← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8214/2018allowed

Adesh University And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2022-04-18Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil12 pages



      

 !"#$## &!# '&#$ !   

 

(((   )

      ((( ) ) &# *+'&#$ +      (((   )

      ((( ) )  ,

 -., ( )  ) ,)  -., ( )) , .



   !"# $%&'# (" ' !" ))# $%&'# *%"+%,-./012.031/# *%+% %4,-.01562.0316

$7'' "# $%&'# *%"+%,-.01562.0316# *%+% %4%5,-./012.031/

   +'# %') $%&' ')8'9# *%+% %1' 0,-./012.031/# *%+% %1,-.01562.0316

''9","'()'# $%&'# (" 7'"')# $%&'# *%+% %0,-.01562.0316   ) ,)"( :  "  % #  (  +%+%  %  &%   '  &   '9%$. * (%(+%,-%/012%*031/) ' /0

1 2/0 $ ) 345/0  ' ,-% 01562  %*  0316  )  '  (  00    /  0  $ )  345/0 "("9:"$:"'&"'))! "

&#& %*&'%;)   '   0<31031/  =>  .13?     9:  "

  %*  8'9#  +'   %*   &')   &'%  @  '&"

=')". '&"?)'!%'

%%% ' '!;+)% '

,%"'%*8'9*%"% 031/.0316 )!" +%$%#9:("&""!"%*"+%.$:*% +&9!

 %(*&*%"% ' '  &')'

%&% "9:  'A!  '(':  "  '  !"#  ("&"  "'  9  &%*  %  " +%.$:9:(':%*&%<=$?' =>>?%*" " $:&%B%*0310,"'))!"'*"9+% %%* 9%%*'*% %%$'%% ' ',%*% "%031/.16+9)" %0/34031/=>.12?#("9: "'%*8'9"'  +% '&% %%"+%.$:% 9<3C%*"' D%' #(     "  &%%  %*  "  )'  %  &%)  *%  " +%=,-%/012%*031/?"'"+%.$:(' &' 9:$%*8'9&%B#'

):# " "$:&# 0310="'** %'E0310&F? "' $:!

$'%&%))!&'

+++%+''&%' '++%$')*%

"&% +'"%"'$9!' *%%%):"'9)"  %*"&%))!9*%!"'

%%"' 0310&"'$!

9+' #'%*8'9*'

 "8'9$'$%)&:# 0313="'** %'F0313%)&:F?  "%)&:"' "$:(''9)"  4

"' %%A' &% ' 35100310% !%$"+%.$: "8'9$'')"&&  &'%') %= !)'%%* %#>'%%*'

&6&

'A!%* $'%?&#033B="'** %'F033B&F?*% !)'!"*&%*"+%.   " &%(' &"'))! 9:"$:9:*)!,-%601<%*0314) '  "$:' '%"$'%*8'9' %"#("&"(' '))%( %313<0312#("9:%  ' 35100310('D'"  " )"%*('"'"$:"' "'%% : %*" 0310&%%%):*>"*9*%'

! %" % '**)' %"$:'+"+%$%%*"0310& "'

8 !

('%&"'))! 9:"'%*8'9 ' #"*%#" %&%)9 "'"'

"'9'&&+ 9:"' 2 +"+%$%%*&%<%*"0310&#("&" ') (""+%(' *&%%*"$:#9.&%=$?' =>>?"%*' '*%))%(.

G=$?%   '  &"  *  '  %"  &"'!#  '  ':  9 +&9 H >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> =>>?%+&9"*& *%$'%&'!%%*  HI &&% !%"+%$%#"$:"'9!$ "  +%(  %  +&9  "  *  &  *%   $'%  &%  '  " &'!% "''  '&%*"$:#("&""'$ 9 ):*'

 '+"+%$%%*"&' '++%$ 9:" !%$!9% :%*"$:#"'

('*%"';'++%$') %*" %*8'9#("&""'9'++%$ 9:"  %*8'9%00360312++''.24%*"'' +''.12%*"  '&#"$:"'9!$"+%(%+&9"*

&'&

"#'&&% !%"%&%)*%"+%# 'A'

+):

&)'"'"+%.$:"'"+%(%*>"**%$'% &%' "+% "'$%'"%:%*!" &%'&%*"+%$%#"' &'%9:!

