High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/8660/2015disposed of

Oriental Insurance Co Ltd v. Runa Devi & ORS

2018-08-30Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

!"#$ !%& #!' ()"* ++ $$#!"

, %&% &!# -#!*(".

% %+(!* !"% /0

&!# -#!*(".

% ++ $$#!"% , %&% !1#$2#334!1#$#335#!*(".

% %+(!* !"% 678)6 678)6 678)6 678)6 % !" % !" % !" % !" )#$"# *-('#" 9( ". #++ $$#!" !( (9

6%1"#.#1&

*-('#" 9( ". #++ $$#!"% !( /0(9

)#$"# *-('#" 9( %+(!* !"(

!( /0(9

:;:;:;

.%( %.#$$*%+(% (9(% (9

#!*

/0 (9

#% <(". ". % #++ #$% # % (&" (9 #=# * *#" * 0/

+#%% * <> ". 6("( ''* !" $#?% <&!#$

.#!*3# .

9$> "?#>< !("' *".#"#'$#?+ ""(!=#%9$ *

&!* '"(! (9". 6("( , .'$ %'"

@49( %.( "".

@'"85<>". =*(= !#? $> &!# -#!*9(& ?!( %(!% (9#?<*.#!4%!' * ' #% *5=.(* *(!

0*& "( !A& % %&99 * <> .? ! #! #''* !" ".#" "((1 +$#' (!

0 !". '$#?+ ""(!

"=#%#-

*".#"". * ' #% * =#%=( 1!3#%# '& ">&# *=".6B%($*C. $ -#"

)?" * .#%

!*&%"

#$ # .#!*3# .#!*.#-!39!%. * .%*&">(!

0. =#%+ (' *!3(!.%<'>'$ #"

+?=. ! . =#%%"

&'1 <> #'# < # !3 (7 77 @ =.'. =#% < !3 * - ! ! # #%. #!* ! 3$3 !" ?#!!

#?<*.#! %&99 * ?&$"+$ !A& % #!* =#% ?? *#" $>

?(- *"((- !? !"(%+"#$ '"( .#!*3# .!#!

&!'(!%'(&%'(!*"(!#!*=#% - !

*"(

.#!*3# . (= -

. %&''&?< *"(.%!A& %%&99 *!". #''* !"

#!** *(!

0. '$#?#!"%#%% " *".#"". * ' #% * =#% %(9#3 #!*=#% # !!3%/

?(!".#!* =#%". %($ < #*7 # !

!". 9#?$> !#?(&!"(9%

$#1.%=#%'$#? *"(=# *%'(?+ !%#"(!

. '$#?+ ""(!.#-!3< !'(!" %" * ". 9($$(=!3 %%& %= 9 #? *<>". <&!#$

C. ".

* ' #% * #?<*.#! * * ! # ?("(

- .'&$# #''* !"

=.'."((1+$#' *& "( #%.#!* ! 3$3 !" * -!3 (9 '# (7 77 @ <>

%+(!* !"( D

C. ".

". '$#?#!"% # !""$ * "( 3 "

'(?+ !%#"(! (! #''(&!" (9 * #". (9 * ' #% * #?<*.#!!#?("( - .'&$# #''* !"D

C. ".

". %+(!* !"( =#%!(".($*!3#-#$* -!3$' !' #"". "? (9#''* !"D 0 $ 9

0 . <&!#$ ! ". #=# * *#" * 0/

"& ! * 9!*!3%&!* %%& ( !9#-(& (9". '$#?#!"%#!*. $*".#"

* #".(9#?<*.#!.#*(''&

*(!#''(&!"(9!A& %%&99 !". #''* !"(!#''(&!"(9 #%.#!*! 3$3 !"* -!3(9".

- .'$ !E& %"(!

!%(9# #% %%& ( % '(!'

! * # "("#$ '(?+ !%#"(!#?(&!"(9%

B7.#%< !#=# * *#$(!3 =".!"

