High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/248/2014allowed

Sukhwinder Kaur v. Kuldip Singh

2015-01-20Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta15 pages

!" #$ % &

'( )( '( **** #+,+!- # ./ %012 -+ #-3+ 44+55 !- ## #%012 -+ #-3+#+,4!0+!- **** %

"#$ % &'

(&% )*$" $# + ,$- $),!" -

/0 1102(&( "$# 0"302 "

-$$ # ,4''5"

0$ 6 # 024''782)*"

9:2 .:"$ $20$ 0

0"02$!$$ : $0""

9 )" " )* #$02;0$# ( $#*, $;"

2# $ "$<9

.:"$ $ : !$$ 0 $0""

" " !0"

02 !)$,(&&1 .$-$$

#,$$" , $# $- $)##0$" 0# 0!$*$ "#$!0" $$"

$0=! * (#0"!$$

$!$$ , *; 0 $ )"":2,)

"0 : )0$"0

02 $:0#.

$0$ 0$!$$ : ,:!$$ 0$!

" 0"02." 02; 0, $# $- $)" $:)0$"0

02 :0#.

" " $" 0" ( ( 444 "

#0!0" $0 ":0"

*/0" ): "

) 0#":0 " 22#02

* $"

020#, "#> ,- $) !02$!$$ :

0" 02 "

2 $ $ !0"

02 !$$ , ;) " 0$" $ !"" 0:$* $ $?$ 0 0

; >$$.$" ; !0"* 0!

;) " 0$ $ ";" $ 0.$)*# #" $2$0! "#.")* ;" $ .#.)0: , $"!0 $$ $?$ 0"! 00! 20$ "#0 "

$* $="$)$0 $:

" !$# *0$ $?$ 0 $!$$: $$ ;

)$0 $"

$!0"*:" #2$0!$":$ $?

.$" $0$ *02$2$ )"

-"*"#* :$ #0";" 0 $#0"#

)

" ;"

! *, 0"

&4 &4 (&&@, ;) " 0$"$ $"

6 $ !

220$ !)*$2 $

" ,)$0 $ $!

" ,$) "" ">00 " 0$) $$0;2

"&'

(&&@ ;) " 0$" $"#02$ 22!!)$ )$0.$$$" "0 $ "

0.$ A$ "20$! 0" 0$ 0 31 &3 &@ (&&B "$ # 0"3'3,33("B102"""/05"0$ 6 / 78: $ $ " ! 0# 0"/ *,- $ " : $*"#$ $0"" $: #$ * "0$ $20$#0"

$002!0$ "2;*$,

$*20$#$02;0$#0;" $!$$ 0"

)0 $0 " $0""

#0"

" :$

2)*!,$$!"$*0) # 0": $ $ !"

") *02 0""#0"#!"

02 "! $2# )*

::*$* 0$) "

"* !" ! $!0"0!:$$22

0# *:2 *": 0

"*$*!0$$0"

)$0 $ 02 "

, :0 $!""

02 !$#, "

" 0 !$$* $ : 0!0" !$# " 0$$ $!""

$" #0 "

$* $$0 0"20$ ;0$#:2)* 0"22$"

2# ,:#: $ : $:")*$ 2#

!$ $" 2$ !$$ 02

: $!

" ")$ 02 $0

02 :0#.: !

)* ,)

" ;$) "

0$ $0$$ $?$20$02 0 # "#"

02) " " $"#02$ 22!!)$ :"" : 2A$ "20$! 0" 0$ : $ $)* "#0 0": $#0 #, $*$20$!02 0":! % " " 02 $ , 200:" :$ 2$!<9 58 $2 $ 0!"? 0"02 !$$ , 0"$: #$ *C 5(8 $ $ 0"$20$ $002=#" :0*$!! *$0$

0"02 0"C $ 0""0 !"

