New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Arshad & ORS
!"#$%&'
%%(( )"!
""*(*"
+% ,"
"
+ # -%"./ "*%%((
"
**0!%./ ""% 1
,"3($ ""*(.45!
&"6$". 7!*.45!&"6$"!4*".
7$ +*.45!89&"6 7$ :(:*$.
4 5! &" 6 $*" 7* $"$! ( ;"$!. !"!/$"*5"!4*($% !" 7 * " )*( . 4 * "% )%6"/".7</-!$"6 " !"#$%&6!"""!;5"4"4" '30# 1 *"" """ * 4 "!;. ($4 $%*!+ (;*(4 *"
%"*($
7* $"$!
( ;"$!(4 *7*"!;* $4"$ -"("(4*44"!;5"4"4" =,93>
91? * "!; 54 "/ 5& 7* $"$! ( ;"$!$"%(**"5"/4(( *""!(?7*"!;* *"*"!;*(%"3("?
5!18 $ **"!;"*"*(&/" 7$(;* **", 7$(;* ,%.**4 "!; 43%";*$(*" *!4/4& 4(3"5""5*?"!((&.*"!;"/5& 7* $"$!( ;"$!"!;4*4 "!; 7* $"$!( ;"$!!"$!(%("! 4"/!<!"/(%"*5&. ***!!$5(" ?*"!; (@/(&$4 "*.* 5& * 7* $"$! ( ;"$! 5"!4* 0"( :%(.-"( *"%$"$@$ !* @& >*$" "%"*((%( + 8 "*!"7 8.8 1 ,# "4" 4"% *,(77$(;*.,%
%"*/"*($.7* $"$! ( ;"$! 481&"*$***? * ;(("/" "4+ .
3%"$*?*! %*$*$(&?$!+ .
.
3 %5& *$ ($*"%"5&."$( "?*& "!((&%!%$*
44.((**""%*%%"
8 +% *(< "$. *" "% 8$!% *%" "$ *< "$(5&"% .*&;/"!%"($"&5<4**($ % ("/(!5!%( +?$" .*;%( **/*(5(44 "4 "% 54"/5&"% ( 4"4"4"% ((! **%(?* *($% $5(4* "4"% 5"<"$<"*"&%"
A/*" .*>"5!($*(!** ;%(((4*($%($ "( $%.*/!(&."% 86!"$%& (5(%&*$%*"!;B! !" *!*!"$%&*$((4 !"*"*"% *5*(4/( 4!"/4( $".!*"%*$"( """*%(;*%"($"&5<. *%"&4"$(*($%
* "$(5*("% 86 !" $%&. ; /"! (4( 5< !"& *&!*((45&*($* ;%(."*""4!*"%."% *(4/(/"/4(*$ "$*!"%(& "/(."*"
1 * !" $%& *!( 5 5(/ (5(& %& $% (%"&"$(*($%
!$" ""$*%" "" B!%%"!(/
"*"4"4!$. *(%"(&(( 4 *($ % / "
. * " #($ >"5!(. -"( *"" """ * >"5!( " $%+ 1. .
3 *"*" C%"!$ "$*(4*($%(("(D* ($. %&5( 5& (( * "% <(& /"((& >* ( " * "4" $ $" % $%.%%"$"("4/*$%!4 "
>* "(*"% 8!"$%& 44"/*%%"**#!"5& &(4*%" %%(%"&4**$5%.*$%!4 "5 *%%((6!"$%&55(/(5(& %&$%*($
*%%( 4/"% : /".
(&"% 1*/%!%%"*"!4*!(
*/*"("!("*%"544 *"!4**""
>*""$"4!$/5&("!( " * !" $%& * "5!"& 4(4$!**"/4*(("!;*!(
9 */;*%"%"%"!5"/4*"" *( "/4*"!;*(5"/*"!;4*" *$."!((&54*"!;4*"!;4 *" >*"".5;**"/"*"!;4 *" "%5("**"*!(5; ***;%(! !(*"/" "*$ "5!"&4(4 >* *$( !(*%%4**$% $!*!(5"!*@"5!"&4(4*
>* "4(&5&("!( %%"4 " * "% "4 (" !( " * "%.*!"$%&*;&!*%(* "$/ !*"4" >*"".
