← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5683/2019dismissed

Mangat Ram (Since Deceased) Through Lrs And ORS v. Ram Parkash (Since Deceased) Through Lrs And ORS

2019-12-20Mr. Justice B.S. Walia13 pages



       



     

 

  !"#!

! $

!"

%&"

'"#



&"(!

  !"#!

! $

!"

%)

    !"#  $ %" &"

" !"

$**+ ,' 

#"-!+ ,'

)"

" . .+ ,' ")

$ %"& 

!** ' & #"

,"* 1

# 2 ""+ ,3#" &45   

+ )

8"* 9!"-6

)": #4 $  ,+

 

/0

."  "

#





"))*  )"

) 96

)" ) 

 * + 8"*

;#  "  1

5 <9'"+ ))*

"))*  ;#  "  1

5

**9 ,* " 7#+ 8"* ;# 

"  

5 # ) 96 )" )

"+ #-; )6  51+1   5+ 4 *

"+ +  4   )+ + 4 "" !"

  *

4!

6 *"6 )  6  )6 "

1 

1 )6  '4

 + *

# 9#*     /0

,



1 )"

 <!

 2

 + -; 9"

3#

4!

#4 +

"6

"  ) ** *  9!"9

")4" !*" 5 

 <9'"+ -;

)" 9" 

8"*

1

/50

=! )" !** 96

'

   "* #

 &" ) # * "+ "" >"

,))** - ) "

1 

1 '"

)+ !""+ # )*") # **6  

#"

?""

#*

.

&

/0

?   + 9!* # 

   +

)" 3# #" 9" 6

<9'"+

 1

'9 )* " ! #" * # 

 !' - "

8"* #"+ #* )" "# )"+

9!"9 "' ) *-"6 '* " 6 '*-* )"

*9

/0

=! 9!"9 "' )+ )"

8"*

*  6 *6

 1+ 9!"-6 -;

)"7#  -" 3# 9" 

3#

 

,))*  *6

)) ")*6+ ,3#" &4

=!

8"* ""+ ,3#" &45   



 *6+ @#*6

  + 4

/10

* "#  #* )" 

 )# ) "

" + !""+

 ##-*+ @#**6+ *-* -  

" #

8"* 

"!

"

=!#+ ) # 9!!"

9!*

;# # #4 $  ,+

"  -  

/0

$" #* ! "* #)  <:-*

#)"

,))*



* !" '

'"; !"  "#  *6  "#*

""#

"

- !"9 #  !"!* ;#

 9!" 9! *6 +

3 #

 !))



" !" )"



+ #* ")  

* *9 9!*   *6+

"  -   *6 @#  - 

 9!!"

#

 #  *6

!' " #-  #*

)"

, *6+ -; )" 9" 

8"* 1+

9!"  !** 96 ' &

  ***6 ( "

 "

="#"6 ?"+ 8"*+ *" "* # ! -

) " !*"

" >" ,))** #"+

!""+ "' ) !) <!

9#* (

A "    

0

<9'"+  "# " "' ) *

# 

   "

3# #"+ #*+

 1

+ "#

"

)" 9!"9 '* "' ) *-"6 '*

" 6 '*-* )"

*9 &* "# + *6

*+ 7 9" )#"# " 6 "'



;"

)" )"  51 6

) "' ) <!

#"

0

=!

8"* !* 

*6 *#* "

 

+  9"( # 1 6+ 9!"  " )*

))*+  *6 #!

 6

9!# 3)* !9  6 #!

*6

 

 *6 1 

 -;

$"

8"* "*6 #)

 '

!( )    "*+"& ,-./ ("0&  1 !# )    ") + "

+       ,-.2 $ 3., -"'

<:-*+ <!

<:-*

#)" ! !*

*6 )"6 #* !' ' 3" # " 

#* -  - #  9!!"

"

#  9!!"

    #!

! #* - " - -  # "

 $"

8"* #"!"

!*

9!* )6 "' "

))* 9" #"

6

# # 3# *6 -# )" !

'* "' ) 3)"6 *  )"

!"  <!

 *6 -* )"

'*

" 6 *6 *-"6 " '*

" 6 " *9

0

$"

8"* -"' *

 *6+ )"47 !

-;  "# - "

 "

="#"6

?"+ 8"*+ !6 ! *" " !*" ! ) 6

#     )*   )

&#;- <"6 <!

,



1+ 9!"

)"#* ) <!

" !*"

! - " ) # 9! )"

! "

;#  * "

)"

#

"

  

 **

)6  ) # !6 9#* - *

3# " "*

#

5

 >"

,))**

#



  "

 

 "!   +

<!

! 3  **

 1 ) #

" 9!"9 ")

 )"

" ;# 

# !' - #**6 )

 1 "

"   *"

" !*"

) #  +5+ 4  ++4 #"

  ) <!

' "

 1

-+ )6 !** " !*"

! )

 ++4

 1 #"

< ) *

! 9! !** )   #"

"" <!

*"6 !+  "#

 #

7 "# " !*"

! * )

# )"

;#  <!



0

, *6+ ) " '

!

