← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2760/2023dismissed

Mahender v. Ramphal And ORS

2023-11-07Mr. Justice Namit Kumar6 pages





     



 !! " !!!!!!$$%%  &#' ($"% "# !!!!!!$

         #  #! )""%*

*

#"$$%% !    !  ,"

 -'%# 

 $$%

 -  " -(  # !

.$ /0" '#

% 1'

- 1'

# 

* 2"

* 3"#/0 '

$#(  

/0#$

 4 ! $%

" /  #   3%%  -  " )'

-(   #

!

! $ /0" '#



% #

1'

-* 3"#/0 $$%

 /0 " $$%%    #$

  4 !5    - ")'

-(  # !

.*"/ 

!

7*# #  $# / -( $#" #'

%'

!2# %0 *%

'

 $#(  

- "(%+   / 8 %'

+ 3 #

* '%%0 / "



!9 $% ""0( +#%

#



- " '

 %  /'

'%  '



%%0 "

 %  3 -

 /0 30

% -   $$%

 /

# ,"

% #* 2"

 " 

 $$%

 3 (#7 %:;

3#*2"

! " #'

#'%

" #+ ' %3* '"

* 3 " " "%$

 <! !=! > '#+0 -*2"

!,"((

$$#

($'# ?  $%  3  $#$#  /0 - - %% ' %

%%-% "( /0%%"  *'$ $# $#0!,"  #  -"/ '# /' %%0 # -# "0"+ # -"* % # $# $#0/'* "0"+/ "

%%-%

"03#$% '-"

-* "$

%( 

 %

+ '#

#* ( ' "

 "

 $#

'%# % * 3 "%  " %%-% $

 " $

 *"0" # -" ("$

/ 7!9 3 '#"# " 3

%%0 2%%'3"

2%%'@ 3 )   $# $#0!9 $% "

$%

@ #:'/0"   + "$ '%$

$#0 3   # * "0

 '

$#(  

  4 !

 /0"$#% #0

/)

"+ '

* )

# ( )

  #0$# *$%

( " '#3 "(%

 

 $#

$%

  $$%   :'

 (  / % 0 % # ! (# * 3'/(  "3#  ( "

$%

  

' #/% / '   "+ %# 0

  '

%#

  3%%  $#(  

-  " $%

 3"

 $

 "  %  '#! %

"+

#$

3 "

' 0/ %

 0 "(  " /  - + ! 4  $

 7"# '(/# # 7 %% '(/#"+/ ( 

# #  3"

" $#

  0 $#

'%# % * " $%

 # %%-%

 3"

" $#

'%#    $#

'%#!  "#

 - 3#   (  3

  4 !    * "

3+#* "0 ( ""0 +##  0 /)

"% :'

3

3 "#-# $#0!93 ( /0"(""%%-  "( "

#"%# 0/ #( ("$  "# 

" 3#    0$#

"'

0! ! %

#$%

"3#  ( 

 *  0 - " +#( 

 " 3#   (   # -"+#( 

#$% ! 5! 6 %% ' 3# #(  /0 " # %  '# +

!

   A""#"$%

#  % "#%

""



" $%  % -3

:'  % #%

$#(  

$#0

#B 

 A""# " $%

 "+  %

' 

'

%"$# '

B





 A""#" $%

 #  $$  /0 " 

"$# 

#(B  + A""#"'

% /% /

)

# ( )

  #0$#0B + A""#" % '#" )'#

#0 "$# '

B +  A""#"'

/## /0% 

B +

 % #  % #%  3%% 

'( #0 +

'$$ #

##$ +

 

! !  # "# - #-'(   # $$#

- +

#

*# % '# #

+

)'

-( 

# !

.! .! --# +  -  " )'

-(   #

 " # % '#*  $# ##  $$%/

#"% 3#$$%% '#* 3"

""/ 

+

)'

-(  # !

! C! ># 

' %

# " $$%% 

 " -( $ /0/ "" '#/% 3'

( %%-%  (# %

#( "(##'%

( #

+

! '#"#

"

-

" '#/% 3/ $#+##% /% /#+#  9"+"#

' %

#"$$%%  $#' "#

! ," $%

"(%+ / 3 #

$#)(/

D8!'$

"*"  "+ " $#

#$ # D8! !  $# )(/

 D8!  $%

 # 3 #

5

 "

$'  $# $#0 

"##   %

  ' )  

!%

"+ / (

#D8!3"

""/ $# /0AE'

+ *  *



(*

*2"

A E+

#='(#*= ' - *3"

$#$# "#$ #D8!!$#"

# %'// " " 47" , + $#$#  3

 #$ #* " +#"$%

% /0   %#%0$# ,"  4 ! "+%# 0+  " /0 "(  $# " #$ # 3"

" " /  ( 

 " 3#   ( 

/0"(!># 

' %" +

"

$#( "  4  "++ "

"+ 0-# + - "( #% % - "(!9 % %# ("3#  ( 

/0  4  

""0"+'/(  "" " #

" %# 0/ + /0"(!$#"#$ #*  " F( "+ " 7"#4 *7 %%4 !  8 

  D A   " 3# 4 #"  '" !!  % ('#  :'# 0# !  %#%0*   '7"" " "8 

C   " 3# D A   " 3# 4 #"  '" %% ('# -  :'#0# 7"#4 *7 %%4 ! C!,"

#

% "/  '%0( 

"#$ #D8!3%% $%   " 3 ""#$ #! +#* # #/'"

#$ #  #  /0 $%

* "   "+    /#

 0 "#

# $# +"

##0!,"#

#* '#/% 3"+# -"%0 /#+ "+#

%#%0 $#"

#! !

'## 

- "+ /  #

 /0 / '#/% 3

' %

#"$$%% " "

3 " " ( # $#+# %%-% # /  ( #

-* #

#( $$#

"(# %+

#

 :'

%3*('

"%'/  %:'

%3 " /  # # #

#

 " $#  $$%! 4

"#$

"/ '#- ! 9 + 3

"/ +*$# $$%

5! 

- $$%

*

  0* 

-%0!  



!!     !! A""#$7 -<#   G<4 A""#$ #/%  G<4