← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3276/2011dismissed

Ranjit Kaur v. Gurcharan Singh & ORS.

2016-11-23Mr. Justice Arun Palli35 pages

      !

 

"##$%&% '  

(%") *+   ,,#--

"

.& *+$/ +

% 0/

"/#+&  #&, # "& !

   *+$/ +

% 0/   ,,#--

"

.&

(%") *+



"/#+  #&, # "& 1'

  2 31 13   

    

  



  

  

!!!!

4- ""

% 0/5   

  

         

   

 

  !  

  

 "

  #

$%&'

( ( 





$%& '

( )* 

+

 

"

 

  

#

$%&'

( )* 

+  



  , %  



    -    

     &  

     ,   %      

    .

  '

/      0

2   2 .

3 4 1

.

%

#   %

+

,   %               

  (

(

 

  

   %

        3 



6! "

     %  

/     

    7   

  (

) 8$-%  %  %

      

      

 " 

 

      %

  ! "

 

9 

%

 "  

 

! 9



    

 

  , % %

 "

 

 -    , %"

0 % 

   

 , %  

  





    

 

  

"  !  %

"

 3 

"

  "     !        , %6  %



%





  

 $ *

:5  



)   $

:5   

)  

   "  -     , % 

 $1 

2# 

   

  

 

    , %+ 

       

  

   

       

  

 6



  "  

"  

 







"     %

 

(



 " 

  %





  

   !    

  .

'

/%

  "

  

   (

  % %  ;

2                   %

            1

 

   



    %'2#     (

( /+







    

   

 



 

  ! "

        %

       

         

  

  $1 

-    



 

     

        

   

   

      

         

     "  < '

=/=* %5$2! 3-%   ,% 01

2 %

 /

%

 



 

 -   

    5   !   "  

 

*

8 

 

   (

( / )

>

             

      %

 ""

 

"   /

)

 1" ,

                  

  -  -  

"%  ///* ;-1

"%

&  *#  & + "

%  )  %  $ & *(! 9

   "& 

3 

   ""

  %

   %    )      %

 &               

 -    " 1  

 %  = &  ?      

 

      

    

 

  "

 

  ; %

  (

 9 %

 !  "

#6"

+



 %

 

 !  "

 =

8 

     

 , %   

 

  , %7 (       , %

 

 %



  "

 @ 

  53   , %  

         9 "

  9 

    A1 "

  

   

  

   

   

-    $1 



3 

  



     







 

   !   9 3 , %    



   3- B;-B   " 

  

3           , %    

"      

    -  

1 53   , % 

3 !

 ! "

  

   

  

   "        " 

# + 3 

    

          

  C  

8     ,  %9   

     

   

   $1 

  -              (

>



 " 



                  

  

 1" ,D5 

4 

  E8;7 4 

:= ;-1

"%

& E8;7 (

4 

:  %  $  & E8;7  



      

 E8;7 /

4

  -  

 E8;;

*

4         !       

  "

 



"

 "E 8;;

)

4

  

    E8;;

=

$  

F    " 

 !    17%-%;4 ( " # 

"!  "  +  !  3%$  %$-B74 (# 3%$  %   74

+ /

8     

1" ,

, % "  -   

  

 

     " 1 -     $1 



."    #

9  

 +   "  %  (   %  $ &  *

8   "    ""%  ) ;-1

"%

&    "  "    9 "  3      %



     &    %

   

        . 



 

" 

 !   

  %

 

    

    %

   

         

 3  "   "  %  )    

   %

  

 .

"%

 

    # 

+   %  )    )

8   "  %  =  &  %    &  *(  1" ,  %  //= &    9   $ 

1    1

"%

 

    %

"

  

     %

   



%

    

  

  

"

    !%  //# + &  * 

    

       %

   

                 

 " 1    %



8      %  = &  * %    &  *( =

 # + 



     

      

    

8    



  "

   

 

"

  

-    

 1 



 

;4

 

   " 

 "    %

 !   "

  3   1" ,  

5!   

   



  ! 55      

 3     ;4      

 



%

# +

    1   %

 



 



 

   %    &  *      %

      

    8-  "   

    

       

 

 "

 9  

    

   " %



 

 

 

 @         G!

7              

 "   

 3   

  

         

    



  "     3   "

   1  A&HF  



  "

9%

 

   

 "  %

 !  "

 

."     "      " 



%

#G!

74(:&+      !   3-%   

 "     6  74  



       "

  

 3"    1" , 

    

  

 -  

  "



(

3

   

  

  1                "     

  

-  1" ,  

 8 $  )1;1 

5 

      "   

   

 -    

 $1 

 "

 9

    



 

 !    