%*&'%');&"'!"&% %%*"& <  )'(%) 9"+%%("!' %"  D%'#  ("&"  "'  9  +%  9:  "    $  &%

&'%;+&+%!' !"%*9%%*'*%  %  %  '%  %  ' '  ,%  *%  "  %  031/.16 +9)" %0/34031/=>.12?' %&%)' "'"'  9%%*'"'')' :9'++%$ 9:"'

'+"''  '&'++%$ 9:"  %*8'9#'* %'9%$#'&&% !):#+':"'"'&%%*" '$%)'%%*"8 !

+' 9:",%,-%601< %*0314#* %'9%$':"'#"#9 ' *%!' "

+! %*&'% ' 0<31031/' 0/34031/#>.13 ' .12+&$): B "'')%9&%&  "'** '$("&""'$9 *) 9:"'+%%"(+%"''+"0310&#  "$:(''"%J % 'A'

%# 9"' '   ' * "*'& ("!' %"&"'))!9:"+%. $:%" &% ' 35100310%*"'  ,-  %  601<  %*  0314  '  "  D'"!  "%*  $   %   ' 313<0312=>.4?' '

  "'')%9&%&  "' +'&%"' 8 !

#*%":'031<.1B#031B.15' 0315.

1/#"+%.$:+%&  %*>%(*'  & 

&7& '

%+%&$(%*"!",%8 !  ' 313<0312# * %'9%$ "'9' "'*%"%031/.16#' %  ' ,%#"*&'  9%%*'%* +$'%%*"'&) !"% "8'9 $'  $  %)&:#  0313  ('  %!"  %  9  %  '  +  " +%$%%*"033B&$ %*&'% ' 3B30031/=> .2? 5

"%98&%(' 9:"+$'$&) ! "+%.$: "%+%%*" $%&' ')#8'9(' %!"#("" $%&' ')%+ "'"&%*033B"%) 9'

  %&) $("" *%%* % " ' &(%) %9'++)&'9)%"+$'$'9)"  "' "'%*8'9"+%&%*'

 !" ' &'+"%+%!$9:" $%&' ')#8'9 " ' %*" %*8'99!%!"%9+%8& '

'9:"&%)9:'!"'"+%. &'% '(':*% )'9): / ' &%)*%"'#%"%""' #"'*%  "'"' '

 +%&"'9&%&)  ' '%*&'%  %15320303#*% ("&" '"'9 ' '++)&'9)"' &%&  "*'&#  "  )!"  %* " '** '$  *)  9: "  &%#

'&"@  &') &'%#8'9#(""'9'  "' "+$'$"'$"+%('  ' '%*>"%(* & ' ())  '  "  9%  %* " '  "  *'&  "'  9 '&A%() !  '  '&&+    "  ,%!   '  3035031/ => .1? 9:" %*8'9 " #

&8& "'** '$#"'')%'

 "' %% +"'"&%* 0310+ "$:%*>%(*#"%($#"+%(' %* '"$'%8 !

%*"%F9)+ ,%+% %"'"+$'&'%&"'!&'+'%%>%9' *    %  &'  ":  &%

&')J   &'%     &'%  9  '  +): &%

&')$' "*"'%&%

'(""*'& +%$  ' ">+ & 9:"+$'% 6

"  +$'  +% #  ("%  "'$  9  +)'   ' +% %4%5+'&%"% +' , .1</14.,-.

0316 ' 32110303#'" ("%"' 'A' %" +%.$:*%"%031/.0316' '+!"  ,% ":"'$'A"' "'":"' #+'&%"&') &%))!9!&' %9:'9'' $:("&""'+9)" +%+&*%"%031/.0316$!'++)&'%*%' % %  ;

  ,%  '  %"  %  ' '   &')  &%#  'A '

% '9)*"'":'9!'

