High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/410/2014dismissed

Karma v. Sonia

2015-01-19Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri7 pages

!"#"$%&''( ) *+ '''',, -- $'

. *#/# 0$"

'''

#,$1 $'

0% *' *1 ,0"$23415!

*3 $'

3 $3/#6 $1 67 8 7 "$# $ - 3 !3 -- $2 13 9/12+ $ $11 !* 1 1'&', ## 1673 11""$ - "#*"! /12 4

4 83 * 67 3 , ""$ "- 1 67 3 * #,$1 $8" /$1 *0 !"$: 3 "$1/ 2 !4&(( "$#3*;3 !< *1"##-/"$+ 2 67 1 !* 1"5*! 48

--8 1' '

$# /$ ## $"

-#4 3 !# 3 !

# * 3 3 *" #8 ##- +$"= 1$>':' 5"-- 2 13$ 3#"-

* $4"#*"!

!!*1"$2"$1/* -"2"/#*" #' 3 6"*33 * #,$1 $"#'('&&> $1 3 "+ + 2 4 #3 8 #+"$* $18 #$!+, $2"5 3 *!$# $*3 2 ' 3 "+ 43 !$# $+3 *3 * #,$1 $8 6 "$ 167*! $1/$1/ "$-/ $! 83"!38 #$6"$1"$2$3

* #,$1 $' *3 #- +$"= "$3 + 2 43 * #,$1 $3 $9"$ 13 !+, $73 $ $13/#43 "*+ 2 8 #$ !$#/++ 1# *'03 3 16 $* #"1"$28"33 *, * $#'8 ?

,*"*3 "-"$23 1"5*! , ""$43 $ -$28"33"# +"-7+ +6 *# $1#+ ,-"! "!"

-#5"#" 13 , * $ -3/# 3 * #,$1 $*!"6-7 ? 3 * 7'3 * #,$1 $!

+ ?$8

6/3 # "1+ 2 $-7 3 "+ ' !!*1"$2-74#3 "- 1

, ""$* $$/--"$23 + 2 67 1 !* $/--"7' 3 # "1 , ""$8 #!$ # 1673 $67"-"$2 8*" $# + $'

#"1 #* "#"$25 *"/#,* -"+"$ *769 !"$#4"8 #,- 1 13 3 +3 * 3 * #,$1 $ 3 1 2"5 $ 3 * !$# $ 5-/$ *"-7' 3

$ 1+" 13 #"$! 3 1 + 2 43 , *" #3 1$ !3 6" 12 3 * $13 "*+ 2 3 1$6 $!$#/++ 1' #/*3 *,- 1 13 #, *3 !/#+,* 5 - $"$3 "*"* *"3 2 #8 * #- +$"= 1"$ #"+,- 8 71/*"$23 +"$*"73 , *#$# $1/?- ! * +$783 * "$3 6*"1 2*+ ? #3 6*"6 3"#3/# 8 #6 "$2, **+ 1 *3 7

2 + 9*"7'

3 * 8 #!/#+"$3 !++/$"7*3 + 2 67 @!3 $2 "' '

0 7 0

?'5 $3 + 2 3 #"# *3 $ # #- +$"= 1 8"3 3 !/#"$ 3 * #,$1 $' A3 $ 3 * #,$1 $

"$ 1 3 2 + 9*"74 3 $4 3"# +"-7 + +6 *# $13 ** - "5 # ,,* !3 13 , * $#3 * #,$1 $ *, **+ $! /?- ! * +$76/3 7* /# 1, **+3 + ' 3 3 * 5 *+ $#+ 1 "$3 , ""$8 * 1 $" 1 $1

,* 7 **1"#+"## -3 # + 8 #+ 1 ' *+3 ,- 1"$2#3 , *" #43 *"

-!/** + 13 --8"$2"##/ #% ;'

A3 3 *3 , ""$ *8 #- ##3 $(7 *#

2 3 "+ 3 * + 2 8"3 3 * #,$1 $B

A3 3 * 3 , ""$ * 3 # * ,/1"

1 3 2 6 *

"$"$2 3 2 C *#B

A3 3 *3 + 2 3 , ""$ *"#-"

6- 6 1"##-5 1/$1 *0 !"$: 3 "$1/ 2 !B

-" '

$#/,,*3 *!