       



  

   1" $" '

/ 

 1  

  "

 

#-   +

  "   "     

 

 

0 %

.

   5-   1    

 - 

      

    "   

 

1  

"    5   

  %  (  &  *( 

 



  

  

 -    

# "  + %  (   

   

  



 " 

 

&%  //= &  *    

1 

    

    1

"  %

                   

   1

"%

       ! "

 

2 1" ,

1    %  //# + &  * 

    

  

   

"%

    

    &- @

F  1 1 4 (9"

"#  +:

"/#+& = ;2,=  

  

#

+              

              

 "        

  

    8          -    ;

&/#/ +  # "+ - ,#+ "%9#

<3"91=&/

3 -

 &#"$ = 12, *    

1  

!

   

%

       %

 

-    " 1 

   

/

&    



 %  ) &  *  1     

1 

   9 

      

"

 "  # 1 +   

 

 %

 5    %  )         

*

8  

1 





  



        1 9      % 1 /%,+ # 0*,"

91+%*-# 0*,"

>+& 

# +111))     

D5 &   

      

 '

       "  



;

    

   

     

  "  &- .1           

    

 

)

8  -  

1 , %"

1 53            

 %

    

           

  

         



 

 1" ,      5!

   



 

      9    " 

1  3  

 

  

 %

  "

     

 

 "     

 

       @ "  

  

  !

"  

       !    1 53    

=

8   ! %

 "

 

 

"

  1" ,      

  

    

  #    " + "    

3     $- B            !

"  

  

   %

 !   "

    

1        

  

6 

 

"

 &



  1  

 *  

1   

)



   

    

   



   



   , %  9

  

    

 (

 

$-B  0  %

"    

  1 



-    

1  (

A 

       "

     #

$   %&'(  &) * 

"

   +"

    , "       -  ,  " 

 

  .

    /   +"

   - , -  .

 " ,

0 



      1 "

        

 /  -     -   .   .

  -  ,   .   +"

  

 ,

 #*  "

  





     "       

/  -     

   

    +"

   

 ,

 



         

#&))2*

,, 4)

 

 





        #&) (* (

,, 22)  -

-    "   .

  



  .1 - .





, 

  

-        

 -  "     

.  

 

.   

  

5     

 . 

- 

     -

"  "

  



 -   .      -  "    -    - "

 #*  -   -

" .

 ,  6 "

  -  

.     " 

 

  /     "  

 "

 



 .

 

 

 #*      7 8" , 

    49% -   .

  :  -       

       +.

, 

    4(

6  "

   +"

       , 

  '       +"

      , "

%&



     "

  

#

$   %2%&  &) *   .

  .  , .-           

 - 

  . 

  %2     4(%           4(

6 .

     .      #    *  "

      +       .  $ , 

.          

- 

 .

    -   "   "



      +       

 

   .

  - 



6     -    



            "

. 

           - + 

      -  -   ;       " - 

  .  

  %2  

   $  



  .

   -  

       

     .

     .  $ , -    -    .      

6 .

 

 

      .  , -       

 .  .

   ,  .      

  "

      

   .

      . 

   "     .

%%

:   .

    

  &     4(  .

 - ,

 -



-         

.  

"

 " 

 

    

   

.   

   

.  - 

 .

 "





 -     

  -   .

     .   

    "     

.

    .

   +"

    .

 -  , <

 #*=     

7 

 -  

    "   - 

   "

      "      "          "

   "     -  

 

   

  -    

 - / .    

6     

.

   +"

  .  , .-   .            

 -   " 

  . "

  " -     

  

%2

6 "

   "   .      "

   +"

   , .-  " 

     .

      .

    

 

 -

.  " -   

,

"

    "          - 

  .

 

  %2  

   $            -  

       

+   "

. " .

   

 

5"  

   /  

      

- -   

    +   . "   .



  .        .



    > -

 



"  -   +"

    -  ,                 . -    

  - 

     







"



 ?

$ ())@ 

   $ &))@ 

8

      . " .

        . .

-

    

-       A +.

B. $ $    424 .

-   

 



"

-    .

    

.   .

 " 1        .    

 . 

6   "  "

.

   .

   C  .   .

 . 

    "     

  

-   "           -  -    

    

   

    -

"    

5    .

    -  D

;E 

 

  %2  

   $   - 

  

  %2

            " 

    

"    

 "    



    "  

 

" 

         "   



   

1      

         

  1  

  

     

1 

   -     . "

.  1     

     

   

A/  G   

 D

            -



/   -



/   - .  

