High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/224/2014allowed

Satinderpal Kaur v. Gurpreet Singh

2018-01-19Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri7 pages

!!"#$#%&%'()*+, - #%.!(/01'( 2//!00% 3$ '(/(!! -#%45 2 !$/%.!% & 67 -- 67 -

3 -77

(!$!% & (8%.!!/-#%45%#$!+.9" !( 5!//!00% (-#8(%:# -#%45+.9" !( 5!(!$/%.!% ;#!5$/(!!((!. 5#$//!04#%$ 5!:'.48!% %..!"(!! . !. < /$$!. =) -5 11 %$0+ ..# #%0 #$ (#" '.4!

.5"

'(.$/'(+4(% #%4.!"(!!.#9("!'%.!(-!" #%> 5! #%.'((#4!" +($5( ? 5!" 6+% 5!=$#$ 5!9!(8!% $#% 5! /! # #%%. 5!$ !8!% $8.!=!(! 5!'( /! # #% '%.!( -!" #% > 5! " @$ #0!. =) 5! //!00% %.(!$/%.!% 9!((#%4 5!(!#% 5 8((#4!=! @!!% 5!/( #!$ 5.=!!%$0!8%#A!.%'0)>+ 3#004!5"B%@0#+!5$#0!( =%B+#$ (#" '(.$/'(%. 5 /( #!$0#9!. 4! 5!($5'$=%. %.@#! 0@%.#()+!5$#0!(=%B+#$ (#" '(.$/'( "5#0.@$=(%' 5!@!.0"B ( #!$0#9!. 4! 5!(%0)($!9!% .)$%. 5 # @$% /$$#=0!( 5!8 0#9! 4! 5!('%.!(%!($

5'$=%. %. @#! $ 5!) "'0. % .:'$ @# 5 !"5 5!( % ""'% .#!(!%"!$#% 5!#( !8/!(8!% $%./#%#%$5!/( #!$5.=!!%0#9#%4 $!/( !0)$#%"!'0)+(8(! 5%%!)!(/(#( 5!#0#%4 5!/! # #% @$'( 5!(9!((!. 5 = 5 5!/( #!$5.8' '00)4(!!. //!(=!(! 5!'( (.#9("!=)8' '0"%$!% 5!//!00% 5. 00!4!.0)4(!!.% "0#8%) 8#% !%%"!(8 5!5'$=%.%.5. 8' '00) 4(!!. % #0! %) "#9#0 ( "(#8#%0 "$! 4#%$ !"5 5!( 5! $ !8!% $ 5! /( #!$ @!(! (!"(.!. % -!/ !8=!( C+ > %. ("5 <+ $ $'"5 5! '( 5. 4(% !. 5! .!"(!! .#9("! =) 8' '0 "%$!% % /(#0 <+ "%$#.!(#%4 5 5! 8((#4! 5. B!% /0"!%'0)>+%. 5!)5.=!!

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

(=%B( 0.4#%4% 4#%$ '(/(!! -#%45+5@!9!(+ (!$/!" =0!$ 5! (! %.0"0=#%! #%#$ !(#% !(9!%!.%.8 !(@$"8/(8#$!.=! @!!% 5! /( #!$ % '4'$ + > % "8/(8#$! # @$ 4(!!.

(!$/%.!% $5008(() 5!//!00% $$'"5 5!#(8((#4!@$/!((8!. %'4'$ ,+>#% 5!/(!$!%"!= 5 5!8#0#!$ =-(#5%.# '('.@(+!(=%B+#$ (#" '(.$/'(5!8((#4!"(.5$ =!!%/0"!.%(!"(.$%%!F'(!<5!8((#4!"!( ##" !#$ "5!. $ %%!F'(! C 5! /5 4(/5$ 5! 8((#4! (! 0$ "5!. $ %%!F'(!G%. 5!#00/5 4(/5!(@5"0#"B!. 5!/5 4(/5$%. 8.!3#.!#08 5!8((#4!"!(!8%)#$%%!F'(!, 5$=!!% 00!4!. 5 5!#% !% #% 5!(!$/%.!% @$=.(8 5!9!()#%"!/ #% !5. 0. 5!//!00% 5 = 5@#004 0)%.$! 0! 5!(!%.( 5#$/'(/$!8((#4!@$(!D'#(!. =!(!4#$ !(!.#% 5!'( -#%"! 5! //!00% @$ $#8/0! 0.) %. "'0. % $!! 5! 80#.! '(/(!!

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

5$=!!% $5@%#%(.!( =(#%4 5!"$!@# 5#% 5!8=# # $8#% #%=#0# )%. $ '! !$ =0#$5 5 5!/!(#.%!)!((#0#%4 5!.#9("!/! # #% $ .!0/$!.$/!(-!" #% 5!" +%/! # #%"%=!/(!$!% !.

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

$/%.!% 5$/' #%//!(%"!%.$ !. 5 5!//!00% #$5#450)!.'" !.4#(0%.@'0.% /' 5!($#4% '(!