")" $"

20$!C

5%8

2 '

0 ) "

$#!, 0"$=!"!"* = : " $2$ " : " )0= "

$ $ 0"0 0"02#$ *"$ 0"; "

$0""

2 $ =!" ( +$" " D 3 $!"$" D%00:"

$D'/0" )>. " D"10;$ " ,:0#0$$0)0$ $;$0"0" ! $$ # $"$0;#0*02A$ "20$! 0" 0$ 0 31 &3 &@ (&&B$ $ "$# 0"3'3E33(EB102 / "

A$ "20$! 0" 0$ 0 4( & & (&( $ $ "$

& # 0"3%E3(3E'&1E%BE%402 / = " = ($# ;*D " * $* 0$ 0 ( &B ( (&( = 3 " 0 $","0;"#50# $0$0# !"

$*8: )* "

!$0 00$

" ;)*!

/0"$" ;"# 02 0"$ " )!0"!0")202 $ ,$" $/0 #! #0"# 0" 0"$2 0$0; )" : #$ *)* 0$)"$ )*!

##0$" *, 0 "(:$# " 0"$9"

#0"F "# #0"0" , 0"

:!: #0 @ A" $; )*

" #$ % &'

(&%)* $" $/0 , .:"$ $$2$$

" "

;$ )!0"!)*-$ > :, $"#0 "$$"

" "-$ >$$,$" #0 "$$"

2# $ 0"$ .:"$ $: !$$ 00"$!

" 0"02." 02; 0, $#

$- $)" $"!*,00:"

$:)0$"0

02 $:0#.

"20$

" *,$!

" 0"( ( 444 "

#0!0" $0 ", 0"$: ;" 0)*/0" ) : "

)0#":0 " 22#02

* $"

02 0#, "# > , - $ $2 $, " !0"

7 !)$,(&&1, .:"$ $!$$ " 9$0""

, ##0$" 0# 0!$*$

& 0"02"

.:"$ $:$

2 $ $!0"

02!$$ $ ) " $"

!"0:$* $ $?$ 0 0

>$ $.$" ;!0"* 0!

0 ;) " 0$ $"

;" $ 0.$)* ;" $.#.)0:")*0" $2$0! "#.

"!0 $$ $?$ 0"!)$0")$ =")# $)$0 $:

" !$# *0" !$$* $: $ ;;" )$0 " #$!0"*, "0"!0 "

,A "$ $?$ 0!"$02$2$

)"2$0!$"

$ !" "#"

02 #$ * :$ "$$ )* 0"$9"

" $ : " 0"$ 0"

&4 &4 (&&@ ;;$) " 0$"$ $ $2 $,$2 $

" ")$0 $ $! " ##0!" )*$) "" 02>$$.$">00 " 020 ) :"

0 02$0""

; >" :"$F ! #" );0 $"!"

" 0"$"$ $,)

$2 0## $$F

0 $ "#"

#0 )* "

: 02 &'

(&&@ :" $0""

#! 0 $ 022# :$ : #$ " $022#

" #$!"20$# 0"$ )$0. $$$" "$":* $ "" 0.$"$2!*0$ 0

8 $ ." )* 0! 0 ."0:" 0 !

# )$" A$

"20$! 0" 0$ 0 31 &3 &@ (&&B "$# 0"3'3E33(E31 02 / :$ $ 0# 0"/ *,- $,"$# 02 "#"

:0$ 0" :";$#! 0$ 022#0"#00 $,$ )":0 :**$)* 0" #$"

2$0"

02$#00 $ ( ( +$" " , $ ) "# 0$, )" "

*: "02 "#"

00.#0"&'

(&&@ 0$ ;$0"02

"$"#

$ 022#02 "0" $2$0! $, 00.

#0 *$ ") $" $ " .$"$ $ 5(8,)" 0"

*,"

$;""

3 $#2#"#"

:#0)*%00:"

$, $02 0"$ 0 " !0$"" 0"

(& &1 (&&@ ;) " 0$"$!0 $" $

0.$)*$" $"#.