# 43 * #,$1 $ @ +"$ 13 *+3 * 0+'0 5" A83,*1/! 13 !," #,*"+ *7!- ## ! *""!

#@'

$1+ *"!/- "$! *""!

#@'

' 03 -# @ +"$ 1 A) * + 3 $1 $1 A: -6"* 0"$23 83 * 3 * #"1 $#3 * 5"-- 2 ' $3 3 * 3 $143 $6 #"1 # @ +"$"$23"+# - A -# @ +"$ 1 "

- A $1

A:' -#,*1/! 1!,79/12+ $1 1C''83 * 67 3 , ""$"- 1/$1 *0 !"$&3 #"/"$$9/2 - "23#67 3"+8 #1 !* 1 @, * ' '

3 *"

- !/* ? "##/ # ' : 2 3 * 6 "$2 "$ *!$$ ! 1 $1 $ ,,* !"

"$ 5"1 $! - 1 67 3 , *" #4 1 !"1 13 # + "$ 5/*3 * #,$1 $ $1 "$#3 $ 3-1"$23 83 $3 # "1+ 2 "#,*3"6" 167- 84"!

$$6 * !2$"= 1$#/!3-"? 2*/$1 $13 * #,$1 $8 #3 -1 $"- 1

1 !* * $$/-+ $+ *" #'!!*1"$2-743 *"

!/* 5"1 9/12+ $ $1 1 !* 1 1 '&' , ## 1 1 !* 1"##-5"$23 + *" #' $! 43 ,* # $ -'

*$ 1!/$# -*3 $#/6+" 13 #/!3-"?

2 # 8 * , *+"##"6- "$ 3 !++/$"7 83"!3 3 , *" # 6 -$2'8 #/*3 *#/6+" 13 3 , ""$"- 1/$1 *0 !"$& 3 #"/"$$9/2 - "23#"- 1673 $8 --8 1 $1 3 * #,$1 $8 #1"* ! 1* /*$3 *+ *"+$"

-3+ 8"3"$ 3* +$3#3 , ##"$23 9/12+ $'8 #/*2 13 3 *"

!/*3 1+"#* 13 5"1 $! - 1673 , *" # $18*$2-7 --8 1 3 , ""$"- 1673 * #,$1 $'

*3 *"$2- *$ 1!/$# -*3 $48 1$ "$1 $7+ *""$3 -' >'

8/-16 @, 1" $$"! 0 !"$: 3 !4 83"!3"#* - 5 $*3 1 !"#"$3 -'* 1#3/#% ; !"# $%&

FF FF FF

8" + 7 -# ,* # $ , ""$ * 3 1"##-/"$3 *+ 2 67 1 !* 1"5*! $ 3 2*/$14 "

"""

FF FF FF

3 *+ 2 83 3 *!$#/++ 1*$ ##- +$"= 16 * #3

2 " $ *# $1 #3 3 # * ,/1"

1 3 + 2 *

"$"$2 3 2 6/ 6 *

"$"$2 3 2 "23 $7 *#'

3"# !- /# ,,-" # 83 3 * 3 2 8 # #- +$"= 1 6 * * * 3 !++ $! + $3 2 D 8#+ $1+ $

!4&>EEC&>E '< 3"#!- /# 8 11 1673 2 D 8#+ $1+ $

!4&>E48"3 !*+>'('&>E'!!*1"$2"483 * +

' ##- +$"= 16 * 3 8" 3 1

2 (7 *# $1 * ,/1"

"$ ? #,- ! 673 *6 8 $(7 *# $1C7 *#3 *

2 4 #3 "# $"- 1 # ? 1"5*! 83 3 * 3 + 2 "# !$#/++ 1*$'#, *@,- $ "$ ,, $1 13"#!- /# 4"3

,,-"!

6"-"783 3 *3 + 2 8 ##- +$"= 16 * * *3 !++ $! + $3 2 D 8#+ $1+ $ !4&>E'

3 +3 *3 * #,$1 $83"- *"$2 A3 ,*1/! 1,*"+ *7!- ##! *""!

$1+ *"!/- "$! *""!

'#, *3 # "1! *""!