- "

8"*

-; * !**

'

+ ' "

#"

 $  ,

8"*+ 9!!+ 

 '

  ( "

 "

="#"6

?"+ 8"*+ -# ) "* # "!*"

*' 3" ")"# #"

    

  

 

 

       



!     

! 

"       !  



     " #   

  $

        %&#'(#)(*&  



  +, ! 

      



  ! -

    

   

!#.

=!#+  *"

* -;

1+ )" '

*6

    '* "' 9" !' (9*

-# **  ) "* # "

1 

1

<9'"+ 9!# " "  ) 96 ))")"

8"*+ 9! !

 -; )" 1+

)" "!96 '( ;#" <!

9!"

  (9 **  )  

"' )

  + )" #! !' '*

" 6 '*-*

)"

*9

<9'"+ ) (9* **

 ) * -;

"' )+ )"  

 ))")"

8"*+ -# !

'* "' ) <!

#"

<:-*

#)"

DD

 

 

      

  :

*

"

<!

#))

3"  ;#" 9!* !" !** $9"

#"  *6

*' 3"

 ")"# #"

)%#/    !0 



 1      

  

    

 

        

        

       

 !        !    

  

#     

  

   +  2  !

 3

 

 

 !   3   



 

    -! 4  



  

 #      

   ! 

      !       # 5

    

      ! 0 

 

15    

  ! 

  

          !

              

   !  !  

 ! 

   



 

 

 

 

 

 0  !

       

    

   !   ! 

     

 

0  !   

  

    



!  

#   

  

  



 

     -      

 !    



 

 0  



 #    0  

 

       # 5    

  

 0  

     !  #

 '

   )

(9*  )""

"' ) -

#-@#*6+ #

9! 

 #

0

<:-*

#)" D



 6 7

"""  "*"

 D     # #





86)(*)7)29(:#*' 3"  ")"#

#"

):#5" 2-2# #2  4 86)(*)7 )29(:; 

 < =5    !  

    

!     #>   

  

0        

       

 

     

  

     0  

 



       # ?

  



       0!     

   #=

,)" "

-'+ )"#* )"")!



 D     !

(  *"

"

 -   9!*  

*6

*' 3"  ")"# #"



)@#    

 A# B# # B!   !     

  

   

      

  #       !      

 

!      #2  

          !  

   

 

 #/ 

  !!

!     

#)%#/  





 !   

   !       # / 0

$(9+ <:-*

#)" D"

#     $ %&



'

( " $ %&   :+ %''(6C7 2 :%:

!* 9!*   *6+

<!

#!  

" !#* *6 

9!!"

# ! -

 # )"6 

*6 ))* 

?)"' )" 

D"

 #     $ %& 

#)" ")"#

#"

C# 

    #"            

   !         

 

  

     

     

    !     

    

  ! # 9#5  

    ! )&*!





  2+ )%$ C$%''9#/

   

   !

 

  

   

   

   !# :# /       

    !    

   

 



     !     

  !   

  !    #/  

0   2

:  D  "

 

     ! )&*!

   !0!  #  

          #  3 !     





#       3



        

     

    



 # /

2 D   



  (  :+ )(@* D+ %&*+ <:-*

! !"

.!#"+ 7+ -"' #"

%#    A 2    2 

# 

!

0  )(C(#        

       ?

#(*C   *> )@>    A2 

 

 !     ?

#(*9  )&  2   )(C(#  5

  A2 

 

     

  0  

  

   #

 

   

   )(:(             

 



%)6)7   C)

A )(:(.#  !  2    2

9% 

 E



  6

      F  7"

  " ,

 ):

+ )(@)#5  

   

!  

 

      0  #

          !     

 ! "  ,

  #  "

            $  #  5     !         B  ?

#   "  ,

    -        !  







 

  

 

 

-    



 

     



 

!   #  5   



  

    

!  "  ,







     # "

!, >   

2 2#2  

/ ?

#))(& )(@9  9 G

)(@@ 65D)(@&6%7 *(7<$ HH##  

 ! 

      ! 

9%  "

   - 

!      !   







  

  

 

 0        

!  #

     !

 0      





  I      

 -       0



!    

 9%   



 

  

  !       

 

 )*   .# 5

    "  ,

    

        0

 

  !#

 

   0

  

 3  #



  5    !F>           ) 

    ($ *+,- '. ,/+$

,+0 C# 5       

     

  3    "  ,

    





       

     3

     0

  !   

         

 9%# /        " ,

 

3 #" ,

 





   



    #  



   #

 #.

=!#+ *9 9** * 9!* 

 *6+ "@#" *( 

"

*6 "@#" "

#6  *6

$  6

*6 -6 3)"6 6 "

)  )# **

"@#" - 3)* -*! # -#  '

"

"#  "#*  )-* )"

9!  

89* @#" @#"6

* -; "' ) 

# #

"  9! ) (9* )""

  + *+  '* "' )

  - " 

#" '* "' ) !' - "

8"*+ '* "' ) 9!"9

*-"6 '* " 6 " *9 9!" )

 

 =! "#  )# "!

)" 

- " # #  *6

9!   2 "# + "' )

-"

" "*6  

       4 $ %"5 +6  ,2 27,- I  E!!"

)(4"

 F4 

E!!"

")"-*

 F4