High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/371/2014allowed

Nirmal Kaur v. Kirpal Singh

2017-12-02Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh16 pages

# $%&%!'(

) ) )))**

))))+ ( ,* ) + ) )+) ,* ) + + +

" #$

" %

! &&& + +- )

) ! '( ") '*++"

"," -$ . - / 0" ! " ! .," /0,1

! ! $ , $ - "$-- , , ,- ", !2 3 $,$ ! " " ! " ! " , , ! " !, -$

566'56'7 -$ # !

-" -$," ) % !$ " !

! 57 ") !," -$.," !! .8 (6 6669. : " 5+ 6669.; ! " ! ! -$ 3 6(6(56'+ ! " . -

"$;6<6+56'+ " , -$ ! " ,!,

, 3 !

. - $ " '+ 6669. , :-$: "'<6=56'+ "-2

";'<6=56'+ , -$! " " " $ " $ " : ! , # 6=6*56'+ ;6=6*56'+ :, $,"

3 ! ! ! 57 ") ! 2 - - ! .8 56 6669. " "! !..," - -$ . - $ - $ ! " : " 5+ 6669., > , # 56'656'+" $ " "! ) ;56'656'+ ! . - !

, 6=6*56'+ $, ! "! ",! "!, -

- !2 ""; # 6<'556'+ ! $"" ," -$

! "! 3 !2 "" "! "

. -

) >!," # , '66=56'?

1 -$! " , -" 3 ! 3 "3 " !- " >, ! -" 3 ! 3 "3 > ! - -,>! , " ('6+56'<,! " ! -" " $ !- " ! >3 1 "! " ! " 5+6=56'< " $ . -

- $ - ! ! $ ! ) , 3

5+6=56'< # !" '5'656'< " $ -" 3 "# ! .) @ " - "! ""! -

! .8 56 , # 9 ! "$ - $ ! " "! ! 57 " ) !," : " 5+ 6669.

6=6*56'+ - 2 ""

"! " . - 6<'556'+

" ! - # !!

" 1 "! ,!"

! - 3 ('6+56'<,! ! !- ,- - ! ! # " $ ! 3 , ! ! " ," $ ! $ , -$ 3 >

.," " "" " $

-!- "$ " .

- " -$ %

! , - . -

! $ "! . - "

!! "! " - $ ," $

-$ ! $, -$3 !-$ !!$ $ /) @ ) - , ! 1 !" .! ! " ! 57 " !> $ - "" :! " ! 5=.

" )

!" ! $ " "! .,

--,! - $ ! - ! , ,!$$ !>,

" $ " ,! ! 57 ")

! - " ! " ! " " ,! -$ " , - ""@ , $9 ,

$ " ! ! , -" : " " "

" ) $ " ! : , "!$,2 " -$ ! " !,!,- 9"!$,2 ! " " !9! " -$, ""!$%$$, $-$ " ! 57 ") !- $ " ) !> !$! -$ ! ) ! ! 5'.,! 3 ! ! ,: " "! " -$ $ $ !

$ , @ $ ! ! -$$ "

1 : "A -! ,, "2$ ! , " , ," $

! 0) >

,3 ! ! , " -, " "!" "

! $ !2 , ! ! ! 9 " $ - $

!-$ 3 , ! ! ! ! ! "$@"

" ," $! 9 " ! $,

/ !- ,$ " -1 "! ! 1 !@!! ! $-$$ " " ", "# !, "

!$ ,!- " , ! - !$,

" , ! $-$! $, -$ 3 $ !" A "

! 57 ") !-$ 2! :! ! , - $ - ! , 3 , " " ""! " - 9 ! !: $ ,! 1 " @! ! ! !, ! ! " ! 57 " !

" "# ! , " " -$3 9" >, " ! 9 ! $, "3 @ , -$ " ! ", 1) 3 ! $ " " "B@3 , " - ""!! !" ! $ "

B ) >!- !3 -!$ "

" >3 , $

- ! 5' ") ,!23 ! '*6=!- ! "$- -#! ") ! )3 $2-" )

! 3 ! 3 /" " C33C0!- ! , ,) ! " $ $ - ! '+'33" " ! " ! 57 ") !- > ! '+'33 ,3 -$! " ,,!-3 2 ! $- !$" "# ! - " ! " 3 ) > ) C- 3 ! " 2& 4 '#

'# +!'& +56 %88& 9) *#:

'4 ;

* 4

'# !4 7&-

@ '*?? 3'=** " ! '+' "

3 "3 ! !- 2 -$3 ,!! " , 3 2 ! $-!$" "# ! - " ! "3 3 - ,""! , "3 " , - " @-!"

" -$) C- 3 < 7 # $!= +!&

9 764 &

'# !4 7& 5667/?0 33(<= , " 3

! $ ,! " "3 ! :$ -$! > ,, - :! "! , ! ! "!,$ " , :$ -$ !$ ! ! " -$ "3 ;-#! " ! '+'33

: "33 /7 ") +

)) 9&) !&4 '

+%'64-

000) , , ! '+' "3 "3 ! ! -:! . )

-#! - !- 3 ! :! , ! '+'33 -$3 ! 57 ") !""!

