High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/33/2011dismissed

Ishwar And ORS. v. Premwati And ANR.

2015-09-18Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal9 pages

$%%"

$# &"

()*'+, -'.$/.

# $ !"

% !" &&&&

' $01 23

'( ")#% * % "

*! # )#% "

+*( , "-#% !

"*% "*)" . "! " "* %

/# $ # 01 ++2 3, 4"5#%6! 3"

# 01

++2 3 !,3'# " ) ( , 7 ( # " )#%"

# +8 7+

3 !,3*($ $#9

++2%(:"#*(, !# #% #! * % % $;# )#" % %# % " , * *( #% ) # , # % +<

72 < 1 ;# # !# %# , " *% ( 3 3# *"# !

% , # )( < % *( *( % # * !## ""

, "" %(/

* % (% % " #"

$ $# , "% %"

*# 2( % # /" ;# * %# ! %% (

"# %#*( (/ # $# / !* = #) ((% *# (% %(/ " ( :"#% !#" /" # # * %>! *" % "!

(!#/" ;# * % *( * )# ! !#* %/( " ! (( #%#" # ! (!"* /% ( """ , ! ?:

% % # / # *(= %$#9

++2* * #! * % % * 9 !:"#*( !# #%/#* 9 !* *( , 0 /# "*( "#"

* ";#" , " (# * 2 @ * ( # ! "

*" *%* % % #

#" " ( * " , $# " *)" !# 3 3 %%"# #* ( , * %!

%* ) # (

* %(*# ( %@* % / $# # # 01 ++2 % " ?

43 5..+.6*7+6. ,*89

3 5..+.88+7+6 .,*89 3 5..+.,:)*9 ;3

*< 8

$ # 01 ++2 3 !, 3 / $# % # ?

3 5..+.6*7+6. ,*89

3 5..+.,:)*9 3

* A # * " # *# %" # ?

43 5..+.6*7+6. ,*89

;*,)+/ = !!# 3 5..+.88+7+6 .,*89 ;*,)+/ = !!#

2 3 5..+. ,)+/ = !!# :)*.6++:9 ;* , )+/ = !!# ;3 5..+."8,)+/ = !!# :)*.6++:9 " ;* , )+/ = !!# ;3

*< 1 # " % " ?

>3 5..+.5**88 % !!#**/8*?@,8 )?6*;,+.8,/.+;80**/*0+/8 8 )/, 8,: 8 8 )+ . .,:) :6+6*.6*07.9 + ' " !!

#/ $# !

"" "# 01 ++2 " %#% , )* # ( ( %" %("%# (# 01? ++2 3 ! ,3 ( (" / ( " % % # (" !#

, " # 01 ++2 % :" #"# ( % , ! ( ' /"*)" $# "*)" ! *!* *(

!" #* *("# *

6"# %# "

#* , " %( * $# ! *"!#"* : " : *" "

:" #* , " ! ""*/

" % !

??!

: " * !

" ": %!

" " "

#* ##* :

% "

# +8 : 90 "

#* # #*

: : "* #*"##%(" ##* % "

/ # # #* ! "

# +8 ,"*"? "

"#" " !!"", !

, ! % ! #* # " ##* ! / !: :,91# % , *#! ! , % ! "

A # " # #*

9 " #"%"* * "#

'$#*!"""# % " "

"! * ( #* (*! " ": !

(!#" *# # * %#* ,# % !

" %" * "

"# " > % #* " 9 #% ( % % *( * %"

#* , # % .#*(% %%" " "# ;#

" / "!

"*#%" " *?"

*( $# "

0 >! % % # , : " %" ( % % ,*;#( *" #" * ,% ! ( :"# #% #" ( "*** !

3$:8 183)?.+2 ;.*"

" 1$3"

# ( #"( (** "* *!#( #"*( #""

## #"

1 .#!

"-#%* # # ( ( "*"%(%! "" %/"* # " *( * "* %# %( "% ( ?:

% % ( (*" # % ,!

2 / ##* ;#

%# % ?

B3 5..+.,+.,*8.;+:8.6+6+ ,+/+8/.;*8?.-,8/:88+ 88 "

!!" 68 ;,+ . 66**A89 3 5..+ . ,+ .,*8 .; /; . 8/ +/+8/.;*8?.-,8/:88+88 "

!!"68;,+.66**A89 3 5..+.+88"

!!";,+ 66**+B,++/+9 ;3 5..+ .+ . ) /+; :+8/ . ;8)?.,+)*79 ;3 5..+.,+)*7-,8+:/. ,7.+/+8.5**88 % !!#**/8*?

@,8)?. 68A *9

8 / ;# # !

??!

* "##*)";# "!#

#4 54

5/ "# # ## " ;# %;# #" ;#

A C# *# % "#* /! ( )#%"

"*#

## (/" ;#

+ ** ( "!

* !# ,/ ( !* ## .#!

""* %(% %

1 C# *( ;# / "

*" ( #"" ( "% % ( ?:

% % # / (!#

7?;# "#(% , !#"?

% % " ,/ "

" ( # !# %

+ C# 0 % !

"" ?"

"*% %#"

% ;# 2 # * % % #;# 9

@#" $# #%" ;# $;#( ' $3

1 +

2 ,