High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/305/2014dismissed

Paramjit Singh v. Jaspreet Kaur

2015-02-16Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri12 pages

!"!#$%&&

()!

*!#+, &&&&--..

& /'"0"

"-'

1 0' &&& "-#2# &

*$ '& 3*!#+,,!#2'425

' --..

! & ,!" -- ., "6#-'''267 ,,0"6 + !#"

)02+(# #22 '2

2%&& - ""267 ,!"

02+4 * #+'0'8,'67 !#!.267,!(0#2'* !# ,!#20 ''!

+ 49:#",'

;

, <='2!"".0 !#( ''!

+67

2 '2!5' 48 "2!"(!""2& &

",'

.74 ,

" # ""

'7 ' 2)02!

!# !#"

-- . "# ''

,'!#( 76# ! 2&,( ''!

+ !"8 "".(#!>2#9&&99678 7# #21 ) '(#7

5!..

+,0

4,"!.

.4!"

?02,!

& ,( ''!

+4 !".!52 + ,' ",0"6 #28!

5!..

+1 #+ #8 .4,"!.

.'3 4!"

* #+'0' #20 ,"

!282. 34 ,'( ,!.2'#4# (.74 '-'

1 0'4 "-'

1 0' #20'-'

1 0'8'

6'#& ' 8 2 7" , ( ''!

+4 , '"-#2#

--..

#2,!" (!.7((6'"8!

,0 ("

'0.

7 #2 (-..2,!(

'"!2"-

.7'( ,!"- '#

,(2+ ',& 85'4

--..

",82,!"!# 6!.!

7 2" ",8 ,#.7"#,!"

'# "&*,0"2 60" '# " --..

#22!2# 2

#7,0",.28'3& @,# --..

'0"2 2 !..+

#20#'

"# 6.2( #2" ,'"-#2# 4","

#!#+ ,!( #2,!"- '#

",80.2 ((!

"0! !2 #280.2!#5.5

,(!# '!(!# . "&0 ,A0 ''.!# , (!.74 ,( ,'

--..

2!2!# ,7 '&5# ,2

, ,( ,'

--..

4 ,'"-#2# 0.2# 2)0"

,,!( #2,!" (!.7 ((6'"&,'

'4 --..

2'"!2!#+"-

.78!

'"-#2#

,(2+ ',!# ,7 '&,' ."4 ,6, 5!0'

02 ,'"-#2# 2!2# , #+ 8 '2" --..

",5#'0"2 , 5( '!

.'.

!#"8!

,,!(& ,'8 "# , 6!

!#6 8# !"' ,.

#7 ''( ,2

!.!#+ !#&*,2!2# -'- '2' --..

#2,!"

,'"!# ,7 '& '2!#+.74 --..

!.2 - !# 0#2'* !# , '2!"".0 !#( ''!

+67 2!5' 2!5' & -## ! 4 ,'"-#2# 2!2# -- #28 "4 ,''4 -' 22 + !#"

67 '!

. 0'

5!2'2'2

2&& & & # "0--'

,!" "4 --..

6"!2"B (!#!#+ ,!(". @ ."B (!#2,!"

,', #2*!#+, @ 0(6'2 ' .8!#2'*!#+, @&

& , '!

. 0'

# --' !

!# ,5!2# .267

--..

2!"(!""2 ,2!5' - !#5!2)02+(# #22 '2

%&& ,.2!#+

--..

, 2 !.2 -'5,!" "

28!

, '0.

767 ,'"-#2# ,".(#!>

!# ( ''!

+&# 4 ,-'"# -- .& & ?

'#2 0#". ' , --..

"06(!

'"-#2#

--..

#2,!" (!.7((6'"8!

, '0.

"0'

,' # #22

,'"-#2# !.2 -'- '( . 2 ,',0",.2 ,'"& 8 "0'+2

0-# ,!#"!"

# '"-#2# 4 --..

2'"!2!#+"-

,(2+ ',!#

,7 '60 ,'6, 5!0'

02 8 '2",!(2!2# , #+

#2", ,'

#2 ((!

"0! !2 !#5.5,!( #2,!" (!.7 ((6'"!# '!(!# . "&@!

," # !#"4.

