High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/306/2014dismissed

Pawan Kumar v. Goldy

2015-01-19Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta10 pages

!"!#$%&&'

( #)*+ , &&&&--..

& /,"*"

.01 &&& "-#0# &

2$ ,&2

!"3)*+ , 4504

, &

! & !#6 66,!40 71 3 8*06+# #0 0 , 0

&& - ""071 300!

.!"

*065 ,# *.5(3,71 !#!.0*#0,2 !# 3!#0* ,,!

6 5%''9!#"3,

;<713!+,0!"".* !#+ ,,!

671 0 ,0!4, ( 0!"+!""05 3*"7 #03 --, 30 3!"*, 71( 1 !#"

-- .& & #"*#""# .5 3

",.4 , 08*0!

!# -,"# -- . "# ,,

0 3,!#+ 17# ! 0&3+ ,,!

6 !"( "".+#!=0# & & "-,!#0*,!

* ." #0 *"

4!..

63,*6 ,353"!.)".!5!"

( ,!& 3+ ,,!

6( #"*++

0 #0* !0(0. >5#+ . 3!.05# +.15 + ,81 !( "7,##?&'&'& ,,!

62*,"3)*+ ,5 3.0, 7, 3, ( ."".+#!=0(!

3 3.0,"!"

,"-#0# 5# +.15 !#>!# +0 1& 3!,,.

!#"7 + !#0 !#>!( "3 4!#6!..! !

!#"(!

3"+ 3!,0-,"# #0 "3 3 0 7 + -,6# 7, 3, + ,,!

6& 23 7, 0 3, -,6# # 1& 37, 3, 3 0# + 0 #1-31"!

!#(!

33!"(! , #0 1" 3+ ,,!

65 !#>!, *,#0 3,- ,#

.3*"& (4,5 3,"-#0# # !#*0 .!4!#3, +

.3+& !#>!3 0+40 # --.!

!#7, 3@+# ..5 ( ,!,6 ,0!#63 ""+# # *# 0+ #00(,1!# (3! 3 31(,"*++#0&# 3+# 3 #* ,15# 34 2 >, "

!4 .5 37, 3, 3,"-#0# >3,# 3-,

*# !##6 6+# 3!""!"

,!# 3!, +!.1& ,# (>5 4!"!

0 34!..

63,*6 ,3 7,!#6 3,"-#0#

7* 3

3, 3,"-#0# ,*"0 "#03,(!

33!+(!

3 #0!

*# !. #0*#."" 3+

, !#>!!""

.03(*.0#

"#0 3,"-#0# &3, ,5 .#6(!

33!"

3, #0 ,.

!4"4!"!

0 33*" 3,"-#0# 7,!#63,7 >7* 31 ,*"0 "#0 3,"-#0# #04# !#>!3 0,*"0 .!4(!

2*,"3&3 + 0, +

!#3!"+

.,.

3 3,"-#0# 7* "33 07#0", !#63!+"!# #* ,1 (!

3* #1, "# 7. *",A *"&3,"-#0# !# ..*"!# (!

33,.0,"!"

, !#>!6 &% .060#&'&B*#0, !#" %B5 5 3#0!

# .0(3! 3!"-#0!#6 #"!0,

!#&"!0" 3!"5 - !#*#0,2 !#' 30 ,!+!# . , 0*,( "+40(3! 3!" ."-#0!#6& ,0!#6.15

!.0 - !#*#0,2 !# ,0!"".* !# + ,,!

671 0 ,0!4, &3"

!0- !#( " # 071 ,"-#0# 71!.!#6 (,!

+# & ( "-.

3 0 *,#03,* 3+

.3*"&3+ ,,!

6 3,"!"

,3 0 ."7# #"*++

0(!

3 37, 3,

#0"33 07 +-,6# &(4,5 37, 3,

#03!" +!.1++7," 0+!#!"

,0+0! !#"0* (3! 3"33 +!#0-,""!# 3!".0 3, 7, !#& ,"

.+# 7,

3 @+# ..5 !#>! 3 0 6# 3, +

. 3+& 3

#03!" +!.1++7,"0+ #00+ , 1 .5 "3 #0-*

#0!