5             

  1     

       "

  -        .   >

-           -      . .  .     

   

       " -  . "

 .

 ,

5" 

-  -  

  .

 C.

 ,   . 



 

  



-     . - 

 .  

    .

"

        

- 



    .

        

  %2 . -  

        -  .  .

  D. "

.  1     

     

   E

0.  -     -  .

 .

     $ $    #   % * 

1 "

+          .    

 

 .   -          .

-

   



        

-   -    .

    

   "        

-@  

     

6-    

 





 .   .

 $ ,            

     @,  

   

       -   

  "

  ,     .  .     

6  . "

 .  1 "

         . "

  # . "

 *   .

       

  %2     4(% -  .  .   -  .  1 

          

  -   

"

 

   

           

+  1 "

           

  "

     

        "        424               .

  

 

  %2  

   $  

+     "

  , .-  





%3

5"   

 

       



"   "     .

  

 

  9&   , 

    4( 

  

      

- 

   .  , .-  ;     

   "- 

 

      !

"

# 

 $%# *    

      ,   

+   

  #*

 "

       



 .

-   

     .

-> #.*

     

> #*



  ;  

   . 

  $"

>  #*



  "

 -  "

            #&*

7      

. "

-      "  "  "

  .     

 .  -  

  "   ;     "    

 

.  / .

   $"

  .+     





#%*

   

 

     -

     . ; 



  

" -

&&  '(    ( )# * -  "

  "

 



-  

. "



 

   "

   

"    .        

  #*

 "

. 

.   

"

"

. 

.  

.>  #.*

.- 

. 

.   

"

" 

. 

.  

.    

 

  

  "       

 ;    >  #*

.-   



 

   

 

  "     

   "       

    "    

    "         >  #*

.-   

 

     .-   

 ;     

 .-  ;     

  ;     

    .    $"

          +      

    "

    

#&*

H    .  # *  - "

.    .    "

   

"    .          #*

 

.

  

 

.     





.   

    "     

. -  .    . 

  > #.*

 

.

  

"      . -   

  

 



 

  

.     



    .            . -  .   



  > #*



   "

  -      

0     

 #%*

 

;    -       "

    

      "

   

"    .              $"

  .      . 

; 



,

<#2*     "

  -            

 .   .

 $"

 

 

-   

 

            %(

  "

      - 

  9& .  +       , ; 

   "

  "

    , 

 



 .

-       ,

 

  "

-  "

 

 

   

     ;   .    $"

 .

    

5"

     ,     

 

 

   

     .



      

    

.     .      .



  -  -    - 

  33# *#.*    

 

  " -   .    , .-         .   

  -  

          "

  ,        

    .

    - -



  . .   ,      .

5

     "      

 -       

.



 

  -

.@    

.    -     .   

 

       -    

  -  +         / ;      

  . -  "     "        

       #  * -      

"

    



  

    .      

1 "

  "   

  "

 ;    "  .

 "

     

 

     

     

 

5   "   

   "  ;    

  "

     , -         . +   .

 $"





   

  33# *     4(

A      , -                

-     "       "

-    C    .

    "        

     

1 

 

 

  

   "   

   .   

   

.  

  ;  

   

       

 ;  

 .

-

 

   -     - 

;   . +   .

  ,

6         

#

$   %2%&  &) *

 "

 +     "   , .-  

  .

     .

    #

$   %&'(  &) *



%'

,

"

  

    "   

  

.  

"

   

    .   

   ;    "   "     

5"



"  -     "

   -  ,     

      





     "   "        

 - -    

 .      

          -    

 



   "     > -

-   +"

  

 ,   .



             

   

-        "

 .

  . "



.  

  -   

       

.

- . 

    -    .+



  .



 #*

-  .

 - +"  8   C.

 ,   

   

      

   .      

 .   .  "

  -   

5 -  

-  

 

"    -  

  81 

   .;

 

 81 

   



   

     . 

 



 

" -   

.;   "

 



"          

  %'&  

 

   4&3 .    " 

"

  

 

 .

 

"   

 " - 

  

 

 "    

    - -  "-  

 - - ;

      

   . 

  

   

   43( 

. . "

,

    

6    - - .

  , "   /   "-  

 -



    - - 

 -      ; 

     

 " .       

 

"

 "   @   

    



"     

 

-     -         

    .



