High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1600/2017disposed of

Sultan Singh & ORS v. Kanwar Pal & ORS

2026-04-06Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan7 pages

!"#$%$ &

!"#$%$ &''''() () () ()( ( ( ( *+,

& *+,

&*$&-. *$&-. *$&-. *$&-. ./%

./%

./% (((00,,

(((00,,

(((00,, 1/%+% 1/%+% 1/%+% 1/%+% &3 / &3 / &3 / &3 /

./ (((%0 &"& (((%0 &"& (((%0 &"& (((%0 &"&

' 45 *( * 2 6

' 45 *( * 2 6 /%& '

/%& '

/%& ' (7 %../ 8"9 #

8 ! //(:

; &- %8"9 #

8 ! / %( /((2( .. 7 /8"9 #

8 ! //%0 &"& ("/$9/( &! //%0 &"& ( 3&/( 2 68( 2 68( 2 68( 2 68( ( 00,, %#, / %7$&- &.

&#<& ! # <0&%

/""=; . /##$"& , $<%/$=+& ,8 &$0

./$& !

//!//" .>/$=+& ,4 8/- /"$&- ."

. ! /"0 %$&#"# %"

8$& / "%$" 83.$#. 70, # &?((@( ( . /$=+& , 9$" 3 /" "

" ?((8 # <0&%

$ & !%(A8)8B .#, %8. ,"$&-

/"0 "$" "+ . / "%$" 3.$#. 3 /%+, ! / %. &-,$-& "/$9$&- ! / / ,,; = /$&- /-$%

$ & (1 )AC)8=;/%0 &"& (( ( . /$=+& , # &%$"/" - ! . "# % ;

/%D %%%%" .& ,$&# < ! %%(@8B0/

< & .8 ./%0 &"& %"/$9/ 3&/ ! / / ,,;3/ /"/" 0 ;# <0&%

#, %$& .! ,, 3$&- < &&/' */( ( */( ( */( ( */( ( "% "% "%

<0&%

$ &3 /""

<0&%

$ &3 /""

<0&%

$ &3 /""

<0&%

$ &3 ( &&+ ,$&# < %(@8B@8E ( "+# /"% 0/% & F0&%%AG %(?8B@8H?8 @( +, $0,$/ ? )( 5 %% !"0&"&#; Rs.3,24,000/- (18,000 X 18) A( +&/ ,F0&%% Rs.25,000/- ( 5 %% !, 9 !!# %(8A8BA8E@ ( 5 %% !%

Rs.5,000/- ?(

,' %( %( %( %(A8888)8 8 8 8B (@ . 0/%& ,8 !$," =; . #, % %7$&- &.

&#<& 8 .

% =& # & " =; . "/$9/ &" 3&/ ! !!&"$&-9.$#,( @( /&" # +&%, ! / % # & &"%

"# %"3 %<$& / &".$% -3 %;

$< ! ( .!$&"$&-% ! ./$=+&

.& ,$&# < !

%%(@8B0/< & . /// & +%(.$&# <$% =

" &

. = %$% ! $&$<+< 6 -% $!$#

$ & $%%+" =; . *

9/&<& ! / ./,9 0/$ "( $%!+/ ./# & &""

9& + +// %0# %.

9& =& """( $ %* /, 1/< /%(9%(,.$ /, 1/< /%(9%(,.$ /, 1/< /%(9%(,.$ /, 1/< /%(9%(,.$ / &%0 / /0 /

$ & /%(8 C *

/ &%0 / /0 /

$ & /%(8 C *

/ &%0 / /0 /

$ & /%(8 C *

/ &%0 / /0 /

$ & /%(8 C *

, &%+/ &#

<0 &;5 "(9%(/ ;* .$ /%(8 *

? &" -< -< -< -<

&/ ,&%+/ &# <0 &;5$<$ "9%( &+ < ,$ .+./+ <

/%(8?

@( )( / # & 8 , /&" # +&%, /$&- & =.

,! ! /%0 &"& ("/$9/ # & &"%

00/ 0/$

# <0&%

$ & .

