High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/243/2014allowed

Inderjit Kaur v. Charanjit Singh

2017-08-17Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh,Mr. Justice Krishna Murari8 pages

!"#$ % &'

)"#*+* ' %, % "!

-)'.&* /00 3&&"-)'4)"+3 /

"' # 56 44 56 4 4 4

"'# 4&)"

,! (&'

'3 11&"' 4&"",! (&'

"' 7)

! '3) ) ' &00 &1 *"!

4 (')" $ '3 )"!*&)&+ ('(3&11 "+)"+'3 -*!+8 "'!&'

!0)1$, 0&

9: '3 !!)')"&1 ) ')(' *!+ , 44 &+&, 3&1) !) 8)

)"+ 3 &001)(&')"*"!

'3 )"!*&)&+ (', 3';'3 ('5 !)

1*')"3 8&)&+ <)'3

"'3&&"-)'4)"+3 11&"'<& 8&) !''3

"'"&:=, >>$ &' 44 &+&, 3&1) *' 8&)&+ , '< (3)1!

", .)&"-' .&* ?!&*+3'

@ &"! & <)"!

4)"+3 ?

"@ <

9" " &(3 , >>> &"!

=, ,

(') 1: " 3 ')')" (1&)8 ! '3&' 3 0& "'

3&!+) "'!<:9*''3

"' '&'

!8) 3& )"+, )"

*1')"+&"!'&*"')"+'3 11&"'&''3 )"

')+&')"3) &8)1:8

&"! '&'

!9 &')"+3 43 01 &!

!'3&''3

"' '&'

!'&A)"+ 1)B*&"! '00 !<A)"+73 *

!'9- (',3 <*1!+)

&')"+ 00 11&"'1

!&11 '3&'3 8&"!

!& *8

1&( "3 * )"+'91)+ '*"

!*''3 8&')8")&1 38 )"4 0'

)!)"+

1:)"3 0& "'

11 * )"+ )1'3: &"! )"

*1')"+ 1&"+*&+ 9: '3 &8)1:

"'3& &1 9

"&)

"'("'

')')"&11 +)"+'3&''3 3&! "' !) (1

! 3 8&)'&1 '&'* )"+ & !) (

&' '3 ')8 3 8&)&+

"' 01 &!

! '3&' )' 9 )"+ '3

("! 8&)&+ '3 &00 11&"')'<& & )801 &&)

"'(1&)8 !'3&'3 3&!+ &'1 &"! & (')" '3 11&"' 3 &11 8) 3& )* <

") ! &'3 )' <& (1&)8 ! '3&' 9 3& )* '3 11&"' '<&!

8'3 '3

"' <& "' *0 ' '3 8&A 01 &!

! '3&' '3 &00 11&"'3&!0 "1:!

(1& !'3&' 3&!"1)A)"+'3

"'&"! 3) 1&')"

01 &!

!'3&''3 11&"') &1&!:1*C*)* 3&9)'

43 <"

& 30 )" 4*"": "(1& , 8&)"'&)"

! & (& &"! ('

43 &"

"'&1)"(8 &"!) &!:'1) <)'3'3

"'&"!'3 " ' <& (1&)8 ! '3&' *

! ' 0)(A *0 B*& 1 " 0 '': 8&''

&"! "

+1 ('

! 3 9&"! &"! 8)" (3)1!

" 3 &11 !

8&"!

1&( <

") ! ' <& !

") ! '3&'

3*"'

!*''3 8&')8")&138 3

"'01 &!

!'3&'3 3&!

"'8"

:'*1)11 &(3&"!

<) 9*' <&"'

"-: 1) &1"

9: '&:)"+ &<&: 8 '3

"' 3 9&"! 3&! )1 ! &" &001)(&')"*"!

4 (')" > '3 ('

')'*')" ("-*+&1 )+3'

'<& + !'3&'

1&<"+! *(3

"')'1 ! ' + ' '3 1) !) ( &

! '3&' & -)"' 0 ')')" *"!

4 '3 (' 3&! 9

" )1 ! 9*' 1&'

" 8&!

"''3&' !)!"'<&"''0(

!<)'3'3 &)!0 ')')" "01 &!)"+ 0&')

,11<)"+)

&8 !#

@ '3

"''

')')"

<)'3 (* 1':D

@ '3 '3 ')')" ) "' 8&)"'&)"&91 )" '3

"'8D

1) E

()!

!&+&)"

''3 11&"''<& 1!'3&' '3 11&"'<& "!*9' &1) 8&) !<)'3"

&1-)'4)"+3,&" &"!

3&!9'&)"

!!) ( 83)89*''3) &('3& )"+9

"("( &1 !,)'

1 ('

!&!

1: ("!*(''3 11&"'3 &)!&('<& '&A "9:'3 ')&1*'& &()(*8 )80 &(3)"+3 ( !)9)1)':43 3&!&1 "'!) (1

!'3&' &1) &0 ')')"*"!

