Harpal Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
"#$
%&%'()*+,- ./+&'%%/.0&&
1
2$ 3&
42
3&&13#$ .
3&
' 555 &'%%/.0&&, 6/' 7
8 1
) 39:3 9 39 93 :3 ;< 7
) 3
=:"&
1 & .
3>
$ 6/3 2 $
; ? 6/
$
.
@ A
9
" 2 @
'
A
3 ">
! " # " $%&$ $ & ! '("))* + , ( ) ) $
+" -
$" ' '
.) , '("
) (' /
) (0' . 1 2
) ( 3 + * ) & 45, )' * 6
7 $# ,***
) $'
#, ' ) 1 * 6 ) * $0
) ("
('(0'
1 , )' # )) )' ) 6 $+3
& ) ,
( '
( "
) $+) , 1 *8 , * 1 *) *)', ) ' $ + 7 , 2 0#
2 # * 6 #
0 '
9 * , 0 '
: $ + &;$$& ) #
0 '
9 * ' $ 1 * ) , <,0 '
: $= $2 &$$& # 6 * , $/ # **' * #*) * #
* $:* , , /4
/4 6 : ,' "0%1 $> 9 &"
>
"> 7
B"
3
#
2
3
B
>
&"
3
2 $
? 6/3 ?
3 #
2
@ A % B
3
&
(
2@ A3> B
3
?
"6/
&'&*D / <+& %'/'1 -$ B3
9:/
"
2$ ?
"
>
2
$
2B3
$
B 8 .
"> >$
A .
@ A 2 $B
2
2
2
$
E $A &
" 2
$
3
$B 3 $
$
3
$ E A .
B
"
E A .
$# "
2
6/
?
E
A /
"
""
$
? B32 2 2 "$
"
B 2
$ BE "A .
# "2
2B > .
B"
""
E
A .
2"
3 $ 3 "
""
E A .
"
#
2 B
> 4 $
"2 B
BE
A .
"#
>#
"B
>
$B ?
6/
: /
9:39 3 ;"/
;83@/A
& &
2$
9 " "
:9@ A
; / $
"2
3>
"> F . $
2
4
2 2
6/>
>
9.
"
> $
$
3>>
"$
$
"
3 2
""
$
$
2
$
B> 4 B
G .
#
$
" ,/3 ) 3 9 2 "> '9"2< $&&5$ $ &* ( ;
(;(;;( (&!?& "1* ? ::*(1
* , ( ) ** 0' 2
('
) ( " ) ( ' . ' /
3
. 3 + * (
,(+
(/ *' $< )"#* ' ) **)
# '* $ " # *
9"2 < $& &5$ $ &* (;
(;(;;( (&!(& "1?* ::*(1
* ,(-- # ' $"# #) )
) * * '$ ' :* @A$&$ 9( * '
* ) ** ' # #
* '$>
.
#
9
,-7//&*++7+'.
%'H-& /'1-'7+ +./%'9:/
A / 2 " -
3 @ ; A 3
.
3>
2 3
23 > >
#
""
3
$
B>
2 $
9:
>
9" / 3$
# B $B
23> 4
>
9
>
9
2
B # B
>
2 I >3
3
9
>
9
2
2 3> 43
" 2B $
# B3 >$
>
2 $A /
"# 3 :;
3J$
K L .
>
?
$B
3 $ B >
$B
9:/ .
2$
>.
>
>
> "
/
"
>B
>
" 2 /
B$
2
.
)$ " &
;:@ A ,. 98 3
"
2 ""
A / 7 2 B 1# # - .
B3 @ 9A
:3
KL/
$ $
1
"#$
3 @A@
A9 @A & C, @&,A @A. 8@ A> "
"
> 2 $
"
" > $
""
>
B
B
B.
B
"
$ 2 > $
$ 2 B $
>
/
36/' 89 8= = 8
:3 ;3 39 939:3 8" /
93
2 "
:9"
"
2 $B
$B?
A / "# 2$ 0 > 3@ A 3J$
K LI
B" #
4 "$B
>
B
2
2 "
$
9:/3$ $B
2
B
4
> $B
1
3 22
2
4 4
> 3 #
$B"&$
"
" 22 /
B $B
3>
>
; 32 M
B"
M M
2 M)
2
B
4 $B
.
B 2
3 > "2 3$ B "
B
""
4
> >
M M3
M
B
M K LI
B
22
$B
3
B
>
2
2"
"
B I B
9:/
$ 2$ 3$
> $
2$ "2$
2 3# 3$
B >
4 B # B
2 B2
2
2> ""
#
2
$#
3
"
B
>$
B
3$
> $ 22
$BB 2 B> $ $
22
B.4
>
""
3 > 2
$
#
2
"
3> >
"
> "
B
K 8LI
>
# "
>B$B
C2 2
2
3>
4 $4
"
2
A /D
D ", 4 3 : 3
KL '>3 ?
