High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1761/2017dismissed

United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Lalita Rani & ORS

2017-04-26Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul9 pages

!"!#$ "% &"'(&

" ) #$# ("

"*""

*# #

!"!#$ "% &"'(&

" ) #$# ("

"*""

*# #

, !"!#$ "% &"'(&

" ) #$# -".#+%+" "

*# #

/ #

*"&0 "

0 "

" 11111

2'3"' +# &&

& + ""

4.# # "# +#"&+"0"

# $ +"3"

" 5 "##4' "

#% "&#6

7#"

+6 + "& #$ 8 +

)+ # 9::

4' + "&" # " $

" + 8";#+ 8+

'"<

" " +# " #+"04 ";

"# !"## $%&'$(")*$+ ) !"# "'%&% $, !$$ $#!-"'% '# " + #

" "&" #+"0 + "& $ 8 +

" $

" + + "$.+ 8+

'"&

0+$ " 3++

;

" 5 +" "'

" "4 $ ,/ 8";#+"

.3 + 8+

'"< #"#3 "0

. "#

'"3 .

5 7"# -* " 7"# =+ +' "+- * " 7"# " "; 4"

. .#

7*,925 0 4'

,($>&"" "#+".

. &" "&

&- # 6+ "; $;"."# +#

' 8";#+"$ +#&"

+ + .

"& 8";#+ 8+

'"< #$# "&$ ?$ #"" +#

6+ "& #

,%6 5"

,,%6 54 + "# $, !$$ $#$!-"'"'%&% &.)$$#!-"'%/

3 #;. " $ +" + 8";#+" 8+

' # 0 3+ "# + "&

:5%6 5 "#$0# %--$#"'$#!-"'%"'%&% $.)$1 $.$)$ 0- $#!-"'% + "&" #+"0# $.+ " $ " + < 6+ #

," 0 " 3 + "; 3+ ."?

3 # " & +"0 +" "+"0

" +

" +" ""

#"#+"#4 .# "."# + 0

3"#"& +" +0+ 0

0 +" 3"# #$ 3 + +"

" #$ " &"'

"#"

" 3 # " & 3"# 4+"

+ "

" #$ " &"' "#. &"

' 4? # ."

$# &#?

" ?

##"

$## "

# " &" ""4 '

! +"# 4 " +" + 0

,+ 3"# +"0."0"

" 0 0. " + & "

." " #$+" +"# "; "3 + +

.0+ *" +

+ "&" #+"0"

# '0

0 + .

0+ + # "#

6+6

0"3"

" 5 3+ '.$ +# " & /=2"

3" *" $ 3 + + $& # *

$ 8 ,%

/%@> /"!*@> /,+ +" +" +" "; "$

"#+".

. 0. + .0+ 04' ($>&"" +#"" 8";#+ 8+

< +"0 # ."

# + A$" $& +6 +" "&##$

B=+ + + #"

+ #"

0 +

& + # # 3+" > C //B 6+ "&" *";#+D$&"

3+ #" + "#8";#+ " 8+

'""

+3 ## 4 > "# /= " # +" +# "$.+ #+"0"&

0+$ " 3++

; " 5 + & " 8";#+3"#"# $ "3"## $'.

2 % &# '"

'3"#"

"# $ 2 % &# '"

" + ++ "& 8";#+"8+

'3 .0. $ #"3 "

.*# E & +"+ 6+ #+ + "&" #4.

#0F "0F +"#3"# + #$

6+$# ## "4 #+

+" + # "&" # "&

"*""*";#+D$&"

+ ."

+ # "#8";#+" 8+

6+ "&" #+"0 " +". 8";#+ 4'"

# ".

7 " 4 +3"#:

99 3+ "#8+

'3"#9'"

# ". + " 4 +4.

"# 99 6";. # +" #" $&# "# + "#" . +" "#8";#+"8+

'3 "4 4 .

+ &3"#"####4' +6 "#*#

5E & + +

"$"

& 3"# "#### "# *# 9 E 6+ 6 +"# "

# +" +" "#8";#+"8+

'3 $&"

" +

& + " + 8 + "# 3 $&"

+' &$# 4 #.5G + & 3"

# + "

>##

' +"#3"# $*# 5 E "$& % # .

+". + "&" # ("

"*""*";#+D$&"

"#'"

#" ,'"

# # 0 +"0." + " 3$',$"')$ $#!-"'%"'%&%2",- '$%*'!'*'$! $#$!-"'

3 + 6 " + &$ BB 3+ "####.

"# 8";#+ " 8+

6+$# + "& $ " $ " + 4 + +"#3"#"####"# *# , E"+ $

"#$& *# E"+ 3"

0"" 3"#"

" 4' +6

8 + "&" #+" # # &"& $ + "#

"$ "

+'3 .

