High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2066/2013disposed of

Ram Sarup v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2015-10-29Mr. Justice Harbans Singh Rai7 pages

!"# ##$$ % (! # !" #$%&' ()*+,' -').+#/ & )!

*!+(,-%- !($ ! *!!"

/ .$-#"'%0 !$-&!'

-').+#/ &0 1(!!.$$#

- (!" 3" /' $ 4(##$-($ !!5 4 ( # !(3"!$ /! $'-( (!(% "

! ( 3" - !(!- 7(8- "4(3"!$ " %$$40$- 1($ !(,- ! !" &!0(4(!*"$ )"!#(

$ !9

",!(

22 %$$40$:. $$.,'

! (1( 3" $$! (!-7($$!8%.! #

!(3"!$ ;- - <9#!! .((.!

($$!-($ .

! $,+ = ! ! "

6 ( - ( $!

"! ,$. % .! ($ ! .( !4! (

!(3"!$ -(.%!-('.!($ $ 4;> (%$" "

, "! :(

.!.(((, #"4 , !("!,'($ ! #! ##$ !

$ !($ !",(($!

"! ,$. ( .! 4$' !+ ( $ ( $ ! 1( $$!( .!# 5# 4 %.($ # $%$" :

5 !#"!1(%$" . $ ( $ #! ! & "!(! ", ( ( 0%!

( " #$ ! ! .! ! ( 3"! $ ( - ! .(( (,.!5# 4 %.( (.!& #!'((.! (#! .

- ! ,$ !!" ,##$ (%$" #!% (#$!"$ 6 2 = ((!( -$!

$ !( ",( ($$!(.!+" !# :.",( %$" (!. "((, $,'( $ !-(.%!- 5# 4 %.(#$ !,'( - ;- - <9(, .! &!$!

$ !(#! #!"(##!9 ,5 $'- ( 0%!

&!' ( " #$'

6 .(!,'( "! (

&!' .! ?1(#$' 6 - #!% ( $$ ( $ ! .((.! ($$!.# ! !

!!#% "

! (-($$ , $ "# ;- - <9#!!1(!$% ?! #$'6 "

@ ",+ 9 ? $!! #",$#"!# ( !- :!! !(",+ ( ( 0%!

( , 3"! 4 $ ! #",$ #"!# ! %!" #! .$$ (!

4 A !(#! '# # ($ .

!, (! ?,'( " "

! ( (! (# % $ ! % ( #! $! 2 999

<6 -

1( ( ,

! 4 ! , ( 3"$'- 4!' $ "

!3" : ( , ( 4 !$ ?#! ( ( !

? !3"$.#! (!5!#!%$ (! 3" $'-( $ .

!(%##!(("! ! ( 4( #( (#! $4 5 ", $ 4!"$"!$ $ $$ %! ( ( ,%!'%$",$ ! (!4 "!!"

$(1( !!.(#!% ( $'$%$( $ ! # , ( !5 ! #!%$ (!

1(3" ,! 4 4," #!% ',' ? 4 $!! (!,' "! #' !# ( !!, !5!-(, "

!(% ! 0%!

1(' 3" $$.,'( $( ! .$$,'(=:#! 4 ($, " :( ., ,'(0%!

(( ,% $$. 4B !(#"!# ?

$!! 3"

1( "!, ,$ ! (.

( 0"!4 %$# )$ ( ",9!4 &!' $" 4 ) (5"$ #!#(!'

( 4!( ! 4#! ( "&!' ",9!4

!" ! -( "!(!,

?( $$. 4 $!! !(,%(!B 3" !#",$#"!#

1("!, ,$! 0"!4 .$$(% $!! $#!! ( &!' ",9!4 $" 4) (5"$ ! ( 4!( #!#(!' ( &!' .$$ (% $!! $#!! !(! ( $!! .$$, $#!! % 1(! $"($" ! #',$ "

! ( #!% ( 3"

1((,'(% $ !

.$$ "#!

!".($ ? 4(!

!%!"4! "

!3"

, ( $!!:.$$ "5 "

$$(#!! !.!5 4"($ 3" ! , 4 $$.#! .($"

4(!( 3"! 4#! <4 ( C 1(! !-( "$! $! ' 4,"##$,$' ( ! !" <#$' 6 .(!4! ? $!#! 3"!$ !#",$ #"!# ( 1(!$% ?!(! "

@ !! "$ $ ! -(,

( .! ,

< !(*!( ($$, ! $.!( ( $!!-"

'"% ( #! $! 699 1( (! #!% ("

699 .$$ ! "

( 4C

1( !#$'6 ",'(0%! .!% 2- ! 4( "! ( ? ('! 1(!$% ?! #$'- 2-"

D ", ? $!! !(3" #",$#"!# (

1(#! * 999 <

- 6 E(#! *"

!! ! - $!! !3"! 4$ !#",$#"!#

!%!"#! .$$(! 4 .! ?,'(&!' 0%!

$$.

* $!! !"!, ,$! 0"!4 $#!! * " $! ! ! ! ( &!' ",94 $" ) (5"$ ! ( 4!( #!#(!' (&!' $#!! * $!! !(! &!' $#!! 1( $! ! $" ( $" ! #',$ "

! ( #!% ( 3" - .(, ,!%(.((#4

!5! (% !", $$' 1(! !- &!' 0%!

( !9 ! ( ! (!9 ?( $!! $$.

* $!! !"!, ,$! 0"!4 $#!! * " $! ! ! ! ( &!' ",94 $" ) (5"$ ! ( 4!( #!#(!' (&!'

$#!! * $!! !(! &!' 6 $#!!

1( $!! $"($" ! #',$ "

! ( #!% ( 3" -

1(!%!.$$,##$,$ $$( 3" .(!.!(%,

! !

2 !!#% ( "

( 3" - D 1(#$' 2-(.(( $!!

!(! (&!' .!!%6- - <9#!! ! - - <9#!! (!!##$,$ $$(3" .(!.!,'($$!(%,

! ! 2 !!#% "

! ( :

(#! -(.!.

,'($$!

.(! #! ! #$ 6

2-( ##$,$'! 2-!#%$' 1( $ ( !(%$" !('!

2,' > (! 3" ! - - <9 6- - <9#!!#!"$ ( !#$(.( ! 4# !$'.'!-( "# #',$

. ( ; >#!

"1(% ! 4#!

$ .(((!$ #!"! ! ," "!, F (!

!!""!$ $ 1( !#$'$!- '# - , ! # % (. 4(%$" 1( ! ! - - <9 6- - <9 $"$ ! $$ 2-(

% .#$-#!% 4 ! "!-( - <9#! (15 4 "

( ! - ( .! ( #! .

,' ( $$!

- ( $ ! ( #! !% , 4! ,' 4 - <9#! ( - - <9.(

! $$ (

.!,'($$! #! ," G (:

( !"

-( - 6-2 <9-.((!"

- <9 #!!

2 !(! ,%-(##$!$$.1( .! $!

"!,$. $'(? %$" 3"!$ 1(; -

- <9#!!"

4.! "

%! "#($1($ !($$ $, $$$("!', %$,$("

!( -').+#/ &

1) (/2'