,/ ";=& /"" & .= %$% ! .9$"&# &/# /" ./$% & %# 0! /&.

&#<& ( A( .

/", /&"# +&%,! / .0 $% &"0/+%" 0/= 7( ( $%& "$%0+ "

- ! %"3 %;

$< ! ( .

%=&.,"=; . &4=,*+0/< $&9 /$ +%:+"-<&

7$&-& ,$&# <$& .# % ! <$& / $%& .# //# 00/ #.(&2 :

,9( -"$%. ./% :

,9( -"$%. ./% )*

)@ )*

)@83./ - ! .9$# $<3 %;

/%8 &4=,0F

"$%# .< . " !

$&-& ,$&# < ! .<$& / 9$# $< &" # &%$"/" . $&$<+< 6 -% 00,$# =, %7$,," 3 /7/ &"3 /7" + .# <0&%

$ &(*$<$, /,;$& =;* 7%.$ =;* 7%.$ =;* 7%.$ =;* 7%.$

/ , 9( &I /.< "*$< & ./8A $9$,

/ , 9( &I /.< "*$< & ./8A $9$, @?

@?8 &4=, .*+0/< .,"

$& .# %% !<$& /9$# $<%8

7$&-& ,$&# <$%& # //# 00/ #.(."#$%$ &$& =; 7%.$%+0/

%=&!+/ ./+0.,"=; . &4=,0F $& /+& /< / 9( / %. *$&.

./% A *

/+& /< / 9( / %. *$&.

./% A *

/+& /< / 9( / %. *$&.

./% A *

/+& /< / 9( / %. *$&.

./% A * 8 3.$, ,#+,

. $&# < ! . "# %"<$& / #.$,"( 3 % .," ! ,, 3%'

J# .$," )(

<$&- .# % ! %"#.$,"83 /& $&#,$&" ##0 ./ % &$&- ! ./$=+& , & .;

/,;$&# <( #& ,;8 $& =; * 7%.$ / , 9( &I / .< " *$< &

./)*

&,$&* @C8(((

$83/$ .=&#.8 %, = /

' JC( .$% $& .# % !2 :

,%+0/

%.,"

7$&-& ,$&# <$%& .# //# 00/ #.(&%

. <$&$<+< 3 -% 0 ;

=, %7$,," 3 /7< & $& # &#/&"*

7&$& # &%$"/

$ &=# +%8

3 +,"= .<$&$<+< < +& 3.$#.%.3 +,".

/&" &=# <$&- < : /D& .$%# %8 .<$&$<+<3 - ;

=, %7$,,"3 /7< &$& .*

!,.$

$< ! 8 $((8 &" +& C8 3 % %( )8@A?B 0/ < & .(K <0.

%$%%+00,$"

A( / .$% 0+/0 %8 3 "9/ . & $!$#

$ & +&"/ $&$<+<6 -%# 8C)?8! / %7$,,"3 /7/$&)3./$&%( @B0/"

%=&!$F"(.< & .,;$&# < ! # <% %(8CB8 &" # &%L+& ,;8 . ;

/,; $&# < ! "# %" .

= # &%$"/" % %(?8?B( . # <0&%

;

=,8 ./! /8$% %! ,, 3%' $& <0&%

$ & !# %"9$7 /< /

<0&%

< +& 3 &## /"

&#3$ . & .,; &# < @ F @ M %(8CB =;* 7%.$ / , 9( &I /.< " *$< & ./8 *

&,$& @C /,; &# < 88C F M %(?8?B + +/ / %0# )G ?8? F )G M %(88@CB "+# B 88@CB M %(A8CB +, $0,$/ ?

A8C F ? M %(88A?

, &%+/ &#

(5 "(1(/ ; .$ C

?0 ) AC 5 %% ! %

%(?8AB 5 %% ! +&/ F0&%% %(?8AB 5 %% !