 '!'"  ' 'A *%" D%' ":"'$'A'

%#'+ "  '  +%+&#  *%  "  %  031/.0316    9:  '9'  ' $:' #"*%#":'%)'9)%+':"*#'"'9 *> 9:"+%.$: 13 &%  9:"&%)*%"+$'+% "' "+%+&"'"*%&%*)'(' 9 !+%"+'' # "*%#"+$'+% &'%9*%& %+':"*#' 9!&"'! 9:"+%.$:+"+%+& 9: "'9'' $:#"%*+&9 (' B#<3#333;.

+' ("'"+%.$:&)' !''

%%*

&*&

12#63#333;.*%"1:'&% "'":'#"*%#% )'9)%+':"' *'9!&"'! *% " 9:"+%.

 "$: 11 ,%)  *%  "  +$'  +%   "'  *  %  ,- %01562%*0316) ''""'')' %"$'%* 8'9' %"#%&% "'"+$'+% '*%& % '++%'&"",%9:(':%*"(+%("":(&')) +% % +%"**%"0 ') %"%* 12#63#333;.  &%   "'  "  *  (%)  '

%  %  &'+'%  *  ' &%

&')J'%  %*  "   &'%  ("&"    %  + 9)    )'( %($#"*'& ("!' %"'%:+%$%#'&%'  "0310&#"8 !

%*",%,-%601<%*0314 ) ' "$:' '%"$'%*8'9' %"'')% "' %*" %*8'9#&%) %9&%%$ 9:" &%)%"'A': ' "'%:+%$%-"'"' 9 +%"'" (%) %99% %+':"*#' "'9+&9 9:" "$: 10 -  "'$  &%   "  9 %  '   9:  "  )' &%)*%"+'' (""''&#"'$!%"%!"" +)' !' "&% %*"&' 14

"*'&#'"'$9&%+%' '9%$# 'A'

+):&)' +&')):"8 !

%*",%,-%601<%*0314) '  "$:' '%"$'%*8'9' %"# &  % 313<0312=>.4?#(""'9) "'#"+%. $:"'$!9'9)"  "0310&#) %*> %(**%"&%' ')%%!)'' %"% "'+&

&!& ' '

 9:"' +):+&')):"'** '$ ' 01130316*) 9:"&%# '&"@  &') &'%#8'9# (""'9&%&  9:"'"''*" &%%*" ,%,-%601<%*0314+* 9:" "$:#(" &%%*"'%*8'9 ' 351003109!!"$:  "!)'%' +%& *%'

%"%!""033B&# %% D'" 9:"%) !"'"033B&9!'!')'&())"'$% !$(':%"+&')''& D'"+%.$:*%" :'0310#(%) !%$"*) #("&"'9) "+%.$: %%%):*>%(*9')%% & ' %+%& 12 +"' 8 !

#*%":'031<.1B#031B.15' 0315.1/#+%(!$'*"' "!' %"% 031/.16')%#"'"'&%&  "'  %"'$"+%(" !' #'"',%!   ' 3035031/"'')%9 9:"

%*8'9#(""+$'%"'$9> + *% "+%$%%*033B& "&%!  "'9 " )!"%*"%+%!$9:" $%&' ')#8'9#%("% "

'  ('  *  %  %  "  %98&%  9!  '  9:  "  +$' $&) !"+%.$:#("%"' %+ "'"& %*033B"%) 9'

  %&) $("" *%%* %%"'"033B&&)'):'++)%$  (' *"%+ "''%.%9'&)'"%) 9'  %"033B& +%$ !  "'  %("' !  ':"!  &%'    "  +&$ $:'%&#"+%$%%*"033B&("&""')) +$') 1<

"+%&*%'

 %*"'"' 9*%))%(

&+& '  %(    "'  9  '

   $   %*&'%  '  15320303 &&% !%"' %*&'%#"'  "'9 '  '++)&'9)("**&*% " '%*+9)&'%"%**&') 'J 15320303#  '!  "9:  "'  %*&'%     &"'))!  ' 0<31031/=>.13?' 0/34031/=>.12?"( +%+* 9:"+%. "$:&'%9D'" '+& ')!(""!)'%%*"*' D%'%*"+%. '"'

("%':'%:+%(&%* +%"'

 1B

"9!"'