!# #4!# 3, +!.1++7,",0!4, !#>! 3,(!"

31(*.0# +

!#3, (!& #&'&'5 #0 3!" +!.1++7,"3 07

#3,# *# ##*.!.+# 3!, 0+ #00(,1 #0"3( *,#0* ,+3,+

.3+& 3,"-#0# #03,

3,+ 0, #4!#

#0 3!" +!.1 ++7," , 7,!#6!#6 7 > 3 ,"-#0# 7* 31 ,*"0 +

!#3,&3 3, 4,+# "+ 0!# 3- !#(, 0#!0 -, 1,,0!"+!""

. +( "+ 0& ,+ -.

0!#6" 3- !"5 ,!

. *, , +0 3..(!#6!""*"$ & @3 3, 3- !#,!"# .0 0 , 0!4, 5 # 3 6,*#0" +# !#0 !# !#5 ..60C

.!& & #"*--, 3!" "5 A +!#03!+".

@5!3 ,! @5*#"3!

+ @ #0 .( # @ & # 3,3 #05 3,"-#0# A +!#03,". @

-2!#63

& 3 ,!

. *, # --, !

!# 4!0# .0 71 !"50 !00 3!""*& !#"

3.0!#6

3 0 !.0 -,4 3 6,*#0" ,*.

1 #0 0", !#&

,0!#6.15 ,!

. *, 4!08*06+# #00 ,0

0&&

0!"+!""0 3- !#!.0*#0,2 !# &# 5 -,"# -- .& '& 3!" *, 4!0 ,0, 0

0 &%& 3 0 0!, 0

7,!#6 7 #>0, , "*+'5D!# 4*, ,"-#0# ( ,0".!

!#A-#""&(4,5 3.

,#0 *#".

, 3 0 !.0 +-.1(!

3 3,0,0

0&%& #0 "3(0!# 7!.!

1 - 1 3.!

!#A-#"" ,"-#0# & & (*.07A-0!# ,, 2 !# (3! 3 0" 3*"$ :

"#$%&$"$'& (&$)&$%& *#%& "$) &+(&$,&,

(- '&&)#$., &@3,!# #1-, 0!#6*#0, 3!"

-- ," 3 *,

3, 3(!, 3*"7 #05 "+ 1753 "#!#0-#0#

!# + "*! !# , 3, , 3!" "*--, #0 # ""

,1A-#"" 3-, 0!#65!

+ 15#

--.!

!# 3 (! , 3 3*"7 #05 ,0, ,"-#0# - 1 3- !#, 3A-#""

3-, 0!#65 #0+# 3.10*,!#6 3-, 0!#6 "* 3"*+ "53 4!#6,6 ,0 3- !#,E"(# !# + 3!# + 3 ,"-#0# 5!

+ "+ 3 *, 7, "# 7.$ ,4!00

--.!

!#, 3- 1+# 3A-#"" -, 0!#6 #0 "* 3 +# 3.1 "*+ 0*,!#6 -, 0!#65"3 ..5 " , "-""!7.570!"-"0

/ (!

3!#"!A 10 1",+ 30

",4! # ! #

3(!, 33*"7 #05 "+ 17&;

?& !# +-(," 3+

. *,

( ,0+ # -#0# .!

.".!

!#A-#"" #01

#0!#0!6# "-*""

3-, 0!#6" #7 #0* 0(!

#13 ,0"3!-#3!",3,- &3-, 0!#6"*#0, 3!"2 !# "*++ ,1!# #

*, #0 #," "*7"

.,!63 # --.!

0*,!#6 3-#0# 1 3-, 0!#6"&@3, 3!" +*# !"# - !0

--.!

5 3# 34,178 #0-*,-" 3!"-,4!"!#

#0"0

0&0*7 5,+01A * !#0 ,,,0, ""071 3+

. *, !" !.

7.*#0,2 !#B 57* +(*.0# 7 7 , "

,!>!#6 30# "-*" (3 4!.

3!# ,!+ ,0,+ # #0.!

