Suresh Jain & ANR v. Union Of India
!"#$ "%&'&#()
*
)+ , - .
"
# "
# $ "
%& ''''' . / , (
" )
"
*+,*-./ 01 2 1 $(
) "
)
3 &%4*5-4*-.6 01 2 " " $ "
01 " 4 0
$ * " " 1 "
2 " $ $"
"
$
% ""
) " 7 ! 2 2
) 88
$3
!01
$7 3 !1 1
2 !
) !
1
( "#
0 ( $7 2 )
1
*--5*-.6
"
)010
)$ 9: $7 2 1
(2 !1
;
" $<.4/%,
1
#=#
""
1
$
)
!
$
= 2 "
4
$$
74>2 "
"
? "
)"
!
0 ) $ "
"
) (
" ""
) " 2 " 2
"
.*6"* 2 1" .5@5
0 A "A
"
"
.*,% "12 0 1"
$
6 ( 2 1 "
" $01
)2
$
) "
"
$
"
.*6"*
"
.*,% "
2
) (
" "
2 1
0 (
1 0
2 1 "#
= " ! 01 2
0
" $
0 ! $ 10 1 2 1
) " 2 1
B 1
)
$ "
)
/ 2 $ 2 1 1
"C 2 " ! ) $
2 $
2 2 "
!
"2
$)
? 1 , 2 0
$
! C
? 1 2 0 )
$
$
2 $ 2 )01 2 1"
2 1 $
0 ! < & 0
) ( $
% . ; 2
) $
D
* ; "" " $2 " 2
"
.*6"* 2 1"D 6 ; ) , 0 " : $
;%. 2 E " 2
) 88
$3
! 3
$0 "#("
)
02 3
" $ $ 3
$
""
) E2 !
) !
( & 1 $9:
""
2
" $<.4/%,
1 E
" %: $
02
) 1 "
) 1 2 1 $
1
2 ) ! 01 $ "
""
2
#
2 ) 2 (2 !
$7 3
/ ((
" " 1
)
(2 $7 0 2
!
) (
" 1 2
"
1" 2 "2
!
)
1
> 0
$9:
" ) ( "
!0
((
"C
) 1)) ) " 0
!0 "
$ :
1
1
!
= $
) 0 017 +
"$ " ( 0
0
"
!
$9:(
0" = 10 #
2
(
$9:
!"
) ( ( 2
)
"
3 . )
@ 3 * 0 "
)
" 4
)
12 1
)2
"#3 . $<.4/%,
1
= 2
)) 2 ""
( "
)
"
C
? 1 0 2 !01 1
) ) " 5
0 "#)
" $ : !
! "
" 8 "
(
!)
>
$ 0!
$ 0 )2 "
$ 01
1
"
1 2
0
#
(2"
$0 "# "#0 ) )
= )) 2 ""
"
) 2 1 !$ 1 ) 2 0
1
11
02 "#
$
( 0
$ 10 ""
0 $"
"
$2
$
F 2
G
$
"
.*6"* " .- 2!
! "
"
0$
0
% >
$ $
1 ( 10
$0 )"
$ :
1
1; 2
$
0
?
)
$$1 "
)
0 )
"
# "
? ( "$ ) !
"
) "
0 " "#2 "
! $ ""
( )
"
) 0 0
0 "# "#0 )2 "
$ "
1 $2 "
)9 )
"
1
0
# 2 0
A
1
( "#A!
$7
$1 "
2
""
% "
)
"
("
0
0"
(
H
02 2 " (
0 ) 2 12
) )2 " 02
3 (
" 2
"
!
$
2 0 : $
;%. 0
01(
" $9:
= 10 #
2
(
"
!01 $9:E 2!
"
2
2
( $ "
0 B %0
"
02 ( 2 0 : $
;%. " 1
1 "
)
2 " 2
) 2
02 3
( $ $ 01
3
$ ( $ 10
) 1 ! 2
" )
$ ) ! "
)
3 (
" : $
01 2 1 "
0!1
"
)"
")
..