'#2 0#".

72'2!"".0 !#( ''!

+67 2 '2!5' & %& ', '!#+.

'#2 0#".' --..

482#

!#2 #7('!

!# -- .& C& '0.

7, "# 6#2!#20#2' , 60 5 '!0"

-'#0# (# " ,-B0'

#2 ,'!+,0'

", 50 .!#2

," - '(D '0.

7D& D'0.

7D!"5!2# 8,'#"-0"

, ,' #2( #!"

""0 ,.!#+" 8 '2",!(','

0"'

"# 6. --',#"!#

8!..6, '(0.'!#)0'!0" .!5 8!

, ,'"-0"&'0.

7( 76-,7"!

.'(#

.& E& ,-B0'

!# "#$%%& %'(" $ &)%#*+( %'("

,- ,+$+.- / , 2 5'7 .

.7 .7>2 , B-'""!# D '0.

7D +'0#22!5' 0#2' , & ,'.5 -'

,''

2" ,0"$ ;

#2' ,"

'7-'5!"!# '0.

7!# .02"6 -,7"!

. #2(#

. '0.

7&,.+ . # - !# '0.

7 ,3!#22+' '0.

7# ""

(0# (

'!(#!

.# , "# 6#2!#2 0#2' , & '6 6.74 ,?+!".

0', 25!"2.7 ''

!#2 '( ( 3!#+ #7

+!5!#+

(-',#"!52!#!

!# ,B-'""!#

(

5' .. ""4'

.!"!#+ ,2 #+'!#( 3!#+"0 ,

(- &, 2.+ .( #!#+!##+.

."!##2!

,!"B-'""!#48,! ,!"'

,'2!! 0.

2!#4, 26#D #20 "0 , ,

5 0"22 #+' .!4.!(6', ,:62!.7'

.=4 ' " +!5 '!" '

"# 6.

--',#"!#"0 ,2 #+'& FF FF FF FF FF FF & '0.

7' ,-0'-"* !#:=:!

=!" 6

3# 6, 5!0'67#"-0" 8 '2" ,'8,! , 0""'

"# 6. --',#"!#!# (!#2 ,.

!"# "

',!(',' # !#0 ,(

'!(#!

.'.

!#",!-8!

, ,'& #

. '0.

7!" "

(!#2 #2.!#+8!

,# ,"-0""20 ,6, 5!''6, 5!0'

'# 67 , ,'& #.!3 , " -,7"!

'0.

7 ,(#

. '0.

7!"2!! 0.

6.!",67 2!'

5!2# & !"# ""

'!.7 (

'!#'#

62'

8#'( ,

#2 !' 0("

# "

"& .!#+ #+0!",4 2!"

--!# (# '0"

!#!##"-0" 0"267 , #20 ,' # #.7 6 --' !

2 # """"!#+

#2!#+

#2 !' 0("

# "!#8,! , 8 #'" (

'!(#!

. .! , 5 6# .!5!#+& , !#'# , 62'

8#'(

#2!#+

#2 !' 0("

# "

3# 0(0.

!5.7& # "

. '0.

8!..# 6 ''

--'

# !#"

# (!"6, 5!0' !# !".

!# #2 ,# -" ,A0"

!#8, ,'"0 ,6, 5!0'!""0! !#

67!

". 0"(#

. '0.

7&, --' ,",0.2 6

3 , 0(0.

!5 ,

" !' 0("

# "('+!#+'( ,5!2# #' '2

,#2'

8 !'!#'# 8, ,' !#'

!# ,2!5' - !#, "6#"06) (#

'0.

720 #20 , ,'&< 9&

,'4"

!#+0 !..0"

!5 ""(#

. '0.

74 *0-'(0'

!#"0"# 1'

2' $ "3" 1'

2'! , 4-

, ,.2 "0#2'$ ; 0#!'( "

'2 # 5' 6 .

!2 28# '

+0!2 # 47 82(!

--'-'!

#0('

"(!#"

# ",0( #6, 5!0'8,! ,( 76 '.5 !#2 .!#+8!

""D(#

. '0.

7D& ,!#"

# "!#2!

2!# ,"0 2!#+- +'

-,"

'#.7!..0"

!5 #2# B, 0"

!5& :!= # #"!2'

!# (-.