'3 (' 3&! 9

" )1 ! 9: 3 43 +*)1': ("( &18 "' '3 &('

"'9 )"+&!*"A&!8&"&"!<& <)'3*' <A, '3 *' 9 1< 3&! !&<" & 0

*80')" '3&' & '3 &00 11&"'3&!3

10&'

!<&:&"!!)!"'9'3 ''&A (& 3 8)" "&"!&9&"!"

!3 ",&0

*80')"(*1!9 !&<"'3&'3&!

"&!*"A&!0

",'3 8)"A)!

<*1!"'3&

'&:)"+<)'3

3)8

+&!)"+3) )!1 "

,'3 *'9 1<"&00 ()&')" 1! '3&' 3 "' <)'3*' <A 3 11&"' 3&! &)1 ! ' 0!*(

"' '3&''3

"'<& "'!)"+&":<A&"!<& )" & (&0&()': ' &" 3) 1) 1)3! 3 1< *' &1 9 1)

! '3

"' .)&"-' .&* <3 3&! ! '3&' & '*!

"' '3 (1&

&"!3 8'3 3&!"1 3 &"!3 9'3 &"!'3&''3 "<&"'

8'3 '1) <)'3'3 83 ()(*8 3* 9&"! 3& )"+)1 !&"&001)(&')"*"!

(')">'3 (','3*+3<)'3!&<"'3

&8 ,<& &1 ("

!&"!'3 &)!()(*8 "''

!&!

''3

3& )"+"'9

!,)'<& ()!

!&+&)"

''3 3* 9&"!3 &001)(&')"!

(

!) ( )1 !9:'3 11&"'"'3 +*"!(* 1':<& '3* !) 8)

! 7)'3 '3 &

(*"

1 9'3 '3

, < +"

'3*+3'3 1< *' (!3 +) &"( 11&"'<) '3&'3 3* 9&"!) &!*"A&!8&"&"!) "'!)"+&":<A& *(33 '

! 3 <)'3 (* 1': 3 (&

"' ) '3&' '3

1 ) & 3)+33&"!

! 1&!: 3& )"+ &" &'')'*!

"' 1A)"+ &'

'3 8)"(3)1!

"<3& 1A !&'

9:'3

"' +"

'3*+3 '3 (! <)'3 '3 ) &

3 &'3 11&"'1&!:) '3&''3

"') &!*"A&!8&"*

!' &'3 &

*1'<3)(3 (80 !'1 8&')8")&1 38 &"!' '&:<)'33 8'3

1:'<& *"!

(80 11)"+ ()(*8

'3&' 3&!'1 9'3'3 "<)'3'3 3* 9&"!

'&00 ()&'

<3 '3

"'8&'

)&1"'3

(!'0 '3&'3* 9&"!) &!*"A&!8&",< (& *11:0

'3 01 &!)"+ 11&"'& < 11& +"

'3*+33 "'& 7, <3)(33& "'9

"("

!9:'3 1< *'3 ')&1*')"

&! &00 ()&')"+'3

"'9 )"+&!*"A&!8&" 3& !&<" 0

*80')" " '3 9& '3 ()(*8 '3&' '3 8)" "& '&:)"+<)'3'3 &'3 00 11&"'3&!)"3 C&8)"&')")" (3) , *98)''

! )" '3 3&0 &)!& )', !'3&' 3 9&"!*

! ' !)"A3 & )1:&"!&

&*1'

!3 3

8&"!!<: &1 3 &('*8 '3

"' 9 )"+ & 3&9)'*&1 !*"A&! 3&

'&91) ! "'"1: 9: '3 11&"' 9*' 9: 3 1! 8'3 9: &00 &)"+ *'') )"'

')"+'0)"'*''3&''3

*++

')"+) "9:'3 (*"

1'3

"'''3 <) F&00 '3&' '3

"' 3* 9&"! !

"' !)"A '3&' 3 "' & 3 & : !*"A&! 7)'3 '3 &

(*"

1 '3 11&"' < (& *11:+"

'3*+3'3 (

C&8)"&')"'3 <) <33& "'9

(""'

!<)'3&": *++

')"3 3* 9&"!"'9 )"+&3&9)'*&1!*"A " ! )" 3 ')')" &"! 3 "' '3&' )"+ 8&1'

!&"!&

&*1'

!9:3 3* 9&"!&"!'3&'3 &!*"A&!0

" 01)+3' & 8&1 <3 ) )"+ ''* ! 9: 3 9&"! 9 )"+ & !*"A&!(&" )1:9

*8 !8'3 &(''3&' (80 !' 8&')8")&138 3 <) <)11"'1 8&')8")&138 &1"+ <)'3 '< (3)1!

" *"1

&"! *"')1 '3

) &" "' 8 "'&1 (* 1':'3 0&&8 '

"1&)!!<")"&":-*!+8 "'& ')"

<3&'()(*8

,'3 3* 9&"!(*1!9 &)!'9 &(& *&1!)"A & !*"A&! 0

", 9*' '3 ("

3) 3&9)' !)"A)"+ <*1! 9

1 ('

!8'3 ("!*('&"!'3 8 "'&10

<3)(33&

"( 9: *(33&9)''3 3* 9&"!&!

