High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7514/2016dismissed

Rohtash v. Ansuiya & ANR

2018-01-19Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri7 pages

!"!#$ #% &'()*

"+ ,--..

/" #"%!'

# +& , 1$ 231 4114 231 4

/ 433 55

&"# $ 1& &0%6 # 7)07

& 1&"+8 #! %&)07

&&"-#0# 55 %"9 #0 + " -&&&0 +!" -- + ;%0:6# 0 & 0

9& ) - ""0 9' !"

%0:)

6!.' %& 4#!-

0!"6!""!#:+!"- !#%#0&4 !#< +!#0%1 : &"+& = + 2)&0!"".% !#6 :9'0 &0!7& # :&%#0

+!"8!&"-#0#

0+!68!

+ &%.

#0+

."0"& 0+!6"!0" +!")++ 0.7..0

!#"

+ 0 !..! !

!#" 8!

+ +& 9& +&5!#5.

8 >;!;

? #0 .7.0

!#" &' + !# +!" - !# & 0!7& +

7&&0

6 : 9 8# + - !" +

@# -.

# * ((( +!.08 "9&#% +80. @+ #0% &"-#0# 8 #&6 .&<A0 '" &6 :9% +& &"+!#0%.:0!#B% &&.!#: 8!

+ #0+!" 6!.'669&"# +-&

"+0!0# "

' !# + ;!# 6!.' #0 &%"0 0;%"

+ + 6!.' 669&" !;

&"-#0# #+ 0"

0 6!#:

++%" 4+6

!#"

+!" +

& 8 " # :0 #0 + + 0 !..! !

!#" 8!

+ +!" + 9+!) 6.')D 6.

4+ #"!"

.'!#"%.

#0+%6!.!

0&B%"

0&"-#0# &"

!#+!6".&6 6!#: +!"+%"9% +0!0# :& ..:0!# +- !#

+ 0. +6

&!6#!

.+68!

+% + #"# #0@#8.0:

# +!" # - # + '

8 " #7#0 8 ""

8!.."

'8!

+&"-#0# !#.+! ""% ++ @ &#

+%"!#.+! #0"

0.!7!#: +8!

+&"-#0# "

0 7!"!

!#: + &# 0 +%"

+!" 9 @ #0 "+ !#0%.:0 !# &B%# B% &&."8!

+ # +!#"

!#&"-#0# +6 +& .#:8!

++!"9& +&+ 07!"!

++%"

!#.+! #0+!6 +&+ 09"&70&"-#0# #0!# 9;

!# 9.-"!

!#8+# 8 "#+!"0% ' .""#9' +6 +& 6#0!#: +!&8 &!#: . +" !# ++%"+&8 "C + #:+ 8&0"9 8# &"-#0# ""% +&"-#0# 0. ++%" #0.0:0

"!# +E6#..).+!+ 8 +&

#09' +9& +& &"-#0# 8++ .":!7#9

!#:"

E6#..+ 0. +&# 0+%" #0"

0.!7!#:

+!" -.

"&7! #0 &"-#0# ." . + &# 0 +%" 8!

+% -&6!""!# #4- 69&()<)&"-#0# .#:8!

++&9& +&+ 0 6 +6

&!6#!

.+6

/!..

: D+8& #0:

!#:" 8!

+% #' %"+ 0&:!"

&0 &"" "

.! 4

!#)

! .":

&:!"

&0 "%#0&4 !#" )(*)<<& 08!

+4 !#<

.! 4

!# 4%.

#-%&!) .+! #0 +!" 6!.' 669&" ."!.0-& 0!#:"%#0& &

!#E6#&6 6"

! /!.# ))!# +%&

+!#!).+!+ ."

+!" &-%

!# #0 0!:#!

' !# + " !

#0 &"-#0# 8!

+0& 8#+&".&6 +" !

' 8!

+% #'"%! !#

# + .

7&&0

+!6". !" &"-#"!9. & %"!#: 6#

-+'"!

. &%.