(

'!(#!

..!

!"4 (#

.- !#4 +#7 #2"0'!#+ 80.2# ( 3-""!6.' !" .!58!

, ,' 0.2 (8!

,!# ,6' 2- ( '" (#

. '0.

7& :!!= # (-',#"!5 --'

. , # !'

(

'!(#!

..! !"4!

6 (" 60#2 .7

!#!""0 ,

,8'#+2-

## '

"# 6.7 6 "32 -0 0- 8!

, "0 ,

5 #20 #2 # !#0 .!58!

, ,'- 7& :!!!= ' .2#"" ' .

3 !# ##

(0# '0.

74 'A0# '02#"" .

#+0 +4 0.

# ( ##'4!#2!'# #2#+.

( ,"0 , 2+'

( 3" ,( ''!2.!'

, ,'"-0" 6".0 .7!# .'

6.& :!5= #

. '0.

7!" "

(!#2&,.!#+ 2- #+0!",4 2!"

--!# (# 4 '0"

!# !# # "-0" 0"267 , #20 ,'' .#+ !( ( 7.

. '0.

7& :5= "0"

!#2 0'" 60"!5 #2,0(!.!

!#+

(# . 0.

0'42!" ((2''#2'

(!"'

6..! ,"-0"& :5!= *0"

!#20#)0"

6. #20 #26, 5!0'

#"-0"

..7 !#+-,7"!

. #2(#

, , ,'"-0"&,

(# (-.

!#2 ,'"0.

2 #+'' --',#"!#(0"

6 5'7+'

54"06"

. #28!+, 7& :5!!= *0"

!#2 '-',#"!6. #20 4 "

02!2 #+.

4 !#2!'# '

. 2- 0' '( #'( ."

'2 #)0+ .3!#2#"" 0"!#+!#)0'7

., ,'2'!5!#+"

2!"

! -.

"0' # ."

(0# (#

. '0.

7& :5!!!= , #20 (0"

6(0 ,(' #) .0"74 ".!",#""4 -""""!5#""4 8,! ,

0""

0#, --!#"" #22!""

!# #2( !# .0-"

( 7 # 6 +'0#2 ' +'

2!5' #

4 +'0#2(#

. '0.

7& :!B= ' '!5!

. !''!

!#"4 A0 ''."4 #'( . 8

' ,( ''!2.!8,! ,, --#"!#2 7 7.!80.2# 6 2A0

'+'

2!5' #

,+'0#2(#

. '0.

7& :B= ,( ''!2.!",0.26'5!82 8,.

8!".

2!#"

# "5' -'!27 '"

8!..# (0# '0.

7&,!.. #20 (0"

6 -'"!"

' !'.7 .#+ ,7 -'!24 8,' '.

!#",!- , " 2 '!'

2 # B

#26, 5!0' "-0"4 8'#+2- 7!#2"!

B '(.72!! 0.

.!58!

, ,'- 7 #7.#+'4( 7 (0# (#

'0.

7& :B!= ,0"6 #2"06(!

",!(".' #-'

!# '!.!>

!#8!

,0 (2!

"#" #28!

,0 #"# '3#8.2+,!"8! #2"!(!.

'.7! 8! 0#2'+" 5 (7 ' 6'

!# 8!

(2!

"#'8!

,0 , #"# '3#8.2+ ,',0"6 #24"0 , #

,"-0"( 7.

. '0.

7& :B!!=

#!.

. 2 !"!# '0"

. , !# ' 0'" ' #"!2'

6. -'!2 8!

,0 ,'

6!#+ #7-,7"!

.!# 7'5 .!2 '

"#(

(0# (#

. '0.

7& :B!!!= #!.

. 2 !"!# !

,' ,0"6 #2 ' 8!

'( ''!

+# , 5 ,!.2'( ,( ''!

6 ( 7 (0# '0.

7& :B!5= @,' ,' , " 6# .#+ -'!2 # !#00""-

!#4!

( 7 !'.76 # .022

'!(#!

.6#2!"67#2'- !'&,( ''!

+ 6 (" !

!# ,0+,"0--'

267 .+ . !&7 '0"!#+ "5'

!4 ,.