! ,, !"!""! $ ! ) ! 3 "3 ! " ! ! " ! !$ ""! " -

! :! "

! ,,!! ! 2 , "! " , ! A

!! ! $ " , ! " # ! " $ " 2 ! ,> ! ! , $9 9 - ! $, -$3 - , 3 -" $ , 2 " ! '+' "3 "3 ! ! 2 ,!!- " " 9 $9, !$ - ) >3 !! !, -$ 3 ! 57 ") ! - ! , ! 2 "" "! " , "!$-

"! !- # -$3

=58 +%'64 8>%'# 7 :

57-'**+/'0)D (7'

57?7 +%'64 '>% :

56''/50)D 7=* +4 '% 9%+4 * 8- '**7/'0 )D 56+ +4 8

9% 5735@4 +%'64 E ; .' "566=

! 5(6*56'' .) - 2 "! " . - - -$3 6<'556'+

! '+'33" .! ! " -$3 6=6*56'+ - , /) @! ! 57 ") !- -$)3 ! " " ! . : $! ,!" -$! " ! ! 9 ! , 3 ! ! ! ! )

) ,!,- -! -$3 ! 5(/'0/0 ,! !"!$-" " ! " ! )

! $2 " ,, -$" " !">3 :! " ! , ! $ " " 0)

! 5( ") ! " ! , $ "3 ,! $ "! A !>! ! ! """ $

" "1 - " "-$ -

- "! "3 >! "

"!, "! #! " > -$ ! 3 $ 1 ", !" " "

!$ ! $ - 2! "-" ! " !- - , ! ! ! ! !$

$ ,!- - "",$$ !

,!"- 1) ! 5( ") ! " , F5(%! ! /'0@$ !

, " "! " .

/0 $ " " ": G:!!," -$ !" -.! /0 -.! /-0 -.

! /!0 "! /0 "! +H $,$2 " ,, -$" " !"

/-0, "

!" G&&&H! /0 " -.! /'0 "! '( $-!! $ !

! ! !! "

, " ! $ $ ! ! $

G/--0, ! " ! !! - - -$" ! " " !

/!0G / - ! ''0H ! ! ,

/ 0 -$ !$ $ !

/0 ,$" -

!! - , ! ! !"!! $ /50" ! $" - $ "! "! $! , - ! $,

!! ! "! 2$ - - ! ! -, G ! -.! $ $ ! ," $ "

!" ! /0 ! /0 ! /0

! /0 ! /0 ! /0 " -.! /'0 " ! '(H G/(0E " ! -- ! ! ! ! $ " " ! 2 #

# ! " - :! "" $ " $ -$ -" $ -$! " " $ , ! ! ,! ! !- - ""!

! " !

H G/70@$!, -$ ! "

! ! !! $ "

" "! ! "HI > ,! ! " "

,!!- ) ! !!- , $,$ 2 " ,,

-$" " !"!

)

" -.

! /'0/0 " ! 5( ") ! ! - !3 "

$-- - " "

- 2 $,$ " ,, -$" "" > ! ! " - -$ " ", " ! !- >" -"! "3 -2-$ ", -$ -- " "" !> - ! "# !, - 2 " ,, -$, 2" "3 $ ! >, C, C -! ! !-$$ ,! $"

" ! - - ! > C, C ! ,!! # $ ,!, - " !

, ",- " ! 5(/'0/0 ") ! >" ,! , - ,

! 5(/'0/0 ") !, - "!

!! ! "!! ) > 1 , - !-$ "$ " ! . 9 : -$ 3 ! 57 ") ! $ 9 " J! ! ! " ! ! , , " ! 5( ") !

2 "" " ""B )

! ! " %7 $4 '# +7%'%9 & '

!'@ +5'

566'/70 33'5+ ,3 ,

, " ! 5( " ,.

F'5 :::

:::

> $ "

! 5( , $ !

! $! 3 !" $"! -.! "

,:::

:::

:::I >3 " , ,. -

-$ " $! ," ! C, C, " ! 5( ,2" " ! 2 " ,, ;! 3 -$" $! ," " ! - -$! , , " ! 5( "

) !@," ! 5(/'0/0

" " " ! " ! $$ , "" :- ! "! $- !3 " $,$

2 " ,, -$" "

!">3 "$ - " $ ! ," $ " !! ! ! -$- $! , " ,"- " !! $ $ ! - - 2 " C, C" " "

! !! !! " ! -- -$ 3 , - ""! " ! " ! ) >3 +5=4 &+4 8

9% 566</'0 /30 '?+ % 4 6A :

38 &4 566+/(0 /30557

, - " $! .

: - $ !! " - , ! ,

! 5( ") ! "! -$ ) !

) @ , " - .$ "

! . 9 : -$ ! -$3 $-

, , , " ! 5( ") ! ! 2 "9

,, "! )

! .) ), 1 , , ! ! ! @! -$3 -! , - . - ! , "

! 1 " ! "

! . -

, ! !-

! - !-" 3 , $ "! . : ! - -$3 >3 ", - ! ,! " ! 5(/'0/0 ") . - -$ $ ! . :, ! , 2 " ,, " "! " " ! ,! . ! !>

- , ".,"" /) @ , " - 3 ! ! 1 "! " !2 "" 6<'556'+>""! " . -

" .

- ! " -$ ! '( " ) ! :!$ ", ! $ ", !

- , # ! 566'56'7 -$

%!4 - 5< ; !! $ 5= %!- ,

))+)

+ +

$ 3= 7

'#-

B4 4 7 &?

@%'627 &!' #(

&2!

B4 4 7 ?!7 =8 (

&2!