Kamal Kishore Dhawan v. Union Of India And ORS
!"# "$ " %""
" "$ "
$&'
() $'* + (
, --
./0 .
+1(2'
$13 --- '& & ( '2 4'2+5+
(
() (&1'2+ --- '+6( '
&+
! " #$"
%%%
! "#$ %&&'()%*+%'(',
&
'
(
! "
#$"
'
'
)
!
'
*+%-./%'(&- * + ,- ./ ,.*/ 0& #-1
" 2
!4 '
2 ' 8"
,- *. ,.*,
"
+ 2&
# , "
2
+ 2& 9 #1 *7 ./ *://
9 ,; .- ,..*
+ 2&
< ! #
./ .; ,..,
*::;
2 #
,; .7 ,..6
*::=# *::-
#
*6 .7 ,../
9 09 1 ( -;;
,../
" 2
0 >1 " 2
0 >1 .- .; ,..;
#
*6 .7 ,../
'
'
= < # ,; .7 ,..6
'
.* .7 ,..;
'
'
9 09 1 ( **/:
,..;
> ( 8
9 .- ., ,..:
'
#
> " 2
-
.- ., ,..: < 01 ( :=*:
,..:
.- ., ,..:
" 2
0 >1 *; .7 ,.*,
2
!
'
/ !
.- ., ,..:
2
8"
,6 *. ,..:
' "
08
+ 2&1
" 9
!
;
'
"
08
+ 2&1
2 4
8"
,- *. ,.*, :
8"
"
08
+ 2&1
!
)
*.
2 ! 4 '
34
8"
"
08
+ 2&1 6* *. ,.*,
,..-#,../
2
.7 ., ,.*6 0& #;1 ,..-#,../
3?'
4 4
,..6#,..7 .7 ., ,.*6 0& #:1
4 3?'
4
** 2
" 2
9 ( .-.@..7=-@,.*- "
08
+ 2&1
8"
,- *. ,.*,
'
! > !
#
"
08
+ 2&1
#
4
*,
4 3?'
4 .7 ., ,.*6 0& #:1 ' # !
'
9
!
9 '
4 !
9 !
*6 2 2
9
,- ./ ,.*/ 0& #-1 2
'
! #
> ! "5 ' !
*7 B
##
2
2
,- ./ ,.*/ 0& #-1 *=
2
,- ./ ,.*/ 0& #-1
6* *. ,.*,
'
&
'
"
08
+ 2&1 *- B
+ *- ., ,..:
0& #*=1
"5 + *6 .7 ,.*.
0& #*-1 '
!
8"
,- *. ,.*,
*/ B
8"
,- *. ,.*, &
,..-#,../ 4
,..-#,../ 3?'
4
,..6#,..7
*;
B
)
+ *- ., ,..:
*6 .7 ,.*.
2
*:
<
,.
2
"5 !
4
8"
,- *. ,.*, "
08
+ 2&1
B
'
# 8"
,- *. ,.*, + *6 .7 ,.*.
0& #*-1
,..6# ,..7 '
B
+ *6 .7 ,.*.
0& #*-1
"5 ,..-#,../ '
9
'
8"
,- *. ,.*, '
+ *6 .7 ,.*.
0& #*-1
# .7 ., ,.*6 0& #:1
,* +
'
'
' + *6 .7 ,.*.
0& #*-1
'
#
"5
3> !4
'
'
2 '
8"
,- *. ,.*,
*; .7 ,.*,
C4 8 C
8"
,- *. ,.*,
&
"5 ,..-#,../ ,, 2
,..-#,../ 4 3?'
4
4 3?'
4
'
,6 9
"5 8"
,- *. ,.*,
8
'
2 '
&
9 '
'
'
,7 + 8"
'
8"
,- *. ,.*,
B &
9
!
) '
'
'
,= <
#
+
'
'
+
'
,..-#,../
4 3?'
4
,..6#,..7
+ '
'
'
"5 '
"5 ,..-#,../
4 3?'
4 '
## ,-
"5
B
@ ,..6#,..7
'
+ *6 .7 ,.*.
,/ +
'
,..6# ,..7
2
.7 ., ,.*6 & & #:
'
@
9 "5
! !
,..6#,..7 '
) ,;
<
"5 ! @
!
'
.7 ., ,.*6
4 3?'
4
' # !
,:
B
"5
) 4
+
'
9 '
4 !
9
"5
9
'
6.
+
D ,..-#,../ ) 9
3?'
4
"5 4
9
9
5 9
5 9
5 9
'
'
6*
'
# 4 3?'
4
.7 ., ,.*6 0& #:1
'
,..-#,../
2 )
'
,..6#,..7
6, B "5
'
34
!
'
'
# ' > !
2
C4 + " ( ;..-#;../ +0 1 23# 4 #5# 7
+10#8 98 7
7
7! 6 ,6 ./ ,.*=
B
/ ;
:
2
#
2
'
##
2 / ;
:
+0 1 23# 4 #5#"1:$
#
!""#$!""%!""%$!"" !""&$!"""
'
'
( )
* +(
8. On the issue, whether the representations filed by the appellant against the Reports for the years 1995-1996, 19961997 and 1998-1999 need to be taken to their logical conclusion, we are of the view, that since almost two decades have passed by since the aforesaid Annual Confidential Reports were recorded, it would be too late in the day to require the Authorities to adjudicate upon the representations made by the appellant as against the uncommunicated Annual Confidential Reports.
9. In the above view of the matter, we are satisfied, that the respondents ought to be directed to reconsider the claim of promotion of the appellant, to the post of Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, for the vacancies which arose during the years 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 on the basis of the communicated reports for the years 1997-1998 and 1999-2000, within a period of three months from today. Ordered accordingly." +
'
+0 1 23# 4 #5# "1:$6
! 2 9 21!!
7
7;
4 7! "'((-$ 7# -6 <',
1= 4 9
7
7;
46 "'(&/$ 7# ,>>
0 ?!
7 2!4
7
7;
46 "'(()$ 7# &> &.>
+
'
C4 + "5 ' ' 2 9 21!! 8 "1:$
' "5 '
'
"5 "5
'
'
#
"5
7
! 9
5 ( 7/ 7;
# , -
.
/
/
/ !""0$",
1 2
&3 ,&- /
/
4 5
*
+ 6*+7
8&3
'
2
0 ?!
7 2!4 8 "1:$
+0 1 23# 4 #5# 8 "1:$
2
+0 1 23# 4 #5# 8 "1:$
8 C4 +
#
"5
+0 1 23# 4 #5# 8 "1:$ ;
+ ; C4 + "5 ! *::=#*::-
*::;#*:::
'
!
#
6= + "
08
+ 2&1
> !
'
#
"5
8" ,..:
9
'
2 9 21!! 8 "1:$ )
,..6#,..7 )
62
C4 + +0 1 23# 4 #5# 8 "1:$6 8"
,- *. ,.*, " 2
'
+0 1 23# 4 #5# 8 "1:$6
#
! '
> !
"
08
+ 2&1 6/ 2 9 21!! 8 "1:$
#
"5 !
'
6;
+
#
"5 '
,..-#,../
3?'
4
& +
#
"5
2 ' '
#
"5 3?'
4
4
'
8"
,- *. ,.*,
'
8
2
6:
'
8 > 2 C "< ( *=:/:
,.*:
@
= 7
7
7;
4 7! 6 ,7 .7 ,.,6 !
8 >
'
!
#
"5 '
'
'
8"
#
7.
## '
2
7* (
7, (
'
8
' " 9 " 9 !
$
4."9
!
$
"5:5+& ;
-
9 :; -
:;