8!#"0 , ""42"

# "'5 ,"

7( ''!

+G# , # '74!

",8""

'+ '2' ,.!#+" #2( !#"

, - !"& # "0 , .!3 "!

!#"4 !

( 7 .

2 (#

. '0.

7&< & # ,-'"# "4 ,!#"

# " --..

('.7 ,'"0.

' ,( ''!2.! #2 0.2# 6

2 " '0.

7 "0 , 2+'

, - !" 0.2 # .!5

+ ,'' ,!'( ''!

+#2" 62!"".52&, --..

!#,!"

!2 5!

B& @H, 2'!

5'(# "( 2!# !#

#2,!""

(# @8 ""0--'

#2 ''6'

267,!"

@ , #2 *!#+, #2 0(6'2 ' @ .8!#2' *!#+,& 0 -'0"

.5!2# --..

@4 @, #2*!#+, @ .8!#2'*!#+,!"# "0! !# ( , # .0"!#

'"-#2# 8!8

!#+ --..

, '0.

7&, '!

. 0'

.7>!#+ ,5!2# ,.2 "0#2'$ ;9&

!#+ , " !# , #24 - !#'

()!

*!#+,4!#,!""8'# !2 5!

B,!6!

@H4 '!

5'(# "4 ""

0 !# !# #2 ,!" "

(# 8 " "0--'

2 ''6'

267 @, #2*!#+,4,!"

@ .8!#2' *!#+,4 0(6'2 '& , #.7

..+

!#" , '0.

7.5..267 !#'

, '"-#2# !#"!"

2 , - !#' .!5 "-

'(,!"- '# "G

' ,.

#7 '( ,2

!.!#+ !#4'"-#2# '0"2

, 5"B0 .!# ' 0'"8!

!#'G

, '"-#2# !.2 -'- ' ( ." 2 ,' ,0",.2 ,'" #2 5# ,'

#2 ((!

"0! !2&,0+, @ .8!#2'*!#+,"

,'"-#2#

!#'8!

, '0.

- !#'

()!

*!#+,#!

,'!# !##'

8,!. -- '!#+ @"

, '0.

767 ,'"-#2# !# ,-'"# "

@ .8!#2'*!#+,& @, #2*!#+,!"

!#' ,0",!"!# '"

28!

#""& @ , #2*!#+,, ."# "

#7-!#

!(4,!""#!&&- !#'8

28!

, '0.

767

,'"-#2# !#,!"-'"# #2,, ."#

+!5# #7 "- !! !#"

# ..+2 '0.

7& ,''45!2# @, #2*!#+, @ .8!#2'*!#+,!" ,0+, #2!"# !.

,-.

!#'

28!

'0.

7 67 , '"-#2# & 206 4 " -' 8# ",8!#+ , - !#'4 , .#+ 8!

, '"-#2# "

2'"!2!#+

,(2+ ',!# ,7 #25#

!(!.!#+- !#4 !#' 2!" ."2 ,!" '"!2# . 22'"" ,(2+ ',60 "0'-'!"!#+.74#627'(,(2+ ',

0'#20- "0--'

, .

!( !#'

2"-!

, - !" 8' '"!2!#+

,(2+ ',' ,.

#7 '"&< &

,'4 ,B (!#

!#5!2# #' '2'.

!#+

..+

!#" --..

,'"-#2# '0"2 -''( ,'(

'!(#!

.20 !" #20"2 !#"!"

,!( '"!2"-

.7'( ,!"- '# "' ,'

#2 ((!

"0! !2 .".7!(-.!

,!(

#2,!" (!.7((6'"-!# 8 '2"

,7 '5 +0 #2+#'

!##

0' --..

, 2 !.2 2!" ." !(42

4(#

#27 '8,# .. ,!", --#2&5# --..

, 2 !.2 -'5

#7'

8 "( 2 -'5 !.0-# ,'"-#2# (#2,'

6, 5!0' 8 '2",!( #2,!" (!.7((6'"67 ..!#+,'- '# "'

67 #5#!#+ - # ,

& 0'

,'4 --..

, 2# 6# 6. B-.