+&&:

&0!#:8+! +"++ 0!.0 &!6!# . 6-.

#0 +!" 6!.' 669&" + 0!7& - !# 8

..:0.' + %# &59.

+ &!6!# " 4+ 0#!0 ..

!#"&:

&0!#:+&9+ 7!%& #0+ 7&&0

"!# +!# - !# +6 : #0+!" 6!.'669&"%"0 + ""+&& 9&!#:!#:.""08&'4+0#!0

!#&"-#0# + 7!#: 7& 7!"!

+ +%" 4+ 7&&0

"+ 8 " 0&!7# %

&!6#!

. +6 9' #0 8 " 6-..0 .!7 8!

+ +& - &# "+6 +& 0.0:0 ." " +&!# 8+! + "+ + " 9# B%!

0 &6 + %& 1"

"+ 4+ &6

+#1)4#!-

+6 +& ."!.0 -&!7

6-.

!# 8+! +8 ."0!"6!""0 0!.0 &!6!#

" #0 +!" 6!.' 669&" &:

&0!#: 06 #0 08&' !# + %&

.+! " %&:0 !# + 8&!

+& 08&' ! ." "

#0" 6!"

--&-&!

0 9'

#0 +!" 6!.' 669&"

"+ 8 +&8# % + 6

&!6#!

+69' 8++ "8!

+0& 8#+!6".&6

+" !

'&"-#0#

"+!""

!..8!..!#: #0& 0' ;!#

+ 6- #' +

!#" &'8!

+&"-#0# 8& # 0 + -.

0!#:" + - !") + ..8!#: !""%" 8& & 60$5 E+ +& &"-#0#

+ - !#& 8!

+ &%.

')!" 8+

E+ +&&"-#0# "0"& +- !#&)!" 8+

< E+ +& &"-#0# !" .!7!#: !# &' 8!

+ &"-#0# )!" 8+

.! .. + !""%" 8& 0 !00 #

--& !

!#7!0# -&0% 09'9 + +- !"+.8&%& #"!0&0 + "

E 8+ + " &!

7&6# "!# +- !#!# +"+ - !0 7!

C EA-&0% 0 +!" 6 +& E 8+ #0&0 +& 7!0# !# + "+ - !0 7!

C EA!#

6- "

9.!"+

!#" &%.

C 6!#0

;D%6 & E)+&9& +&4+!7D%6 &

E #0"+ -- &0+&". E< #0-&0% 00 %6# "C

5 !"# % -.

9"&7+&

6- 8 "6 & 9&!#:!#: 9% & # !.!

!# 9' "#0!#: + - !" + 60!

!# # +&

6- 8 "6 09' +%& 9' ..!#: +- !"!# +%& !#

&0& -&"% +6 !

+& "

+& & - 6- #' # "6

&6" & +!& - %. .!7!#: 9% !#"!"

0 & 0 & 0!7& .

!6!#:

8 " !6-""!9. & +!6 "

' 8!

+ &"-#0# %#".& 07+6# .'%&:0

+ 0!#0%.:0!#

&'8!

+&"-#0# )+&"!"

&2" +%"9 #0 4+ 8 " %#0 !#0%.:!#: !# + !66&

" 8!

+ &"-#0# 9' E) +6 +& %#".+ " # #00

9.!"+09'+!""

C EA

+!"6 +&)0%&!#:

+!& "

' !# + +%" !# /!..

: D+8& ) + 0 %#0 &"-#0# !# 9;

!# 9. -"!

!# 8!

+ &"-#0# 8+!. 8 " # 0% '+6 +& 5 &68

!+ ."6

6- -&7

"++ 0+ &0"67! 6!#:!#"!0&6 +&6 8+#"+@# @0 #0-%"+0 +0&"+"

8&"-#0# " #0!# 9;

!# 9. -"!

!# + "

!0 7!0# !" 9".% .' # &' -.

0!#:" 8+&!# !

+ " 9# 7&&0

+ "

!0 !# !0# + 0 9#

+0!#.+!9' +6 +& # %# 7 :% !#0!#!