&% / $+< )?8) F M %(C8?B

%(8))8?B K ( & .0/%& # %8 70, # &?((@( %0/ .& $!$#

$ &$%%+"=; .5 = +/ <<$%%$ &/8 /;

8 $&$<+<6 -%! / %7$,,"3 /7/$& .;

/@3 %%(A@(A 0/< & .(%%+#.8 .# <0&%

$ & & ## +& !, %% !"0&"&#; $% =# ,#+,

"=;

.$&# < ! %%(A@B 0/< & .( ( .!+ +/0/ %0# / ,% =# &%$"/"$&9$3 ! "#$%$ & =; . &4=, 0F $& / ; * .$ %+0/

( . "# %"3 % ;

/% ! -

$< !.$%"

.( % %+#.8 &

""$ $ & ! )G /"% !+ +/ 0/ %0# % $% = # &%$"/"8 3.$, # <0+ .# <0&%

$ &( ?( . #, %( / . 0 /& % ! "# #, (@ $% . <$& / =/ ./ ! "# %"8 %%+#.8 ,, /& $ ,"! /# <0&%

$ &+&"/ ..

" ! , %% !# &% / $+<(. < +& /""+&"/ ./# &9& ,% &"% =/9$%"$&9$3 ! .,

, 3, $"" 3&=; &4=,*+0/< $&/ ;* .$*+0/

/ ;* .$*+0/

(

C( &9$3 ! .!

&"#$/#+<%

&#% ! .$%# % "#$%$ &% /!//" ./$& = 98 . # <0&%

$ & $% /3 /7" +&"/' */( ( */( ( */( ( */( ( "% "% "%

<0&%

$ &3 /""

<0&%

$ &3 /""

<0&%

$ &3 /""

<0&%

$ &3 ( & .,;$&# < %(A@B ( &&+ ,$&# < %(?8BNA@FO @( "+# $ &PAG %(@)8@?BN?8H@)8@?O )( + +/0/ %0# %P)G %()?8@BN@)8@?Q%(@8AO A( +, $0,$/ !>?4 Rs.8,66,376/-N%()?8@F?O ( 5 %% !"0&"&#; Rs.8,66,376/- ( +&/ ,F0&%% Rs.18,000/- ?( 5 %% !%

%(?8B %(?8B %(?8B %(?8B C( 5 %% !# &% / $+< %0 +% ,8 !$,$

, %( %( %( %(8)) 8)) 8)) 8))8 8 8 8BN%()?8BF@O

<0&%

Rs.10,46,376/- & /% P (AG 0/ & /% P (AG 0/ & /% P (AG 0/ & /% P (AG 0/

&&+<

&F#%% < +& ( &9$3 ! ."#$%$ &=; . &4=,*+0/< $& /<$&"/ *$&-. 9%( &; ;

, /%(8 A * @ /<$&"/ *$&-. 9%( &; ;

, /%(8 A * @8 !

/ ,#+,

$ & ! .&.

&#" < +& 8 .% <%.

,,= &%!//"=; /%0 &"& %($& . &7## +& % ! .#, 3$ .$& 0/$ " !37%!/ < "

;(.0 $#+, /% ! .= &7

## +& % , &-3$ . ./L+$%$ " #+<& %$&%+00 / ./ !%.

,,= !+/&$%."=; .#, /%0 &"& %("/$9/ 3&/3$ .$& 0/$ " ! 3 37%!/ < "

; &"&"!+,%.

,,=" & =;/%0 &"& %( !

/9/$!$#

./ !3$ .$& 0/$ " !! +/

37% ./ !

/ , &-3$ .+0 "

$& /% (.# <0,$ &#%.

,,= /0 / "=; . &7 ./$=+& ,# &#/&"( ( &9$3 ! = 9"$%#+%%$ &8 .0/%& ,$%0 ,;

,, 3" .3 /" ! ./$=+& ,$%< "$!$" ## /"$&-,;( ( &"$&- $%#,, & +% 00,$#

$ &% 8 $! &;8 %.

,, ,%

&""$%0 %" !( () () () ()( ( ( ( N 2 6O N 2 6O N 2 6O N 2 6O

+,% .$

./%0 7$&-B/ % &"'

% 6.

./0 /

=,' %