  .        " 

"

  +"

  

 ,



( *+

 , # 492*

,, 2&2

       , "   

 ;

    

 

 

    



"  #

*  . "

 ,

    

       

   43(

5

           . "

""         "       .  " ,  "

 

 -  

   

    

" - . 

    .   -  / .







 "  "     " ,    

" - .       

 

  

 . #  " 

*   "  



 

    

  %'&  "- 



"

 - -    - .       

%9

5

  "

  . 

 ,   :        

 

 #* -

-    

 



 

  

D

    - 

    E -  - D . 

 .

     

 -   -   E

 +"

   F

" ,

+ -+'.

 .+     # 449* I

F #F * (%4  -   

"C 

-  - "

 

  " ,   

 

 

             "

  

  "     

 -   -   

  .  F

" , 

 - -  "   

   

.  

"

 . "

       F

, 

   

6-

  - 

 -  " 

.   

"

  



 -  

    .

  

 +"

  

 ,

A

    :  -  +"



 

        

 -    

  "     

   

  

%4

6-

       



   " 8  

 ,   -  

   .

  



     .1 - .

     -    

 



 

5 -

    

 #* -   :     "

     7 8" , 

    49%       

.  

   





 

- .   "  

 .   

   .

 

.

5     

        

    +"

 

  

-  -  

 

 .

 

.       . -  -     

 



- .  

   

. -  - .    " 

.  

@   "-  

  

.



 

2)

 " 

  

 

 #* -

-   .

  :     "

   -   .+

 "

 +"



 

  

 #*

0



   

  . ."       ,

6-  

 



" 

-      +"



 



 

 -   "

  +"



    :  .  - D 2

7  -  -   +"



    5

 -     +  

 . +"

   

  

  %4   :



  4%9

5  "   

      -

+  

 . +"



 2  &   +"

       , -      "   

     

       



  "

  - 

  D5 &- 

     -               "        23 & (= "     - 5 

         -       -    

 "



6 3 -   

 !

    "  =(& 

7  "     -   "   

 "          

 " & %  ) 

 

       

 "   

4    2  

 

   " 

%  )=  4F &  =(          

D5 I) 



 

 

           !

    





 "

# 

  



      !

       

    

    !

 

     





   



    

  



 =



 

   

 "$#%

 

  



   

 



     



      





 &''(  

  

')* #+ 





 

')* #+   !                        #-               

   +

     

    

        J # + 

     

#+            



# + 3     

   "  5  #+           5  

   "     

"



  5   

5  5 #+      

            9           )=    "       J #+"      

   

      )     

#+

5  #+       &  

"

     I ." 

       "            1

"%

   

   "  $    

"%

 

      #$   )  



 %11  +

 2    $  ) =  $ 4F & =(   

 %



   6  (

G"

"

  "  4 F &   - % 1  





D5 

3   

    "$  ) =  =)  $                      "   %  ) =(& 

"

         4



   ."

 "

  "          

   

      *  #  !  "

= 

+ -   + , -   3   

     %  )"

      

"



     

   

"  

    

  "!

    

   %  )= =(&  # $  ) = =)$ +   "  "       

  

  

(

3        

 "   

     1

"%

    %

"

 

3 4 3

 "

     #     F $-% 7 , % J   ; % 

 +   

    "

     .  -  

  



      

"

   

  

      %

  "

"    

          

       - "     

"

   

       %

 #     + "

        



   "    

 :  - 

A ,    "

  

  

             

"

 : 

 .   2  

       

   "

 "  

     

 "

"

   "   346 A ,6   



/

9                    

     

!   , %"

    

$-B3

       

1   -   

1 53  

 , % 

 

   

               "     

     %



3   "  

              1        , %   

 $-B  "

 %

    -    

  

      -         

         "   

    $-B 

 ?"     

     "  

 

! , % "

   

  "



 " "

"



1 53     

1 

*

."     

  "  ! "

 

 %

   !  8 3  - 1       

 

""    "   %

#5 



+ 

     

   %

 " 

  

 6"

 "! 

   

'

 9 

" "  1   " 1 

 1     

"

 

 

  

  "   -

  

 !

"  

   

   

  !

"  

 "   

1 53

   , % )

. 

" - %   

  %  = 4F & 

   %    ;-&  *#" 

" + %

#5



+   

  

 $-  B                       

    %

#"  %

       +

.

"

5

" 

   !

"        

      1   "

    

1 53   , %  

  -  

  #

   ( +        

    

 

  "  

 

"     

 

6 =

."  "      -  

1  

  "   

  ?13!

9#4@#+ 5          4 :  ?:'

4$

 ?:'