 +%%%"+'%*"'#("&" '&&% '&(""'%:+%$%#"%'%'%(": "+(+%"%) %&& +&')):(""%98&%# ("&"  '  9!  %!"  %  9  '  9:  "  &%)  *%  "  +$' +% #&'%9'&&+ ("&"(%) 9&%':%"'%: +%$% "+&+)%*%++)(%) %9'++)&'9)'*''" +%.$:&%& ' ':&'#+&+)%*%++) &'%9$%A %*%&  %!'%%' $%)'%%*" '%:+%$% 15 !' "+)'%*"+$'+% = ?#("% '+%,-%01562%*0316#"'":"'$'A' % %"9'%*"+%+& 9:'9'' $:' "'$ +'&+' "&')&%))!("&""' 'A+)'&#**&% ':"',-%/012%*031/#("&""'9+* 9:" " $:#",%%3B32031/"' +' "*%))%(!% . "&% %*",%

F )9'%%" **>'%9+% & 9*%"%!')'')%"

& $& "'+%*''** '$ '  &%)  *%  "  '  %  &%  *%

'9!"#% ')**&%*

#8'9'"' "'9%)):%&%'+" 9%*'% 9*)) +%&%9:"'%'+&9 D%' 9:&!"!"%*"%%*))+"+% !' '  &')' -"'  9:" +! %*&'%"'"%"'))'9 9:"!') &%%*%+*&' '

%D'" !')&'!%:'' "'(%) "'$%%98&%* ":'*)) +"%+   8% %0<32031/   9+ % %&'9% "+ &:%* " '(+%' "% +' " +"%%&%+:%*"% 9+)'& %"*)%*" &%& &' 9 '9%$I % + 9:"&%)*%"+'"'"+$' +% = ?#'" %*"'

%#( ' '('%* "*'&%*+ &:%*"(+% 1/  ':9'  ""',-%01562%*0316#("&" "'9+* 9:" #%433/0316#*%))%(!% (' +' .

' &%)*%"+%9 "'" *:'#"*(' +% (%') 9" &% :'#"*%"%* 12#63#333;."'9  '  ')%!("''%**:'"!% #"

& & +%'9!"' %%' "&)'   +  %*  $&#  %    +  %  9"')*  %* +% %4 "&'9' 8% %0<360316

'(")#"+%' & %&%% +%"*#'"'9 +% "*:'#'+ D %*"%*&'%' "'

"'))998&% %&% %*"+%

+% %4')% & %'))%("+% %' "&)'I 16 ,%)  *%  "  +%.$:  "'  *%   "'  ' '** '$"'')%99  9:"  'A!""' ":(%) +':"*' %"&"'!#' &  9:"!",% ,-%/012%*031/ *&"!' "'9 ' %" &%+%*"'** '$#("&""'$9'++  ')%!(""+): *) 9:" "$:%,-%01562%*0316 03 $(%*"'9%$#('))%(,-%/012%*031/) '  "$:' '%"$'%*8'9' %"9:D'"!"

+!  %*&'%;)  '  0<31031/  =>  .13?  *% '

%%"% ' ',%%">&"!"%* "+%.$:*% +&9!%(*&*%"%

' '   &')  '

%  *%  "  %  031/.16  '  "    %* 9%%*'*%% ' ',%*%"%031/.16 +9)" %0/34031/=>.12?#("9:"'  "'  +% '&% %%"+%.$:% 9<3C %*"' D%'#9!$%)'%%*"'' "

& #&  '&%*" "$:' " "$:&#0310 '   ,-%01562%*0316) ''""'')' %" $'%*8'9' %" 01 '&%D&%*"'9%$#"+%.$:") ) %*>%(*' ')%") ) % 9' " +$'+% = ?#("%'+%,-%01562%* 0316#(%) "'$% +%"*#'"'9*> 9:" " $:*%"%031/.16' 0316.03")!"%*"*'&"' "  %*&'%  '

 !  "  033B  &  "'  &%   %  *%&  (* 15320303  9  ) ,):

    9) , .:

   

 !"#$## +8 -""+'A!;'% 

;% -"" +%'9)

;%