)
# 01 2 1
!
)0
1
02 "# 2
1
$
"
2 !
$
)
0
1 ") 01
0
)2
)
"(2 0 1 "
)02 "# E 2! $ $ 2 " !
0
0
1 2 1
"#2 "2 = " $
2 "2
1
" ) $9:( """ $0 0$
0 2 1 0 $ !
" $9:2 1
$ "#02
2 "
12 "
( 2 )
?
2
2 "
"
0 2
) $ "#2 " = = " $ 0 2 )
"# "
"# = " $
0 D(
2
2 $
$ "# $2 "
12 "
E
0 "
2 " $ 2 !0
2! 2
0 1
"# 2 0 0 ) 1
$
$ )0 : "#
1$ ) ! 0
1
02 "# 2 " $ "
0 " 1 !!
"
) ! 1
$
"
$9: 2
) $ $ "#
2 "
12
1
) $0 )$ 0
1"
0
02 "#
""
$
)
0 "" 0
?
0
)" 2 1 0 " $0
) $" $
2 1
B 1 " 2 1 "#
" " " $
$ "
)
?
0212 1
) "
$
2 1
2 2
) 7
2 "
"
!
$ 2 1 $D"
1 2 "
1!
"
$ "
) 2 1 "#D
"
..6 2 1" $ $
2 1
$ " ""
$ 0 2 1 ""
2 "$
#"
"
$
)"
$ 1
? 1"
0 ; 1 2 19
C !
$
2 1
0 !01 $
)
D 2 0
) !0" 1
)
1!
" : (
1
)2 "
$ ) ! $ ) 7 ( $
)
11
"#3 . $<.4/%,
1 3 2 19
C !
$
2 1 ""
"
$0 )$ 0=" .* (
=
))
)
$ "
)
2 0!
$ $ $ 2
?
= :
#2 0 #
)0
12 "
2 ""
10" 01
0 0 "E 2!
!01
2 0! "
=
0
1 2 0"
"
)
$ " 2 $
)
0 " "
= 0!1
" $ ""
2 !1
)
"
3 * "
01 (
) 2
!
1 2
"
.*6"* 2 1" .5@5 0
.6 > $$ !
0
"
!
= " 2 %"
"
)"
"$ "($ 2 " 0 01 " "
0
# 0 (
"
1") " 2 01" ) 1
"
)
02 3
(;%.
" $
0
$ $
$ $ 3 2 1
12 !
C
) $9: 2 1
3 2( "
1 ) $
01C ! !
0
"
2 " 2
3 ..-+@$9:2 )
)
""
0 @6,
$
) ., 0 ! )! )
!0 01 2 1 0
" 0 ! 0 1 !
"
C A
? 1
$
$
)2 !
) 0$ 1)
$
)!
" $
)
0 " 1
) " "
0 "" !
2
"
"$ "
"
* $1"
!
2 0 2 & ""
)1 $) "
*+-,*-./ 01 2 1 $(
) "
) 01?
2
)
!
" $ ""
$
" $2
$
2
)
"
.*6"* " 0 " ) 1 $
$ "
.*,% "
"
" " 2 1 ""
2
$
.55-
" %. 8 2 1 0$ "
$
$ 0 ,-- #
10" ""
1 *-.62 " 2 $
1 $ "
$
2 $,-- # @-- #
" $ 1 *-.+( $0 )$ 0
1 0="
$" E
A0$
F(&#(#$(1& .'&( "2&3
- 0
) 0 )
" $
$ "
$
0)
! 2
" 0
""
$ ) $
!
0
""
)2
2 01( "
2 (
$ " "
$
0
) 2
$ "
$1!
2 2
0!
! .< 1 2 ,-- # 2
)2 5I
$
""
$ 2 0 @-- # $
$
$
"
2 2"
$
$ @-- #
)2
J5I
$ 02 0" " $
= )$
1$ "
$
$ ( 2 0 .
* $
; #
)4
K ; 0 K