!# 8,7 , - !# , 2 6# !.2 # & & 8,'

" !#"

# "4 '2!#+ ,!(4'.

994!&&7 '"-'!' ,!.!#+ !#&, --..

, 2 !.2 B-.

!# '"

!22.

7!# !.!#+ ,2!5' - !#&,' '# # '

!#"

# " #25!2#

",8 , #20 , '"-#2# 8! 6 '0.& # "0 , !' 0("

# "4 --..

, 2 !.2 -'5

28!

'0.

767 ,'"-#2# & ,'.5 !#2!#+"' '2267 '!

,0"$ ;& # ,'+'0#2 2!"6.!5 ,5'"!# !#' !"

,0+, !

8 " ..+2

!#' #2,!" (!.7((6'"8'

28!

'0.

767 ,'"-#2# 60 !!

!""4- !#' ,!" (!.7((6'"(0"

, 5 #5#2

# ,

'(0"

, 5 ..2- '# " ,'"-#2# 8!

'A0"

-'5 !.0-# ,'"-#2# , #+,'

02 8 '2" !#' #2,!" (!.7((6'"

!# ,!"'+ '2 ."4- !#!""!.# "#!

,'!

"6# ..+2#'-'52

#7'

8 "(

-'5 !.0-# ,'"-#2# (#2,'6, 5!0'

8 '2" , - !#' #2 ,!" (!.7 ((6'"& ,0+, @ .8!#2'*!#+, '!2 B ++'

,!"

5'"!#67"

!#+

,8 " #5'"

" " "#0(6' !(", '!2 -'5 !.

0-# ,'"-#2# 60 ,'"-#2# '0"2

2 ,!" 'A0"

#2 'A0"

'"-

6."60 !

!"# " !#'

#7'

8 "( 2 -'5 !.0-# ,'"-#2# (#2,'6, 5!0' 8 '2" !#' #2,!"

(!.7((6'"&'5'4,, "# 2!" ."2

!(4 2

4 (# , ' 7 ' 8,# , ' #7 ,'

'"-

6. , 5!..

+ ..+2.7 '!2 -'5 !.

0-# ,'"-#2# & & 4 ,0"4 ("0

,5!2# !.

#' '28,# 2# 0 ,"

# , !

)02+(# "!"0#2 ''(6!#+"0! !# 0'# !#2!#+

,'"-#2# ,

!#'8!

, '0.

76 0" #"

'0.

, #20 (-.

!#2 ",0.2 6 I+'

5 8!+, 7I" ( , # .0"!#

!#'"-0" ## 6'

"# 6.7B- .!58!

, ,'"-0"& (0"

6"( ,!#+('

"'!0" #I'2!# '78

'( ''!2.!I& & 0'

,'#2" 6-!# 20

"-'

!#'J" -.

4 ' , ( ''!

+4 '"-#2#

2 (-..!#+ , - !#' .!5 "-

.7 '( ,!" - '# " #2

", 80.2 0" !.

,7 #+0 + + !#"

!#' #2,!"- '# 2!2 # 2 #7 ,0",.2 8'3& ,!" 80.2 6'!#+ ((# (# ..+2 '0.6, 5!0' '"-#2# "(8,'!# ,7 '99&85'4

!#, "6#!.2#& &!&& (' # 7 '"& ,!"

" -'5!"!#" * !# , !#20 ''!

+ 8,! , #0('

,+'0#2"

2!"# . - !#'

2 ' 2!5' #2 # , +'0#2" !"

0## ""

'7 #20#'

"# 6.2.

7!#!.!#+ !#& , - !#' , " # B-.

!#2 !# ''+#0(

!# '5#2 ,7 '99

!.!#+ !#4!&&& &&< & ?

'#2 0#". ' , --..

8 " 0# 6. 2(#"

,' 8 " #7 ''' ' -'5'"!

7 !# , !#2!#+"

' '2267 '!

. 0'

6!#+6 "2#(!"

--' !

!#'(!"'

2!#+ 5!2# 8,! ,( 78 ''

!# ''# 67 ,!"0'

& '2!#+.74 !#2!#+#('!

!# -- .4 ,"

(!",'672!"(!""2& ,

- 71 %8#9"#3 5!

, - +6"