"'9

"&(& *&1!)"A ,'3

<& " ((& )" '3 11&"' ' 1

1 &11 9 &')"+ &"! !)"A)"+

&+* +&')"'3&' 1*C*)* 3&9)'

"'& +!+*"!'9 1)

!'3&''3 &A 1*C*:&1&!:<*1!1 3* 9&"!&"!(3)1!

1:9 (&*

"(80 !'!<A &"! *

(&& & 3)(1 3 ("

:&"( ,!"'0 8)''3 *'' !&<&")"

'3&' +*)1':&": 8&')8")&1<"+<&&"')"+ !) 1) )"+3 "''3&' '&:)"+

1:& 3* 9&"!

! ' !)"A &"! 9 &' 3 ' )

''1 ! 0)"()01 1&< '3&' <3 " " B*

')") 0*''&<)'"

)"(

C&8)"&')"!*9')"+'3 '

')8":)" (3) , &8 <*1!9 1)

!'9 ( (' *(3 803&

" 1&)! 9: '3

"' '3&' 3 ) *"")"+'3 9* )"

&"!) (&0&91 &")"+9*''3 &)!&('

"))') 0 !<)11"',)"&":8&""

,0 8)''3 *''&) &'&("(1* )" '3&'3) &")"+<*1!("!"

3) ("!*('!)"A)"+3&9)'

&"!3) (* 1 ("!*('9& 3)"+G9 &')"+'3 <) '&A " )"' ("

&')" '3 &(' '3&' '3 &001)(&')" )1 ! *"!

4 (')" > '3 (' 9: '3 9&"! 3&

<)'3!&<" 9: 3)8 '3 '3

&' "

'&+ 3&! &) ! &' & )"&1 !

)"'+ ''3 8&)&+ !)

1 !*"!

'3 ('3 &11 +&')"&+&)"

''3 11&"') '3&' 3&!<)'3!&<"3 ("

"'*"!

'3 ('3 ()(*8 "

&001)(&')"*"!

'3 ('3& )"+9

")1 !9:9'3'3 0&')

&")"!)(&')"'3&'" &((*"' 8 &*1'9'3'3 0*

&":'3 0*

,'3 :3&! !

()!

!'0&'(80&":7

1'3&'&":"!)&"1&!:<*1!"'1 8&')8")&138 3 "*"1

&"!*"')1, (80 !'! *"")"+3 <" 30&"!) (&0&91 8&)"'&)")"+3

1, 3& +) "*03 (1&)8&":':0 8&)"'

"&"( 3) ()(*8 &1 1 (') C'

"''3 8 "'&1(* 1':&"!&+":,'3 11&"'3&!

* )"+ ' ) &" &!8)''

! &(' '3&' '3

)!)"+

1:'3 1& '

3 8&)&+ 9A "!<"&"!)

1:&" 80': 11& *(3'3*+39 &A!<"'3 :) "'&001)(&91 9*' '3 01"+

0&&')" <)'3 " &''

80' 3& )"+ 9

" 8&!

9: '3

"' '

*8 (3&9)'&')", C( 0' <)'3 & &( &001)(&')" *"!

(')">'3 (','3 11&"'(&"9 +&"'

!) ( "&((*"' ("!*(''3

"'3

"<"+&00 ()&')" "'3 0&''3 ')&1*'<3)(33& "'(& *11:0

("!*(''3

C&8)"&')"'3 3& &1 "'9

"(& *11: &!9:'3 ')&1*' " ) <'3 &9 ()(*8

,< ("

'&)"

!'31! '3&''3 11&"'3&

"&91 '

'&91) 3'3 (* 1':<3)(3 )"'3

"'(&

&00& "'1:&8 "'&1(* 1':9

03:

)(&1(* 1': ')')" ) &11< ! )"!)"+ '3 1< *' " )

! +*"!-*!)()&1

0&&')"&"!'3 !) (

&8 &"! '3

"' '&A " & )"&1 !

)" +&!)"+ '3 8)" ",("

)"+'3 0 ) )"

4 '3 (','3 +*"! (* 1':3& )"+9

'&91) !<

8)'&000)&'

'+&"''3 (

-*!)()&1

0&&')" ' '3

*)"+ '3 )! -*!)()&1

0&&')",)'<*1!9 0 "''3 0&')

''&A &":!

)" (* '!:'3 8)"(3)1!

"'<)11 "'&)1'3 1 +&1("

<)'3'3 1&0

')8 '3)"+ &)!)"'3) !

<)110 -*!)( )+3'

0&')

'(1&)8'3 (* '!:'3 ")"&((!&"( <)'31&< ?4@ *+* ' %, % ? 4 4@ &"-&: '3 &A)"+G "

G '3 0'&91 #