Sumitra Devi v. State Of Haryana And Another




  
 


 

 



  !!

 "# $

!% &!

 

 !"#$

%&'()$ %$'" *%

!'

()*$#+,$-&

."

$% ) ()/%0,$-)))-#) ()))10-&

."

!% & )2) %$'" *% %
+,
!  %   $!  *  "0&  &  .   452  ) %#,"

6!$, )785&&4)4)2922&. !49:& 429
,!&

- ;$,-!., 0 ,1$00$!*!6% .&,!!,$"  $*!! ""& <.

!&&89)5)2922=>

2?)

6! 1!, ,!&*#.

%0 !% & )2  &  $   !,   .

.&  $ )   1 -  1$  $   "!%.*0!-"00#$%! &!0&$# !

&$!&!%-1$.$!%%" $.

!) $*!! "$!-$% !

;,$$% 1 "$!

*#%#,$.

"$!% .&,!1 0&*"0 >.!&*! "% .!! "$ &$!-$ 6!

&00$!*!6% .&,!!,$" #*6!$&$ ! "+!.)

$!  & &!&&89)@)2922&.&$%!

%%  *"

  $  0   <
006  (,!  "

  .

&,  $ !!-  !  .

&&  *"

  $     &  $  0   <
006 (,!1!0!

&.& !&!% )
  %!.    $  !-  0&  (
-  &  !  $!

.

 % &&72)7)2928$!% & ( ( 445@5 2922

$! )A$$% $$!0!

>&$ ,0!! .

%0)$0 &..!&<% .

&&

2@)77)2922) $*!! "$!!-0&(
- &$!

.

.0&&$% $%%!$$%!$ &  .

!

00#&$$! $..!&$%! .!&$% <..!&$!*&.0&  .0& ""& 1 .!!)) )BB&&:)2)297@& )7925 "297@& !. !7B4 


-. B- &*&) C&.

!0"

$% !*!$$&!%!

 ,$"0#*!&!. 0)!*!$" ,! * $$%!1$$  "!%.*0!

$ .

!&$) C&  .

!0  "

  $  .

%0  $!  ""&  $ !*!! !&*#.

!0"

% &$!*!$.

%0 $! *+. "$ 6! !6!$&)
$ $&0&.

!0"

$%!-%!&$.

& &$% !*#0&(
- &)$.

!$!* "".&$%!.!& $.!!% .&,!&.

7B4 
,!$% %&,&!$!* & ".$ .

!6.!!%01)

*%!0 "! #%

! "$452) ))1 0& !$ 1$$,$ #;!.$ &!-!#*.!!#

, "". # &&$! &  % *! "$% .!!

"#   $1! !.$&! "+!.). 829) !600#0 "

.

!& -1$.$%!.*!$% .&"

 .

% &, "$ "".!&$
& 0 &) /%, 1$ "".!00,&0#.

& &$".$* $$%!$ .*0#!0&$&!%-$ .

".0% !. 1 0&*"0>.!)$ D*0 % * ".!!.0&,
 



   



  B.S.Joshi and others !State of Haryana -.+
 '/0+1/+ "

1&*#$!  00.$.! "3/,4-+'5.- .+6 '7/89-.+:    $ &0 1$$% % ! 

&$%!.!&!0&$01) $"- D*0% Gian Singh ;State of Punjab and another
  '/0+1/+   "$&0 1$$!!&$001!0&*#$% "

6!$,

"$ State of Haryana ;Bhajan Lal: <<'/00
'

)

:7 "$+&,&!!&'





 

 









 





 

 !

 


"


#





   


 




 
  




$


%&'





  








 (





 "



 



 


 




 )*
+ ,


 
#

-

+

,


 


 


(




   

  
 !
(

"

 









 


 
   




 

 

 



  (


  
 -
 
"



-








 
 

(

 
  



  


 

(



.
-
 -


(-
 


 

 (










/


(










 
$




  
 




  

(
$

 (- (
  


 
















.
0







1 


 


(








 .



 

(-
 *


 
 
( 

 


  

 


 
2 


 
  (
 3

 (
 

  




 



 





-


  (




  
  -
  -


-
 

-
  



.
 

 





 
  ( 



 (-
 




(





 





(
  



 




 


 





 


  (

 -


(

 

 -



  


 






-




(

 





 .

 







 
  
 
 

 

 
# 

"


#


  

 

 
( 




 










  











  -
  



 


 

  

 
  (

 


#



 







 

 




 
  

  
 
 





  


 






  
  


 
#

-

   







 
 



+ ,


 

-







#


 4 %%0#,$01!0&*# D*0% %0$ 

"+&,!&$!,$ -!%%$1$$%!$  & .

!-$.

"$% .&,!1 0&* 0#*! "% .!! "$ &*#00 1,&..%,$ %# "$% !*#6!$,$ 1 0&*!.,$&! +!.- 1$.$!%0#$ *+. "$0,!0.,& . 452) !!0-$! "&!$$.!$&!60#"00! 1$$*&%!!0&*#+&.0%.&!&$.-

)785&&4)4)2922&. !49:&429
,!&

- ;$,-!.,&00$!*!6 % .&,!!,$" 6!$&6$%  $*!! $.

!)

&0!! !#$$%!!$00* &*#$ ! &.

& ! "$.

! &$!!.

&& *"

$.

*0 1)

 !&!00 1&) 
%$'" *%    %&=$

 

0.;# A$$!%;,<!

&'

!<

A$$ % *0'

!<