%"2/ F+ #!!&?9 (?". *#" (99$!3(9".

'$#? + ""(! "$$ #'"&#$ #$G#"(! C.$ * "

?!!3 %&'.

'(?+ !%#"(!#?(&!"

". <&!#$.#%#'' +" *". #3 (9".

* ' #% *"(< %. ?(!".$>!'(? .#%< !#%% %% * "( < %/ B7 + ?(!".

B0". * *&'"(! .#% < ! ?#* "(=# *% + %(!#$ #!* $-!3 H+ !% % (9 ". * ' #% * #!* # ?&$"+$ (9

.#%< !#++$ *"(#%% %%$(%%(9* + !* !'> .#"#+# "

# F!'

#% =#%3 #!" *"(=# *%$(%%(99&"&

(%+ '"% %&? (9 % $#1. .#% < ! #=# * * "(=# '(!%( "&?#!*#%&?(9%

B79( 9&!

#$#!*$#%" " % . $#<$">"(+#>". '(?+ !%#"(!#?(&!".#%< !. $*"(< A(!"#!*% - #$< "= !". !%& #!' (?+#!>#%#$%((=!

- (9". - .'$ ( (9

% #" ". .#!*% (9 !"#$

!%& #!' (?+#!>)?" *(&!% $9( ". #++ $$#!"7 !%& #!'

(?+#!>.#%'(!9! *". %'(+ (9". #++ #$(!$>=". 3# "(E&#!"&?(9'(?+ !%#"(! ".#%< !# 3& *".#"=".(&"

< !3 #!> '$!'.!3 -* !' .#-!3 < ! #**&' * ".

!'(? (9". * ' #% *.#%< !#%% %% *?

$>(!%& ?% % #!*'(!A '"& %#"%/ ?(!".

#%"(&3.""(.#-

< !#%% %% *!("?( ".#!%

?(!".=.'.=#%".

?!?&?=#3 %#*?%%<$ "(#!&!%1$$ *=( #"". $ -#!"

+(!"(9"? ".#%< !# 3& *".#"". <&!#$.#%

3-!3#!#**"(!(9 F"(=# *%9&"& + (%+ '"% =.

#%!

". 9#'"% (9 ". '#% %!' ". * ' #% * =#% ! ".

# (- !? !" ?+$(> !( #+ ?#! !" ?+$(> !(#**"(!"( !'(? (!%&'.'(&!"%.(&$*.#- < !3 #!" * ".#%#$%(< !

# 3& *".#"". '$#?#!"%.#*9#$ *"(+ (- (! '( *". #3 (9 * ' #% *"(< %#!* - !!". +(%"?( " ? +( "

#3 .#*< !? !"(! *#% %#++ (H?#" $> 6 #!!3 ".

<>".#"". #3 %.(&$*.#- < !"#1 !#%?( ".#!

> # % #!* '(!% E& !"$> # ?&$"+$ (9

#% (++(% * "(

%.(&$*.#- < !#++$ *"(". ?&$"+$'#!* "%9& ".

& 3 * ".#" - !". #?(&!"(9% $#1.#=# * *"(". =*(="(=# $(%%(9'(!%( "&?%?&'.(!". .3.

%* / ( /0(9

%#"". .#!*%(9". '$#?#!"% % 1!3 !.#!' ? !" (9 '(?+ !%#"(! ) # ! * '(&!% $

% !"!3". '$#?#!"%.#%# 3& *".#"". * ' #% * =#% =( 1!3#%# '& ">&# *#!* # !!3%/

?(!".

#!*!( "(+ (- %&'.!'(?

". + (+ "( (9". 9 ?.

=# !3. .#* < ! H#?! * #% C

<&" * %+" %&'.

'$!'.!3 -* !'

". <&!#$.#%#%% %% *". ?(!".$>!'(?

"( < %/ B7 + ?(!". !%" #* (9 %/

B7 + ?(!". & ".