A-#""- ""071 !0*, &# 3,(,0"5 ,!>!#6 0# 3"-*"# 3#*,!#6 3 *, E"!# ,!+,0,!" !#"

,.! 3 #01 # !#"

0 ( !#6 #0."".1 !.. !

A * !#*#0,2 !#B &@3, 3"-*"(3!" 1+ # !." 0!" 3 ,6 3.!

7!.!

15 3 3,"-*" ##

7, 0 0- !+ #"*+!#6A * !#-, 0!#6",, .!"!#6

3 +*# & *, ## 7 +* "-

, (

3!#6 .

0!"70!# 3!# ,!+,0,"- ""071!

"3(!#6!

"3.-.""#""

!#!

"!#"

!+-.+#

!#& (*.05 3*"57 --,-,!

4#!#

7"# #1"- !! -,4!"!#

!# 5 "

,!> 0# 3,,!#6"-*"!#A, !"!

"!#3,# -(,*#0, !#' 30!4!. , 0*,, 0(!

32 !# ,

3, # .

4 66,!40- 1 ">!

"#, +#

3,*63 A * !# " A * !# !" .#6 #0 ,0**" -, 0*,&

0."" "

15 3,+01*#0,2 !#B ,6 ,0!#6 A * !#0 ,,!# ,!+ ,0,0"# "

#0 7.!

0 , !#6*!"30 71 "

,!>!#6 3 0# 3 0 *.

!#6 "-*"& 3*"5(3, 3"-*"(3!"0!, 0 - 1 3+ # #0 .!

!#A-#""5 3.6 . #"F*# ",!

"##- 1+# ,

30# !0"-*"!".!

7. 7"

,* >& B& 3 0, "!63*, !# "-"0"$" ")"- 1 "0"2 )# 33"* 445 6 7 /40 .!#6(!

3"!+!.

,"!

!#3 0# ! 0 *#0,$ :3-*,-"73!#02 !# !"

!" +

. ""3*.0#

>*#0*

#0*# !,

6 "*-,!,!# # !

3,!63 *. .

!+" ( >,- 1& 3 -, 0!#6" *#0, 2 !# 3 ",4

.!+!

0 -*,-"5 !&& 0*,!#6 3 -#0# 1 -, 0!#6" # 7. 3( >,- 1 "

7.!"3 ,!63 "(!

3* 7!#6!# #1+ ##,3!#0,0!#

+- 71.

>!# # !

."*--, & !" ,*

!#B -,4!0", 3#, +# ,0,"A * !#G7* 3-, """* 3A * !" .#6 ,0**"# #0!A * !#!" 7 #"!0,0 3 #.1 + 30 #, +# 5 +

.-, 0!#6"3 4 7"

10 !.. A * !#!" +-.

0&-* !

0!,# .15 " *,

37#!

#,0,*#0,2 !# 71 ,", 3-, ""A * !#5 3- !"+ 4 #0*,5!#"+ ""

5 ##0.""

8 ( & 3#, +# 71A * !#(*.0# ." *, 3, 378 " &

.-, 0!#6"

"3*.070 .

3A-0!

!*".1 #0,.! ,00

3- !"&;

%& # *,,!#6 (!

3 3 ,"

!0 4!( #0 ..(!#6 -,#*# +# . *

!63*, !#$#%" "-3 2"- 1 #-&$)-"

9"$)-" "-3 2"-! 4 "* ::! #03, 0"3!63*, !# %-&0"(;-"(; <&$2"%" ;==" "

1 %-&0"(;-"(; <&$2"%"

90"3"*"!

445

6 7 : 3!"*, !#"3 >"-

( 1 "$"2!

48 ? 5 3 ), .

!63 *, !# "$."*"3 1 <&*"0";)9"$ ,"-#! 44 &-"*"

0-!#0 "*#0,$ :?& # 3.!63 740 !"!#"53.0

3,0,- ""071 3.

,#02*7,0!#

*06!# &&&%%0

0?%%!" .

,.1!..6 .

#0 -,4,"& 3 *, 7.( 3 0 !#3,#

8*,!"0!

!#*#0,2 !#' 3!4!. && 6!4 !