$!0 $$$!$" :#

$ " )0 $ $!"$ " #! " $# ! 2$0! #

#02

$!"$" $3"2 * #0$$0)0$ ;$0"02%00:"

!$*,10;$ " ,":02 ,

2)0

$0# "2# )* 0" "

" $"# %

"# )0;,"0;"#:0$ " "!:)*

0$)

E#0"

$0;$ 0 0"02 0"$"$ : " '

$" #0 " 20$ "

$ "# ;"#02 $!" "#" " "!#, : 22#"

0$0; )" : #$ *)* "0)"$ )*!20$ )0

*$ "#(&&@ :!"

0")*$" $#0 "$(02

! "

$0""

; "

!$0 00$

" 0$0 # ;"#,)

;" !2 2 $" : ")0= $;"#:#0)*#0 0$$ &3 & (&3, "!0;"# 0"20$" ;"# :# : 0: )

" $$ !2 "0$ #"*;"# 1 " 0 $",$"#0 "20$ $ : ;!"# !*0$!*"0 ;;"#, )

$00 0"02: 0"$#" ##0"*0"

02$0:"#"#""0 )0: .;"

02 :."" #02

$"#0 "#0"

0"02 0"$:$ "$""

$ 0 #"#"

#0 )#0)*$:##0 ) "# 02G#$ *G

0:$ 0"$ $, $"

2$0!$0:";"#

$ #0"

# 0:$ $0""

)" $ " $ !

$0""

: $" " $ $"

>" :,:$;: !20$%9'*0"*" $2 $,

9 $ $" $- $) 0!

#0";""#* "; "0 0; $0

$- $) $ 2$0! , 0 #$!"#)$" A$

"20$! 0" 0$ 0 31 &3 &@ (&&B "$# 0"3'3E33(EB1 02 / ,$ $ " ,:#2 $ $,$ "

02 $0""

% 00:"

$, $ 02 "

0; $#00 0

9#$- " " $ $ "

022# ,)*"0 $ #02! " 0", #") ! );0 02 0:$ :#$ :#$0! $ 2 0"20$#$02;0$# @ $ !"

02$"#0 "20$ !* $ 0)

$# ;)

$#0! *;002!$

$" $0 0","0 0"*"$$ $ 02 0"*" $0# 0 2# " 02 $0""

, )

0 =" $0"20$#";$*2#

!E#$# ! "#

0$ )* $" #$09=!" 0"

*, 0"$ 2 $!$$ ; : >" :0"*20$&E'*,)

" ;$*"= )$ , $2 $, $ $" " 0 02$2$ )" $- $): #0""

*,:;" $- $))# :0 $" 22#02

* $"

020# 0 0 ) , !

2 $ * $ ;"

$ *,#0";""#* "; "0 ; 0 :$:$" $- . $),)

;0 "

$ 0 0)# )"

;" $) " ":$" " 0 02$2$ )"

4 %00:"

$0 "$!0 $ )" 0" 0 >" :, " ;; 02 0"

$*" "* =" !0 $02

$!0 $ 0$" >" :,)

*:$ ")

02 ; )# $!0 $:!0*" "

) 0# " :

*" - $ 0 2 $ !$$ $ $" " $"0!02$ !0 $

"/.>$$.$"$ $?$!0 $

$"2$ 0 ""! 00 $!0 $. " $"#02 "#* "0 0; $0 )# )"F $$" : $ (& 00 ) , #$!"#)$" A$ "20$! 0" 0$

0 31 &3 &@ (&&B "$# 0"3'3E33(EB102 / 0# 0"/ *,- $,$ $ " "#02 ,$ " #F

02 $0""

, )

#0!" ;"# "

2" "

02#F

:#: ""

"!0 "

0#0"

0"02 #" #""0 $;"*)"2 2$0!