# 3& *".#"". * ' #% *=#%?#!"#!!3#$# 3 9#?$> (99- ? ?< % =*(=#!*9(& ?!( %(!%#!*&!* %&'.

+ '&$# '

'&?%"#!' % ". * *&'"(!"(=# *%+ %(!#$#!*$-!3 H+ !% %%.(&$*.#- < ! ".(9". %#$# >!%" #*(9 B0".

".#"". <&!#$.#%?#* ) # ! *'(&!% $'(!" !*%".#"".

<&!#$.#%!("#=# * *#!>#?(&!"&!* ". . #*(9$(%%(9 $(- #!*#99 '"(!#!*9( =.'.% $#1. #'."(". ?!( %(!% %.(&$*.#- < !#=# * * "#!(".

%&<?%%(! #% *%".#"

". <&!#$ .#% !(" #=# * * #!> #?(&!" "(=# *% ? *'#$ "

#"? !"B H+ !% %!'&

*9( ". + (*".#"". * ' #% *.#*

?#! * #*?"" * ! .(%+"#$ &+"( .% *#" (9 * #".

0 #-!3. # *$ # ! *'(&!% $9( ". +# " %#"$ !3".

!<(".". #++ #$%#!*.#-!3#$%(+ &% *". ( 3!#$ '( (9 ". '#% ".#" .#* < ! E&%"(! * ".% (& " % (9 ".

'(!%* *- =".#"". '(?+ !%#"(!#?(&!"#=# * *<>".

<&!#$ =(&$* E& '

"#! #*A&%"? !"% <> #++$>!3 ".

+# #? "

%$#**(=!<>". + H(& "!". '#% (9#"(!#$ #"(!#$ #"(!#$ #"(!#$

!%& #!' (?+#!>)?" *- #!#> ".#!*(".

/405

!%& #!' (?+#!>)?" *- #!#> ".#!*(".

/405

!%& #!' (?+#!>)?" *- #!#> ".#!*(".

/405

!%& #!' (?+#!>)?" *- #!#> ".#!*(".

/405 4-$5 @ 4-$5 @ 4-$5 @ 4-$5 @ @ % 3# *% ". ?(!".$> !'(? (9 ". * ' #% * % '(!'

! * ". '$#?#!"%.#*#-

*!". '$#?+ ""(!".#".

=#% # !!3#%&?(9%/

?(!".=.$ =( 1!3#%# '& ">&# *$#?#!"%.#- H#?! *C =#!3.=.( .#** +(% *".#". =#%#% -' + (-* #!*.#*9#'$"#" * ". !3#3 ? !"(9#?<*.#!4* ' #% *5#%# '& ">&# =".6B%($*C. $-")"* $("(/ .#%

!*&%"

#$ #

.#!*3# .(!#?(!".$>%#$# >(9%/

B7C * +(% * ".#". =#%". (+ "( (9 =#1 '& "> -' %#!*#$%( (*&' *". ( 3!#$#"" !*#!' 3%"

!=.'.". !#? (9 #?<*.#!.#*< !*&$> !"

* *$ %%"((<% - ".#"#%#

% -' + (-*

=#1 '& "> -' %?&%"< * *&'"!3# %?#$$ #?(&!" - > ?(!". 9 (? ". %#$# > (9 ". * ' #% * "(=# *% ".

'(??%%(! !* %&'. '

'&?%"#!' % !( H' +"(!'#!< ?#* "(". #%% %%? !"?#* <>". <&!#$ (9". ?(!".$>!'(? (9". * ' #% *"(< %/ B7

C &!# - ". =*(=.#%#++ # *!".

="! %%<(H#!*.#** +(% *". #3 (9.

.&%<#!*"(<

> # % - !". +(%"?( " ? +( " 9$ '"%". #3 "(<

> # %#++ (H?#" $>. <&!#$ #%%&'.

.#% 3."$>#'' +" * ". #3 (9". * ' #% *"(< %#!*.#%#++$ *".

