High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7490/2016allowed

Laxman Singh v. Bhupender Kumar & ORS

2019-04-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"#

$$%% &'( )#($'*( '#'

+$ ,'

-$'*('./'

##0/./ '#$$%%

!1/* ''./ ''$2

,'5% !#

!"###*( '.

" 6( 7'. ' /%%" 2'$('. , !#'8. 9#% ' +8'. ' #'("# # #' !# ##*( '#6'("#% $('!

# '&#%. ::"'$ )#($'*( ';

'/'. <#' ;8'=#%% !>'%?(' = $7 (''''6'"2 @+3A@ A #''

'''#"''.% " $#( + %

$'##% .

6(3 $

.#%"8##(%8'('"' +8' '7%

6'"'"'2 @+3 B 3 .# 8#%#"

''6"'/67'$2

;)#($'*( ''# "%" '.8#%""#8'"## '7%( 8##.6##''%%8C##% ('"'/( 1('#$'C#'#.'$2

.#''

'/''87%/"#''6#C##% 1('8 < >/' @$%. +8'. 8#' # 8 %%7'.#''#% ' /'% #$%'' ( +

%8$#'

""#$.%%##''$$( $$'%$'8' "#% $

?#8' (6 6#%'$ 2

.##'%"%61#%%""# 6%7# % $"#('#% '.8'

D' % 6#% '$ 2 % # %'%#'$2

+$ 2 3 ; (' $7 # 8' %67%'/'(%"%61(6 "# '$2

8#/"/%/'/"% # '$ ; (' $7 8 ' '"'"#8%% %%##''$$'7' %#% $

3 # $%" # $'. %%8" ( 8' '

D##' !"##('1('/#(%' #<$%('#"%"'/"#" /#%2 @+3A@ A67'$%%"#$E ,,

? ( 2

$'/. 8##' # $' % $E?8# (E,,

D##''$2

8#%"/%/ '/"%#E?E,+

)##$'%/($$'#''$/ %

? '' $'/ # . # $'5% # !# #< *( ' ,D . !# !(6## =# ,D .

!# &<#!#' ,D3.F@=&''!"#,D.!# + ,DA.!#

!"#,D !# !6',D

# #' #. '$ # 7 8

'#'"'"( .#9'6(%8#%$'%7%%8" # $ / 8'

. 8' $ + 3.A5%"8#'GH$'( ' #%" #$%%#'%I#%"'$2

%6%$7# ( $1%7/'%%7 @8/'.

'$2 386%/%6%7$7 $

%"## $8'# 8%8' .#% #%#$'$$%<"# $.8##8"/#'$

+$ 2

$$' $ '/

D#''$2 3;(' $7$$'#'("#(%

?#/#'%'(%'#$$%%%' (%''$2 3;(' $76""#'("# #''

9#9'6(%$$'#/(6' #'('#"8#'"'(2

!"##('1('/#(%'#<$% ('#"%"'/""''67'$2

%%"#$ D#%"(2 3J

#9'6(%# #%( ##''86"(' '%$('$8" '''$%'.#((' $786%/%6%7 $7 $%7'$2

8'#%%6% $7 # $ ( ' 6' ('" (# %( ''/ 67 # 9'6(%. # '%/ $' ' 6" '$'(('

!! "

$ % % %

A % & %

'(# )

'($

% % % % % &

%% %

# +

!"#$

#$$ % , $ % % % %

%% %

- . /" 0

" %

( (% % *

%% % %

% %%

012 3

% %%

# 5*#-%

%0%

% ( %

# +

% %

@8/'. # 8#% $$'# # 9'6(% # 6 ''( / ? & '( ))!*

+#, - -

,/.#' -(")#@K6%!($' =('%"8#'"' $('!

#'&#%8#''

''7"#'%%7 8#8'# $('$'(<.86'/# '%76( 8''7"8(% ##''86"(' '%$('$#'86'#' ('$%7. #''.%6%7(%6#8''' (' $78%6%$7# $ 9###' 8# %'# # (#'7 9# 6'/ # 9'6(% # 8#

: # #'%%78##''8# 8%8# .6<'$'/#%.8##(%6$% 8#($' '.(' $78 %6%(/%' #(' $%7'%%78'"

9#(' $7%%6%/ %6%7 9#(#" (2 3 %%# '$'#%%6%$7 $

'"'(2 ."6'/67#'%=(' #8/'7(%$$'#$$%1(( 9# $'5% 8#%""#8 ''# #(#1('7##('%$('". % "7.%(78##'<#8#(('C### 6 $' 6%/%$("%7%$$'C# ##$( + .5#' $'#'7 '$'.#% #(''(''"#' .%6 ($$'#''6 9#% # !# #<*( '.=%'< (<%'#=%>'#)%=#8<.+8'.8# ##"(''

!0/6%%F ,D 5)8# '$'%' "/#1('5% 9#6%%'

:.5 9#9'6(%#('%7'(%8## 6%%"(/"'8#%' #% '##"('#6%%##(%#/6 $(#.'L('"#'# % $'/#6%% 9#6'/#9'6(%#1('#( 8##%' %$%(6%8'#7$

9#% '/68'( +

:.5'% ' 9#9'6(%#%%8( + . 5#% #66%%$'/67,D !(6##=#.+'*$'. $ @$% 9'( ='. +8' ,D3 &<# !#' .+'<$'.>$%!'.+8' 9#9'6(%# %"### 7 $$% '#6%%. '$ '$('# #9'6(%#(%6 %/#( 9#(# %$%%867#9'6(% '#+ . 5 M :

(% . (#68' #% *$"/8#('1('#' "( $'#$%I#% 51('.#("#6 $'6"(6%$'' ('%#'( '/"1('# '/#(%' ( + .5 8'#% #'"'

"#9'6(%#8'7 (('# # '$' #'" $' ('" 1('. "" ##$%""#''%%8($' #/ $ '6% (8''$' ( +

A.58'#% ('##

"('###'". (# 68' ='"#'( #. (+

A.58'#% ('##

9# (8'('##$%# + 3.5 "' 9<"'%/8##"%("

#'L(' 1('$'<$%''%71" #'('$' $'/'77$ "(1(' ('67#1('5% .( +

.58'# %

9#9'6(%#8'7 (8'((' %$ (+ .58'('##

98'$('". (+ A.58 8'67#9'6(%.8## 6%8' %7$' ('"1('%#"(# '7('"67# ? /'7(%L(7(#' ('"671(' ( + A.58'('##

' # ' # ( ('" 1('. # '%$'$#% #/6.( + A.5 8'#

'#'##% #%%66%8%<.'( 8'<(%'%'$''('"1('.( + A.58'8'%

9#% $ (+ . . 5

9#9'6(%# 8' % ( + 3.A5 $%"8#'GH$'( ' #%" #% $%%#'%I

?#87.## ( +

. 5

. . 3.A 9#$$%%5% #%%6%'/' ## (8#'#' AH$'( ' # %" $$% %% (% $7 D# '"' # %

$ 8' %% # #' '$ #%% 6 1%7 /'%%7%6% 9##'' #%%' # "/#'"%8'

D#(# .#$$%%%8$'%7 )'1

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#