&')&"-#0# ## 9+.0 9!#0%.:!#: !# "% +

!# 9"# !" 7&' "' .7.

!#" &'9% "%9"

!#" +&+ 9 "# 9. #0 :# 7!0# -&0% 0 +%:+ 0!& 7!0# -&"# + 7!#: "#

&' !" # &B%!&0 9% + 6!#!6%6 &B%!&6#

+0 ')0

!6"+%.0 6# +& &0"

+ -&"# 8+ !" ..:0 + 7 !#0%.:0 !# &' %.0 + 7 "# 9.--& %#!

0#0 #0C-.

!# +"

6+ &!

.%&

&!:+ .' 0!"9.!70 + "

&"-#0# !#0%.:0!#

" &' -- &" 9 6!":%!00"%"-! !#

!#""6 9-&;%0! 0 6!#0

7&&0!# --.!

+0!0# &.!"+ +7!"!

&"-#0# %#".& " # #00

+&:!"

&%.

+!6 #0 +!" 6!.' 669&" !"

8+! + +

..' 0!"

%&90 + ."

!#" 06 #0 08&'8%.0 #"

% 6#

. &%.

' 4!# + &!6!# " !" "

!.. -#0!#:) !

8!.. # 9

--&-&!

C-&"" #'-!#!##6&!

" "# " +8!

!." +.:

.&60'+ 7!#:9#0 .

+ &%.

')"++ 0: "

% &' &60!" !.

9. +& 9' --& +!#: + %& %#0& + + E6#..+ "9# #"

% 0&-&7# !#: + &!6 86#& !.!#: 6-.

!# 1&.' 8! + 7!#: .0:0 &!6!# " +%"9 #0 +!" 6!.' 669&" !

". 8%.0 # #"

&%.

'+ +&

!#" &%.

'+ 7# 9#"%9"

09' #' 7!0# & &&9&

!77!0# +.8&%& "&!:+ .'& %&#0 !#0!#: &:

&0!#:

" &%.

' + 7!#: # 9# "

9.!"+0 +

!#" 0"& !# & 7 :% !# + -.

0!#:" # &0& "

9.!"+ 0"& !#) !

!" "!# B% ##

+ !# !# 0"& #0

%6 0"& !# & -&!0 '

&" 8!

+% #' & "# 9. %" + 9

9.!"+0 E + 7 ." #"!0&0 + # !# %#". &

+ 6 : + " 9&@# 08# +& & # + # "

&%#!# ""% +0!7& "+%.09:& 0# +!" # #- !#8 :!7# !+ %.0 0B%

.' 6-#"

+&"-#0# "+ 6!:+ +!#@- !#: 6- #'9% 0C-&""0+!"!# 9!.!

- #'.%6-"%66 !# # ""% + +0 &0!7& ## 9 :& 07#!!

!"-&"%60

+6 :+ "9&@#08## %# "-

!# +- !""!0 +!") -&%"

. +7!0# -&0% 0 9'&"-#0# !"&.

%0 "+ #0+!" 6!.' 669&" + ." .0:0 6-.

!# &"-#0#

6- -&7

"+ + 0 9# 8&#: + #

%# +!" #0% + 7!#:!.0 6-.

!# +&"-#0#

+&%:++!"6 +&!#

6- + ""+&!"!#0!

!7+!"#:

--& +&8+! ++ ## 9:& 00 &0!7& # %# +!" 8#8&#:"

6- ""6 + 79#6 09'+!6

#'66#

&B%!& +&"-#0# & %&# #0.!7 6!

9.'8!

++&&%#0 0!7& "-.

00+ 7!#:# 9#-&70)80# !#0 #':&%#0 "!0 + ;%0:6# + .8& %& 0!"6!""!#: + - !# %#0& !#< + # +:&%#0 &%.

#00"& !# !"6!""0 >114? #% &'()* >

/ 433? "

E+ +&"- @!#:A& "#0$ "A E+ +&&-&

9.$ "A