?&$"+$ (9

. <&!#$.#%?#* #* *&'"(!(9 B0". "(=# %(!#$#!*$-!3 H+ !% %(9". * ' #% *&'.- =% #% 3&* $! %%%& *<>". + H(& "!". '#% (9 #!#> #!#> #!#> #!#> ".#!*(".

% ".#!*(".

%4%&+ #5=.

!"=#%. $*".#"!#'#% (90 "(* + !* !"% #* *&'"(!(9 B0".9 (?". ?(!".$>%#$# >< ?#*

. <&!#$ .#% #=# * * # F !'

#% "(=# 9&"& + (%+ '"% *?"" *$> ". * ' #% * =#% ! ".

(- !? !" % -' !( (! # + ?#! !" A(< % + #!#> #!#> #!#> #!#> ".8% ".8% ".8% ".8%'#% 4%&+ #5 #+ %(!=.(=#%% $97 ?+$(> *#!*=#%!

". #3 (90 "( % #!#**"(!(9

F(&3.""(< 3 #!" * "(=# *%$(%%(99&"& + (%+ '"% "%%(* '" *

. #?(&!"#=# * *<>". <&!#$(9%

B7 % $#1."(=# *%$(%%(9'(!%( "&?#!*%

B7"(=# 9&!

#$ H+ !% % # !(= %'#$ * *(=! #" %/ B7 %

B7 "(=# *% $(%% (9 %"#"

%0 B7"(=# *% $(%% (9

/ '(!%( "&? #!* %

B7 "(=# *% 9&!

#$ H+ !% % &'.

* *&'"(!%< !3* '" *#3#!#%+ +# #? "

%$#**(=!!

#!#> ".8% #!#> ".8% #!#> ".8% #!#> ".8%'#% 4%&+ #5

0 . ( 3!#$ '( *%=(&$* - #$".#"". '$#?#!"% .#*#**&' **('&? !"# > -* !' H.<"%0"( ".

? *'#$ <$$% "(=# *% +& '.#% (9 ? *'! "' #?(&!"!3 "( %

B7 ".#" .#* < ! !'&

* (! ". "

#"? !" (9 ".

* ' #% *9 (?". *#" (9". #''* !"

0#!*&+"( .% * #". (!

0 . <&!#$ .#% '(?+$ " $> (- $((1 *". %#? . #?(&!" 9$ '" *!". ? *'#$<$$% H.<"%0"( %

B7 (&!* *(99"(%

B7%#%%&'.

#=# * *!9#-(& (9". '$#?#!"%

!- =(9". #<(- ". '(?+ !%#"(!#?(&!"% #%% %% *#!*'#$'&$#" *#%9($$(=% ( #* ?(&!" 6(!".$>!'(? #%#%% %% *<> ". <&!#$ %/

F !'

#% "(=# *% 9&"&

(%+ '"% / I

FJ /

B0". * *&'"(!

"(=# %(!#$#!*$-!3 H+ !% %(9 ". * ' #% * /

(?+ !%#"(! #9"

#++$>!3 ?&$"+$ (9

6 *'#$<$$%B"

#"? !"'.# 3 % %

(!- !"(!#$. #*% $(%%(9 %"#" %

B7 $(%% (9 '(!%( "&?%0 B7 9&!

#$ H+ !% %%

B7 %/

/ ("#$ %

@0 @/B7

. #9( 7'#$'&$#" *B -% *'(?+ !%#"(!#?(&!"<

$ #% *!9#-(& (9". #++ $$#!"%9( ".=".. #" (9!"

#!" *<>". <&!#$!". #=# **#" *0/

%.#$$ ?#!

!"#'"

/ ++ #$%# *%+(% *(9!". #9( %#*"

?% 4 5 4 5 4 5 4 5

6 6 6 6 (" (" (" (" C. ".

%+ #1!3B #%(! * %B( C. ".

+( "#<$ %B(