#3 1 6"*33 * #,$1 $"# '('&&>' 3 + 2 6 8 $ 3 , *" # 8 # #- +$"= 1 $ >':''3/#4 3 "+ + 2 43 * #,$1 $8 #+"$* $1 - ## 3 $ ( 7 *# 2 ' 3 , *" # 3 1 $ !$#/++ 1 3 2 ' 3 * #,$1 $ 3 1 1"#8$ 1 3 # "1 + 2 6 *

"$"$23 2 + 9*"7 $143 * * 4,* 7 13 3 + 2 6 1"##-5 1'3 ,* # $, ""$/$1 *0 !"$: 3 !3 6 $"- 1$('>':4"' '6 8 $3 2 ,* #!*"6 1/$1 *3 # "1 ,*5"#"$' /*3 *43 , ""$# ?"$2* #"/"$!$9/2 -*"23#8 "- 1$C'&':83 * "$3 $3 1$1"#!-# 13 !3

3 * #,$1 $3 1"- 1 , ""$*1"##-/"$+ 2 $3 2*/$13 3 + *" #8 !3"-1+ 2 ' 3 @, * 1 !* 8 #6 "$ 1$C''67!$!

-+ $+ *"

!#*+3 !/*!$! *$ 183"!38/-13 5 $ !$3 *"23# 3 * #,$1 $') ,"$2"$5" 83 !# $1!"*!/+# $! #3 !

# 43 *"

-!/*3 1*"23-73 -13 * #,$1 $ $"- 13 1 !* * $$/-+ $+ *" #'3 * - 5 $"$1"$2#* !*1 1 673 *"

-!/** 13/#% ;:'

$3"#!

# 43 + *" #8

( #- +$"= 1$>':' $1""# $ 1+" 1 !3

"--1 73 , *" #3 5 $!3 6" 12 3 *'# , *3 ,- * "# 1673 * #,$1 $3 + 2 "$ 3 !++/$"7 * , **+ 11/*"$23 +"$*"7 3 , *" #3 + 2 6//?- ! * +$7"# , **+ 1 * 3 7

"$ 3 + 9*"7' 3

-- 2 1 3 83 $ 3

"$ 1 3 + 9*"7 "$ /-7 :43 -$28"33 *+ +6 *#3"# +"-78 $ 3 , * $ -3/# 3 , ""$ **/?-

! * +$7' 3 * * 4 " "# + 1 / 3 3 * #,$1 $3

"$ 13 + 9*"7"$3 7 *:

$13 * * 3"# 2 3 "+ 3 + 2 8

6/>7 *#'3 , ""$ * -- 2 13 3 *1 6"*3"#'('&&> $1#3 3 #,*1/! 13 * *"+ *7 !- ## *""!

$1 *"!/- "$! *""!

$1@'

'483 * "$3 *1 6"*3"#* !*1 1 '('&&>' *+3 *3 -#+ 1 3 # + $ $ 3 3 3 1 6"*3 3 , ""$ * "# '('&&>'3 * "#$* #$1"#6 -" 5 3 # "1 5"1 $! ' 3 * #,$1 $ $13"#8"$ ## #3 13 3 , ""$ *8 2 1 6/G7 *#

3 "+ 3 *+ 2 6/3 73 5 $6 $

6- ,*1/! $7!- * $1!2 $ 5"1 $! #/6# $"

3 # "1 -- 2 "$' A3 $ 3 * #,$1 $3"+# -8 2 1 6/>7 *# 3 "+ + 2 4 " "# 1""!/- 6 -" 5 3 3 , ""$ *8 2 1 6/G7 *# 3 "+ '

) * 5 *43 5 *#"$3 *+3 ** 2 *1"$23 6"*3 , ""$ *4 !

$$ 6 1"#6 -" 5 1'

3 * * 4""#+ 1 /3 3 , ""$ *8 2 1

6/(7 *# 3 "+ 3 *+ 2 '03 3 $

2 + 9*"7# * $1#3 3

-* 17* ,/1"

13 # "1+ 2 '3 * * 43 *" #"#-"

6- 6 $$/-- 1/$1 * 0 !"$: 3 !'< &'

$5" 83 "$1"$2#* !*1 1673 *"

-!/*83"!3!/-1 $6 1 +$#* 16 , *5 *# * **$ /#"$ $7+ $$ *6 "$2 # 1$+"# ,,* !"

"$*+"#* 1"$23 5"1 $! $* !*14$ "$ * * $! "#!

-- 1*673"#/*'$# H/ $-74"$1"$2$+ *""$ 3 "$# $ -43 # + "#3 * 671"#+"## 1' *

+ !, -./-$0 1 ' * + 26# !,