← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/751/2012disposed of

(O&M) Gopi Ram Yadav And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2016-02-04Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi11 pages

     ! "#$%

$ 

$ &&' (



)

*&%+ **,, - . / *

0'

1#2 0" .

0 .3. 024  

 

    

  



 "##$

"##% "&#' %$$(

%$$)

*$"*

 

 %(*' %()& %#&+ %#'( %(#+

*$"*

 , -

  



#'$'

*$"*

 . .

/

  



)#" ""&& (*&&

*$"*

 - 

0

   ! 1



  



 ""'* *'*$ *'** +)+'

*$"*

 2 3

  



 *()$ #+$& &"#

*$"*



 ! 

   - 3

  



")'&

*$"%

 . 

0 

  



 "$&) ""$( ""$& """* "#$)

"#"+ "+'& "+&+ "&++ "&%( "*$&

*$"*

 4, 5/

  

/ -

  



 "$)% "$'"

*$"*

  / .

.

  

 67.819

 %##"

%('# :

%)%'

*$"*



3

  



 "*$% "&(% +)%* )%&+

*$"*

 .

  - .

  0

 ;



  



 "#(% "'+( "'#* "&() "&(&

+$)+ +)*) (**$

*$"*

 5 5 .

   . 5 3

  



 *")& *"'' %%$+ %%$#

*$"*

 / 5 

   , .

/

  



)"&)

*$"*

 6 2, 

 %##) %#') %#&* %(%) %(+&

*$"*

 



 "&#% +'*% )"'$ )**(

*$"*



 

   4 .

;

0,

    < 6 2,

%#)&

*$"*





-

 7 "

=    



 /

0  ,/> 3?.<!@

*   

> 3?.<!@

% =   ,/

   > 3?.<!@ AAAAA 0 .3. 0245" 2

*%$ 



"%( 2   



 %##"

%('# :

%)%'

*$"*

 2  7 . 8

1

/  

B7.819B



7.8819

/ &+ 2   



 )#" &"# "$)% "$'" "$&) ""$( ""$& """* ""'* ""&& "*$% "*$& "+'& "+&+ "#$) "#"+ "##$ "##% "#(% "'+( "'#* "&%( "&++ "&#% "&#'

6 "&(% "&() "&(& *")& *"'' *()$ *'*$ *'** %$$( %$$) %%$+ %%$# +$)+ +)*) +)%* +)+' +'*% #+$& #'$' (**$ (*&& )"'$ )"&) )**( )%&+

*$"* :

")'&

*$"% 

0 2   //



 6 2,  )"698 )#698

*$"% :

**698

*$"# 



/ C  

C 

0  0 0



 

  

   2 



)#"

*$"*

 /

 4 .

7



 

  D / +%'



""

/ 0  .

7



 

/  

 /    , 

5  7 7 ;  !   5

2 E 2  F /

 0   < 0 0  /  /  

/ E

  1 D

8



0   1 

     . +

D

C

 "'&+

B

B



0 

** $* *$$*

0

0   *' $% *$$*  . (

 D

C

  

// 0 *  $% "* *$$* 

0

 

     

 



      

 !  "

#

$$$ %

%

#

% 

!  &

$$$ #

#

" '( # #

$$$ % #

% #

&

# ') * #

$$$ "

"

&

&  #

$$$ % #

% #

(

 +, * # #

$$$ #

#

- ! % #

$$$ 1

0  

2,   . "'

 C   / "%(

 0 0

  

/   // 0  ** "* *$""

D     / 



 *(#*'"&<6   D   *$G

 

   . *%



 ;

    / 0 

  "%(

 2  2 /   7.819  &+ 0

 6

2, 

 2 

0

0

*%$   2    7



 

 2

   



 

 

 

 

  



  0  

 /

  7.819

 2  2

/ / 

2 /   6 2,  

0  

0 2   / 

      



 2  

 



    ?E =*< 

0  



  0

   ! 

7 0 '

  1

- 0 

 

    /   / 



 

    

    8 

 

     **

/ 0       .

   (/ ((

/

 0  

/*(

    (  1

 2 /3 2)0)  (

/

  (*2

**(4 (2*  )   0  (/3    +

(  +

) / 

0 2 0

)0 / (( )   2( (   /



3

)

0 2***   5 * /  

/3  

+

(6

/  ( /2* / *'/   (1  728(*9 6

(  ')8(*9   ( (  72 (8(*9 6! (  728(*9 1 ( (  '):

1 /

2  

 

2 /   7.819  2

/  

   /  8 

0

 

  /  /   @

0    H

 /   E

)

 





 C 7   

  

  // 

0    /   / 

D . 