%)."'8!% @# 5' (!.#%4# %. 5 5!@(%4$ ()5$=!!%/' ( 5 =!(! 5#$'( 5($$ 5!(!$/%.!% (!F (%!'$(!$%$ #$/' !.D'!$ #%$" 59!=!!%(#$!.=!(! 5#$'( ;! (!(#% (8 4#9#%4 %) #%.#%4 " /!(8# #%4 5! /( #!$ 0!. !9#.!%"!=!(! 5#$'( #$$! 0!./(#%"#/0!0@ 5 ('.9# # !$00 /("!!.#%4$;5!%('.#$/0)!.% 5!'( + 5!//(/(# !(!8!.)#$ //("5 5!$8!'( //(#$! 5!'( 5!8%%!(#%@5#"5 5! ('.5$=!!%/0)!.;!59!4%! 5('45 5!."'8!% $/0"!.% 5! (!"(.%./(#8"#!=!0#!9! 5 5!. !8((#4!#% 5!/(!$!% "$!+ $ /!( 5! #%9# #% "(. %. 5! 8((#4! "!( ##" ! #$ '4'$ ,+ > @5!(!$ 5!.#9("!/! # #%@$.8# !.0)#0!.'%.!(-!" #%> 5!

" % -!/ !8=!( C+ > #! @# 5#% , .)$ 5! 8((#4! 5! "#("'8$ %"!$#%@5#"5 5!8((#4!5.=!!%/!((8!.#!'%.!(/(!$$'(! (/! "$! =! (!4#$ !(!. 4#%$ 5! (!$/%.!% % 5! =$#$ "8/0#% %%!F'(!0$(!#%.#" #9! 5!"#("'8$ %"! 5 ('. 5$ /(#8 "#! =!!% "88# !. % 5! //!00% ( !F (%!'$ "%$#.!( #%-5!"0#8$5!($!0% %0) =!9#" #8(/!=' 0$ 9#" #8('.@5#"5(!D'#(!$ =!0B!.#% =) 5!$8!'( -($ 5!#0#%4//0#" #%((!"00#%4 5!(.!(. !. /(#0 <+ #$ "%"!(%!.+ @! (! 5! "%$#.!(!. /#%#% 5 $ /!( :'.48!

!""#$% &+ > G+.!"#.!.%'4'$ +G+ 5!//0#" #%((!"00#%4 5!(.!( . !/(#0<+% 5!=$#$('."88# !.% 5!'( 5$ =! "%$#.!(!. %. .!"#.!. =) 5! $8! '( % 5! =9! $#. :'.48!% (!0#%"!5$=!!%/0"!.% 5!:'.48!% 5!-'/(!8!'( #% !

' ( ) * +"& , ! - ./ 0!+ **C - <*+ @5!(!#%# @$5!0.$00@$&

5!=9!$#./(#%"#/0!5$=!!%00@!.#% & +1 2

3%&# 4 $ %&+ > > <+ $ @! 59! ((#9!. "%"0'$#% 5 /(#8"#!('.5$=!!%/0)!.'/% 5!//!00% @#! !(5!(#%4"'%$!0(= 5 5!/( #!$+@!(! 5!/#%#% 5 5! //0#" #% ( (!"00#%4 5! (.!( . !. /(#0 <+ 5$ =!!% @(%40)% !% !( #%!.=) 5! 5!%..# #%0#$ (#" '.4!+'(.$/'( 5! //!0 #$ 00@!. 5! //!00% @#! #$ .#(!" !. //("5 5!$'""!$$('( E#$ (#" '.4!+'(.$/'(@# 5#%/!(#. %!8% 5 $!!B 5!$! #%4$#.!(.!(. !./(#0<+ ( #!$(! .#(!" !. //!( =!(! 5! 0@!( '( % !=('() G+ , ( "%$#.!(#%4 5!/0!('.%.($! #%4$#.! 5!.!"(!! !(5!(#%4

5 = 5 5!/( #!$%.4#9#%4 5!8#(//( '%# ) #0!(!/0)%./(.'"! !9#.!%"!5!0@!('( E$'""!$$('( $500/$$(!$5$/!B#%4(.!( 5!/!( #%:'.48!% %..!"(!!. !.<@#00(!8#%$ )!. (00#% !% $%./'(/$!$@# 5' /(!:'.#"! 5!(#45 $ 5!//!00% 9#0%) 5!(0!40(!8!.)#% 5!"/"# )$@#!'(/(!! -#%45 #$ % ' /0"! =$!(9! 5 $ 5! (.!( 5$ =!!% /$$!.#%/(!$!%"!"'%$!0( 5!/( #!$+$# #$.!!8!. 5 = 5 5! /( #!$59!% #"!(//!(%"!=!(! 5!'( % !=('()G+, /) 5! (.!( =! /' ( 5 .#$/ "5!. 5! '( "%"!(%!.

- %'()*+,

3 -77 $%:) ;5! 5!($/!B#%4E(!$%!.& !$E ;5! 5!((!/( =0!& !$E