5;5"5!"&4(4
" *"4 (" !( " * %" 44 *"!4**"". **!5$$5&("!( "*!"$%&* "5!"&4(4 5% >*%"3($*(!4*"( (( !$"&/* ***;%( ! "4%";4*4"!;*" *! 4/4&* %";*" !*.5; **"*"!(4&5!*"!;4 *"* >**;%(5!18 $ * "(&$"4*!". *!&*(4*B!$
>*" *4 * * (( ( " >* %"3($*/@$,E >(5. **%"/* & !* 7!* *!5$ * /A@ ,E 3 ****!((&!%%"** ($4***;%(! 4(4"% 5& "4%";4*4"!;
*$(*" '"!("*!"$%&* *,E >(5**"@$** (%4 *$*.*"".*5;5& F! $/5&* 7$ 5 *( 5(" %;!% !@4/"$"
A/*" . +"4"4 **54"4"4"/"*4"!;
* +*"4"!$5"*4"!; (($ "/""%((&$
. 5"/* *"/"
"!"*"/4*(%"$(! **!""!"*4(4"/4 +%
!$$!%*!"4%* 5@ ** 4(4**%!*5";%.. 5"**""&*"*4*$4" **"!; 4*" 7$("(&."% "*"!;4*$"" >*"".* /!5&*($*4!"5!
"4"*!*"&""5&("!("* !"$%&
! "
#
$$ %&&
%&&'5&*%@#!" *" *( (4 */!(& *"!; %";$(*" *!%";4(4**""/" "/4"$(% 1 ;$%*. 4(4**"/*($4"$%% ".4**"!;(&($!!(/* "!(4**.*:4*#!"*(*"/"5** /*( "B!((&4(4!*4 !%*(5&*%@ #!"
$&/ *<!4$*(%** %%(($!* E**"" "5!"&4(4 4. **54/;%4/ * "!$**/!5&*%" *"5&*""!(* */*(**" /*(%";*".5;"5!"& 4(4 >*<!4$"""5&("!("*!" $%&*(%*$/4* >*"".*%( "5!"&4(4%!" "5&("!("*!" $%&!5 *!&$""<
>*@"4!$%!" "5&("!("* %%(( **$%$! "*4*" */$!(&%"!*"" ** ("!("*%" **>"5!(;44 *58189&"*/"!;"/"*
;*$*(&$5+ .
3"<4* ($** "4+ .
3%"$*"$*/
!(5! **%%"**>"5!(4
: /".*>"5!(*$9 C$! " !!"%"%. */ *<!4$ ( "
#
)
* ! $ %&+ , && (& 1 C * $! *!( */ 5 "!!"%"% 4**$*(&$* ;+ .
G1.
H+ 1.
3 >*>"5!(*"4*(&$!31* $! "%"((/4@%*/ " !*"& $
- . )
) $ %&&' , ++ $ 4 * * %&($$!+ .9
3%"$*.!( %&$!+ .9
@ H+ . .
3
>*>"5!(*!$!(%(". **;%4 / *4**5%"%"(&! 4** $%%&5($!+ . .
@H ..
3
>*>"5!(* "!$+ (;* "( "!$*($3%" 8. * .
+ (* (/ + 9.
3 " !"( @% : /"./ *"!*"&( "
#
)
* ! $ !%".*($ "(4$%!"/(* + 9.
3 !(.+ .
3 "("!$
+ 9.
3!"(@%.(+ .
3 >*($% $!+ ..
G .
H ..
3
>* >"5!( * "4(& " $% + 1. .
3 >*$ "! +
..
3 >* ($ !(5(4"I 9C%"!$"$*(4 * ($ % (( !( "(D * $! +
..
3 *""$*"4( "*(( "$*$
7 * $! * 5 "!. * " * "4""($%$!*($* *"4"@%*(($%"%"(& *$!$%*("&5%5&* !"$%&.*($*(("!*$* !" #$%&*" * !"#$%&*((5("/" *"$!"$*($%"( 5& &(4 @!%%(5"*>"5!(
E*!*$.*%%((( %"(& *
F"<
!"#$ %&"'
!()$* "&#
'# !+,
"&#