$
2
9 89:" />
2$ '
B ""
2$ $ 2 $B
> >
"2
"
2
9 "
$
B "> @1
#$3 @A @
A 9 @A & C , @&,A @ 99A >
?
>
; "
"
2 $B
2 $# 3
2$ />
?
"
%""
2
""
2
$ "" $B ?
> 2" ""
B ""
$
$
> >
/" ""
?
3 2B
>
B>
3>
B
3
3 ""
$ ? B
"
?
" 2
> $
$ >
#
? 2 /
$ 2
2
2
>$
B. >
$
" "A / " B
7 1 # 3@ A :3 6/>
9:3 9/$
7 1 # @
A > $
3
3
2 >
> 4
>I 2 2
>>
2 3
7 1 # "
3
4
3 "
" 7
"
?
6/3J$
3 K 8 L>
"
>
2$
9 " 6 2 2 #
"
32
B
""
2 6 2 2 #
$B
B?
6/
>
; .
$
> 2 & $
$B
!
2& 7
3 3 (
B3>
>
; ?
$
"
C"
& $
3
C
,
2
C
$
>
3 3
.
"2
$#
>
,
2 $
9 / $ $ &
"1# 3B & C 5&3
,
) "J$
3 >
?
"6/3>
"> K 8L.
"
2
$# 32B$ 22
">
8@ A
;
>
$
"B
#
"
>>
/ B
>
E
8@
A.
#
?
/" 2
$
2
2 " #
"
2 ""
I 2 ""
>
$B
9 "
:9.
>
?
;
"
2$
8 @
A / " >
2 $ ?
#
; 3
2
"#
>#
"B
>
E
8@ AI
>
> 2$ $
E@ A
"#
@
A
$
"B E
8 @A .
>
2 6
/" 2 $ ?
2
2 B "
C
$ "
$ 2 E
8 @ A /
>
; >
3
2
B"
""
2 B ""
2
B
B$ ?
2 "2 B " 2
""
B 4 3
$
2
B .
"
" $
E
8@
A&
"
2
2B$
2
2 "
B
" "
>
?
E
8 @
A
""
"
2 22
3 "
3 2
3
B " 2B
"" ?
E
8 @ CA /
2B ?
"
>"
$ B"
2 "
>
# E
8@CA.
B C
@
A @ CA $ +2 ""
"
2 > $
2
B
2 " 2
.
> $ #
?
""
B 4 "
2 "
2 " 2
2> >
$
/ 2 .
" B
3 $: &!
&3 3J$
3 K
L.
""
N2$ J $ 2 $B
>
9 &B 2 $B >2
3
2
9 3>
C
2 " *
.
2$
B
9 3> 2B#
"B
""
4 N2$ J""
B4 2$ '
#
2 ""
"
2 > 4"
9
2$
4
>
$B
; .
34
> "
"
" #
$
;
$
"B =
"#
K L .
3
""
"
2 $B
2 B
"
3 ?
>
; 3 " ""
2$ .
$ $B
""
B $B"
"
2 3
"
B3
"
3
4
BO
B $# " 2
"
#
2 K 9L/
""
""
2 B "
$
"
B $
2"
#
2 "B > B
>B $# >" C /
B 3
2
4 3
>
34
>
3
"
>
3>
3$
"
3 $
"
.
"
B>
; >$
" #
.
$ "
>
$ #
&
>
; 2B
#
3 >
"
"
3 2B
#
%
3
3 $ $ 3 B $
$B
< ?%$ #$ 1 ?%$DB &C555(E F(6A <DB & C 5!!(E& F K L /
>
""
""
2 2" ""
2 "$
"
B 2
$ B3 $
$
>
B3" ""
2
B
+"" $2 $
?
> B
22 B$ 2B $ "
""
3 >
N
J
$B 3 $
$
$ 2 /
F B2
" $ G
.
>
; " "
4 "2
1
B"
#
3/2"
""
B "
"
>
4
#
; ? 6/ $
"
8 / 4 > B 0 B > B3 B&
C ; 2 5;
3 8 3 J$
$
"
",
B>
3> "
3$ B >
""
>
: 1
"
> 3"
322
3 "B3
B >
9 B "
2 B " 2 /
$ 2 B
B&
; / 2
4 &
" 2
3 &!BC ;3J$
FK:L& " I
@
A'
9" :
3 2
O B$
2
B "
*
#
" ?
6/=
" 3>
$
/ B
3 6/
$ ?
3
" O > 2 B
G
1 $ 3 $
2
"
#
; " "
4 ?
2 $ / "
> "
6/
$ 3 >
23
$B ?
?
$ $
B
& @ A3 "B3
> @&'%%/.0&&A ,-71+ # I
4 =
I
$ '