02#F

$:0, *$ #.02$00202#$ "#$!"# !

# $ " "$02$002$F $20$$0;" 2#

#;!

$ ( (+$"" , $ )"# 0$,:0"

*" 022#02 "#> - $0"&'

(&&@ :" $$

"0$:"$#0"

$0" 22,$ $,:"0$ 022# 0$ " ;$0" 02 "

0 0"

(&&@ ( && - #!"

$022#" "

#$!"20$#0" ,:0:#$ " $022#

, 00.$"

#0 *$ "$"# ") " $ " 0.$"$ $ ((

$" #$09=!" 0" 02 ( +$" " , "0 "

##0 )$;)* :##0 # ;"

) 0"#$) * 22$! !"

$ $" "#"

:$#0$)* 0# $"0 " 0"# : ""*#0$ 0

: 0$ $:"* $0"20$! 0)0 "

"# 0## $$"# ."#" 022#02 0"* 022#$"

*#0 ) : " (3 !$*,3 $!"$" :"0 $# *$

: ": 02 "

)$0 $00 ##0$" 0!,0 "; /.>$$.$

"2$0"

02 0 02 " #$ " )0 2 $ 2 2 $ !$$ 02 $ $ ;" : "$0 "; /.

>$$.$"2 $0! ! $ ) " "$

$0"##0 "

02!"20$0:$*"$ $?$ . $" $0$ *02$# )""0 002 0 /.>$$.$" ;!0"* 0!

:2 $ )*3

0"(& &1 (&&@ ;;$) "

"$ $ $" 0

,$ $0 ":"

$# :0" 00:"

$2$0!$"#."

:$" !)

$# $ 2 $ 0"

&4 &4 (&&@0 ) " "$ $ "$"#"; !

(% $*)"0)$; )0; % 00:"

$,"$$ " "#"

02(& &1 (&&@, :" $0

$ "#., : $# )* $ " )0 $!"$" !"

023 $!"$" #""0 ) )$ !$*20$ $0" :" )0 $0$$ ;02

")$0 $00 :"

$: ")" " )0 ""0$0" 02* 0$

!$*, 1 0;$ " : $ ; 02 "

"$0"."0: )0

);0 $"#0"

# 02

0:$

#" 0 "0 ) "0$#*:""0;"##0 ))* $)

! ('

'/0" )>. $" ," 0" A$

"20$! 0" 0$ = $ $ " $0""

0" #0!"

02 ,$0;"0 $A$ "20$! 0" 0$ = (

6 )$" 0 4( & & (&( $ $ "$ # 0" 3%E3(3E'&1E%BE%4 02 / 0 :# )F "

* 022"# "$ # 0" 3'%E' 02 / : # : $ $ " 0" !"

020"$$ " 0"02

;

00 ) , A$ "20$! 0" 0$ = ( A$ "20$! 0" 0$ = ( #0 "0 ) $# * $ 0 ! $!0"

) :" "

" $0""

)

#$ "*$2# 0" #0"

# 02

"*?" =$0"G#$ *G $0 "02;0$#

"$ # , 0"G) =/0 "

"$<9 6"$

# $

%%%%%% %%%%%% &' ( ) '*#'$# $

. / (@ ;"# )* "

, # )0;,

"0 ) *$0; : *02 " $:

!0 #$ * "0 0"**#* $"$ $)

0 ;$!"

")* $ "" $"$ $?" $ 02 2 !" #0 "0 ;" #0! 20$:$ 0 $2

0")*!." 2$;" !"

0"0

*, 2"" 02$" $#0 0" 0

& "($ " 0"$0" $0 "02 ;" )" : #$ * )* $0""

0"02$!$$ : )*#$02;0$#

##0$" *,

" #$ % &'

(&% )*$" $#0 , " "

0:"

!$$ 02"

: 0;)*#$02 ;0$# : )(;

!" #$ % &

#$ %