0  ,/  *% $& *$"+  

(

7.  .+&&  $+&  -  2  89&&&  ,,    :

 

 C  *& $" *$$% / / 2 

 7   2/ ,/  .+&&$+&B 

2  B2 ./ 0

0

 

7.819

 

2,   ,

 

 C  / 2 

   

 

 

 

 

0

 

2 /   7.819 , 

    

  ,/  

 C    / 2 



/    

   *$

/ 0

 

   / 

    

 

2  

   "#$$$$$<6   

<- "&&#

 /       0     8  2 

0  

   





2

 

/

 

  2

  !   2   2

 0  6, / 

/ /  2    8 C

 

 



0    / .

  

  



   

  /

  0



 ! 

7 0 '

8 

        0 0 /    0     1 ;

,/

;.&<-. !9=;9<289&&& ,,5!&,5

)7 :  &+&,:)6(5 0

 0 2

0

 0 B2 ./  

2  / 1 ;

 "* "%

 ,/ ;.&<1 

 

 

0     .1 (3 0

 **(

 ((2 0 2) ';2 *5   

 

        

8(*9  0 (  ( / 

*2) /  (/* ( (

*     / ( 2**

0

+ 

   /    '0+ /( + 0  ( **(

  0 0  2

/   *( /(((2

/2)

  / (0

(2)  

 < 

(/   /3  0((

 0

 

>  *

(  1  6  0(  (

       (      /3  0(  (   /3  2)$ *((    //

     0  0

    1  6  0( (

 10/ (*( 0(*( *  $**(     /3     4  (  + 0      

  / 2(+

(2) ';2 *5        

   

 

  

   !

"##$ %"& '''

$()* "##$

 +",)2

/= .1**(

     / *((   /* / (  0 /(

* ((  ( 2( **(

  

+/ /( /(

0 2* ((    // * /  / 2) (

* (  4     /   2/(  + (*(

 (/*2  2 (   **( 0 / (

* (( ( ( (

  + *0



3    + *

* / *  /

  +  **( /* ( ( 0 >

 

   * ( + +  ( 0/((

( 2(

( / )(0 + //  

  (  /

(           

(    ( / + */ ) (// /( /(

(*((  

( 

 3(

(( (

(4(*/    /3    ( + (+

2 

  3 )   + * >     + 0  '

?  ( ** ) * / *  /

 /    +    6(?$*(3 )    6(&#  *  (3  )  4    *     (/ /

 ((

   / (/ /( /(  ( /((:

,

0  (   02) ';2 *   4  + ( / ('

 

 

  % - .    &  / '

 !

"##0

 +#, ( 

0(= .4+ 0 2(+

2) * ( (3 )**

/2   /( 

 )  

3(

 ( ) + *(

   + (  *(

    3

  (

2     2

 **( 4 (   ( *+    + /    3(

(



((/((  

 / 

) / /

( /1  0   + 0   2 <  ( (

 /

 @   + >   (

(   *      2  <   +  6(% #?$ (( @1 /(($2/

 (   

0    2 <  (

  (5  :



0

0

 0 B2 ./

0 1 ;

  

2 

 0   , E

/   



 "#$$$$$<6  

E C 





 /  20   

  . +

   0



<- "&&#    . +

 / 

** $* *$$*   0 / 

E   

0   "*G 

 / 

   /  /

    2

"*G 



 "#$$$$$<6   

/   /  %**)"&'<6  



  %**)*$$<6   /  /

  

2   0

0

 0 B2 ./ @ 49-. /5

76:., (      

0 



 

 %**)*$$<6   



  . +

 .

   /2  

0

 *$G

 

 

/   . *%





 

,

 0    

 / 0 

 

     /

    0

   / 

 0  2 /   7.819 

/  2

/ 0

  2  / 

/ 

2 /



 6 2,  

0    / 

2

0 E  

0 

  

 %**)*$$<6   *$G 

 

/  

  . +

 ; 

0



  2  /      

    0

2  / 

*%$  6 2,    

 /

0 0

  0 .3. 024B $+ $* *$"( " $

+ (