" ,0,& 3 0 !#3,# 8*,!"0!

!# -,4# 3 7*" 3 -, "" 3 *, & # 6!4!#6 !

",0,5 3 *, 7.((*.03 7#8*"

!!0 "

,!> 30# 54#! 3,!"

#"* 3-,4!"!#!# 3!#0* ,,!

6 &#"

A, !"!#6 38*,!"0!

!#"4"

0!# 3 *, 5 .(, *, 3 3,(#!

"3 #0"!#0"- !, #03 ,0 6,

*" .6 . -!#!# 3 ,4!"!# !#, !. #A * !#- !#5(3! 35 ""

71 #,85&!##!

) ,+> ,E" " % .BB5!"# # "16!#63!63( 15 #0!"7"

: (!

3 ..!+-#0, 7." #0-,

.0!! *.

!"&; & @3, 3 + # -#0# .!

( " # - !0 !# -*,"* # #,0,- ""0*#0, 5 3!"*, !# -#,9"$ ;3"- 1 $#2" @- 1&-

56 5#1#*6

3.0

3,,!#6 "-*"( "0!"# .0 73 ,0#+,!

",0!"71!#6 3,0,

3 *, (!

3 3..(!#67",4

!#"$ :#

#!E" "9"*-, <5 3!" *, ..(0 -- .!.0 71(! !#"

0 ,0!4, , 30#

3 3*"7 #0 ( " "

,* > # *# ## 1+# + # "!A0*#0,"

& .4 - ? 38*06+# !"A

7.($ :0*7 5(! #!. - !#*#0, ,0, *. ? !4!. , 0*, 0 , , 4,1 3!" +*# 33*"7 73 *.0*-*#0, 3 # +- *, ." ,0!"70!# ,"

!0*, E",0,5 7* 2 !# 3 +-(," +

. *, + > # ,0, , + # -#0# .!

#0,A-#"" -, 0!#6" #01 #0!#0!6# "-*"&

3!" +*# !" # + 0 !.

--.!

5 3# 378 #0-*,-" 3!"

-,4!"!# "

#0 0

0& @! ## 7 , 0

> !+ #"*+!#6 A * -, 0!#6" , , .!"!#6 3!" +*# & 3 #0* 3,"-#0# 3*"7 +*#

4 # *+ 1&H (!"#

-(,."" #

7,!#6 33*"7 7>& 33*"7 #0 " !.0 + > 3- 1+# +

#0.!

!#A-#"" 3(!53!"0#

#7"

,* >* &0*7 5!# 3!" -- .3 !","-#0# &!"0# !" #

!#0!#3!"

!#!.0*#0,2 !# &#

3, 0 !"!#" 3!" *, !# 3% >"-$ 7&1# 1 #"-" "3!

48/ /A @;-)&1 ";- 1 7"*#( #$.9!

4: A 3% ;-#$)&- ";- 1 "*)&1 #$.9!

4: / A 9&&*" 7&1# 1 ")"$ "*!

#0 ;3-"%# 7&1# 1 "# "-2",9!

4:/5 6 : !

!" 3.0

(3# 3*"7 #0 !." - 1+ # #0.!

A-#"" 3(!53!"0# !" 7"

,* > * &3 #"F*# !"

-- .!" 7 ..(0 #03!"- !#*#0,2 !#

!" 70!"+!""0&;

& 2!+!.

,4!(3 ."7#A-,""071 3!"*, !#,9"

"$# 1 ",9 "* 445 6 ! "$%# 7&1# 1 "*=#- #$.9 445 ! @;-B&&% ";- "*#", @;))# 1 3"- #$.9 6

#0"$% ,9 1 "*>#$)&- ;3"- 6 & 3 3 " !.0 + > 3- 1+# # *# .!

!#A-#"" "0!, 071 3!"*, #05 3,,53!"0# 7"

,* >&# 3,(,0"5 3##- 1+# + # ,

!#A-#""*#0,2 !# 50!"# ."

,3 ,!#6 -- .#+,!

"&#"F*# .15 +!"3,71 0!"+!""0& 5

6 7@ "$;"-0 4!

/ 5 6 67"