

( ,

( ##! "(!(." , "!1! ( 1"- !- ,"( 4 --!1(!,"(. $.!" ./(- (( 3 ! ( #"

#-#1"

/ ! 1"- !- "( ./!

( ".4$! (1 .#-#1" !-

! ,!!. ! ! !- . #! " "4"-

"# " . . ./ # # 4 !

# ,! ! ! "--# !" ! !"

. (.3 !/( "-" 1"-

-/./!"--",!!"

4!- !

"! ( "

( 1655: 41. $655;

E!! -"(., !"

(, ( " $ ".(" .1 .".-!""-!#!

!/, -4# !("1 $.!/, !"4#(7"- 1"

/ ! ( ! 2!(." !"!!"

((

8 !, ,!! !- ,"( 4 ,"(" 1 ./! (

!(" 4 ./!1,"(( !-"

"( ./!1 ,"(!-"

# ! " ,"("-(!(

(!"$655A,!!/ 1 ("

-4#" !($!"--"

" ( !""1(! !"! ,"(".-!"4"

((! !"4#(7"-

(,! !

"( !1(4 1"- $.! -4#,!! 3( ("4!( "!( /" !,- "

!( "#!

"-( "# "--/-"

( !"""

/$655;$,!! "--" 1 !1!"(!( #"$!. "1(( ("(!

!"4(7"-

(,!! ( -# ! !- ,"( . 6 5;

655;$! #!( ( ,!! !1 # -" (! ? (,".("1-(" 4" 1"/ "(/ ! "(/ E:>,"("-( 4 ./! !(" (7"

-/(1-"

E:>6

!"36!6=!.#3-!3>!2?4.*!/!!"36!6!3>!2? !"$

*;&9!7@ !- "(

#$ $

!% &

!% $

! 2!(." C(-"!"!!"

((! , ,!! !- ,"( 4 (

. 4 ./! ( E:>" E:>6 E!!( ( 4 ! "

/$! - . 1-- ."

! "! ! ! !-

"4#"

4 "!(" -($ --,( !"!"

" !"--"4,!(!,"(-4#,! ! ,"(( !!"(! "( !1# "41"-

-/ A

!".4(!-/#

-/"--#

4 ./! "#"(!"--" "

( !"! "! !"--" - " "-("

(

4-( 1-""#"(!1" !( "1-/11. ( ( :%;2>:5A>B @ "! 1-" :65 @

,! !!"- " #4./!1$"? /,"(#

./ - $ = 9 !

( 1"#!(@11(($@!" #"

E6"

3#!

"$ - ' 4+$ "# "$ ! ? /" (.1 !( ( !? / $ ! " !(.

! $" !/, "

( = 6

66 5 655%$# #( ./ "! !"--"$!/, !/( "--/ #- ( /"(" (- ,! !$!/!"

( 3 (! (( !."(( !? /

$! --,#

65 5:

656 E:>&,"("(( ./! 3"."1"#!(@11(($@!" #"

!82 )

( $

% $ % )

* $ +%,

! -.

$ /#

,!1$22234

5 & !

5 &

9 B

1 "-/$! "-( 4 !""!

1"-

"(."

#= B& 6B 5:

655% (:65$&5%$%B$ ;6" 652D @ "- "C@C4($1 $,"(#

#( ./ "

(!1"

$ "! !"--"$"#"(!1" !( "1-/ 11. ( = # !" !

1"- #( -" ! ./

(!1"

, !#."".( (( -",$!(@ 4

66 5:

65 E:>$ !"

?"(! ! (" = ( 1" 6" ! (? #(

;

!-#! ".4 "

1(" ($(? ""

!""--"3"!"

1" 4" ,!! "! E6

(!1"

" ( "-(-/1- "! " !( "1-/11. (

1"- "((,!(1- 14" #!1!"

"(( $,! !"1 )

-/*,!! 1"# ( '+'"+ ! %&&

!"(.!- ./C.-7@ " 3 #1

!"(, ./ "4-!"C " "-(

1"- 1-"(

./!

((,- 4"

".-/" .".-/ (1" 1"-

-/$ ( !"(,- -!! (( -"1" 4

!($ ! .# #! 4 (".-(! !" ! "--"" ! "1-/11. (!"

(.3 ! 1"- " !/( "-

-/" "-(!"!"--","(-"

#""

- ( - ,! !,"(, (0 1"-

-/ "( ! $!

((.-(!"!1"

"#.,!"

(!"

& " "

1,! ! ( !" 4"-

#-/$! 3 #1"(( ./-"

"-@ $ ((-4#!1"

"#., !"

(./"

$ "--( 4" !""- .# 4 1 (! ./ (1((

+* !"#!$% &'

( &

#$ %