" *# 5 E"+ +" " $ "

.3 +" #$& *# 5 E "+"# # ." 6+$# 4 + + "& # + # "&" # "& ("

"*""*";#+D$&"

3 + + *#

: E " $ +" + + "$.+

"& 8";#+"8+

+"# " + < +6 +"# $ +" "#< 3+ +#"&" 3"#"# $ " # $'.2 # '"

" + & " 8+3"#"4

" # $ " 0#0 "3"

#$ .+ $" $ % # . + ". "&" #-".#+%+" "D &"

8""#55'"

#"5'"

# 0 '"" '. + " 3 $',$"')$ %($%"

5%&*'$6 +&$ BB3"#" 4' +6 +"#

+" + < + "

#3 + +

*# 5 E3++ $*# E 3"

0"" *# 5 E " $ "#

" $ & '"*# 5 E"# # ." 6+ "

" #$ " &"' +"# + #"

" ""

#"."# "+ +"3"

+ "

" #$ " &"' +"# .$ +" + . + 6 + ##$ .

. #

$#""."# + $& #4

$.+

# +# " @> / +#

' 3++ +"#3 "0

.3"#.

& 8

5 7"# 7"#-

" 3+ "# + "; 3"# &.

& - 7"#

" 6+ " " #+ 3"#B"

;B +# " " # +" + "; 3"#.

. +# #" +#

'3"# . + .+ 3"

# "; #3+ &. 7"#-

# *$ #:"9 +*$ # * "*.$ #"8 : + + 0 "&

0+ #+"

3 33+"

"+."

" # "

"?$ # "

##.

" #+"

"'#$+ # ?$

##.$ ++"# 4 &"3"

+" +&"' 3 + $ ". . +#" ' "#8";#+ 3+ 0. +#

&" "

0 $ ." +

." +"

$ + 4$

7+"#$ "

.$ +" + .

#3 . "#

3++3"#4. 04'"#8";#+0

8 : + 6+8

0# +" 0 " 3 3+ &

' #+"

+" " +&# +&

' " #$+ #+"

3# +"# . "

#$ '> +&

' 4+ + 0 #" 3 +"

" #" '&"#$ # 6+$# +#

'3"#4. 04'"#8";#+ 0

0# # + " +

+#$ " &"'

" 4+ "4 "' + 6+6 +"#"

" " + "3 " 34' + % #" +&$. "3"

#"."# +3

# "3"#4"# ? $ # "#$ &## ! +"0 +"

+ "

" #$ " &"'

6+ #" "

. "

4' +6 +" + " +"# "; "$

"#+".

. 0. +

.0+ 4. 04' ($>&"3++8";#+

'"< +"0 "

"# + " "

" +" +# "# + #3 "0

. "#

0# #

8 : + " 3"#""# 4$

.# +#" +"#$ '4#$##4' +6 3+ ". " $ + "3 " 3 4' +# % "7 # $

%%&'$(")*$+ ) !"#"'%&%)$8 '9$&'$#!-"'%

5 5 : ,63 3+ +"#4+ +" 3+ " $;4. 0 " "#+".

. &" $;"."# " 0

' 3++ $" #3 "0

. #$ . +" + &

+ " 4+ +" 3"#""# 4$

. ! +#"?$.& +#% +"# $ 2": 0-"'%&% ;'$) 0-

65 : ,6 3+ +"#4+ 4'7 B4 "+'"

/ "#+7.+% +" $4 "0+ 3++# 0

'"&

' 3+++"#,

#4 &# +" &$+ +"

4$ +" 3 "" .0 # " >4 #$& +" &$# 4" 4$

'"$#

0 '" ! +"#+" + "#+".

. 0. +#

0" +

" 4+ +" #""# 4$

. ! # .

#$+ " ."

. 4$

. 3"# "#4' +"

" #$ " &"' #3 # " & "

##$ ."

. 4$

.3"# "&4' +

6+ # +.

#+ 3 +" +" 3"#"$# 4"$# .

. +"

"#8";#+ 3+ 3"# 0. + #

3+ "#"#8+

'"< 3 +

"#8+

'"< 3 # $& "

"$#. +" "'

6+$# + 6 +"# .+ ' + +" "# 8";#+ 3"#

. +#

'3 + 3 # #

" +

#$ " &"'" ";"0" ".# "' "0 +

0# # 8 : +

!03 +"4 0 +#% # "'& + # ""

+&$."3"

" 5 "## 4' +6 #$+ " + # ""

#&## /+

' +#

4 " + # "##

H".$ =+ + #";.E "# H# =+ + *